You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson just announced as CPFC manager
November 16 2026 3.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy Hodgson just announced as CPFC manager


Page 19 of 20 < 15 16 17 18 19 20 >
palace chick Flag South Croydon 24 Mar 23 9.29am

Originally posted by fishbone

Yes i watch the training video and I couldn’t see olise!

Isn’t Olise with the French U21’s?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 24 Mar 23 9.46am

Originally posted by palace chick

Isn’t Olise with the French U21’s?


Yes as is Guehi with the England Team.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 24 Mar 23 10.15am

For a bit of balance compared to some of the recent cheery posts let’s look at the last time Roy arrived and our first 11 games which is what we now have left to play.

Hodgson lost 6 out of the first 11 matches in that 17/18 season, total return was

Played 11, won 1, drew 4, lost 6, total points 7

If you look at the team he had at his disposal then the midfield choices were Puncheon, McArthur, Cabaye, Milivojevic, Loftus-Cheek, Schlupp, Townsend.

His teams also had Zaha, Speroni, PVA, Ward, Sako, Dann, Tomkins, Fosu-Mensah

Everyone saying he had no players to work with but I look at that squad and the current one and there is not much difference.

Admittedly, that year we went on to play well and his teams looked in control a lot of the time. At the end of the 19/20 season however he lost 7 out of the last 11 matches, total return was

Played 11, won 3, drew 1, lost 7, total points 10

Then if we look at his last season with us in 20/21 total return was

Played 11, won 3, drew 1, lost 7, total points 10

My point in all this is that during Hodgson’s last appointment with us, we started badly (not a good omen) and twice finished a season with just 10 points. Will 7-10 points keep us up? I’m not so sure.

Some will bang on that we have an easier run in than the seasons referred to above but the facts are the facts and it shows we don’t end seasons well under Hodgson and he didn’t start well with us either as the team struggled to get used to his tactics.

I’m not saying he won’t do it and he might be able to turn us around but I’m not positive at all about it as I don’t see the character in the team compared to previous years.

 

eaglesdare Flag 24 Mar 23 12.24pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

For a bit of balance compared to some of the recent cheery posts let’s look at the last time Roy arrived and our first 11 games which is what we now have left to play.

Hodgson lost 6 out of the first 11 matches in that 17/18 season, total return was

Played 11, won 1, drew 4, lost 6, total points 7

If you look at the team he had at his disposal then the midfield choices were Puncheon, McArthur, Cabaye, Milivojevic, Loftus-Cheek, Schlupp, Townsend.

His teams also had Zaha, Speroni, PVA, Ward, Sako, Dann, Tomkins, Fosu-Mensah

Everyone saying he had no players to work with but I look at that squad and the current one and there is not much difference.

Admittedly, that year we went on to play well and his teams looked in control a lot of the time. At the end of the 19/20 season however he lost 7 out of the last 11 matches, total return was

Played 11, won 3, drew 1, lost 7, total points 10

Then if we look at his last season with us in 20/21 total return was

Played 11, won 3, drew 1, lost 7, total points 10

My point in all this is that during Hodgson’s last appointment with us, we started badly (not a good omen) and twice finished a season with just 10 points. Will 7-10 points keep us up? I’m not so sure.

Some will bang on that we have an easier run in than the seasons referred to above but the facts are the facts and it shows we don’t end seasons well under Hodgson and he didn’t start well with us either as the team struggled to get used to his tactics.

I’m not saying he won’t do it and he might be able to turn us around but I’m not positive at all about it as I don’t see the character in the team compared to previous years.

You make some good points. I would like to point out however that when we ended seasons under Roy we had our flip flops on! We were well safe! Nothing to play for....I can't remember a relegation run in under Roy the last time I remember was under big sam when we sealed survival against hull city 4-0.

Interesting to point out tho after our extended break due to lockdowns we couldn't win another game....maybe we won 1? we also had an extended break due to the world cup just gone and we can't win a game except 1 I think!

 

Den1923 Flag 24 Mar 23 4.29pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

For a bit of balance compared to some of the recent cheery posts let’s look at the last time Roy arrived and our first 11 games which is what we now have left to play.

Hodgson lost 6 out of the first 11 matches in that 17/18 season, total return was

Played 11, won 1, drew 4, lost 6, total points 7

If you look at the team he had at his disposal then the midfield choices were Puncheon, McArthur, Cabaye, Milivojevic, Loftus-Cheek, Schlupp, Townsend.

His teams also had Zaha, Speroni, PVA, Ward, Sako, Dann, Tomkins, Fosu-Mensah

Everyone saying he had no players to work with but I look at that squad and the current one and there is not much difference.

Admittedly, that year we went on to play well and his teams looked in control a lot of the time. At the end of the 19/20 season however he lost 7 out of the last 11 matches, total return was

Played 11, won 3, drew 1, lost 7, total points 10

Then if we look at his last season with us in 20/21 total return was

Played 11, won 3, drew 1, lost 7, total points 10

My point in all this is that during Hodgson’s last appointment with us, we started badly (not a good omen) and twice finished a season with just 10 points. Will 7-10 points keep us up? I’m not so sure.

Some will bang on that we have an easier run in than the seasons referred to above but the facts are the facts and it shows we don’t end seasons well under Hodgson and he didn’t start well with us either as the team struggled to get used to his tactics.

I’m not saying he won’t do it and he might be able to turn us around but I’m not positive at all about it as I don’t see the character in the team compared to previous years.

Interesting and worrying but also some hope as his career stats say we may win 3 and draw 2 of our remaining games and lose 4 with one game that could go either way but on balance a win or draw is more likely, than a loss, so our final points total may end up around 27 + 11-14 which may give a final total 38-41 which might save us, however depends on the team and how they play. Hopefully, they will hit the ground running as they will need to because any opponent below us will be fighting for their lives just like us hopefully!

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 24 Mar 23 4.55pm

None of us want to see the return of the style of football we endured towards the end of Roy's last stint, but I am certain we will see a huge shift when Leicester visit.

We also know that, in bringing him in, SP was looking for a short term fix to see us stay in the Prem next term. It's not a long term appointment and unlikely to become one.

Unfortunately PV lost his way but I am heartened that Paddy will be a key member of the coaching staff and, as others have said, judging by the spirit on the training ground the players will respond positively.

Come on you Palace and good luck Roy!

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

PatrickA Flag London 24 Mar 23 7.34pm

Football is such a strange game.
The two players supposedly not unhappy with the Vieira departure were Edouard and Eze, presumably because they didn't get the minutes they felt were warranted.
Now Roy with his reputed distrust of flair players and somewhat perceived negative approach has been tasked with undoing the harmful effect on these players of one our supposedly more positive managers in Vieira so that they can flourish again.
My head hurts in this topsy turvy world.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 24 Mar 23 7.44pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Football is such a strange game.
The two players supposedly not unhappy with the Vieira departure were Edouard and Eze, presumably because they didn't get the minutes they felt were warranted.
Now Roy with his reputed distrust of flair players and somewhat perceived negative approach has been tasked with undoing the harmful effect on these players of one our supposedly more positive managers in Vieira so that they can flourish again.
My head hurts in this topsy turvy world.

Hearsay? I'd say PV was justified in sidelining them, both lazy and contributing little to the overall effort. I do wonder how Roy is going to approach the first all important game - no time for shirkers or those who won't do exactly as instructed. Should be interesting.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 24 Mar 23 9.15pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

For a bit of balance compared to some of the recent cheery posts let’s look at the last time Roy arrived and our first 11 games which is what we now have left to play.

Hodgson lost 6 out of the first 11 matches in that 17/18 season, total return was

Played 11, won 1, drew 4, lost 6, total points 7

If you look at the team he had at his disposal then the midfield choices were Puncheon, McArthur, Cabaye, Milivojevic, Loftus-Cheek, Schlupp, Townsend.

His teams also had Zaha, Speroni, PVA, Ward, Sako, Dann, Tomkins, Fosu-Mensah

Everyone saying he had no players to work with but I look at that squad and the current one and there is not much difference.

