You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 16 2026 10.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus (LOCKED)


Page 196 of 753 < 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 >
becky Flag over the moon 02 May 20 8.06am

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

In 2008 we committed 0.7% of GDP to PHE pursuing global health assistance and strategies for precisely this reason. We played a big role in managing the Ebola outbreak in 2014.

As with most events when it comes to humans - we quickly forget what happened in the near past and focus on the now. Do we really need that? We don’t need to fund that. I don’t remember that. It wasn’t that bad was it?

It’s not a political issue. It’s a human trait. It’s how we’re wired - history will always repeat itself until we have a system that can predict for us.

Cycle forward 12 years and adequate funding to prepare for this kind of scenario got binned a long time ago. We were simulating for pandemic response in 2012 (I think we know why in that specific scenario) And now here we are.

We’ve not done badly but let’s not kid ourselves and think we’ve done ‘well’.

To say no one knows how they’d prepare for it on the face of it is true - But also insanely obvious

What you’re not thinking about or even aware of is what was being done to help reduce the unknowns in this exact situation was killed off some time ago - and this is the result. We had a strategy and we got complacent, had to cut budgets (allegedly) and went for the thing they felt had the least chance of reoccurrence based on memory.

Foot and mouth, BSE. Happened ages ago innit

SARS, Ebola - not our problem. We’re an island, we’ll be fine

Classic normalcy bias. Take the first easy answer and move on. The majority of humanity is a joke.


So if we'd thrown bucket loads of money at preparation for a pandemic, bought and stored PPE to cover EVERY type of viral or bacterial infection (that required for Ebola is vastly different from that required for COVID-19)and stockpiled it for years and years (never mind that most of it would have been wasted by degrading before ever being used as it is so specialised) we'd have been ok then?

Foot & Mouth, BSE SARS and Ebola were not global pandemics - you did not have 2/3rds of the world scrabbling to get PPE and ventilators simultaneously, and because they are all ones that are known and understood, any response to an outbreak will be swift and accurately targeted. COVID-19 was new, unknown and initially unpredictable in its behaviour.

Yes,you can have a strategy for pandemic planning, but you cannot dot the i's and cross the t's until you actually know the full type and characteristics of what you are dealing with: unknown is exactly that - you can allow in your planning that there may be unknown factors, but you cannot plan for an unknown by it's very nature.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Sir James Hird Flag Mount Martha 02 May 20 8.38am

Hi Guys,
What a b****** this virus is.
Being an ex pat, it gives me pain that there are so many fatalities.
Our deaths for whole country is around 90.
First thing our government did was stop all international flights. Kept cruise ships away (except one) Most of our break outs originated from cruise ship Ruby Princess. The locked down all states, no travelling. schools on line and thats it.
Stay safe.
Mike

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 02 May 20 9.53am

Originally posted by croydon proud

Nonsense, and throw in a comma or full stop now and again!

Woosh

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 02 May 20 9.59am

Originally posted by silvertop

Woosh

Also nice to be criticised by both left and right

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 02 May 20 10.13am

Originally posted by becky


So if we'd thrown bucket loads of money at preparation for a pandemic, bought and stored PPE to cover EVERY type of viral or bacterial infection (that required for Ebola is vastly different from that required for COVID-19)and stockpiled it for years and years (never mind that most of it would have been wasted by degrading before ever being used as it is so specialised) we'd have been ok then?

Foot & Mouth, BSE SARS and Ebola were not global pandemics - you did not have 2/3rds of the world scrabbling to get PPE and ventilators simultaneously, and because they are all ones that are known and understood, any response to an outbreak will be swift and accurately targeted. COVID-19 was new, unknown and initially unpredictable in its behaviour.

Yes,you can have a strategy for pandemic planning, but you cannot dot the i's and cross the t's until you actually know the full type and characteristics of what you are dealing with: unknown is exactly that - you can allow in your planning that there may be unknown factors, but you cannot plan for an unknown by it's very nature.

