You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish vs Pulis
November 16 2026 1.24pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Parish vs Pulis


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
dg1937 Flag 19 Jan 14 10.55am

In yesterday's programme Parish talked of having "numerous irons in the fire". But he also said he'd only bring in "the right players at the right price and on the right personal terms". Let's face it Parish does have 'previous' when it comes to brinkmanship - buying the club, the Summer window. Personally I don't think you can judge a window until it's closed.

I don't think we need a lot - someone who can score goals and some cover at centre back would do me. But let's be honest Big Sam is looking for that too and 'someone who can score goals' would be able to pick and choose his club. Pulis will know that as well as anybody.

 

MPE Flag Maidstone 19 Jan 14 10.56am

Moody was here briefly before Pulis signed, so am sure TP was fully aware of what Moody's roll would be. Pulis did state the other day, no player would be signed if he didn't want them, so maybe the names moody is putting forward, are not TPs kind of player? We will see how things pan out over the next two weeks.

 


Just when I thought that I was out...........they pull me back in

deleted9 Flag 19 Jan 14 11.02am

It's going to be tight this season but let's look at the positive in that we are not actually in the relegation zone without Pulis/Parish signing any players. The longer we keep this up (especially if we beat Hull)the more I reckon they will think 'do we actually need to buy players?

We will have players coming back from injuries over the coming month (Murray, Thomas, KG) which could galvanise the squad and encourage that competitiveness a new signing might bring. Guedioura would be a good example of that, I believe he has really lifted performances in the past couple of games.

We won't be bringing in 2 or 3 players, more like 1 at the most in my opinion.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 19 Jan 14 11.06am

Quote dg1937 at 19 Jan 2014 10.55am

In yesterday's programme Parish talked of having "numerous irons in the fire". But he also said he'd only bring in "the right players at the right price and on the right personal terms".

Did he actually refer to the fact that "he would only bring in" as most people would say that "we would only bring in"

 

dg1937 Flag 19 Jan 14 11.14am

I stand corrected, he used a mixture of "I" and "we" in the article but "we" would have been more accurate in the context of this specific quote. He also said: "What I can assure supporters today is that we are actively seeking additions to the squad"; and "Tony, Iain Moody and I have identified a list of targets".

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 19 Jan 14 11.26am

Quote braunstoneagle at 19 Jan 2014 10.52am

parish said that moody was brought in as he had a better knowledge of transfer dealings/certain aspects of football than he did.

he acknowledged a weakness in his own skillset and plugged the hole by employing moody.

Fair enough, but surely in that case Parrish should give Moody a clear budget and leave him alone to get on with his job. Why is Parrish even commenting on transfers in the media, or involved in any way? As you've just said, it's not his skill set. And please don't give me the line that "he's the owner. He can do what he wants." That's a business model for failure...not success.

When I ran a department of a corporation, I didn't expect my CEO to answer questions about the performance of that department, nor did he have any inclination to do so. If I did well, I got a pat on the back. If I did poorly, I was fired. But at board meetings (and media interviews), I answered for my work. Parrish -- if this is indeed why Moody has been brought in -- would do well to limit his comments to the realm of financial performance and annual reports which are the domain of the CEO. Not transfer activity, for which he's recruited someone to do the job.

From where I sit you have three people not on the same page at all. Parrish has brought Moody in as you explain above, but he's undermining him with his constant media comments about purse strings and wage structures. Moody probably has his ideas about what to do but it's important to remember that he's standing on his own two feet for the first time, no longer working for a friend in an environment in which he feels secure (Malky, Cardiff) and furthermore having to report to a massive ego (Parrish) and satisfy someone with a world of experience (Pulis). In truth, Moody is young and inexperienced. He's really only done the job for a couple of years. And Pulis probably thinks he knows better than both (and he's right; he does) and is frustrated that he's got not one fool but two between him and the squad he wants.

Sounds like what our American friends call a clusterf*&k to me. All I can say is that while no manager's history in the transfer market is perfect and Pulis has certainly made his mistakes, when it comes to making the moves needed to keep us up, I know damn well who I'd prefer in the driver's seat and it's not Parrish or Moody.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 19 Jan 14 11.28am

How about a scenario that sees Pulis leaving at the end of the season and Malky Mackay coming in as manager ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

sydtheeagle Flag England 19 Jan 14 11.36am

Quote NEILLO at 19 Jan 2014 11.28am

How about a scenario that sees Pulis leaving at the end of the season and Malky Mackay coming in as manager ?

