You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Bedroom tax
November 22 2026 1.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bedroom tax


Page 2 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Ibanez 31 Oct 12 3.22pm

I think its worth pointing out a few things:

- This is not a tax at all. It is a proposed reduction in free money for those who have more rooms than required.

- The details are not anywhere near finalised and it is premature to assume that there won't be safeguards to protect those who legitimately need extra rooms (e.g. for medical reasons).

- The UK's housing benefit bill is insanely huge and is so incredibly generous that, in some cases, it allows people who qualify to live in superior accommodation to many who pay their own way. It needs cutting and only the most hardened socialist would disagree. Stopping people from getting it for larger houses than they require is nothing other than common sense.

Benefits should be about need, not luxury.

 

fallenangel1979 Flag 31 Oct 12 3.29pm

Quote Ibanez at 31 Oct 2012 3.22pm

I think its worth pointing out a few things:

- This is not a tax at all. It is a proposed reduction in free money for those who have more rooms than required.

- The details are not anywhere near finalised and it is premature to assume that there won't be safeguards to protect those who legitimately need extra rooms (e.g. for medical reasons).

- The UK's housing benefit bill is insanely huge and is so incredibly generous that, in some cases, it allows people who qualify to live in superior accommodation to many who pay their own way. It needs cutting and only the most hardened socialist would disagree. Stopping people from getting it for larger houses than they require is nothing other than common sense.

Benefits should be about need, not luxury.


////////////
This

 


On the 24th December 2013 my life changed forever. Miss you

Fancy helping a charity [Link]

Or read my blog [Link]

Ibanez 31 Oct 12 3.31pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 31 Oct 2012 3.09pm

Quote Ibanez at 31 Oct 2012 10.02am

Why should we pay for people to have a spare room?

Seems quite reasonable that if they want more rooms than they need then perhaps they should pay for it themselves?

Why not provide housing benefit for people so they can remain in their home during a period of transition between jobs.

Realistically speaking, rehousing people because they have a small spare room will just create even more strain on the system, as there is, as we all know a shortage of space, and moving someone in is going to be a nightmare of epic proporitions if they have a private landlord or family present.

Stupid, impractical and costly idea wheeled out by politicians dedicated to being popular rather than being practical.


I agree with your first paragraph - I like the German model of very generous benefits for those recently out of work but very limited money for those who are long term unemployed and not seriously looking for work.

Rehousing would be unpleasant but I think its preferable to the tax payer paying for people to live far beyond their means forever. It has to stop somewhere.

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 31 Oct 12 3.37pm

Thought I had a spare bedroom but turned out to be a study.

Also when is a box room a box room and not a cupboard or walk in wardrobe or similar 2010s living requirement?

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 31 Oct 12 4.23pm

It's a complex situation that needs addressing. But I don't think the bill should go through unless there are changes.

 

UnbornShaitan Flag Too close to Penge for my liking 31 Oct 12 4.46pm

Quote nickgusset at 31 Oct 2012 4.23pm

It's a complex situation that needs addressing. But I don't think the bill should go through unless there are changes.


Have to say that it is exactly that attitude that has led to almost an entire generation (or a very large portion of) of kids growing up having never had the opportunity to play in their own back garden. Especially in London. Its the entitlement generation who take all and deprive those of the future who cause these issues. And once again the famous Gusset can't see the good it will do. Of course it will not happen overnight, and of course there are those who will lose out. But maybe, just maybe, it will help younger families in the future look forward to a time where a garden and a house (not a cramped flat) are a real possibility.


Take a walk down some roads in Bromley that are almost entirely social housing stock. 3,4 and even 5 bedrooms each. Occupied solely by an elderly couple or even a single elderly person (talking from experience of local charity work i do) who won't move because its their family home. Then go and talk to those families in cramped flats with 2 (or more)kids to a box room.

Something needs doing and this is a massive step in the right direction (other measures like the affordable rent scheme are being put in at the same but you choose to ignore this).

We should not be paying for people to have properties they don't need either through the benefit system or through the subsidising of rent.

I have noticed you have failed to offer any viable alternative solutions to the growing housing problem. Care to offer any.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 31 Oct 12 5.02pm

Quote UnbornShaitan at 31 Oct 2012 4.46pm

Quote nickgusset at 31 Oct 2012 4.23pm

It's a complex situation that needs addressing. But I don't think the bill should go through unless there are changes.


Have to say that it is exactly that attitude that has led to almost an entire generation (or a very large portion of) of kids growing up having never had the opportunity to play in their own back garden. Especially in London. Its the entitlement generation who take all and deprive those of the future who cause these issues. And once again the famous Gusset can't see the good it will do. Of course it will not happen overnight, and of course there are those who will lose out. But maybe, just maybe, it will help younger families in the future look forward to a time where a garden and a house (not a cramped flat) are a real possibility.