Admittedly, that year we went on to play well and his teams looked in control a lot of the time. At the end of the 19/20 season however he lost 7 out of the last 11 matches, total return was

Played 11, won 3, drew 1, lost 7, total points 10

Then if we look at his last season with us in 20/21 total return was

Played 11, won 3, drew 1, lost 7, total points 10

My point in all this is that during Hodgson’s last appointment with us, we started badly (not a good omen) and twice finished a season with just 10 points. Will 7-10 points keep us up? I’m not so sure.

Some will bang on that we have an easier run in than the seasons referred to above but the facts are the facts and it shows we don’t end seasons well under Hodgson and he didn’t start well with us either as the team struggled to get used to his tactics.

I’m not saying he won’t do it and he might be able to turn us around but I’m not positive at all about it as I don’t see the character in the team compared to previous years.

His stats were won 2 (Chelsea and Stoke), drew 4 and lost 5 giving 10 points for his first season. The next 4 games we won 2 and drew 2.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Dubai Eagle Flag 25 Mar 23 6.49am

Also it could be argued that this time of joining us -
he has only recently had 4 years with us so he knows the place virtually inside out with a few of the new player exceptions, so he wont need to have that steep learning curve that new managers often have to go through -
He has been appointed for the remaining 11 games -probably one single KPI (Dont get relegated) so every game for him & the club should be treated like a cup final, he will have a clear & concise brief, no other long term thoughts to get in the way, he only has to get hold of the team & drag them over the line -
At the end of the season his role is done -
At 76? ish no matter how grateful we are for what he does or doesn't do in those remaining matches its highly unlikely that he is going to be offered or accept another full season at CPFC -

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

His stats were won 2 (Chelsea and Stoke), drew 4 and lost 5 giving 10 points for his first season. The next 4 games we won 2 and drew 2.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 25 Mar 23 7.14am

I was anti this but now I’ve thought about it I think Roy might keep us up. I think PV would have taken us down. Most players know him and I’m sure respect him. 50 years in the game must count for something tactically and the fear factor could be taken from the players now, knowing that it’s his head on the block.

 

The Dolphin Flag 25 Mar 23 8.03am

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

If I'm honest, I'm just bored with the whole Wilf saga right now. One of, if not the greatest player to ever wear Palace shirt, his legend status is entirely secure but he's run his contract down (as is his right) and the protracted manner of his impending departure has done us no favours. Best the speculation ends and, with luck, Wilf knuckles down and cements his status by leaving on a high note. I'd have no issues if he removed the distraction by announcing immediately "these are my eleven games at Palace and I'm going to go out with a bang." It's time the club and the player both moved on.

Wilf has neither said or done anything detrimental.
All conjecture and hype is by the media and us.
He is behaving impeccably in my opinion.

Edited by The Dolphin (25 Mar 2023 8.03am)

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 25 Mar 23 8.51am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Wilf has neither said or done anything detrimental.
All conjecture and hype is by the media and us.
He is behaving impeccably in my opinion.

Edited by The Dolphin (25 Mar 2023 8.03am)

He has one of the worst attitudes / temperaments in English football, both on and off the pitch. I have numerous dealings with the club, players and staff and speak from personal experience.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 25 Mar 23 9.19am

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

He has one of the worst attitudes / temperaments in English football, both on and off the pitch. I have numerous dealings with the club, players and staff and speak from personal experience.

Interesting you should say this. I have wondered if he is on the personality disorder spectrum as some of his repeated behaviours do point in that direction.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 25 Mar 23 10.05am

I kinda felt that Wilf,s petulant attitude had been formed mostly out of frustration that his career path had stalled, when he had the opportunity for the big time (UTD) it didnt pan out as he had hoped & then again several years later when he felt he was on the verge of a second upward move chance with Arsenal their bid fell short of our aspirations both in what was on offer & what it would cost for Palace to replace him -

He now has an opportunity to make his own decision ( well at the end of the season anyway) so he can see who offers what & then make a decision - it will be interesting for him to see ( & of course us) what kind of offers come in for him -

