This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
the NO signings = positive thread
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Joeberto Streatham Hill 20 Jan 14 11.03am |
|
|
A couple of signings would be positive. Apologies if this all sounds a bit familiar:
One up front to help us threaten and convert a few more of the chances we have been making. The Danish lad Makienok being mentioned might fit the bill? Unless Murray's return is imminent, and perhaps even if it is, we need more to throw at it in attack.
One at the back to compete with DD & Gabbidon, and ultimately take over from the latter who is doing a sterling job but is 34 years old. Better to get someone in to start integrating and give another option now, rather than leave it to the summer. Not Dann though, due to the stupid money involved, so the question is can they find the right man?
I think one or both of those would not only improve the squad and options, but give a signal of intent and boost to the current players.
|
Lyons550 Shirley 20 Jan 14 1.53pm |
|
Quote doublesuited77 at 20 Jan 2014 12.35am
i'd rather have one big signing than several smaller ones. remember people said the exact same thing about arsenal during the autumn transfer window
Done wonders for West ham that theory
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World
|
maxipalace in a box 20 Jan 14 4.14pm |
|
Quote NEILLO at 20 Jan 2014 10.47am
Quote maxipalace at 19 Jan 2014 8.32pm
Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 6.06pm
Put another way, this the "I think I know more than Tony Pulis" thread. In other words, an open forum for people to make fool's of themselves.
Edited by sydtheeagle (19 Jan 2014 6.06pm)
goldberg and jordan already made fools of us as a club. A boy from.the youth team was the difference in the play offs between us brighton and watford. Dont forget where you came from and how you got there.
being sustainable as a club means upsetting a few people then i applaud the owners. There is no definitive guide to running a club
'' Made fools of us as a club '' ? And those guys lost most of their personal fortunes along the way.
That boy from the youth team was part of the infrastructure that was invested in - the Academy.
You are right, people are going to find the sustainable strategy tough to take, but there has to be a limit to that or the club becomes uncompetitive and starts to get a reputation for being unambitious.
The bottom line is that 2010 hired - at significant cost - a proven PL manager. If that manager says we need to bring new players in to give us a better chance of staying up, I trust his judgement.
Potentially making signings give us a better chance of staying up but it isnt fullproof. It gives managers options but whose to say we havent got the right personell here already. I dont believe everything a manager says. He made a rash assertion about our defensive qualities which i think he has since reconsidered. This isnt Stoke where he had a rich benefactor willing to splash large amounts.
|
Plane Bromley 20 Jan 14 4.17pm |
|
Quote maxipalace at 20 Jan 2014 4.14pm
Quote NEILLO at 20 Jan 2014 10.47am
Quote maxipalace at 19 Jan 2014 8.32pm
Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 6.06pm
Put another way, this the "I think I know more than Tony Pulis" thread. In other words, an open forum for people to make fool's of themselves.
Edited by sydtheeagle (19 Jan 2014 6.06pm)
goldberg and jordan already made fools of us as a club. A boy from.the youth team was the difference in the play offs between us brighton and watford. Dont forget where you came from and how you got there.
being sustainable as a club means upsetting a few people then i applaud the owners. There is no definitive guide to running a club
'' Made fools of us as a club '' ? And those guys lost most of their personal fortunes along the way.
That boy from the youth team was part of the infrastructure that was invested in - the Academy.
You are right, people are going to find the sustainable strategy tough to take, but there has to be a limit to that or the club becomes uncompetitive and starts to get a reputation for being unambitious.
The bottom line is that 2010 hired - at significant cost - a proven PL manager. If that manager says we need to bring new players in to give us a better chance of staying up, I trust his judgement.
Potentially making signings give us a better chance of staying up but it isnt fullproof. It gives managers options but whose to say we havent got the right personell here already. I dont believe everything a manager says. He made a rash assertion about our defensive qualities which i think he has since reconsidered. This isnt Stoke where he had a rich benefactor willing to splash large amounts.
The manager, and as that's what we employed him for, we really should listen to him.
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 20 Jan 14 4.20pm |
|
Quote maxipalace at 20 Jan 2014 4.14pm
Potentially making signings give us a better chance of staying up but it isnt fullproof. It gives managers options but whose to say we havent got the right personell here already. I dont believe everything a manager says. He made a rash assertion about our defensive qualities which i think he has since reconsidered. This isnt Stoke where he had a rich benefactor willing to splash large amounts.