Take a walk down some roads in Bromley that are almost entirely social housing stock. 3,4 and even 5 bedrooms each. Occupied solely by an elderly couple or even a single elderly person (talking from experience of local charity work i do) who won't move because its their family home. Then go and talk to those families in cramped flats with 2 (or more)kids to a box room.

Something needs doing and this is a massive step in the right direction (other measures like the affordable rent scheme are being put in at the same but you choose to ignore this).

We should not be paying for people to have properties they don't need either through the benefit system or through the subsidising of rent.

I have noticed you have failed to offer any viable alternative solutions to the growing housing problem. Care to offer any.

Like I said, it's a complex issue and as the bill stands it will affect many people who will suffer as a result- read the link I provided earlier.
My thoughts on this are not as black and white as you portray. Yes, there is a need to move people from houses that are too big for their needs, however there are grey areas which the bill does not cover- see the link earlier again.

Alternative solutions to the housing problems...
Many second properties lay empty. Compulsory purchase them and use them as social housing. It's a travesty that there are more housing spaces than people who require housing, it's just they cant access them.
Shelving is also a good idea. A three bedroom house can sleep 8 to a room if the right sort of shelves are used- or perhaps hammocks.
Maybe the poor should be forced to eat their young ( a Swiftian solution admittedly [Link] )that way the problem of housing and food shortages could be solved.

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 31 Oct 12 5.25pm

Quote UnbornShaitan at 31 Oct 2012 4.46pm

Quote nickgusset at 31 Oct 2012 4.23pm

It's a complex situation that needs addressing. But I don't think the bill should go through unless there are changes.


Have to say that it is exactly that attitude that has led to almost an entire generation (or a very large portion of) of kids growing up having never had the opportunity to play in their own back garden. Especially in London. Its the entitlement generation who take all and deprive those of the future who cause these issues. And once again the famous Gusset can't see the good it will do. Of course it will not happen overnight, and of course there are those who will lose out. But maybe, just maybe, it will help younger families in the future look forward to a time where a garden and a house (not a cramped flat) are a real possibility.


Take a walk down some roads in Bromley that are almost entirely social housing stock. 3,4 and even 5 bedrooms each. Occupied solely by an elderly couple or even a single elderly person (talking from experience of local charity work i do) who won't move because its their family home. Then go and talk to those families in cramped flats with 2 (or more)kids to a box room.

Something needs doing and this is a massive step in the right direction (other measures like the affordable rent scheme are being put in at the same but you choose to ignore this).

We should not be paying for people to have properties they don't need either through the benefit system or through the subsidising of rent.

I have noticed you have failed to offer any viable alternative solutions to the growing housing problem. Care to offer any.

Nick has a point - it does need further thought and definition.

I suspect that as you get older your view may change; if the policy is to “house share” by renting a spare room out it is offering the wrong housing to the wrong demographic. These older people have rights just as much as the youngsters, who nowadays grow up with instant gratification and over blown sense of self importance.

If there is such an inalienable right to semi-detached living, why pay these single elderly a premium to move? Incentivise them to move not penalise them.

The problem is partially politics in the last half century and partially the nature of cities. The housing stock, council houses are no longer built, most of those around affluent cities sold to private ownership. Grand building plans that have ended up with loads of flats that nobody wants.

Next I suppose the elderly that own property should be made to compulsory sell and move into sheltered flats? Why not give it away?

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

UnbornShaitan Flag Too close to Penge for my liking 31 Oct 12 7.11pm

Oh come now Nick you can do better than that. An idea has been put forward that is a fairly good one Yes there are flaws but really not that many that can not be worked out. And you make the assumption that people will just be thrown out of their properties. I think the reality will be very different as this is a longer term solution not a quick fix.

Lets just get straight to it. You mainly object to this why. Because it affects you and yours maybe (not an accusation but you have offered little reasoning as to your objections) or maybe because of where it comes from and your unnatural hatred of all things tory.

This idea that we should fund people for what is a luxury and not a necessity is barmy. You seriously can not be arguing that it is ok for the tax payer to subsidize social or private property for those who do not need it. How is it wrong to get people to downsize.

I notice that in your solution you fall back to your comfort zone of attacking those you perceive to be better off than you. Your solution, as you well know, is completely unworkable in the real world (not least the legal aspect) and so you will always be able to point and say "look at those evil people who are richer than me". Not to mention the fact that it is unlikely that your solution would affect you financially. Now i would agree that we should start to look at limiting second home ownership at least until we go on a monster house building session.

Your solution is as silly as the ones you offer at the end which are clearly there as a mocking tool to hide the inadequacy of your objections.

Now pefwin i agree older people have rights but (despite it not really being their fault) we are in a situation where by enforcing these rights others are suffering. I am not suggesting throwing people out of their homes overnight but you can not argue that it the best use of a limited stock of housing when you have 1 or 2 people in a multi-bedroom house. When it comes to privately owned property it is simply that, the state should not be able to intervene, we are only talking of property that is subsidized through benefit or because it is social housing.

Finally i don't know why you get the impression that i am some young whippersnapper looking at the older generations with some envy. I'm not that young and my views on this are unlikely to change. You say youngsters want instant gratification and in part you are right but not in this case. It should simply be about the best use of council stock. The council should not be there to provide you with a specific house for life.

 

johnno42000 Flag 31 Oct 12 7.48pm

What about areas where there is surplus social housing?

The area where I live has surplus social housing 1,2, and 3+ bedroom properties. Why should people be penalised when there are no lodgers to take in? People who would lodge simply get themselves a housing association/Council property.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 31 Oct 12 7.52pm

Quote UnbornShaitan at 31 Oct 2012 7.11pm

Oh come now Nick you can do better than that. An idea has been put forward that is a fairly good one Yes there are flaws but really not that many that can not be worked out. And you make the assumption that people will just be thrown out of their properties. I think the reality will be very different as this is a longer term solution not a quick fix.

Lets just get straight to it. You mainly object to this why. Because it affects you and yours maybe (not an accusation but you have offered little reasoning as to your objections) or maybe because of where it comes from and your unnatural hatred of all things tory.

This idea that we should fund people for what is a luxury and not a necessity is barmy. You seriously can not be arguing that it is ok for the tax payer to subsidize social or private property for those who do not need it. How is it wrong to get people to downsize.

I notice that in your solution you fall back to your comfort zone of attacking those you perceive to be better off than you. Your solution, as you well know, is completely unworkable in the real world (not least the legal aspect) and so you will always be able to point and say "look at those evil people who are richer than me". Not to mention the fact that it is unlikely that your solution would affect you financially. Now i would agree that we should start to look at limiting second home ownership at least until we go on a monster house building session.

Your solution is as silly as the ones you offer at the end which are clearly there as a mocking tool to hide the inadequacy of your objections.

Now pefwin i agree older people have rights but (despite it not really being their fault) we are in a situation where by enforcing these rights others are suffering. I am not suggesting throwing people out of their homes overnight but you can not argue that it the best use of a limited stock of housing when you have 1 or 2 people in a multi-bedroom house. When it comes to privately owned property it is simply that, the state should not be able to intervene, we are only talking of property that is subsidized through benefit or because it is social housing.

Finally i don't know why you get the impression that i am some young whippersnapper looking at the older generations with some envy. I'm not that young and my views on this are unlikely to change. You say youngsters want instant gratification and in part you are right but not in this case. It should simply be about the best use of council stock. The council should not be there to provide you with a specific house for life.

If you read what I have written, I haven't actually objected to the bill, just the bill in it's present form, for the reasons listed earlier which I shall repeat.

Others threatened with benefit cuts include lone parents or grandparents who use their 'spare' bedroom to share the care of their children or grandchildren, couples who sleep separately for medical reasons and disabled people who have had their homes specially adapted for their needs.

Crucially, that extra room often isn't 'spare'. It is the place a family carer stays when a parent is ill, or the space a teenage child needs for privacy and study. It is part of normal life. We believe that penalising some families for living the lives most people lead is unfair and unjust. Yet that is what is going to happen from April 2013 if the Welfare Reform Bill goes through unamended.

I've also said...


My thoughts on this are not as black and white as you portray. Yes, there is a need to move people from houses that are too big for their needs, however there are grey areas which the bill does not cover- see the link earlier again.

Something that you have chosen to ignore.

Now posters like you automatically think that I set to a Tory idea = bad default setting. I do not, you just project that onto me. I suggest that you read exactly what I post, rather than just having a go.

Edited by nickgusset (31 Oct 2012 7.53pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 31 Oct 12 8.41pm

Quote Ibanez at 31 Oct 2012 3.31pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 31 Oct 2012 3.09pm

Quote Ibanez at 31 Oct 2012 10.02am

Why should we pay for people to have a spare room?

Seems quite reasonable that if they want more rooms than they need then perhaps they should pay for it themselves?

Why not provide housing benefit for people so they can remain in their home during a period of transition between jobs.

Realistically speaking, rehousing people because they have a small spare room will just create even more strain on the system, as there is, as we all know a shortage of space, and moving someone in is going to be a nightmare of epic proporitions if they have a private landlord or family present.

Stupid, impractical and costly idea wheeled out by politicians dedicated to being popular rather than being practical.


I agree with your first paragraph - I like the German model of very generous benefits for those recently out of work but very limited money for those who are long term unemployed and not seriously looking for work.

Rehousing would be unpleasant but I think its preferable to the tax payer paying for people to live far beyond their means forever. It has to stop somewhere.