You miss the point entirely.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 02 May 20 10.27am

Originally posted by Sir James Hird

Hi Guys,
What a b****** this virus is.
Being an ex pat, it gives me pain that there are so many fatalities.
Our deaths for whole country is around 90.
First thing our government did was stop all international flights. Kept cruise ships away (except one) Most of our break outs originated from cruise ship Ruby Princess. The locked down all states, no travelling. schools on line and thats it.
Stay safe.
Mike

We didn't ... and then "led by science" our government took another three weeks to notice almost every other country was doing it. We're still letting people into the country unchecked and now we're talking about easing some lockdown measures for the rest of us because, we're not absolutely sure but, we think only the equivalent of three full planeloads of people are dying from Covid-19 each day. Impressive eh?

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

SavoyTruffle Flag 02 May 20 10.34am

It’s literally just a game to them.

Who cares if loads of people are dead because we’ve got people who massage our figures and make us look good.

At a time when so few trust political leadership this shouldn’t be celebrated. Seen people complaining for on weeks here about fake figures coming out of China, if blatant lies were coming from Iran, China, Russia etc people would call it what it is, why do some seem complicit.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 02 May 20 10.39am

Originally posted by SavoyTruffle


Who cares if loads of people are dead because we’ve got people who massage our figures and make us look good.

At a time when so few trust political leadership this shouldn’t be celebrated. Seen people complaining for on weeks here about fake figures coming out of China, if blatant lies were coming from Iran, China, Russia etc people would call it what it is, why do some seem complicit.

This thread would be quite quiet if it wasn't for HOL's pair of commies who are using every opportunity to bash the government

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 May 20 11.08am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

This thread would be quite quiet if it wasn't for HOL's pair of commies who are using every opportunity to bash the government

Spot on. Government bashing at this time is pathetic and childish imo. Ffs let us see this through and then let the enquiries begin.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 02 May 20 11.14am

Originally posted by silvertop

Also nice to be criticised by both left and right

I just re read that one and it was a genuine question. You could have loosed on me but you didnt. Fair play sorry bout that. Lucky we arnt all as clever as me or we'd all be stupid

 

SavoyTruffle Flag 02 May 20 11.40am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

This thread would be quite quiet if it wasn't for HOL's pair of commies who are using every opportunity to bash the government

I think you’ve just proven my point, resort to labels rather than critically think about the point I’ve made.

If asking to not be lied to is bashing the government then guilty as charged. If it makes you feel better to put your head in the sand that’s fair enough. Thought there were more principled posters on the HOL.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 02 May 20 12.22pm

Originally posted by SavoyTruffle

It’s literally just a game to them.

Who cares if loads of people are dead because we’ve got people who massage our figures and make us look good.

At a time when so few trust political leadership this shouldn’t be celebrated. Seen people complaining for on weeks here about fake figures coming out of China, if blatant lies were coming from Iran, China, Russia etc people would call it what it is, why do some seem complicit.

'twas ever thus with politicians.

After being slow out of the blocks in testing the government set an ambitious target personally I don't think we should get too hung up about the numbers. I am still not convinced what good this will do.

For instance if someone self isolates by the time they have an appointment and get the test results back they will probably be free of the virus anyway. What we really need is an instant test.

As to the numbers what should really matter is from now on we are doing mass testing on a daily basis and to try and ramp up the number continuously.

As to the lies well each government has their on way of recording these numbers. Belgium has a high death rate because they include "suspected" deaths which we don't. Others do or don't include deaths outside of hospitals.

As others have said we shall have to wait for the inquiry before we know how well or badly we have done.

One final point it has been suggested if Corbyn was in power they would have done better than the Tories I don't believe that.

If we can agree for one moment that the government has followed the expert advice then Corbyn would have done the same thing and probably made the same mistakes. The argument that Labour would have put more resources into the NHS and so be better prepared only works if Labour had been in power for at least 5 years.

I accept that the Tories have underfunded the NHS but a 3 month old Corbyn government would not have time to turn the NHS around.

Anyway whatever mistakes have been made in the past I prefer to focus on the here and now rather than the wishful thinking if only the voters had ...

Edited by Badger11 (02 May 2020 12.28pm)

 


One more point

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 02 May 20 2.57pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Also nice to be criticised by both left and right

At least you see both sides, unlike a lot of blu noses on here, i have stated that i quite like Boris and he isn"t doing a terrible job, just that the few mistakes he made probably cost tens of thousands of lives, but lots of blu noses on here think he has done a fantastic job and nobody else could have achieved it, utter nonsense, but a blu nose will always be a brown nose, where Boris is concerned , so expect nothing else!

 

Cpfc1861 Flag 02 May 20 3.03pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Spot on. Government bashing at this time is pathetic and childish imo. Ffs let us see this through and then let the enquiries begin.

signed up here to get away from this on the BBS seems I may have made a mistake. The hindsight brigade are everywhere i see.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 02 May 20 3.03pm

Originally posted by croydon proud

At least you see both sides, unlike a lot of blu noses on here, i have stated that i quite like Boris and he isn"t doing a terrible job, just that the few mistakes he made probably cost tens of thousands of lives, but lots of blu noses on here think he has done a fantastic job and nobody else could have achieved it, utter nonsense, but a blu nose will always be a brown nose, where Boris is concerned , so expect nothing else!

Tens of thousands of lives! What didnt he do that cost those lives. About 30k dead all told, you actually beleive he is responsible for 10001 minimum.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 02 May 20 3.05pm

Originally posted by Cpfc1861

signed up here to get away from this on the BBS seems I may have made a mistake. The hindsight brigade are everywhere i see.

Hang around it gets even funnier on the TR grooming gang and brexit thread.

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 02 May 20 3.10pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Tens of thousands of lives! What didnt he do that cost those lives. About 30k dead all told, you actually beleive he is responsible for 10001 minimum.

The go out and mingle, then oh, no, stay in and isolate? The Italian flights for a month unchecked? The lack of PPE in hospitals? You seriously think the virus hasn"t spread and multiplied continuously because of these clangers? really? Even the most die hard CON must admit that"s impossible , but as i said, a die hard blu/brown nose will see nothing wrong , nothing wrong at all!

 

Cpfc1861 Flag 02 May 20 3.10pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Hang around it gets even funnier on the TR grooming gang and brexit thread.

Oh great more of that s*** not going to give my opinion on those threads as I havent read them. But i can imagine theres a few ostriches on that thread. We need nigel Pearson to sign up here and call them out leftist tossers. That's not a dig at all lefties by the way just the militant bunch.

Edited by Cpfc1861 (02 May 2020 3.11pm)

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 02 May 20 3.16pm

Originally posted by Cpfc1861

signed up here to get away from this on the BBS seems I may have made a mistake. The hindsight brigade are everywhere i see.

Welcome cpfc, you seem like you will get on well here, long as you don"t criticise anything the gov do, and your original post implies that you will be among like minded people mostly, but if we all gush at Boris , whats the point of a thread? We could just call it the great job hm gov are doing and all post well done bojo, but that would be pointless, surely?

 

Cpfc1861 Flag 02 May 20 3.22pm

Originally posted by croydon proud

Welcome cpfc, you seem like you will get on well here, long as you don"t criticise anything the gov do, and your original post implies that you will be among like minded people mostly, but if we all gush at Boris , whats the point of a thread? We could just call it the great job hm gov are doing and all post well done bojo, but that would be pointless, surely?

I believe nobody is above criticism I'm neither dedicated labour or tory I tend to swing my vote depending. however I believe critsism should be free of political bias and given constructively. Whilst I think the government can suffer some criticism for being unprepared I also think that given it's a new virus and we have never had something like this in our lifetimes a little bit of learning as you go and mistakes are acceptable making comparisons is pointless now because whether people like it or not its likely every country will need to expose its citizens it's just doing it the right way.

 

Page 196 of 753 < 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic