You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Russell Brand - class warrior or complete bell end
November 22 2026 2.29am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Russell Brand - class warrior or complete bell end


Page 19 of 25 < 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 >
paperhat Flag croydon 13 Dec 14 9.36am

Quote Johnny Eagles at 13 Dec 2014 12.24am

Just watched QT. Tried hard to be objective.

I thought:

Russell Brand played the man not the ball in swiping at Nigel Farage. He didn't engage with the questions much and got found out by the bloke who asked him why he wouldn't stand for parliament (but given the state of the shouty idiots in the audience you have to wonder what sane person would want to listen to them moan at you for a living).

He made his populist lefty points well enough. They were simplistic but no more simplistic than any one else's except maybe the journalist.

He's actually gone (very slightly) up in my estimation. I think he does care and he does actually bother. If only the world were as simple as he'd like it to be but as it isn't it probably does need people like him.

I'd still vote for Nige over him any day though.


I felt pretty much the same, the first question about politics being belittled and coming second fiddle to adversarial nit picking was a great question, if only it set the precedent for both Farage and Brand to snipe directly at every other person on the panel. Lets face it, QT has been a soapbox for this behaviour for years. "whats your view on X?" - "well, I think blah blah blah but thats better than your mob who are racists"

He got found out to a degree by the guy who has latterly been named as the brother of a UKIP MEP, but as for the shouty idiots, unfortunately, these are 'the common man', especially in the likes of canterbury - these are the views that are so easilly swayed and the people so easilly led. - A frightening snapshot of the british public of today (although Farrage won't have had the BBC allow any of those foreigners in, obviously)

Edited by paperhat (13 Dec 2014 9.40am)

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Hoof Hearted 13 Dec 14 11.04am

Quote paperhat at 13 Dec 2014 9.36am

Quote Johnny Eagles at 13 Dec 2014 12.24am

Just watched QT. Tried hard to be objective.

I thought:

Russell Brand played the man not the ball in swiping at Nigel Farage. He didn't engage with the questions much and got found out by the bloke who asked him why he wouldn't stand for parliament (but given the state of the shouty idiots in the audience you have to wonder what sane person would want to listen to them moan at you for a living).

He made his populist lefty points well enough. They were simplistic but no more simplistic than any one else's except maybe the journalist.

He's actually gone (very slightly) up in my estimation. I think he does care and he does actually bother. If only the world were as simple as he'd like it to be but as it isn't it probably does need people like him.

I'd still vote for Nige over him any day though.


I felt pretty much the same, the first question about politics being belittled and coming second fiddle to adversarial nit picking was a great question, if only it set the precedent for both Farage and Brand to snipe directly at every other person on the panel. Lets face it, QT has been a soapbox for this behaviour for years. "whats your view on X?" - "well, I think blah blah blah but thats better than your mob who are racists"

He got found out to a degree by the guy who has latterly been named as the brother of a UKIP MEP, but as for the shouty idiots, unfortunately, these are 'the common man', especially in the likes of canterbury - these are the views that are so easilly swayed and the people so easilly led. - A frightening snapshot of the british public of today (although Farrage won't have had the BBC allow any of those foreigners in, obviously)

Edited by paperhat (13 Dec 2014 9.40am)


It's a shame that Brand clearly spent his time rehearsing his put downs and popularist sound bites rather than researching facts.

To this end he looked pathetic sat next to the journalist that knew her stuff and made complete sense throughout the debate.

Farage was only responding to snipes at him by Brand and the Labour woman, but when allowed to speak actually answered the questions without waffle and irrelevances.

Finally.... the moronic woman with blue hair in the audience shouting "racist scum" etc was a disgrace and should have been ejected.

