You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?
November 16 2026 7.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?


Page 19 of 44 < 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 >
Maine Eagle Flag USA 10 Dec 18 5.10am

Hodgson must be backed in January or fired beforehand.

We are in a perilous situation at the moment.

Parish has failed to assemble a proper squad in terms of the final third, we are short not 1 or 2 but possibly 3 or 4 players. Recent signings of attackers have been seriously poor. We have no game changers or any players which can worry a defense outside of Wilf.

Hodgson has failed fo adapt to the situation he finds himself in and currently we don’t have the Fulham Roy but the Harry Kane taking corners version.

Not making a single change after Brighton considering the performance there and that it was 3 games in a week is criminal. Not giving Riedewald a proper chance is criminal whilst we give minutes to Puncheon. Not at least having Kaikai on the bench is criminal.

After Brighton he had to make changes. He is a massive fan of inaction.

Hodgson is so old fashioned and rigid with his team selections and in game management and it’s really hurting us lately.

He needs a squad to work with that he actually believes in or he needs to be fired.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Painter Flag Croydon 10 Dec 18 8.14am

Originally posted by Den1923

Sadly, SP records speaks for itself, 6 years in PL and no progress, he is obsessed about the stadium refurbishment, which will look great in the championship half empty, he has regularly botched up transfer deals that are consistently left to the last minute and then fall through. The club is toxic from within, evidenced by quality players talking to the club but then the deal never gets over the line. Freedman is the Director of Football in name only because he has done nothing to get players in, probably, he is not allowed enough rope by SP. Good previous managers have fallen out with SP. He has allowed us to drift with a paper thin squad for over two years now and without a decent striker for over 12 months and then there is just three wins this season and if we do go down he would have overseen the biggest loss in revenue in the clubs history, not a bad record I suppose?

As for the other board member they are responsible for allowing him to get this far without questioning him on his performance which is at best E-.

You answered your point in your first sentence. Overseeing 6 years in the Premier, which hasn’t been achieved by any previous Chairman.
This doesn’t mean by any means everything in the garden is rosey quite patently there are problems.
Biggest lost in revenue in our history! He increased the revenue to that level, you can’t have it both ways.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 10 Dec 18 8.18am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Hodgson must be backed in January or fired beforehand.

We are in a perilous situation at the moment.

Parish has failed to assemble a proper squad in terms of the final third, we are short not 1 or 2 but possibly 3 or 4 players. Recent signings of attackers have been seriously poor. We have no game changers or any players which can worry a defense outside of Wilf.

Hodgson has failed fo adapt to the situation he finds himself in and currently we don’t have the Fulham Roy but the Harry Kane taking corners version.

Not making a single change after Brighton considering the performance there and that it was 3 games in a week is criminal. Not giving Riedewald a proper chance is criminal whilst we give minutes to Puncheon. Not at least having Kaikai on the bench is criminal.

After Brighton he had to make changes. He is a massive fan of inaction.

Hodgson is so old fashioned and rigid with his team selections and in game management and it’s really hurting us lately.

He needs a squad to work with that he actually believes in or he needs to be fired.

There are reports on here, that Reideweld played for the U23s in the week and was terrible looked unfit and overweight. None of us watch the players train, quite obviously none impress to push for a starting place.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Dec 18 8.29am

Originally posted by Painter

There are reports on here, that Reideweld played for the U23s in the week and was terrible looked unfit and overweight. None of us watch the players train, quite obviously none impress to push for a starting place.

Supporters wish Hodgson was more flexible with his team selections and substitutions but his options are really limited with the players he has at his disposal.His hands are really tied and for that reason I have sympathy for him.

Newcastle who finished 10th last season are having difficulties at present but their supporters revere Benitez and their wrath is aimed at Ashley for what they see as under-investment in their team.Newcastle's net spend in summer was £8 Mill not short of our net spend of £10 Mill.

 

The Dolphin Flag 10 Dec 18 8.35am

The whole club is a bit of a mess really but I don't hold RH responsible.
He makes mistakes of course but that happens week in and out at every club.
Manager after Manager, letting core players go too early (Pardew's reign), the transfer policy generally.
There is so much that needs sorting out but every season we just end up fighting fires and there never seems to be a way forward.
Relegation, like it or not might be the best way to take stock of the situation and get ourselves back on track.

 

The Dolphin Flag 10 Dec 18 8.38am

[Link]

and then I saw this in another thread - absolutely spot on!

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 10 Dec 18 8.54am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

[Link]

and then I saw this in another thread - absolutely spot on!

Well it sums up what a number of people have been saying on here.

The only bit I have issue with is the assumption that the likes of Kirby and Daly will break through into the first team. And relegation would put huge pressure on the justification for building the new stand.

I'm surprised that the until now passive investors of Harris and Blitzer haven't started challenging the way Parish is running the club.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Dec 18 8.58am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Well it sums up what a number of people have been saying on here.

The only bit I have issue with is the assumption that the likes of Kirby and Daly will break through into the first team. And relegation would put huge pressure on the justification for building the new stand.

I'm surprised that the until now passive investors of Harris and Blitzer haven't started challenging the way Parish is running the club.

Supporters of course don't know what goes on behind the scenes in relation to the conversations between Harris,Blitzer and Parish.

 

leejaneagles Flag 10 Dec 18 9.01am

Originally posted by Willo

Supporters wish Hodgson was more flexible with his team selections and substitutions but his options are really limited with the players he has at his disposal.His hands are really tied and for that reason I have sympathy for him.

Newcastle who finished 10th last season are having difficulties at present but their supporters revere Benitez and their wrath is aimed at Ashley for what they see as under-investment in their team.Newcastle's net spend in summer was £8 Mill not short of our net spend of £10 Mill.

This is a really good point. Newcastle and us are in almost completely the same position but presumably because their Manager is Spanish, in his 50's and has the look of someone that knows what he's doing, is receiving none of the criticism.

I remember how long people were still defending Frank De Boer last season, presumably because of the same reasons that people had been duped into thinking he was a Jose or a Pep.

When you think what Roy done for us last season, after that start, there should be no questioning his ability or if he's at fault. It's obvious he achieved miracles with a very poor team that still had Cabaye, Loftus-Cheek and purely from a formation/tactic perspective, Christian Benteke.

You can't ask someone to do the impossible 2 times in a row, this time with an even worse squad.

The lack of respect he gets from some is astounding. He's still called 'Woy' by some on here because of his speach impedement. I've seen comments that say Roy looks like 'he doesn't know where he is', presumably because like most 71 year olds he has some wrinkles and sunken in tired eyes.

Swap the 2 Manager's and I think Newcastle fans would be happy to support Roy if he done the same for them last season and lay the blame solely at the feet of Ashley. But if we had Benitez, even if we were a couple of points worse off, I don't think many would be questioning him on here.

 

Den1923 Flag 10 Dec 18 9.12am

Originally posted by sprites

Never heard such tosh.

Every single one of our first 11 would walk into any championship squad. 5 or 6 of them would walk into most premiership teams outside the top 10.

Then there's our squad players, who are also decent championship level - Punch, Riederwald, Kelly, Ward etc.

Clearly you do not watch them very often, if you think three wins from 16 is good then I'm on the wrong planet, face facts we have given Soton there only win this season so far and we shipped three goal in about twenty minutes against West Ham and before that Brighton!

 

Aray Flag South London 10 Dec 18 9.17am

Very sound analysis here robdave - the midfield isn't balance and playing our wingers as forwards isn't working. time for a reset Roy

Originally posted by robdave2k

Well the one saving grace is that is about £220m out of his price range.

Hodgson to me just looks tired. I think the England situation damaged him. Last season he was on a hiding to nothing as we were gone. There was no expectation so it was a free shot. Much like when he took over with England.

When the expectation kicks in that’s where it becomes an issue.

He never fancied Zaha for England and Roy’s approach is safety first. Unfortunately sides are figuring him out. Our wingbacks are attacking and neither mark up particularly close. PVA in particular. They then have MacArthur and Meyer in front of them - not Wilf and Andros so are caught.

Even Sam preferred Schlupp to PVA to start and in a side that needs to be defensively sound PVA wouldn’t be my first name on the sheet. Schlupp is a woeful footballer, but he doesn’t spend the game thinking he is a right winger when playing left back.

It’s all a bit Mike Bassett. The flair players are being asked to do a job that isn’t there normal one - negating them. Meyer and MacArthur aren’t wingers. But they are being asked to do the same - now you have four players out. Luka doesn’t have Cabaye anymore and doesn’t have Meyer either as he is out of position.

There is no point having two defensive midfielders if your fullbacks are being found out and things are coming from crosses.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Dec 18 9.26am

Originally posted by Aray

Very sound analysis here robdave - the midfield isn't balance and playing our wingers as forwards isn't working. time for a reset Roy

Because Hodgson understandably just doesn't trust the recognised forwards to deliver which is a sad indictment of our strength in forward areas.

When one purchases two forwards and wingers are preferred to them in their natural position what message does this send out to Messrs Sorloth and Ayew ?

Get a Rondon type player, have Zaha and Townsend in their natural positions, bring in a player like a Fabregas or Shelvey and we would see a significant improvement.

 

Aray Flag South London 10 Dec 18 10.05am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

[Link]

and then I saw this in another thread - absolutely spot on!

His analysis of where we have gone wrong has something going for it - who can argue we have poor infrastructure and appalling scouting. But personally I can see some considerable flaws in his approach. As for his main conclusions, well I disagree almost completely.

Lets remember we got promoted way earlier than expected and the club has made a series of mistakes - Holloway and Pardew - that we are still rectifying.

Also remember that Pulis managed to build a legacy at Stoke but by the end the fans were begging for him to leave. As for Big Sam, who thinks he was ever going to be happy at a small club - with a small budget? Sorry to say it but he's a dinosaur too.

Where the author is completely wrong is to suggest we have only one option but to accept our fate. Why?

There's no proof that we go down and bounce back up - where the author is correct is that we could easily become a Sunderland, or Bolton, if we didn't return quickly!

We'd risk our squad being subject to a firesale, with the strong possibility we'd only have the dross left. Unless we have a host of quality youth player ready to go - we'll be struggling with a demoralised set up against the better funded Villas and Stokes etc. I cannot believe anyone would willingly vote for that. No thanks!

And why would we get a great young manager just because we're in the Championship? The whole conclusion is a fallacy.

From a hiring perspective, we're a better prospect now because we have 13/14 good players and around half are actually of real quality.

Where he is onto something is about trying to break the mold from a manager perspective. Who follows Roy? There is a good chance he'll be gone at the end of the season, if not before.

Unless we want to take a "chance" there is probably only one other currently unemployed manager that is proven quality - Moyes. He doesn't fill me with huge enthusiasm but we could do a lot worse.

Personally I've always liked the look of Jokanovic. No secret he made some big mistakes and should have trusted the players that got Fulham promoted rather than spent so big. But their defence is built around Calum Chambers...nuff said.

I dont think he is another FdB - he is a young smart progressive manager. We'd be lucky to have him in my opinion but I would settle for Moyes too.


 

the despotic banana Flag Dept. of Baboon Maintenance 10 Dec 18 10.19am

Hodgson isn't responsible for several years of incoherent short-term planning, but the board isn't responsible for his training and tactics.

So the blame is probably something like 80:20.

 


Ask me about Ronald de Boer.

Bangell Flag Oxford 10 Dec 18 10.21am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

[Link]

and then I saw this in another thread - absolutely spot on!

Anyone who thinks that relegation could be in any way positive is absolutely clueless. Look at our squad - very small, and all on big wages. Who is going to take the likes of Riedewald and Schlupp (55k per week each) off our hands? Nobody. All our good players will leave, so we'll be stuck with a core team of massively overpaid but not remotely talented players, eating up the weekly budget that could be used to rebuild the squad.

