This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 May 2014 10.41am
Quote Kermit8 at 09 May 2014 8.27am
They could well be an unwitting Trojan horse for those with real and dangerous right wing beliefs in the future once they get a small foothold. Not quite sure how it will evolve but purely from an historical perspective better not to take any chances imo with helping a party which could easily swing much further to the right gain some actual power. Having bordering on extreme politicians I'm a bit puzzled, Kermit. On the one hand you say they are extremists, on the other hand that they are an unwitting Trojan Horse. A lot of your opposition to UKIP seems based on the premise that they are extremist, dangerous, right-wing, etc. Yet you and Nick and Serial and Willo haven't actually offered much substance to back up this assertion. It smacks of fear-mongering to be honest.
1. I find their stance on climate change extremely worrying. I can almost accept climate change sceptics, albeit I disagree with them completely, but the fact that the education secretary for UKIP claimed if they got in to power they would stop education of man-made carbon emissions being a major contributor to the issue (linked in a previous post) not only goes against the scientific overriding opinion, it shows a desire to impress their minority views on children which isn't far off the Evangelical desire to teach the Creation story in science classes. For example, I'm against austerity as part of the neo-liberal doctrine that has ruled economics for the past 40 years or so. Doesn't mean I don't think it should be taught in economics classes, just I think all sides of a case should be given. 2. I disagree with their deputy leader's desire to slash the NHS [Link] . I believe that his underlying conviction for wholescale privatisation is an extreme view to hold on the matter and would be incredibly damaging. 3. UKIP's almost total disinclination on any cross-atlantic cooperation in the European Parliament because they hold the misguided belief that it is exclusively bad is an extreme view, and is highlighted in their voting against bills which are quite evidently good, such as tighter enforcement on laws against human trafficking or the killing of protected species. I agree with them that the EU is far from ideal, but to over-exaggerate the detrimental affects of the organisation is to prevent the genuine discussion on Europe they so ardently desire! 4. And of course I detest their conflation of all unemployed Europeans as being a threat to British job security. I think that that's the politics of the far right, as it is total exaggeration and evidently inaccurate, yet they put it as a billboard for the forthcoming elections. I would never stop anyone voting UKIP and sort of see why many may decide to do so in disillusionment. But for the life of me I can't see why people would vote for them based on any other policy except their Euroscepticism, and would argue that, policy-wise, a group such as the Greens, Left Unity or TUSC are much more valid 'protest-vote' alternatives. Edited by serial thriller (09 May 2014 2.41pm)
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
|
Quote serial thriller at 09 May 2014 2.38pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 May 2014 10.41am
Quote Kermit8 at 09 May 2014 8.27am
They could well be an unwitting Trojan horse for those with real and dangerous right wing beliefs in the future once they get a small foothold. Not quite sure how it will evolve but purely from an historical perspective better not to take any chances imo with helping a party which could easily swing much further to the right gain some actual power. Having bordering on extreme politicians I'm a bit puzzled, Kermit. On the one hand you say they are extremists, on the other hand that they are an unwitting Trojan Horse. A lot of your opposition to UKIP seems based on the premise that they are extremist, dangerous, right-wing, etc. Yet you and Nick and Serial and Willo haven't actually offered much substance to back up this assertion. It smacks of fear-mongering to be honest.
1. I find their stance on climate change extremely worrying. I can almost accept climate change sceptics, albeit I disagree with them completely, but the fact that the education secretary for UKIP claimed if they got in to power they would stop education of man-made carbon emissions being a major contributor to the issue (linked in a previous post) not only goes against the scientific overriding opinion, it shows a desire to impress their minority views on children which isn't far off the Evangelical desire to teach the Creation story in science classes. For example, I'm against austerity as part of the neo-liberal doctrine that has ruled economics for the past 40 years or so. Doesn't mean I don't think it should be taught in economics classes, just I think all sides of a case should be given. 2. I disagree with their deputy leader's desire to slash the NHS [Link] . I believe that his underlying conviction for wholescale privatisation is an extreme view to hold on the matter and would be incredibly damaging. 3. UKIP's almost total disinclination on any cross-atlantic cooperation in the European Parliament because they hold the misguided belief that it is exclusively bad is an extreme view, and is highlighted in their voting against bills which are quite evidently good, such as tighter enforcement on laws against human trafficking or the killing of protected species. I agree with them that the EU is far from ideal, but to over-exaggerate the detrimental affects of the organisation is to prevent the genuine discussion on Europe they so ardently desire! 4. And of course I detest their conflation of all unemployed Europeans as being a threat to British job security. I think that that's the politics of the far right, as it is total exaggeration and evidently inaccurate, yet they put it as a billboard for the forthcoming elections. I would never stop anyone voting UKIP and sort of see why many may decide to do so in disillusionment. But for the life of me I can't see why people would vote for them based on any other policy except their Euroscepticism, and would argue that, policy-wise, a group such as the Greens, Left Unity or TUSC are much more valid 'protest-vote' alternatives. Edited by serial thriller (09 May 2014 2.41pm)
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
This sums it up for me. Edited by nickgusset (09 May 2014 11.08pm)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.