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 13 Dec 14 12.13pm

H

Quote SwalecliffeEagle at 13 Dec 2014 7.53am

You've got to hand it to him. I mean, he's masterfully constructed this image of himself as a champion of the people. Whilst the majority of adults see him for what he is, he has a strong base of popularity among many naive, young people and he's exploiting it to great effect. Regardless of the whole 'Champagne Socialist' tag that's rightly been pinned onto him, he continues to build his profile through promoting some tenuous connection he has with the working man and disillusioned youth. Anyone watching QT last night can't have missed his syrupy use of the term 'mate', not to mention the clasping of hands together as if in prayer which surely communicates his sincerity.

He addresses ills in the Westminster establishment recklessly but sensationally (because that sells books), advises all young people to boycott elections (which would lead to minority parties he purports to detest gaining the ascendancy), then laments the lack of a clear choice between the parties (yet, in the next breath, he's slating the one party promoting an obvious deviation from the political norm in UKIP).

But his cleverness lies in his ability to critique the establishment and then, when picked up on his suggestions or challenged on matters of substance, he stands back and protests that he's 'not a politician'. Or at least I'd like to think he's clever, because the only other conclusion is that some people are incredibly thick.

Blimey and I thought I was cynical!

I'm just not sure people, Brand included, are that calculating. If Brand has masterfully got youth opinion to where he wants it, what does he get out of it?

I think he's incredibky simplistic and his tired anti-elite rhetoric has nothing to offer, but I think he probably does genuinely believe it and at least he bothers to debate. He could just live the life of riley.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

sanitycheck Flag 13 Dec 14 12.50pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 13 Dec 2014 12.13pm

Blimey and I thought I was cynical!

I'm just not sure people, Brand included, are that calculating. If Brand has masterfully got youth opinion to where he wants it, what does he get out of it?

I think he's incredibky simplistic and his tired anti-elite rhetoric has nothing to offer, but I think he probably does genuinely believe it and at least he bothers to debate. He could just live the life of riley.


The trouble with many posts on here, like the guy you responded to is that it offers little other than a carbon copy of what you could see on any of the other 30 odd pages. At least an element of balance enters into your critique of Brand. Even his appearance on Question Time appeared to improve your perception of him, which I was surprised about really because I thought it was a complete disaster .

Concerning the 'tired anti elite rhetoric', if we go back to the days of the bail out and bankers bonuses people were all for this. People didn't want huge reckless loses to be socialised and profits privatised. They didn't want more avenues of influence for the few and none for the common man. They realised for a second that we'd been royally f***ed over. That's all forgotten about now because so many are hanging their hat and hopes on UKIP, but little has actually changed. Both of these aspects of society still need addressing and just because the narrative has been solely pushed to immigration, these other problems don't go away.

The irony is, the most likely scenario due to the voting system is that mass support for UKIP will come to very little. When that hope is gone, will it be okay to start talking about the structure of government itself and who they really work for again? Of how your vote 'doesn't count' and hence there is no real choice? Will that be back in vogue then, and suddenly not simplistic and for 'students' and 'idiots' as several others have pointed in this thread. I suspect that it will.


Edited by sanitycheck (13 Dec 2014 12.52pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 13 Dec 14 1.13pm

Quote sanitycheck at 13 Dec 2014 12.50pm

Even his appearance on Question Time appeared to improve your perception of him, which I was surprised about really because I thought it was a complete disaster .

I agree !

In the 'Daily Mail' Quentin Letts likened him to a shirivelled balloon after he had been verbally attacked by a UKIP following member of the audience.

Brand might be a perfectly nice chap and he has his views but alas my views are diametrically opposed to his ! Chalk and cheese spring to mind !


 

Bubbs Flag Edinburgh 13 Dec 14 2.54pm

Anyone else playing the Russell Brand irrational hatred bingo on this thread?

So far I've got student lefty views, simplistic, naïve, Andrew Sachs, bell end, tool, cock, moron, druggy, hippy vote dodger, champagne socialist, gullible followers, unintelligent hypocrite...