You know what? The thing that would prevent this is that Malky is at Norwich by that point. But if not, would not surprise me one bit. Good guess. If Malky IS at Norwich, would not surprise me if Moody joined him there as between Parrish's ego and Pulis' experience, there doesn't seem to be much need for him here.

I wonder if Moody was hired in the belief that we'd recruit a Petrescu/Karanka-type younger foreign manager in which case he might have had a clearer role, but when we ended up with a vastly experienced English manager, he became a little surplus to requirements?

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Plane Flag Bromley 19 Jan 14 11.36am

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 11.26am

Quote braunstoneagle at 19 Jan 2014 10.52am

parish said that moody was brought in as he had a better knowledge of transfer dealings/certain aspects of football than he did.

he acknowledged a weakness in his own skillset and plugged the hole by employing moody.

Fair enough, but surely in that case Parrish should give Moody a clear budget and leave him alone to get on with his job. Why is Parrish even commenting on transfers in the media, or involved in any way? As you've just said, it's not his skill set. And please don't give me the line that "he's the owner. He can do what he wants." That's a business model for failure...not success.

When I ran a department of a corporation, I didn't expect my CEO to answer questions about the performance of that department, nor did he have any inclination to do so. If I did well, I got a pat on the back. If I did poorly, I was fired. But at board meetings (and media interviews), I answered for my work. Parrish -- if this is indeed why Moody has been brought in -- would do well to limit his comments to the realm of financial performance and annual reports which are the domain of the CEO. Not transfer activity, for which he's recruited someone to do the job.

From where I sit you have three people not on the same page at all. Parrish has brought Moody in as you explain above, but he's undermining him with his constant media comments about purse strings and wage structures. Moody probably has his ideas about what to do but it's important to remember that he's standing on his own two feet for the first time, no longer working for a friend in an environment in which he feels secure (Malky, Cardiff) and furthermore having to report to a massive ego (Parrish) and satisfy someone with a world of experience (Pulis). In truth, Moody is young and inexperienced. He's really only done the job for a couple of years. And Pulis probably thinks he knows better than both (and he's right; he does) and is frustrated that he's got not one fool but two between him and the squad he wants.

Sounds like what our American friends call a clusterf*&k to me. All I can say is that while no manager's history in the transfer market is perfect and Pulis has certainly made his mistakes, when it comes to making the moves needed to keep us up, I know damn well who I'd prefer in the driver's seat and it's not Parrish or Moody.

It has been established that you find Steve Parish 'vulgar' and you seem to be seeking any opportunity to further the conspiracy theories. Give it a rest as you're very boring.

It would also help your argument if you could spell his name correctly, just out of respect for your victim.

 

Plane Flag Bromley 19 Jan 14 11.38am

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 11.36am

Quote NEILLO at 19 Jan 2014 11.28am

How about a scenario that sees Pulis leaving at the end of the season and Malky Mackay coming in as manager ?

You know what? The thing that would prevent this is that Malky is at Norwich by that point. But if not, would not surprise me one bit. Good guess. If Malky IS at Norwich, would not surprise me if Moody joined him there as between Parrish's ego and Pulis' experience, there doesn't seem to be much need for him here.

I wonder if Moody was hired in the belief that we'd recruit a Petrescu/Karanka-type younger foreign manager in which case he might have had a clearer role, but when we ended up with a vastly experienced English manager, he became a little surplus to requirements?

This above, just underline what I have stated in my previous post.

 

beer man Flag Kent 19 Jan 14 11.40am

Doesn't look like we'll be spending much anyway

Parish on 5 Live:

[Link]

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Jan 14 11.42am

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 11.36am
there as between Parrish's ego

Think that Parish is being depicted as the re-incarnation of Jordan. Young businessman with flowing blonde locks and always willing to be in the public eye.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 19 Jan 14 11.43am

Quote Plane at 19 Jan 2014 11.36am

It has been established that you find Steve Parish 'vulgar' and you seem to be seeking any opportunity to further the conspiracy theories. Give it a rest as you're very boring.

