You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 7.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 19 of 71 < 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 >
lefty27 Flag ipswich 28 Oct 18 11.45pm

It was ok today, but went so flat at 1-1, you’d have thought we were losing. All picked up at 2-2 mind, sat in the Whitehorse with my boy for the first time in years and could only hear the Arsenal. Always wondered why sit the away fans next to the family stand?
Bit disappointing the HF not returning now they have got what they want.

 

.TUX. Flag 29 Oct 18 6.29am

Originally posted by bicycle repair man


Absolutely, today clearly shows the choirboys are irrelevant.
The team and supporters were terrific,we don't need an embarrassingly concocted "singing" section.
All Palace fans should be equal,and an "atmosphere" at a game should evolve naturally,as it did this afternoon.

Quite the opposite but keep on dreaming.

 


Buy Litecoin.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Oct 18 8.15am

Originally posted by lefty27

It was ok today, but went so flat at 1-1, you’d have thought we were losing. All picked up at 2-2 mind, sat in the Whitehorse with my boy for the first time in years and could only hear the Arsenal. Always wondered why sit the away fans next to the family stand?
Bit disappointing the HF not returning now they have got what they want.

They were moved there because the policing charges are much lower than when they were next to blocks A,B,C of the lower Holmesdale and the HF. That was in the championship when we were losing £5 mil each year before we sold a more valuable player to cover it.

 


COYP

becky Flag over the moon 29 Oct 18 8.48am

Originally posted by Mapletree

I didn’t think the atmosphere was that great considering the excitement of the game

I wonder if that could be because people were too busy watching an exciting game of football to be arsed about singing the latest chorus?

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Oct 18 8.51am

Originally posted by becky

I wonder if that could be because people were too busy watching an exciting game of football to be arsed about singing the latest chorus?

Your voice and singing shouldn’t impair your vision and never has before when we’ve had a real atmosphere.

And that bit in bold explains a lot on why the atmosphere has been so sh1t. Thank you.

 


COYP

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 29 Oct 18 8.55am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Your voice and singing shouldn’t impair your vision and never has before when we’ve had a real atmosphere.

And that bit in bold explains a lot on why the atmosphere has been so sh1t. Thank you.

^^^ This ^^^

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 29 Oct 18 9.00am

Originally posted by becky

I wonder if that could be because people were too busy watching an exciting game of football to be arsed about singing the latest chorus?

Exactly becky..

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 29 Oct 18 9.19am

Originally posted by becky

I wonder if that could be because people were too busy watching an exciting game of football to be arsed about singing the latest chorus?

I'd say that's very much the case; it's what most normal people attend a football match for.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Oct 18 9.25am

Originally posted by bexleydave

I'd say that's very much the case; it's what most normal people attend a football match for.

You can’t sing and watch at the same time?

Some of this site’s well known radio presenters can completely absorb the game and sing. Hambo?

 


COYP

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 29 Oct 18 10.46am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

You can’t sing and watch at the same time?

Some of this site’s well known radio presenters can completely absorb the game and sing. Hambo?

Most of the (so-called) HF had their backs turned away from the game at most matches, so NO, you(they) can't.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Oct 18 10.47am

Originally posted by eagleman13

Most of the (so-called) HF had their backs turned away from the game at most matches, so NO, you(they) can't.

It was about 3 or 4 who didn’t watch the game actually. The other 196 did, so did the hundreds or thousands around them.

 


COYP

fromtherope Flag In the woods of deepest Surrey 29 Oct 18 11.52am

Steve Parish is a fool. His decision to kick out hundreds of loyal longstanding supporters for the sake of a few noisy kids is the daftest I have ever seen in football, and football is full of daft things!

All so he can promote the "brand".

I know a good number of people who sit in Block E, one group is a family & friends of ten. They will not be able to sit together elsewhere in the ground, confirmed by the ticket office, and they will not be coming back next season. So not only does the club lose ten incredibly loyal season ticket holders they have also lost already the goodwill of those who are mates of the BLOCK E REFUGEES

Parish won't change his mind so it is a lost cause. A shame for a club that has always been proud of it's loyal fan based and family.

 


I am enjoying being back at Selhurst and having a beer with my mates just like we have done for the past 40 years. Through Thick and thin we stick with our club. Not chairman, players or managers, OUR CLUB!

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 29 Oct 18 11.57am

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

You are talking complete and utter nonsense.

hello pot this is Kettle


The so called HF are a passing fad,

The fanatics formed in 2005 so I wouldnt call 13 years a passing fad ? Maybe You'd call CPFC2010 a passing fad ??

whereas Marge and Bert are the life blood of the club,who turned up during the bad times ,and will still turn up when inevitably the bad times return.

The life blood of the club is the TV money like it or lump it gate receipts from any of us are not the main bread winner for any clubs in the prem any more, it's sky's money and merchandise that is the main bread winner, and for your info I've been going to football at Selhurst since I was 6 41 years ago. And in my opinion the HF create an atmosphere unparalleled through out my time at the club. The display at the FA Cup final was surley the best in the FA cups history.

If the HF believe they have such an influence over the team's performance then they have betrayed the Palace by disbanding,and if we are relegated this season,it will be partly down to them in that case.
What you said " in the pub the other night" means diddly.

I don't profess to know what the HF think, what I am giving you is my own personnel opinion, which is just as valid as yours. if we are relegated this season it will be because we don't have a goal scorer, which is criminal considering how long we have had to get one. That fault lies firmly with the board and people who run the club. However I do believe that the atmosphere does help the players, so yes in a certain type of warped context you could be right, and I have never said that the HF have behaved with nothing but the best intrest of the club, a lot of it smacks of spoilt brat type behaviour. However the undeniable fact is that the atmosphere is better with that without.

Furthermore what you say on a football website means diddly as well.

Marge and Bert have paid their dues and have every right to retain their seats,they won't flounce off if things aren't going well on the pitch.

Errrrm that's BS I've been going a long time as have you no doubt, and I can remember getting 7-8000 if we were lucky, so no I'm not having that one. And whilst they may have paid there dues it gives them no more right than anyone else in the ground who buys a ticket. They do not own the seat for which they pay. i've had the same one for about 6 years now and would move if it meant the atmosphere coming back.

There's more to supporting Palace through the generations than waving flags and banging drums.

Is there? Because from where I sit those fans in the HF have followed the club through thick and thin up and down the country for well over a decade. I thought as fans we were there to get behind the team and sing our hearts and souls out supporting the team or am I wrong ?


The harsh reality is that Marge and Bert are the club,they are the ones that support the Palace even when times are at their worst.

The harsh reality is that Marge and Bert are no more important to the club than the HF FACT. However in this case the HF offer more in the way of physical support lots more in fact. And as such should be rightly recognised for it.

Give me one solid tangible reason based in fact that you could argue for them not moving ? Not wanting to move because "I've been here years" is almost bordering on being egocentric.

All I have done is way up the pro's and con's of upsetting (for want of a better word) each group of fans, and they HF simply offer more to the club as fans. Now you might not like that FACT. but it is an undeniable one.

And Eagle man 13, I'm surprised at you, you know me try not to be so condescending, we clearly disagree but I'm allowed my opinion, as you are yours, making assumptions about me is making things a tad personnel. Lets not go there.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 29 Oct 18 12.20pm

I spoke to a member of PTID (NOT the HF but apparently close to them) on Sunday

His belief is that nobody will be forced out. In his opinion those people that ask to stay put and become a part of the singing section will be able to do that

I await anyone in authority confirming that.

If it is true then I am happy, I wouldn't have minded moving into the HF in any case so them coming to me is fine. As long as they show respect to us old uns, which I suspect is not entirely guaranteed.

 

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 29 Oct 18 12.48pm

This whole fiasco is a farce,childish,petty,pathetic and embarrassing.
The slags on the south coast are pissin themselves,with the choir boys,going on strike.

Block B was where the choir boys were and that is where they should have stayed,until the new stand is built.
The club would then have been able to give advance notice (2 years at least ) that this move was going to happen and they would also have been able to give E block first dibs on the new stand.

By the way I like what the choir boys did with the banners and the added atmosphere (home and away) but Block B was their home.
I notice its called a singing section now,not the HF,wonder why ?


 

turbohorsebox Flag Coulsdon 29 Oct 18 12.55pm

Originally posted by ZIGnZAG

25 year season ticket...

Is that seriously a thing?
How much did it cost?
Why 25years?
What if you died?

I went to one of the dinners where Jordan was trying to sell these. Started off at 50 years but there was a 25 year offer as well.

Cant remember how much it was but it was significantly cheaper than buying annually.

And you could bequeath it when you died.

I didn't take up the offer, but the dinner was nice!

Thinking about it, it was good of the current owners to honour the commitment.

 


All good. Nothing bad.

soulboy Flag Lewisham 29 Oct 18 1.35pm

Originally posted by bexleydave

I'd say that's very much the case; it's what most normal people attend a football match for.

Erm, your indifference to singing seems to be at odds with your tag-line that berates Brighton's inability to raise an audible chorus?

 


"Deviance is a freedom enjoyed in a city of lightly engaged strangers"

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Oct 18 1.46pm

Originally posted by soulboy

Erm, your indifference to singing seems to be at odds with your tag-line that berates Brighton's inability to raise an audible chorus?

Ha ha ha.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Oct 18 1.46pm

Well said above, Dannyh.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Oct 18 1.50pm

Originally posted by aquickgame2

This whole fiasco is a farce,childish,petty,pathetic and embarrassing.
The slags on the south coast are pissin themselves,with the choir boys,going on strike.

Block B was where the choir boys were and that is where they should have stayed,until the new stand is built.
The club would then have been able to give advance notice (2 years at least ) that this move was going to happen and they would also have been able to give E block first dibs on the new stand.

By the way I like what the choir boys did with the banners and the added atmosphere (home and away) but Block B was their home.
I notice its called a singing section now,not the HF,wonder why ?


Rumours are the new stand is a lot of years away.

When we get our atmosphere back they’ll be singing their cringe ‘Ole Ole Ole Ole seagulls’’, which I heard on MOTD. Our singing comes from an independent bunch of Palace fans and always has. No song sheets or clappers or free club flags. Fans fund it when needed.

I couldn’t give a shoit what they think once we’ve restored our atmosphere, however it happens. At the moment you have to ignore any taunts until then.

 


COYP

Page 19 of 71 < 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic