Quote Jonny_Johnson at 18 Nov 2012 10.06pm
Quote Bert the Head at 18 Nov 2012 10.01pm
Quote The Sash at 18 Nov 2012 9.22pm
Quote Bert the Head at 18 Nov 2012 9.09pm
Quote The Sash at 18 Nov 2012 7.49pm
Quote Kermit8 at 18 Nov 2012 7.38pm
They do this every few years. Kill scores of civilian Palestinians - a lot of them childen - in retaliation for two or three deaths on their side in the guise of fighting terror.
It suits them to murder. Keeps the status quo. It also perpetuates hatred. So the wheel is ever turning. Fvcked up in the head government in Tel Aviv. Rabin was the last reasonable one in power. His own side murdered him. Because he wanted to make things better.
An axis of evil.
Not quite true Kerms. Rockets are routinely fired onto Israels civilians and given that all of Israels neighbours are quite open in their desire to wipe Israel and Israelis off the map and Israel are quite prepared to act quickly and not really worred about whats proportionate and whats not to try and apportion 'blame' when anything kicks off is pretty moot imho.
Israels backing by the US, its disregard for territorial rights dont do anything to help the situation either nor does the rhetoric about martyrs and martyrdom and sabre rattling from Hamas at every opportunity
A conflict that will never end in our lifetime
I find it ironic that everyone keeps banging on about "Israels neighbours are quite open in their desire to wipe Israel and Israelis off the map" but isn't that exactly what Israel is doing to the Palestianians?"
Just because you dont fawn over the poor oppressed Palestinians it doesnt automatically make you a supporter of Israel.
The fact Israel has enemies on all sides of its border does give a wee clue to understanding their (over) reaction and hard arsed stance though surely ????
I don't understand why Israel continues to be seen as the injured party when they continue to ignore the UN ruling that they return to the '67 border (didn't we invade Iraq for ignoring a UN ruling?) and herd the Palastinians into quasi concentration camps.
Yes. You really don't understand. The Palestinian leadership rejected the partition of Palestine in 1947 culminating in the Arab-Israeli war in 48.
They did of course reject the Partition Plan and, with hindsight, that was probably a mistake as they would be better off now had they accepted it. However at the time (and with hindsight) the Plan was a grossy unbalanced proposition and it is hardly suprising it was rejected then.
All sides have made huge errors in the last 80-odd years in dealing with the 'Israel issue', and that includes the UK and the international community. I do not think anyone nowadays would propose the creation of a new nation state in a region surrounded by reluctant neighbours but, at the time, we didnt really consider the Arab states as being of great importance.
However, we have to deal with what we have now and this of course requires movement on both sides but primarily from Israel to acknowledge that they were given a unique opportunity to re-establish a jewish state and, if they want to preserve it, they need to be a lot less aggressive in their overall foreign policy. This does not mean simply accepting the attacks on their people, but it does mean that the response should be moderate and proportionate and with clear signs of regret that it should be necessary.
Only then, and with a much more constructive and less arrogant foreign policy, can Israel ever hope to be properly recognised by its neighbours (some of whom would be be prepared to do so, in theory, if the general mood within the arab community was less hostile to Israel).
On the Arab side, universal recognition of Israel is politically a long way away, but the moderate elements and states have to respond positively to any move by Israel to improve relations.
Will it ever happen? It doesnt seem likely but then neither did peace in Ireland 20 years ago. One lives in hope.
Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!
My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.
(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)
|