How does one determine that a room is vaccant or a bedroom? My old flat had a 'third bedroom' - but no one ever used it, except this woman who'd stay there a couple of nights. No way anyone could actually live in it.

The expense of finding people new accomodation (deposits and moving) and administring the whole thing will end up costing more than the money saved. Then you'll have to have appeals pannels and hearings and evictions served to move people out - many of whom will be living in social housing anyhow - possibly into private accomodation such as bedsits.

What if its a family, sticking a stranger in their spare room, whos on welfare could definately be problematic as well.

Ill concived, poorly thought out, conservative policy aimed at posturing on welfare, without actually addressing existing problems.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 31 Oct 12 8.42pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 Oct 2012 7.48pm

What about areas where there is surplus social housing?

The area where I live has surplus social housing 1,2, and 3+ bedroom properties. Why should people be penalised when there are no lodgers to take in? People who would lodge simply get themselves a housing association/Council property.

What happens where its an ex-offender, for example, or someone with mental health issues, or disability etc can you just stick them in someones spare room?

I can see the future headline 'Released Paedophile Housed with Family'


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

johnno42000 Flag 31 Oct 12 8.50pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 31 Oct 2012 8.42pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 Oct 2012 7.48pm

What about areas where there is surplus social housing?

The area where I live has surplus social housing 1,2, and 3+ bedroom properties. Why should people be penalised when there are no lodgers to take in? People who would lodge simply get themselves a housing association/Council property.

What happens where its an ex-offender, for example, or someone with mental health issues, or disability etc can you just stick them in someones spare room?

I can see the future headline 'Released Paedophile Housed with Family'



That's a good point.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 31 Oct 12 10.24pm

Quote nickgusset at 31 Oct 2012 10.14am

Quote Stuk at 31 Oct 2012 10.13am

Get a lodger if you have a room to spare and not enough cash to pay your bills, simple really.


Not sure if you're allowed if claiming housing benefit...


Well don't declare it then .....most don't.
Actually this caught my eye it was to the right of Gussets article and much more interesting.......


[Link]

 


Pro USA & Israel

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 31 Oct 12 10.28pm

Quote Jimenez at 31 Oct 2012 10.24pm

Quote nickgusset at 31 Oct 2012 10.14am

Quote Stuk at 31 Oct 2012 10.13am

Get a lodger if you have a room to spare and not enough cash to pay your bills, simple really.


Not sure if you're allowed if claiming housing benefit...


Well don't declare it then .....most don't.
Actually this caught my eye it was to the right of Gussets article and much more interesting.......


[Link]


Oh I forgot to mention....YAWN another Tory Cund Rant BOOOOOOOORRRRRRIIIIINNNGGGGG......

 


Pro USA & Israel

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 31 Oct 12 10.47pm

Quote Jimenez at 31 Oct 2012 10.24pm

Quote nickgusset at 31 Oct 2012 10.14am

Quote Stuk at 31 Oct 2012 10.13am

Get a lodger if you have a room to spare and not enough cash to pay your bills, simple really.


Not sure if you're allowed if claiming housing benefit...


Well don't declare it then .....most don't.
Actually this caught my eye it was to the right of Gussets article and much more interesting.......


[Link]

Most housing benefits are paid according to rental agreements with landlords. Private owners rarely have much recourse to housing benefit.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 31 Oct 12 11.09pm

Quote Jimenez at 31 Oct 2012 10.28pm

Quote Jimenez at 31 Oct 2012 10.24pm

Quote nickgusset at 31 Oct 2012 10.14am

Quote Stuk at 31 Oct 2012 10.13am

Get a lodger if you have a room to spare and not enough cash to pay your bills, simple really.


Not sure if you're allowed if claiming housing benefit...


Well don't declare it then .....most don't.
Actually this caught my eye it was to the right of Gussets article and much more interesting.......


[Link]


Oh I forgot to mention....YAWN another Tory Cund Rant BOOOOOOOORRRRRRIIIIINNNGGGGG......


Have I mentioned the Tories? As it is, yes it is another coalition ill thought out plan. Was pleasing to see them lose a vote in parliament today.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 21 Feb 13 2.49pm

[Link]

Seems that opposition to this is building up steam...

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 21 Feb 13 2.54pm

It does make me wonder what the hell politicians get up to all day when they come up with rubbish like this. All this pointless tinkering around the edges, coming up with micro-wheezes which, even if they do get implemented, don't make a blind bit of difference anyway. And all because they're terrified of offending anyone and losing a few votes.

Stop piddling around. Just cut all benefits in half for, say, the last six months of 2013. Wallop. 35 billion saved in one. Sure, people would moan and kick up a stink. Tough titties, benefits'll go back to normal at the start of 2014, it's free money anyway so stop moaning.

Edited by Johnny Eagles (21 Feb 2013 2.55pm)

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Page 2 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Bedroom tax