You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson
November 16 2026 3.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy Hodgson


Page 19 of 27 < 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 28 Dec 23 11.53am

Originally posted by derfes

i think there are two simple metrics on which we can determine whether to sack a manager.

Win %

viera: 29.73
Hodgson: 32.26 from 31 games

if we lose to brentford, everton, arsenal and shefield wednesday then Hodgson's win percentage will fall below vierra's

Points per game
Viera :1.229
Hodgson:1.258

current points won is 39
accordingly we have vierra equivalent point attaintment equivalents.
Brentford:39.35
everton : 40.58
Arsenal : 41.81
Sheff wed:43.04


current points won is 39. I'd want to examine after sheffield wednesday, but Hodgson's record this season( never mind the bournemouth performance) isn't encouraging.

The big difference between this and the Vieira situation is that under him, we looked like we could never win a game. The performances became totally unacceptable.
I think that only in the Bournemouth game did we perform anything like that badly.

The trouble is that no one can predict the outcome of sacking Roy.
I'd be happier to see new blood at the club in January than a change of manager, especially since the current available options are not very appealing.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (28 Dec 2023 11.53am)

 

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 28 Dec 23 11.56am

Originally posted by IP4Eagle

It reminds me of when I handed in my notice at my first proper job I honestly thought I'd still be the model employee in my two weeks of notice - in the end I was sent home after 3 days because actually I couldn't give a stuff because why would I? You need a manager, regardless of ability, who's fighting for their career, their reputation or to try and get a better job. Someone with skin in the game.

I like Roy, but Roy can do what he likes, say what he likes and deep down has absolutely nothing to motivate or push him so he's not gonna be staying up all night trying to find the way to unlock the teams potential, why should he?

Whilst refreshing candour is always appreciated his slating the fans for being spoilt, telling the press Chelsea wont be "worried about the team he's bringing" and everything else is just symptomatic of someone who is beyond comfortable in their situation, and his comfort will in no way be impacted by the teams form.

He needs to go, and we just need frankly anyone right now who might give it a f**king good go at it because as someone else said we're in freefall right now.

You make a very good point. I can relate to that but at my point of retirement. I was working out a 6 months period with a lifetime knowledge of the industry but felt no concern about our performance. It could be Roy is subconsciously going through this which could be further justification for relieving him of his duties. If the Board really want Cooper then they should take him now and they will stand or fall by their decision. Not sure I would but I don’t have to decide.COYP

 

taylors lovechild Flag 28 Dec 23 11.57am

One other factor is that Parish might be growing increasingly concerned about Hodgson's less than professional responses to the media that seem to follow every disappointing result. He's starting to become somewhat of a comical cantankerous old man and the spitting on the ground last night was a bit embarrassing. On one hand it would be sad to see his time at Palace end on a low point, but on the other hand it could get lower.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 28 Dec 23 11.58am

I do want to say that I heard Cooper turned us down previously but we put a different spin on it. However, things change quickly in football.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Dec 23 12.05pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

One other factor is that Parish might be growing increasingly concerned about Hodgson's less than professional responses to the media that seem to follow every disappointing result. He's starting to become somewhat of a comical cantankerous old man and the spitting on the ground last night was a bit embarrassing. On one hand it would be sad to see his time at Palace end on a low point, but on the other hand it could get lower.

My dear wife has referred to me in terms which equate to a "Cantankerous old man".

There have been comments about Mr Hodgson being seated seemingly detached from the game. It s feasible he was feeling a tad unwell and the "Spitting" could have been the result of an ailment.
I was certainly "Spitting feathers" last night.

Edited by Willo (28 Dec 2023 12.06pm)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 28 Dec 23 12.09pm

Originally posted by Willo

My dear wife has referred to me in terms which equate to a "Cantankerous old man".

There have been comments about Mr Hodgson being seated seemingly detached from the game. It s feasible he was feeling a tad unwell and the "Spitting" could have been the result of an ailment.
I was certainly "Spitting feathers" last night.

Edited by Willo (28 Dec 2023 12.06pm)

I can't imagine you strolling down Worthing seafront gobbing on the beach, even if you were to be inflicted with a bronchial issue. Seeing any manager spitting is fairly unsightly, but somehow it does look worse when that manager is in his mid seventies.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Dec 23 12.20pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I can't imagine you strolling down Worthing seafront gobbing on the beach, even if you were to be inflicted with a bronchial issue. Seeing any manager spitting is fairly unsightly, but somehow it does look worse when that manager is in his mid seventies.

I cannot recall the last time I traversed Worthing seafront, I am not too enamoured with the town. I reside west of Worthing and have no recollection of salivating on my local beach.If I had a bronchial issue and needed to do so in haste I suspect I would gallivant down that path probably with a degree of sublety.


Edited by Willo (28 Dec 2023 12.23pm)

 

stevo Flag Reigate 28 Dec 23 12.57pm

I do think we need a change and it’s time for Roy to go, however what’s not his fault is the 2 strikers we have, the 1 left back and further penny pinching at right back for years.

What he’s also not responsible for is the further negligence from the setup in not replacing Wilf and don’t get me started on splashing out on Henderson, when the money could have been used to fill the aforementioned gaping holes in our squad.

Parish & Dougie need to take a real hard look at themselves and decide wether they’re the right people to take us to the next level and by that I don’t mean next level down.

 


Slowly slowly catchy monkey

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 28 Dec 23 1.08pm

Its basically two choices Roy's goes and a new coach comes in to freshen up the tactics and a more attacking attitude with a couple of loans, or we buy a couple of players that will go straight into the first team and a couple of loans as well, i would like to see both happen, but i think the 1st option will happen, its gone stale, the training must be monotonous

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Plaistow Eagle Flag 28 Dec 23 1.28pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Its basically two choices Roy's goes and a new coach comes in to freshen up the tactics and a more attacking attitude with a couple of loans, or we buy a couple of players that will go straight into the first team and a couple of loans as well, i would like to see both happen, but i think the 1st option will happen, its gone stale, the training must be monotonous

I agree Lanzo - think Roy is lost - body language last night seems to support that..!!

IMO - we’ve thrown away 5 points in the last 2 games due to poor tactics and game management - both Brighton and Chelsea were there for the taking had tactics and game management been more positive..!!

And therein lies the heart of the issue it’s the negativeness that’s costing us and that now seems to be reflected in the players.

That’s why Roy has got to go - TBH I’m surprised that there hasn’t been an an announcement already..!!

COYP

 

VinceHilaire Flag London 28 Dec 23 1.47pm

Anyone else going the through the ‘fuming’ don’t talk to me for 12 hours scenario.

I just get so upset with Roy and his tactics - my poor wife…going to buy some flowers now!

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 28 Dec 23 1.52pm

Like you I think the first option will happen but because SP will see sacking the manager is a cheaper way of changing things than recruiting players.

Sad end to Roy's time. He really should have left and retired at the end of last season with his stock held high.

Why it took a long time to announce him as manager is probably due to the fact other possibilities were approached and turned us down. The entire summer window was a shambles from the time it took to re-install the manager, to the lack of first team ready additions to an already imbalanced squad.

Two of our attacking options of the bench this season have been JRS (playing League 1 last year) and Ebiowei (who was a bench warmer at Hull).

That is the prime reason why we are struggling.

Roy is getting the stick whilst Teflon Steve and the board stay quiet. Of course, if we win against Brentford, he'll be posting on social media.

We are in exactly the same situation we were a year ago. You can change the manager every season, but eventually gambling with a ineffective squad will take us down.

I suspect it could be this year.

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Its basically two choices Roy's goes and a new coach comes in to freshen up the tactics and a more attacking attitude with a couple of loans, or we buy a couple of players that will go straight into the first team and a couple of loans as well, i would like to see both happen, but i think the 1st option will happen, its gone stale, the training must be monotonous

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 28 Dec 23 2.05pm


Prior to the Chelsea game Lee Dixon mentioned we have the 12th highest budget in the league and 12th is where we're looking to finish.
That may be the reality but it's a bit depressing to have the financial side of things expressed so starkly.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 28 Dec 23 2.06pm

Originally posted by Davepalace707

That’s next season

 

taylors lovechild Flag 28 Dec 23 2.16pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle


Prior to the Chelsea game Lee Dixon mentioned we have the 12th highest budget in the league and 12th is where we're looking to finish.
That may be the reality but it's a bit depressing to have the financial side of things expressed so starkly.

Look at the top 10, Brighton is the only club not to have spent a lot of money to be there. I remember a few years back reading that generally speaking the size of the investment reflects where teams finish in the PL. If Brighton don't invest they'll likely be back further down the table within a few years. Likewise if Forest can continue to invest like they have been they'll probably sneak into the top 10 and start sniffing around the European spots.

