You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Brighton abuse
November 16 2026 8.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Brighton abuse


Page 19 of 20 < 15 16 17 18 19 20 >
Direwolf Flag Lincoln 31 Jul 17 3.32pm

Originally posted by eddiqc

What a load of bollocks.. If I was gay, I wouldn't care if people called me queer or a bender, etc.. because being offended by those "insults" would mean that I'm ashamed of it.
Bloody leftist idiots need to grow some balls, insults are both part of life and sports.

Presumably you are not gay so how can you know whether you would care or not?

 

eddiqc Flag Tunbridge wells 31 Jul 17 5.25pm

Are you saying that I don't know my own personality?

 

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 31 Jul 17 5.39pm

Originally posted by eddiqc

Are you saying that I don't know my own personality?

Not at all - I'm sure you know your own personality very well. My question is how can you know that you would react in exactly the same way whether you were gay or not? Surely your current reaction is based on your current situation?

 

eddiqc Flag Tunbridge wells 31 Jul 17 7.52pm

I see what you mean, but I have received the same level abuse for other things and I don't let it bother me. Water off a ducks back my friend.

Edited by eddiqc (31 Jul 2017 7.53pm)

 

Podyonkers Flag Atlanta, Georgia 31 Jul 17 7.54pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

What is 'toss'? Do you mean Yids? Never heard of 'toss'. Well, plenty of Spurs fans themselves refer to 'The Yid Army' so I don't think they are being anti-semitic.

Intent is everything. If Palace chanting was intent on targeting the gay community then 'yes' it is homophobia. But i don't think the chanting is. It's directed at Brighton fans.

I wouldn't miss it if it stopped and have never indulged myself in the chanting but I see this as too accusatory.

Just to address this particular point, I would disagree that "intent is everything."

One way to look at this is through the eyes of the gay community. Seems only fair, since the OP is asking us to do just that. It's up to us all to decide whether he has a fair point. And one way to make that determination is to ask, "What if it were me?"

So, I think it's worth extrapolating; finding a different cause, for example - one that hits closer to home. What if you lost a member of your family to suicide? What if your little sister has Downs Syndrome? What if your brother is transgender? What if your family has had to deal with the tragedy of losing a family member to Alzheimers disease recently? There are lots of what-ifs, and lots of people in this world who are marginalized or dealing with disadvantage.

Now, imagine that just after you lost your family member to suicide there was a chant aimed at, say, Leeds United because Gary Speed killed himself? The justification might be, "Well, it's not aimed at Gary Speed. It's just a wind-up. Besides, intent is everything." Imagine how you would feel as the crowd around you made a joke about something that your family just experienced. I would imagine you'd be fairly upset, and unwilling to sing along.

That's how the gay community feels when they hear homophobic chants.

 


Stealing their women and eating their food since 1987.

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 31 Jul 17 8.58pm

Originally posted by eddiqc

I see what you mean, but I have received the same level abuse for other things and I don't let it bother me. Water off a ducks back my friend.

Edited by eddiqc (31 Jul 2017 7.53pm)

You have an admirable level of tolerance for abuse sir. I'm not sure I would be as tolerant of abuse that was directed at some facet of myself, be it sexual orientation or some other characteristic.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 31 Jul 17 10.28pm


This is very much like the concern shown when black players came onto the scene. There were ranks of Liverpool fans barracking Vince Hillaire for being whatever, but their best and most loved player was John Barnes. There is a sort of humour here. There have been some suspected gays in Palace teams over the years and rumour has it one was transferred out as he caused problems in the dressing room. A good player too. But what reason do you give to the buying team as a reason to ofr-load the player? He went on to better things.
A player at Reading almost gave the game up because of the remarks concerning his ginger hair. Another good player. Quite a handy tool to have is an element that can make a player not want to perform on the other side. According to Ian Wright Jim Cannon made his life hell on the training ground with racist banter. The toughening-up process. Did John Terry really hate Fernandez? Believe that and be gullible.

 

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 01 Aug 17 12.59am

We'll just shout "Eagles eat seagull" to the tune of the "Hes just too good for you," and then proceed to watch Wilf tear them apart again.

 


[Link]

Nevada Eagle Flag Carson City, Nevada 01 Aug 17 5.46am

BHA abuse? ABUSE THEM ALL YOU CAN!

 


Sing up ya bums

eddiqc Flag Tunbridge wells 01 Aug 17 8.31am

Originally posted by Direwolf

You have an admirable level of tolerance for abuse sir. I'm not sure I would be as tolerant of abuse that was directed at some facet of myself, be it sexual orientation or some other characteristic.

I wouldnt call it tolerance for abuse, I just don't care what some random person thinks of me. The only people in my life that matter are my friends and family.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 01 Aug 17 10.12am

Originally posted by eddiqc

I wouldnt call it tolerance for abuse, I just don't care what some random person thinks of me. The only people in my life that matter are my friends and family.

Its admirable that you are able to ignore personal jibes and realise the opinions of your loved ones are far more important. But we need to draw the line somewhere on this. Imagine you are passing a person in the street who is being roundly verbally abused on a personal level by another, causing that person to wilt. Would you really just ignore it and say its nothing to do with me as i can take that kind of abuse anyway?
I'm no brave hero but I would find it hard to one intervene. So when I'm sitting next to someone at a football match who is behaving in that abusive manner at the club I love and have supported for a long time, should I not feel responsible for taking some kind of control?

 

eddiqc Flag Tunbridge wells 01 Aug 17 11.14am

Well, I never said I don't care if other people are being verbally abused. I was merely saying that *I* wouldn't be affected if the abuse was directed at me.
I always protect people on the street when I see any kind of abuse being directed at them, but that's a different kettle of fish in my opinion. I honestly don't think that anyone at a football match should take the banter / jeers seriously. There is no right or wrong answer here, it's all a matter of opinion.

 

Mr_Flow Flag London 01 Aug 17 11.23am

Originally posted by eddiqc

What a load of bollocks.. If I was gay, I wouldn't care if people called me queer or a bender, etc.. because being offended by those "insults" would mean that I'm ashamed of it.
Bloody leftist idiots need to grow some balls, insults are both part of life and sports.

Out of interest, what would your stance be on people calling people names relating to racial descriptions? Is this acceptable?

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 01 Aug 17 11.25am

I'm not gay myself and wouldn't abuse any gay fan weather he or she support Brighton or whoever as I know some gay people who I would call friends.

My best mates sister is gay.she prefers women to men,so what.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 01 Aug 17 11.58am

Originally posted by eddiqc

Well, I never said I don't care if other people are being verbally abused. I was merely saying that *I* wouldn't be affected if the abuse was directed at me.
I always protect people on the street when I see any kind of abuse being directed at them, but that's a different kettle of fish in my opinion. I honestly don't think that anyone at a football match should take the banter / jeers seriously. There is no right or wrong answer here, it's all a matter of opinion.

Thats a good reply and i didnt seroously think you or many would cross the road as i suggested. But someone being aggressive in a humorous manner may not be a reason to ignore it. But, yes, as i previously posted, football fans do have a fantastic sense of humour and mustnt be taken seriously as they dont mean it seriously. But other less appreciative, let's say more challenged fans will take this seriously and Jon in, in a full scale aggressive manner. Perhaps the Stilling arm of a more mature person is called for.
I went into a pub recently and got talking to a bunch of Shrewsbury supporters (yes there are some) and one said, in an aggressive manner he thought I was gay. Rather than take offence and kicking-off, I replied it was funny how far some will go to get a blow job, and, after a short pause, l told him he was safe as i only go for the good looking ones. Laughter from his mates, and eventually him. I'm just glad I wasn't too wasted when he made that remark and when my missus turned up to run me home she gave the bloke a peck on the cheek to show how much she missed male contact! Lol

Edited by adrian b (01 Aug 2017 12.01pm)

 

eddiqc Flag Tunbridge wells 01 Aug 17 12.23pm

Originally posted by Mr_Flow

Out of interest, what would your stance be on people calling people names relating to racial descriptions? Is this acceptable?

People react differently to racial abuse. I'm half French (one of the many reasons I love Cabaye ), I spent many years being insulted for it, I never cared and still don't give a damn. I know it's not the same as being called the n word for example, but it is similar.
I know quite a few coloured people who just laugh it off, but others who get deeply offended by it. It really depends on the personality of the victim.
To answer your question though - I don't agree with racism and it definitely isn't used in a lighthearted manner or as banter in football.

 

eddiqc Flag Tunbridge wells 01 Aug 17 12.33pm

Originally posted by adrian b

Thats a good reply and i didnt seroously think you or many would cross the road as i suggested. But someone being aggressive in a humorous manner may not be a reason to ignore it. But, yes, as i previously posted, football fans do have a fantastic sense of humour and mustnt be taken seriously as they dont mean it seriously. But other less appreciative, let's say more challenged fans will take this seriously and Jon in, in a full scale aggressive manner. Perhaps the Stilling arm of a more mature person is called for.
I went into a pub recently and got talking to a bunch of Shrewsbury supporters (yes there are some) and one said, in an aggressive manner he thought I was gay. Rather than take offence and kicking-off, I replied it was funny how far some will go to get a blow job, and, after a short pause, l told him he was safe as i only go for the good looking ones. Laughter from his mates, and eventually him. I'm just glad I wasn't too wasted when he made that remark and when my missus turned up to run me home she gave the bloke a peck on the cheek to show how much she missed male contact! Lol

Edited by adrian b (01 Aug 2017 12.01pm)

Nice story, that's the same sort of thing I'd do.
I don't see the point of reacting to situations like that in an aggressive manner, who does it help? What good does it do?
With regards to the section in bold. I completely agree. Once there is no jocular intent, then clearly there is something wrong that needs to be addressed. Unfortunately it is difficult to quell someone's anger in situations such as those, but that's not to say that one shouldn't try.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Aug 17 12.43pm

This 'abuse' and so called 'homophobic aggression' is continuing to be exaggerated. What was a juvenile song sung by about half a block in total is being made into something more. Carry on if you must.

 


COYP

sa_eagle Flag Just outside Cape Town 01 Aug 17 12.43pm

Saw this on iPlayer but sadly it turned out to be unconnected BHAFC.

Brighton.png Attachment: Brighton.png (108.14Kb)

 


Cynic or realist? It's a fine line!

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 24 Sep 17 2.51pm

Emma from @proud+palace is on the holradio pod tonight.

Well worth listening.

 

Page 19 of 20 < 15 16 17 18 19 20 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Brighton abuse