 


'Better stop dreaming of the quiet life 'cos it's the one we'll never know'

SwalecliffeEagle Flag Swalecliffe 13 Dec 14 3.15pm

Quote sanitycheck at 13 Dec 2014 12.50pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 13 Dec 2014 12.13pm

Blimey and I thought I was cynical!

I'm just not sure people, Brand included, are that calculating. If Brand has masterfully got youth opinion to where he wants it, what does he get out of it?

I think he's incredibky simplistic and his tired anti-elite rhetoric has nothing to offer, but I think he probably does genuinely believe it and at least he bothers to debate. He could just live the life of riley.


The trouble with many posts on here, like the guy you responded to is that it offers little other than a carbon copy of what you could see on any of the other 30 odd pages. At least an element of balance enters into your critique of Brand. Even his appearance on Question Time appeared to improve your perception of him, which I was surprised about really because I thought it was a complete disaster .

Concerning the 'tired anti elite rhetoric', if we go back to the days of the bail out and bankers bonuses people were all for this. People didn't want huge reckless loses to be socialised and profits privatised. They didn't want more avenues of influence for the few and none for the common man. They realised for a second that we'd been royally f***ed over. That's all forgotten about now because so many are hanging their hat and hopes on UKIP, but little has actually changed. Both of these aspects of society still need addressing and just because the narrative has been solely pushed to immigration, these other problems don't go away.

The irony is, the most likely scenario due to the voting system is that mass support for UKIP will come to very little. When that hope is gone, will it be okay to start talking about the structure of government itself and who they really work for again? Of how your vote 'doesn't count' and hence there is no real choice? Will that be back in vogue then, and suddenly not simplistic and for 'students' and 'idiots' as several others have pointed in this thread. I suspect that it will.


Edited by sanitycheck (13 Dec 2014 12.52pm)

Forgive me for not fannying around with thirty pages of debate. I read the topic, I gave my views.

 

SwalecliffeEagle Flag Swalecliffe 13 Dec 14 3.17pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 13 Dec 2014 12.13pm

H

Quote SwalecliffeEagle at 13 Dec 2014 7.53am

You've got to hand it to him. I mean, he's masterfully constructed this image of himself as a champion of the people. Whilst the majority of adults see him for what he is, he has a strong base of popularity among many naive, young people and he's exploiting it to great effect. Regardless of the whole 'Champagne Socialist' tag that's rightly been pinned onto him, he continues to build his profile through promoting some tenuous connection he has with the working man and disillusioned youth. Anyone watching QT last night can't have missed his syrupy use of the term 'mate', not to mention the clasping of hands together as if in prayer which surely communicates his sincerity.

He addresses ills in the Westminster establishment recklessly but sensationally (because that sells books), advises all young people to boycott elections (which would lead to minority parties he purports to detest gaining the ascendancy), then laments the lack of a clear choice between the parties (yet, in the next breath, he's slating the one party promoting an obvious deviation from the political norm in UKIP).

But his cleverness lies in his ability to critique the establishment and then, when picked up on his suggestions or challenged on matters of substance, he stands back and protests that he's 'not a politician'. Or at least I'd like to think he's clever, because the only other conclusion is that some people are incredibly thick.

Blimey and I thought I was cynical!

I'm just not sure people, Brand included, are that calculating. If Brand has masterfully got youth opinion to where he wants it, what does he get out of it?

I think he's incredibky simplistic and his tired anti-elite rhetoric has nothing to offer, but I think he probably does genuinely believe it and at least he bothers to debate. He could just live the life of riley.

You really think that the revenue he creams off the whole issue is just a side issue? You don't see his book entitled 'Revolution' as exploiting the situation. I respect your views and I don't wish to be a cynic but I find the idea that he's genuinely concerned and right to express his far-fetched suggestions hard to swallow.