It wouldn't be like Burnley's relegation, where we could add a few new faces around the core of the team and go again. We would have to build an entirely new team on the cheap. Even if we did have the cash, anyone trust our current transfer team to do that?

Going back to the Championship = going back to the Championship. For years.

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 10 Dec 18 10.53am

What's the bet Parish lives to survive another failure of a season? Does "but he saved the club" really still cut it with you lot in 2019? Surely it's embarrassing seeing what other clubs have made of their promotions? Looking at our squad outside the first 11 or so is enough to send a man into counselling

Roy is making a dogs dinner of this season but the way our club is run helps him not one bit. I think we'd all agree now that the big money vanity signings and lack of a Palace way have been a mistake. Can't fix the squad until we get rid of the 80k+ underachievers clogging up our wage bill and then we have to take a modern approach to rebuilding (ie decide on style of play, recruit manager proven to coach it well, buy players who can fill in the gaps from all over the world, preferably without spending 20m and 80k on each via having a good scouting and analytics system, give the manager time to get their system drilled into the players, back the manager over the players and get rid of anyone he does not deem good enough and the dissenters like with de Boer). We nearly did it with FdB but lost our nerve and went back to the comfort of firefighters.

I think we can all accept down times as long as there is progress being made, something being built. Can anyone say we are now? Is there anything about our club that is sustainable and fit to keep us a stable PL club for the years to come with the hope we can push for top half and maybe even Europe like Bournemouth? Best I can think of is the academy news and that will take ages for the place to be turned into a facility fit for Cat 1

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 10 Dec 18 10.56am

Agree with all of that apart from FDB. He was an irresponsible car crash.

 


COYP

premier fan Flag BR4 10 Dec 18 11.04am

In my opinion we've been very unlucky and we're a bit too quick to look for a scape goat.

We've recently had some very tough matches and secured excellent draws against Arsenal and Man Utd.

We've followed this up with a very convincing win against Burnley.

We appear to have been robbed by the ref at Brighton on two occasions which severely affected the players on the night. This was also an away game so do we really expect us to win?

Lastly West Ham (away match again). They are on fire at the moment. We outplayed and won the first half but unfortunately conceded to a wonder goal early second half. With their tails up it was always going to be a struggle from there on.

Clearly we need replacements or the return of quality strikers (whether that is Benteke or Wickham who knows). Another option is to spend big in January if there is someone out there to buy. I'd like us to do this.

Lastly, it might be too late but I'm sure RLC wouldn't turn down and move back to us, even if on a loan. I know he's got more game time recently but I can't see that happening on a regular basis at Chelsea or any other top 6 club. He needs game time to ensure he's back in the England team in time for the Finals in Portugal next summer, which I'm sure will be on his mind.

Keep the faith people, I know its tough but its still early days to start panicking.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 10 Dec 18 11.15am

Originally posted by premier fan

In my opinion we've been very unlucky and we're a bit too quick to look for a scape goat.

Napoleon once said that he would rather have a general who was lucky than one who was good so perhaps we should be looking for a manager who is luckier

 

Medway Eagle Flag Whitstable Kent 10 Dec 18 11.48am

I cant believe that we are starting to blame RH for the mess caused by Steve Parish, IMO The club is totally mis run by people at the top. Roy was the messiah last season saving us with a totally depleted squad, He did make it clear that SP needed to be active in the transfer market otherwise we would be bang in trouble again, As always and as a consequence of SP totally ignoring the advise of his Manager we are where we are, No strikers available and a very poor bench, IMO STEVE PARISH himself and whoever he has put in place as his backroom team are totally responsible, for the poor and inadequate running of our club, I wish he would relinquish his role as chairman and accept he just is not up to the job

Edited by Medway Eagle (10 Dec 2018 11.49am)

Edited by Medway Eagle (10 Dec 2018 11.51am)

 

Page 19 of 44 < 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?