I hope for our sake that if he is going he goes early in the window so we know where we stand & can make a proper plan for life without him - worst outcome for palace is that he decides on the even of the window closing that he is off -

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Interesting you should say this. I have wondered if he is on the personality disorder spectrum as some of his repeated behaviours do point in that direction.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 25 Mar 23 11.35am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

I kinda felt that Wilf,s petulant attitude had been formed mostly out of frustration that his career path had stalled, when he had the opportunity for the big time (UTD) it didnt pan out as he had hoped & then again several years later when he felt he was on the verge of a second upward move chance with Arsenal their bid fell short of our aspirations both in what was on offer & what it would cost for Palace to replace him -

He now has an opportunity to make his own decision ( well at the end of the season anyway) so he can see who offers what & then make a decision - it will be interesting for him to see ( & of course us) what kind of offers come in for him -

I hope for our sake that if he is going he goes early in the window so we know where we stand & can make a proper plan for life without him - worst outcome for palace is that he decides on the even of the window closing that he is off -

Agree with a lot of this.

As for Wilf being disappointed with his career path I would imagine that is spot on. Whether we like it or not he has been the biggest fish in our relatively small pond for some time now and I think he has always somewhat resented that.

The problem is however that he has to take the responsibility for this. I honestly don’t think any huge clubs were interested in him for a couple reasons: firstly being that his style of play is very individual and therefore his ability to contribute to a team effort was near non existent and secondly his temperament which I would believe has meant a lot of top clubs and managers would not even entertain the touching of a barge pole.

If he was ever going to play at the highest level he needed to address this in both adding to his game and adopting a maturer, ‘consummate professional’ attitude and he has only ever addressed the former which has somewhat coincided, and therefore I’m inclined to believe been adapted, due to the drop in his energy levels and pace.

United came very early and was bad timing in being signed by Ferguson but then him leaving however once again he has only the mirror for investigation if he ends his career having not achieved that he might think he was capable of. I also believe the aforementioned cost him his real shot with England.

The hope is and always had been that his departure would spark a new identity for palace and one that does not hinge almost exclusively on a single player. If he does go however recent history does not inspire me to believe this will happen. If he stays, it may well see Anelka’s ‘incredible sulk’ status threatened and that could be highly damaging.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

CT Charlie Flag 25 Mar 23 4.20pm

Wilf won't receive offers nearly as generous as he'd wish, but he'll receive offers higher than what we're willing to pay him.

At that point, he'll need to decide between taking the risk of seeing less playing time elsewhere and remaining a star at Palace.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 25 Mar 23 9.27pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Also it could be argued that this time of joining us -
he has only recently had 4 years with us so he knows the place virtually inside out with a few of the new player exceptions, so he wont need to have that steep learning curve that new managers often have to go through -
He has been appointed for the remaining 11 games -probably one single KPI (Dont get relegated) so every game for him & the club should be treated like a cup final, he will have a clear & concise brief, no other long term thoughts to get in the way, he only has to get hold of the team & drag them over the line -
At the end of the season his role is done -
At 76? ish no matter how grateful we are for what he does or doesn't do in those remaining matches its highly unlikely that he is going to be offered or accept another full season at CPFC -

Just to say we have played 28 games so far so we have 10 games left not 11. I'd take an extra game if it was Bournemouth though.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

samprior Flag Hamburg 25 Mar 23 9.52pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

He has one of the worst attitudes / temperaments in English football, both on and off the pitch. I have numerous dealings with the club, players and staff and speak from personal experience.

Macca spoke highly of him recently in an article posted the other day. Saying he's a winner and a role model for younger players!

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 25 Mar 23 10.01pm

Originally posted by samprior

Macca spoke highly of him recently in an article posted the other day. Saying he's a winner and a role model for younger players!

He may well be, and should be, a role model for younger players but he's only a winner in as much as he wants to win, how many players don't? But surely winning things is part of it too.

 

Page 19 of 20 < 15 16 17 18 19 20 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson just announced as CPFC manager