Edited by SwalecliffeEagle (13 Dec 2014 3.18pm)

 

sanitycheck Flag 13 Dec 14 3.55pm

Quote SwalecliffeEagle at 13 Dec 2014 3.17pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 13 Dec 2014 12.13pm

H

Quote SwalecliffeEagle at 13 Dec 2014 7.53am

You've got to hand it to him. I mean, he's masterfully constructed this image of himself as a champion of the people. Whilst the majority of adults see him for what he is, he has a strong base of popularity among many naive, young people and he's exploiting it to great effect. Regardless of the whole 'Champagne Socialist' tag that's rightly been pinned onto him, he continues to build his profile through promoting some tenuous connection he has with the working man and disillusioned youth. Anyone watching QT last night can't have missed his syrupy use of the term 'mate', not to mention the clasping of hands together as if in prayer which surely communicates his sincerity.

He addresses ills in the Westminster establishment recklessly but sensationally (because that sells books), advises all young people to boycott elections (which would lead to minority parties he purports to detest gaining the ascendancy), then laments the lack of a clear choice between the parties (yet, in the next breath, he's slating the one party promoting an obvious deviation from the political norm in UKIP).

But his cleverness lies in his ability to critique the establishment and then, when picked up on his suggestions or challenged on matters of substance, he stands back and protests that he's 'not a politician'. Or at least I'd like to think he's clever, because the only other conclusion is that some people are incredibly thick.

Blimey and I thought I was cynical!

I'm just not sure people, Brand included, are that calculating. If Brand has masterfully got youth opinion to where he wants it, what does he get out of it?

I think he's incredibky simplistic and his tired anti-elite rhetoric has nothing to offer, but I think he probably does genuinely believe it and at least he bothers to debate. He could just live the life of riley.

You really think that the revenue he creams off the whole issue is just a side issue? You don't see his book entitled 'Revolution' as exploiting the situation. I respect your views and I don't wish to be a cynic but I find the idea that he's genuinely concerned and right to express his far-fetched suggestions hard to swallow.


Edited by SwalecliffeEagle (13 Dec 2014 3.18pm)

All profits are going to social causes. But of course that won't be good enough, because like the peeling back of layers of an onion it'll be 'prove it', then 'causes for druggies though', then 'well he has enough money anyway so what does it matter' and 'but it still boosts his profile, that's the only reason he's really doing it'. If your mind is made up about someone, it doesn't matter what they do even when it helps others. Just because you dislike someone it doesn't mean they perpetually operate via pure self interest.

Edited by sanitycheck (13 Dec 2014 4.27pm)

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 13 Dec 14 4.54pm

Quote Bubbs at 13 Dec 2014 2.54pm

Anyone else playing the Russell Brand irrational hatred bingo on this thread?

So far I've got student lefty views, simplistic, naïve, Andrew Sachs, bell end, tool, cock, moron, druggy, hippy vote dodger, champagne socialist, gullible followers, unintelligent hypocrite...


You forgot TOSSER!

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

OldFella Flag London 13 Dec 14 5.05pm

Quote sanitycheck at 13 Dec 2014 3.55pm

Quote SwalecliffeEagle at 13 Dec 2014 3.17pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 13 Dec 2014 12.13pm

H

Quote SwalecliffeEagle at 13 Dec 2014 7.53am

You've got to hand it to him. I mean, he's masterfully constructed this image of himself as a champion of the people. Whilst the majority of adults see him for what he is, he has a strong base of popularity among many naive, young people and he's exploiting it to great effect. Regardless of the whole 'Champagne Socialist' tag that's rightly been pinned onto him, he continues to build his profile through promoting some tenuous connection he has with the working man and disillusioned youth. Anyone watching QT last night can't have missed his syrupy use of the term 'mate', not to mention the clasping of hands together as if in prayer which surely communicates his sincerity.

He addresses ills in the Westminster establishment recklessly but sensationally (because that sells books), advises all young people to boycott elections (which would lead to minority parties he purports to detest gaining the ascendancy), then laments the lack of a clear choice between the parties (yet, in the next breath, he's slating the one party promoting an obvious deviation from the political norm in UKIP).

But his cleverness lies in his ability to critique the establishment and then, when picked up on his suggestions or challenged on matters of substance, he stands back and protests that he's 'not a politician'. Or at least I'd like to think he's clever, because the only other conclusion is that some people are incredibly thick.

Blimey and I thought I was cynical!

I'm just not sure people, Brand included, are that calculating. If Brand has masterfully got youth opinion to where he wants it, what does he get out of it?

I think he's incredibky simplistic and his tired anti-elite rhetoric has nothing to offer, but I think he probably does genuinely believe it and at least he bothers to debate. He could just live the life of riley.

You really think that the revenue he creams off the whole issue is just a side issue? You don't see his book entitled 'Revolution' as exploiting the situation. I respect your views and I don't wish to be a cynic but I find the idea that he's genuinely concerned and right to express his far-fetched suggestions hard to swallow.


Edited by SwalecliffeEagle (13 Dec 2014 3.18pm)

All profits are going to social causes. But of course that won't be good enough, because like the peeling back of layers of an onion it'll be 'prove it', then 'causes for druggies though', then 'well he has enough money anyway so what does it matter' and 'but it still boosts his profile, that's the only reason he's really doing it'. If your mind is made up about someone, it doesn't matter what they do even when it helps others. Just because you dislike someone it doesn't mean they perpetually operate via pure self interest.

Edited by sanitycheck (13 Dec 2014 4.27pm)

You should try posting on football for a change. You might get to like it.


 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

sanitycheck Flag 13 Dec 14 5.15pm

Quote OldFella at 13 Dec 2014 5.05pm

Quote sanitycheck at 13 Dec 2014 3.55pm

Quote SwalecliffeEagle at 13 Dec 2014 3.17pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 13 Dec 2014 12.13pm

H

Quote SwalecliffeEagle at 13 Dec 2014 7.53am

You've got to hand it to him. I mean, he's masterfully constructed this image of himself as a champion of the people. Whilst the majority of adults see him for what he is, he has a strong base of popularity among many naive, young people and he's exploiting it to great effect. Regardless of the whole 'Champagne Socialist' tag that's rightly been pinned onto him, he continues to build his profile through promoting some tenuous connection he has with the working man and disillusioned youth. Anyone watching QT last night can't have missed his syrupy use of the term 'mate', not to mention the clasping of hands together as if in prayer which surely communicates his sincerity.

He addresses ills in the Westminster establishment recklessly but sensationally (because that sells books), advises all young people to boycott elections (which would lead to minority parties he purports to detest gaining the ascendancy), then laments the lack of a clear choice between the parties (yet, in the next breath, he's slating the one party promoting an obvious deviation from the political norm in UKIP).

But his cleverness lies in his ability to critique the establishment and then, when picked up on his suggestions or challenged on matters of substance, he stands back and protests that he's 'not a politician'. Or at least I'd like to think he's clever, because the only other conclusion is that some people are incredibly thick.

Blimey and I thought I was cynical!

I'm just not sure people, Brand included, are that calculating. If Brand has masterfully got youth opinion to where he wants it, what does he get out of it?

I think he's incredibky simplistic and his tired anti-elite rhetoric has nothing to offer, but I think he probably does genuinely believe it and at least he bothers to debate. He could just live the life of riley.

You really think that the revenue he creams off the whole issue is just a side issue? You don't see his book entitled 'Revolution' as exploiting the situation. I respect your views and I don't wish to be a cynic but I find the idea that he's genuinely concerned and right to express his far-fetched suggestions hard to swallow.


Edited by SwalecliffeEagle (13 Dec 2014 3.18pm)

All profits are going to social causes. But of course that won't be good enough, because like the peeling back of layers of an onion it'll be 'prove it', then 'causes for druggies though', then 'well he has enough money anyway so what does it matter' and 'but it still boosts his profile, that's the only reason he's really doing it'. If your mind is made up about someone, it doesn't matter what they do even when it helps others. Just because you dislike someone it doesn't mean they perpetually operate via pure self interest.