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 28 Dec 23 2.30pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

I agree Lanzo - think Roy is lost - body language last night seems to support that..!!

IMO - we’ve thrown away 5 points in the last 2 games due to poor tactics and game management - both Brighton and Chelsea were there for the taking had tactics and game management been more positive..!!

And therein lies the heart of the issue it’s the negativeness that’s costing us and that now seems to be reflected in the players.

That’s why Roy has got to go - TBH I’m surprised that there hasn’t been an an announcement already..!!

COYP

Yes so am i , maybe when we lose to Brentford, the axe will fall , there wont be a league game until jan 20 after that .

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 28 Dec 23 2.43pm

SP said he believed PV would have kept us up, but he couldn't take the chance, so had to release him. Gotta think that the same thoughts must be going through his head right now. Is it solely his decision or does he have to run it by our uninterested owners?

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Teddy Eagle Flag 28 Dec 23 2.44pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Look at the top 10, Brighton is the only club not to have spent a lot of money to be there. I remember a few years back reading that generally speaking the size of the investment reflects where teams finish in the PL. If Brighton don't invest they'll likely be back further down the table within a few years. Likewise if Forest can continue to invest like they have been they'll probably sneak into the top 10 and start sniffing around the European spots.

FFP should be a lot more stringent with some of these clubs. It's inconceivable that they're all keeping to the rules.

 

YoDougie Flag London 28 Dec 23 3.14pm

Finally found a moment to fully express my views following the loss yesterday against Chelsea.

I believe we have reached a moment where the blame must be equally split between both Roy Hodgson & Steve Parish/The Board.

Starting with the board, regardless of the views of the Viera sacking, bringing Hodgson back to finish the final 10 or so games last season was a very sensible move. He steadied the ship, albeit against on-paper 'easier' opposition and kept us safe. There was a lot of frustrated fans in Roy's final season and that gave him the opportunity to receive the hero's goodbye which he quite frankly deserved.

However, in those 3-4 months it was Parish/the board's responsibility to be scouting a new successor. I genuinely don't quite understand the thinking behind appointing Roy for 1 more year. It's not long term and therefore doesn't help our club move forward. Just retain and stay still for a year.

I've seen a similar argument recently and historically here before which is 'who else can do the job?' and I really despise this weak argument. Firstly, we are an established Premier League club - the idea that nobody would be attracted here is ridiculous. Secondly, it's not down to us as fans to identify someone. We know the big available names i.e Cooper, Lopetegui - etc, but we have a scouting team who should be identifying exciting and available managers from other leagues, domestic and abroad. They exist and we've seen other clubs find them and become successful with them over the years.

With Roy Hodgson, we've regressed to negative tactics which frustrated us all in his final season with us. Play for a draw, using his same 12-13 players on rotation, players being played out of position, and subs being used very late if we're lucky.

I've seen a few comments asking if anyone else could do better with our team? My view on this is strongly yes. Our team is not a poor team - it's a skeleton squad for sure but we have some very good talent here. Olise & Eze are our star boys. Guehi & Anderson are a superb CB pairing. Lerma, Doucoure (when fit) are both strong, talented midfielders and Hughes has been much improved this season. Richards is playing out of position but his defensive abilities - tackling, interceptions and tracking back is very very good. But a midfielder he is not. Our spine is strong and we genuinely have no idea how good players like Franca, Ozoh, JRS because their minutes have been minimal.

Finally, something I've noticed is whilst we don't want to sell players, we almost never earn any money from any player sales. With FFP, we can spend a certain % of club earnings. Well, if we aren't selling ever, our earnings and profit are of course lower. I'm not saying we should sell our top players but we need to be smarter to reinvest. Zaha for example should not have been allowed to leave for free. Even if we secured £20mill for him with a contract and agreement with him we'd let him go, that's further investment available for us to build the squad and manager/coaching staff. This is an issue that doesn't get discussed enough. Every club makes player sales, except us.

Unfortunately, Roy needs to leave now. But the board needs to adjust the way they are running this club. (This is not a Parish out post)


Edited by YoDougie (28 Dec 2023 3.20pm)

 

davehuggins Flag 28 Dec 23 3.22pm

100% agree

 

Page 19 of 27 < 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson