Quote legaleagle at 30 Jul 2015 9.04am
Quote leggedstruggle at 30 Jul 2015 7.46am
Quote legaleagle at 29 Jul 2015 10.52pm
You make a fair point about the scandal of unoccupied homes.
In 2014,it was estimated that there were 700,000 unoccupied homes in the UK but 2 million in France.In terms of the present situation in France, there are legitimate questions as to why the French government has seemingly been not unhappy to let large numbers live in squalor near Calais rather than taking steps to deal with aspects of that.
It would seem many are "economic migrants" as opposed to asylum seekers".We have pretty strong immigration policies in place re anyone who is not an EU national (or closely related) seeking to enter and I would suggest pretty strong "border control" (not least because we are an island) compared to many EU countries.
In relation to the humanitarian crisis arising from many travelling from outside the EU into the EU,I can see the force of the argument for humanitarian resettlement being evenly spread (according to population etc) around the EU,including the UK.It is difficult to suggest we are or are likely to be worse off than say Greece or Italy in terms of any present/up to now "burden".
In terms of anyone wishing to seek asylum,I am a strong supporter of the UN convention regulating asylum and refugees and from my work (admittedly 30 years ago) advising asylum applicants precisely how so many are not economic migrants/after claiming benefits but people escaping hellish persecution/discrimination.But there would seem to be some logic to anyone claiming asylum needing to do first it either in the first "safe" place they reach after leaving where they live or (for example with Yugoslavs already abroad when the wars broke out there in the 1990's) the country someone is in when the situation arises at home making it inappropriate for them to have to return.
Edited by legaleagle (29 Jul 2015 11.10pm)
LOL, you do make one laugh.
Why don't these "people escaping hellish persecution/discrimination" flee to nearer countries, say Rumania, Bulgaria - do you think it just possible that the lure of housing, benefit handouts and the prospect of irresponsible fools like you supporting them might come into it?
Edited by leggedstruggle (30 Jul 2015 7.46am)
I am glad "the fool" has made "the idiot" laugh
The majority in Calais,as I stated,are not asylum seekers.However, no doubt to your mind all are one and the same being Johnny non-European foreigner.
Welfare benefits are "better" in France and Germany than in the UK.But again don't let that stand in the way of your tunnel-visioned prejudices.In any event,economic migrants (not asylum seekers) are attracted to the UK as a place to make something of themselves,ie perceived economic oportunities to work, not to claim benefits.Coupled with the global use of English and people wishing to go somewhere where a language they have some knowledge of is spoken.
Turning to the minority of those in Calais seeking asylum and taking your "logic" that they head towards the UK solely becausde the benefits-claiming potential is best,in terms of reality as opposed to prejudice,its worth looking at the most recent statistics for 2014 for people seeking asylum within Europe....France over 64,000,Germany over 203,000,Sweden over 80,000,Italy over 65,000,Hungary over 42,000, and the UK behind all of those at over 31,000.
Where in my post above am I "supporting" illegal entry? But,again, don't let your tunnel visioned prejudices stand in the way of that...
Incidentally,your examples of Romania and Bulgaria are silly anyway,given their geographical location,so most unlikely to be a logical "first safe country" a person seeking asylum would come to.
Edited by legaleagle (30 Jul 2015 9.14am)
At least you accept that the majority are not in fact asylum seekers at all (although you go on to describe them as "seeking asylum"
. As they are not asylum seekers, would you agree that we have no responsibility whatsoever to have them here then? How many are you going to put up in your spare rooms at Legaleagle Towers by the way?