Edited by sanitycheck (13 Dec 2014 4.27pm)

You should try posting on football for a change. You might get to like it.


You should try reading the topic of this thread, captain sidetrack.

Edited by sanitycheck (13 Dec 2014 5.16pm)

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 13 Dec 14 5.41pm

Quote SwalecliffeEagle at 13 Dec 2014 3.17pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 13 Dec 2014 12.13pm

H

Quote SwalecliffeEagle at 13 Dec 2014 7.53am

You've got to hand it to him. I mean, he's masterfully constructed this image of himself as a champion of the people. Whilst the majority of adults see him for what he is, he has a strong base of popularity among many naive, young people and he's exploiting it to great effect. Regardless of the whole 'Champagne Socialist' tag that's rightly been pinned onto him, he continues to build his profile through promoting some tenuous connection he has with the working man and disillusioned youth. Anyone watching QT last night can't have missed his syrupy use of the term 'mate', not to mention the clasping of hands together as if in prayer which surely communicates his sincerity.

He addresses ills in the Westminster establishment recklessly but sensationally (because that sells books), advises all young people to boycott elections (which would lead to minority parties he purports to detest gaining the ascendancy), then laments the lack of a clear choice between the parties (yet, in the next breath, he's slating the one party promoting an obvious deviation from the political norm in UKIP).

But his cleverness lies in his ability to critique the establishment and then, when picked up on his suggestions or challenged on matters of substance, he stands back and protests that he's 'not a politician'. Or at least I'd like to think he's clever, because the only other conclusion is that some people are incredibly thick.

Blimey and I thought I was cynical!

I'm just not sure people, Brand included, are that calculating. If Brand has masterfully got youth opinion to where he wants it, what does he get out of it?

I think he's incredibky simplistic and his tired anti-elite rhetoric has nothing to offer, but I think he probably does genuinely believe it and at least he bothers to debate. He could just live the life of riley.

You really think that the revenue he creams off the whole issue is just a side issue? You don't see his book entitled 'Revolution' as exploiting the situation. I respect your views and I don't wish to be a cynic but I find the idea that he's genuinely concerned and right to express his far-fetched suggestions hard to swallow.

Edited by SwalecliffeEagle (13 Dec 2014 3.18pm)


I don't think he's selfless, far from it. I think much more than money or power he's in it for the attention. It must be gratifying, living the life of a super-rich celebrity while telling yourself you're improving the world. Believe me, I'm extremely cynical about Russell Brand.

But he's probably less of a hypocrite than, say, Tony Blair, who spent most of the time as prime minister secretly moaning to people about not being as rich as the super-wealth people he got to hang out with.

And maybe it's all a clever act to make money but watching him on QT made me think he does genuinely believe the stuff he goes on about. And while he's no mother theresa, he's certainly no Simon Cowell either.

By the way, I thought your point about criticising westminster and then standing back when it comes to the hard questions was spot on.

He had a go at Creagh and Mordaunt - ''but you're in parliament!!!" - as if they have the power to decide anything! Not even cabinet ministers get to decide stuff nowadays, let alone opposition mps.

But who isn't guilty of that?

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

TUX Flag redhill 13 Dec 14 5.41pm

I think 'Captain' is a few promotions too many.

 

OldFella Flag London 13 Dec 14 6.05pm

Quote TUX at 13 Dec 2014 5.41pm

I think 'Captain' is a few promotions too many.

You and Sanitycheck should get a room : ))


 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

TUX Flag redhill 13 Dec 14 6.48pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 13 Dec 2014 5.41pm

Quote SwalecliffeEagle at 13 Dec 2014 3.17pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 13 Dec 2014 12.13pm

H

Quote SwalecliffeEagle at 13 Dec 2014 7.53am

You've got to hand it to him. I mean, he's masterfully constructed this image of himself as a champion of the people. Whilst the majority of adults see him for what he is, he has a strong base of popularity among many naive, young people and he's exploiting it to great effect. Regardless of the whole 'Champagne Socialist' tag that's rightly been pinned onto him, he continues to build his profile through promoting some tenuous connection he has with the working man and disillusioned youth. Anyone watching QT last night can't have missed his syrupy use of the term 'mate', not to mention the clasping of hands together as if in prayer which surely communicates his sincerity.

He addresses ills in the Westminster establishment recklessly but sensationally (because that sells books), advises all young people to boycott elections (which would lead to minority parties he purports to detest gaining the ascendancy), then laments the lack of a clear choice between the parties (yet, in the next breath, he's slating the one party promoting an obvious deviation from the political norm in UKIP).

But his cleverness lies in his ability to critique the establishment and then, when picked up on his suggestions or challenged on matters of substance, he stands back and protests that he's 'not a politician'. Or at least I'd like to think he's clever, because the only other conclusion is that some people are incredibly thick.

Blimey and I thought I was cynical!

I'm just not sure people, Brand included, are that calculating. If Brand has masterfully got youth opinion to where he wants it, what does he get out of it?

I think he's incredibky simplistic and his tired anti-elite rhetoric has nothing to offer, but I think he probably does genuinely believe it and at least he bothers to debate. He could just live the life of riley.

You really think that the revenue he creams off the whole issue is just a side issue? You don't see his book entitled 'Revolution' as exploiting the situation. I respect your views and I don't wish to be a cynic but I find the idea that he's genuinely concerned and right to express his far-fetched suggestions hard to swallow.

Edited by SwalecliffeEagle (13 Dec 2014 3.18pm)


I don't think he's selfless, far from it. I think much more than money or power he's in it for the attention. It must be gratifying, living the life of a super-rich celebrity while telling yourself you're improving the world. Believe me, I'm extremely cynical about Russell Brand.

But he's probably less of a hypocrite than, say, Tony Blair, who spent most of the time as prime minister secretly moaning to people about not being as rich as the super-wealth people he got to hang out with.

And maybe it's all a clever act to make money but watching him on QT made me think he does genuinely believe the stuff he goes on about. And while he's no mother theresa, he's certainly no Simon Cowell either.

By the way, I thought your point about criticising westminster and then standing back when it comes to the hard questions was spot on.

He had a go at Creagh and Mordaunt - ''but you're in parliament!!!" - as if they have the power to decide anything! Not even cabinet ministers get to decide stuff nowadays, let alone opposition mps.

But who isn't guilty of that?

I agree tbh.

But if attention happens to be his latest 'vice' then it's far less damaging and far more informative to the public at large than his previous vices.
The fact that he 'has no answers' seems to occupy the thoughts of many here. How come?
Why these same people are not concentrating their efforts on those that DO cause the problems HIGHLIGHTED by Brand and several others baffles me.

Each to their own.

Edited by TUX (13 Dec 2014 6.59pm)

 

TUX Flag redhill 13 Dec 14 6.54pm

Quote OldFella at 13 Dec 2014 6.05pm

Quote TUX at 13 Dec 2014 5.41pm

I think 'Captain' is a few promotions too many.

You and Sanitycheck should get a room : ))


I'd love to offer the same advice but I'm guessing finding you a friend would be too tall an order?

It's possibly too late, but maybe Santa can help


 

sanitycheck Flag 13 Dec 14 7.07pm

Quote TUX at 13 Dec 2014 6.48pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 13 Dec 2014 5.41pm

Quote SwalecliffeEagle at 13 Dec 2014 3.17pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 13 Dec 2014 12.13pm

H

Quote SwalecliffeEagle at 13 Dec 2014 7.53am

You've got to hand it to him. I mean, he's masterfully constructed this image of himself as a champion of the people. Whilst the majority of adults see him for what he is, he has a strong base of popularity among many naive, young people and he's exploiting it to great effect. Regardless of the whole 'Champagne Socialist' tag that's rightly been pinned onto him, he continues to build his profile through promoting some tenuous connection he has with the working man and disillusioned youth. Anyone watching QT last night can't have missed his syrupy use of the term 'mate', not to mention the clasping of hands together as if in prayer which surely communicates his sincerity.