It would also help your argument if you could spell his name correctly, just out of respect for your victim.

Touche with regard to the point about spelling but the fact that I don't like Parrish doesn't mean I can't write a well-reasoned criticism. It's a pity you responded with a barb at me rather than addressing the perfectly valid points I raised.


Edited by sydtheeagle (19 Jan 2014 11.43am)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

sydtheeagle Flag England 19 Jan 14 11.46am

Quote Willo at 19 Jan 2014 11.42am

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 11.36am
there as between Parrish's ego

Think that Parish is being depicted as the re-incarnation of Jordan. Young businessman with flowing blonde locks and always willing to be in the public eye.

As Braunie pointed out, there are superficial similarities but also profound differences. Parrish is a highly competent businessman. Jordan was never that; at best, he was once a lucky one. However, there is no denying that what the two of them have in common is a huge ego (and flowing blond locks.) But that's where any similarity ends.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Jan 14 11.48am

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 11.43am

the perfectly valid points I raised.

Sydtheeagle

A lot of the points you raise on HOL certainly resonate with me.I enjoy reading your erudite and well-considered posts.


 

Plane Flag Bromley 19 Jan 14 11.49am

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 11.43am

Quote Plane at 19 Jan 2014 11.36am

It has been established that you find Steve Parish 'vulgar' and you seem to be seeking any opportunity to further the conspiracy theories. Give it a rest as you're very boring.

It would also help your argument if you could spell his name correctly, just out of respect for your victim.

Touche with regard to the point about spelling but the fact that I don't like Parrish doesn't mean I can't write a well-reasoned criticism. It's a pity you responded with a barb at me rather than addressing the perfectly valid points I raised.

Edited by sydtheeagle (19 Jan 2014 11.43am)

You didn't raise any. As I said, you are only interested in promoting your conspiracy theories and you still didn't spell Parish's name correctly, you're either ignorant or you're trying to goad someone, it isn't me btw.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 19 Jan 14 11.50am

Quote NEILLO at 19 Jan 2014 11.28am

How about a scenario that sees Pulis leaving at the end of the season and Malky Mackay coming in as manager ?

I can't see that happening as Malky Mackay has had enough problems with one interfering chairman so probably will want to find a club where the chairman is happier with a lower profile

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Jan 14 11.54am

Quote Ian J at 19 Jan 2014 11.50am

where the chairman is happier with a lower profile

Ouch !


 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 19 Jan 14 12.01pm

Quote Ian J at 19 Jan 2014 11.50am

Quote NEILLO at 19 Jan 2014 11.28am

How about a scenario that sees Pulis leaving at the end of the season and Malky Mackay coming in as manager ?

I can't see that happening as Malky Mackay has had enough problems with one interfering chairman so probably will want to find a club where the chairman is happier with a lower profile


i am perplexed as to how steve parish is being referred to as an "interfering chairman" ?

at worst all i can get from various media comments is that he doesnt want to mortgage the future of the club with extravagant signings.

after all its his (and the other 3 owners) money he is spending!

lets just say for arguments sake that pulis wanted to sign peter crouch, and parish wanted to sign tom ince.

and lets just say that both combined financial packages of transfer fee & wages were the same.

i would back parish 100% of the time for trying to sign a player who we could always get a return, and quite possibly a profit on in 3/4 season time.

i completely understand that pulis wants tried & tested PL players added to the squad 2 weeks ago...but i dont blame parish one iota for digging his heels in doing what he thinks is right for the club in the long term.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


sydtheeagle Flag England 19 Jan 14 12.04pm

Quote Plane at 19 Jan 2014 11.49am

You didn't raise any. As I said, you are only interested in promoting your conspiracy theories and you still didn't spell Parish's name correctly, you're either ignorant or you're trying to goad someone, it isn't me btw.

Now that is a stupid thing to say.

I don't mind being disliked or disagreed with but to say that what I wrote earlier does not contain any valid points is absolutely idiotic. I have a lot of time for many of my adversaries, but I have no respect for you if you cannot even engage in a reasoned debate.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish vs Pulis