He addresses ills in the Westminster establishment recklessly but sensationally (because that sells books), advises all young people to boycott elections (which would lead to minority parties he purports to detest gaining the ascendancy), then laments the lack of a clear choice between the parties (yet, in the next breath, he's slating the one party promoting an obvious deviation from the political norm in UKIP).

But his cleverness lies in his ability to critique the establishment and then, when picked up on his suggestions or challenged on matters of substance, he stands back and protests that he's 'not a politician'. Or at least I'd like to think he's clever, because the only other conclusion is that some people are incredibly thick.

Blimey and I thought I was cynical!

I'm just not sure people, Brand included, are that calculating. If Brand has masterfully got youth opinion to where he wants it, what does he get out of it?

I think he's incredibky simplistic and his tired anti-elite rhetoric has nothing to offer, but I think he probably does genuinely believe it and at least he bothers to debate. He could just live the life of riley.

You really think that the revenue he creams off the whole issue is just a side issue? You don't see his book entitled 'Revolution' as exploiting the situation. I respect your views and I don't wish to be a cynic but I find the idea that he's genuinely concerned and right to express his far-fetched suggestions hard to swallow.

Edited by SwalecliffeEagle (13 Dec 2014 3.18pm)


I don't think he's selfless, far from it. I think much more than money or power he's in it for the attention. It must be gratifying, living the life of a super-rich celebrity while telling yourself you're improving the world. Believe me, I'm extremely cynical about Russell Brand.

But he's probably less of a hypocrite than, say, Tony Blair, who spent most of the time as prime minister secretly moaning to people about not being as rich as the super-wealth people he got to hang out with.

And maybe it's all a clever act to make money but watching him on QT made me think he does genuinely believe the stuff he goes on about. And while he's no mother theresa, he's certainly no Simon Cowell either.

By the way, I thought your point about criticising westminster and then standing back when it comes to the hard questions was spot on.

He had a go at Creagh and Mordaunt - ''but you're in parliament!!!" - as if they have the power to decide anything! Not even cabinet ministers get to decide stuff nowadays, let alone opposition mps.

But who isn't guilty of that?

I agree tbh.

If attention happens to be his latest 'vice' then it's far less damaging and far more informative to the public at large than his previous vices.
The fact that he 'has no answers' seems to occupy the thoughts of many here. How come?
Why these same people are not concentrating their efforts on those that DO cause the problems HIGHLIGHTED by Brand and several others baffles me.

Each to their own.

When the front page of every trashy newspaper states 'Brand is a Nobhead' as the most important story of the moment it's little wonder people end up being preoccupied with that thought too. As you say though, it acts to get people from talking about the actual concerns he's raising and to undermine them by proxy. Rather clever, as in actually clever, not the kind of "I'm Columbo, Brand's been found out" clever that some are patting themselves on the back about here.

Edited by sanitycheck (13 Dec 2014 7.11pm)

 

Dougiecito Flag In a dreamworld 13 Dec 14 8.51pm

Russell Brand. Two words associated with cattle and you lot are grilling him!

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 13 Dec 14 9.08pm

Oh by the way Tux bud, whilst waiting on my Roast potatoes the other night you happened to say in an earlier post that I was obsessed with rusty rockets. So I did a quick count through of this thread ( sad I know but I like crispy roast spuds) and for the record you've posted approx 40 times ME about 10. Just Saying..

 


Pro USA & Israel

Page 19 of 25 < 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Russell Brand - class warrior or complete bell end