Alright then.
1. What do you expect TP to do when Delaney or Gabbidon get injured or suspended?
2. What do you expect TP to do when Gayle or Chamakh get injured or suspended and Murray can't play more than 25 mins and can't get his form back?
Sean Lock uses a very good analogy for what Ryan Air are doing with cutting costs. They're playing Kerplunk with the airline."
Being in a position where survival is possible with 16 games to go means you do improve the squad because risk/reward is in your favour, not the other way round. If we were 6 points adrift and then lost to Hull then it wouldn't be worth it, but we should add now, and as a bonus it's a start on the Summer activity as well.
COYP
|
Joeberto Streatham Hill 20 Jan 14 4.21pm |
|
Quote maxipalace at 20 Jan 2014 4.14pm
Potentially making signings give us a better chance of staying up but it isnt fullproof. It gives managers options but whose to say we havent got the right personell here already. I dont believe everything a manager says. He made a rash assertion about our defensive qualities which i think he has since reconsidered. This isnt Stoke where he had a rich benefactor willing to splash large amounts.
True enough maxi, but then not making signings isn't fullproof either. At this stage it would surely be better to get in one or two than none at all?
TP is the one to say whether or not we have the right personnel, and most of his recent statements suggest that we are still a bit short of what he wants.
|
maxipalace in a box 20 Jan 14 5.42pm |
|
Quote Joeberto at 20 Jan 2014 4.21pm
Quote maxipalace at 20 Jan 2014 4.14pm
Potentially making signings give us a better chance of staying up but it isnt fullproof. It gives managers options but whose to say we havent got the right personell here already. I dont believe everything a manager says. He made a rash assertion about our defensive qualities which i think he has since reconsidered. This isnt Stoke where he had a rich benefactor willing to splash large amounts.
True enough maxi, but then not making signings isn't fullproof either. At this stage it would surely be better to get in one or two than none at all?
TP is the one to say whether or not we have the right personnel, and most of his recent statements suggest that we are still a bit short of what he wants.
A manager always wants to sign new players though. I think at this stage team spirit is just as important. We made 16 signings - brought in a new manager and two assistants. Soon we are going to be taking a financial risk. He is going to have to try his best with what we have. He is on a good bonus to stay up
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 20 Jan 14 5.46pm |
|
Quote maxipalace at 20 Jan 2014 5.42pm
Quote Joeberto at 20 Jan 2014 4.21pm
Quote maxipalace at 20 Jan 2014 4.14pm
Potentially making signings give us a better chance of staying up but it isnt fullproof. It gives managers options but whose to say we havent got the right personell here already. I dont believe everything a manager says. He made a rash assertion about our defensive qualities which i think he has since reconsidered. This isnt Stoke where he had a rich benefactor willing to splash large amounts.
True enough maxi, but then not making signings isn't fullproof either. At this stage it would surely be better to get in one or two than none at all?
TP is the one to say whether or not we have the right personnel, and most of his recent statements suggest that we are still a bit short of what he wants.
A manager always wants to sign new players though. I think at this stage team spirit is just as important. We made 16 signings - brought in a new manager and two assistants. Soon we are going to be taking a financial risk. He is going to have to try his best with what we have. He is on a good bonus to stay up
You obviously know nothing about risk/reward. SJ didn't give a shoit how the cards were stacked, just add to the squad. We're now in a position where our fate is in our hands with regards to league position, morale is high, performances are consistently good. Now is the time to add. SP knows as such, we've made bids and are looking around, it's just you who wants to zip the pockets closed. RN would've loved 20,000 of you when the time was right to keep us in the Prem instead of watching WBA do it over 20 years.
COYP
|
doublesuited77 London (Camden) 20 Jan 14 7.07pm |
|
|
lets also remember that backhalf fixtures are nowhere near as congested as the fall so depth is a bit less important.
The only reason why we will need multiple players for depth is if we make a deep FA cup run or have some replays.
If we lose to Wigan (which sadly i expect us to do because i dont think TP fields a strong team with Hull 3 days away), we will only have 1 short rest game (everton).
Be Loud, Be Proud, Be Palace
|
maxipalace in a box 21 Jan 14 10.08pm |
|
|
all quiet on the home front....
|
beer man Kent 21 Jan 14 10.17pm |
|
Quote doublesuited77 at 20 Jan 2014 7.07pm
lets also remember that backhalf fixtures are nowhere near as congested as the fall so depth is a bit less important.
The only reason why we will need multiple players for depth is if we make a deep FA cup run or have some replays.
If we lose to Wigan (which sadly i expect us to do because i dont think TP fields a strong team with Hull 3 days away), we will only have 1 short rest game (everton).
And there was me thinking we were playing in the English PL
|
djmobi Oxford 22 Jan 14 9.15am |
|
|
I think that as long as we bring in a central defender (Ramis from Wigan) and a striker (Jones from Stoke) we have plenty of cover everywhere else.
If we can f*** Jerome off and replace him with Jones as a Loan and pay a few million for Ramis we will have enough cover everywhere, wont damage the current team spirit and will give ourselves a great chance at staying up.
|
alaneagle1 Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 22 Jan 14 9.22am |
|
Quote djmobi at 22 Jan 2014 9.15am
I think that as long as we bring in a central defender (Ramis from Wigan) and a striker (Jones from Stoke) we have plenty of cover everywhere else.
If we can f*** Jerome off and replace him with Jones as a Loan and pay a few million for Ramis we will have enough cover everywhere, wont damage the current team spirit and will give ourselves a great chance at staying up.
This is the same Jones that refused to play for Stoke.? Earns big wages.? Would be surprised if he joined.
Palace 13th 2017/18.
|
djmobi Oxford 22 Jan 14 11.29am |
|
Quote alaneagle1 at 22 Jan 2014 9.22am
Quote djmobi at 22 Jan 2014 9.15am
I think that as long as we bring in a central defender (Ramis from Wigan) and a striker (Jones from Stoke) we have plenty of cover everywhere else.
If we can f*** Jerome off and replace him with Jones as a Loan and pay a few million for Ramis we will have enough cover everywhere, wont damage the current team spirit and will give ourselves a great chance at staying up.
This is the same Jones that refused to play for Stoke.? Earns big wages.? Would be surprised if he joined.
My understanding is that he refused to play for Stoke because of differences with Hughes, but Pulis and him get on I believe.
Also his wages cant be a lot different than Jeromes who I believe we are currently covering in full. Even if he is on 5-10 thousand more than Jerome, surely that isnt much to pay for someone who is likely to score more goals.
|
alaneagle1 Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 22 Jan 14 12.47pm |
|
Quote djmobi at 22 Jan 2014 11.29am
Quote alaneagle1 at 22 Jan 2014 9.22am
Quote djmobi at 22 Jan 2014 9.15am
I think that as long as we bring in a central defender (Ramis from Wigan) and a striker (Jones from Stoke) we have plenty of cover everywhere else.
If we can f*** Jerome off and replace him with Jones as a Loan and pay a few million for Ramis we will have enough cover everywhere, wont damage the current team spirit and will give ourselves a great chance at staying up.
This is the same Jones that refused to play for Stoke.? Earns big wages.? Would be surprised if he joined.
My understanding is that he refused to play for Stoke because of differences with Hughes, but Pulis and him get on I believe.
Also his wages cant be a lot different than Jeromes who I believe we are currently covering in full. Even if he is on 5-10 thousand more than Jerome, surely that isnt much to pay for someone who is likely to score more goals.
Jones appears to score 1 goal every 6 Games so i would not sign him.
Palace 13th 2017/18.
|
djmobi Oxford 22 Jan 14 1.17pm |
|
Quote alaneagle1 at 22 Jan 2014 12.47pm
Quote djmobi at 22 Jan 2014 11.29am
Quote alaneagle1 at 22 Jan 2014 9.22am
Quote djmobi at 22 Jan 2014 9.15am
I think that as long as we bring in a central defender (Ramis from Wigan) and a striker (Jones from Stoke) we have plenty of cover everywhere else.
If we can f*** Jerome off and replace him with Jones as a Loan and pay a few million for Ramis we will have enough cover everywhere, wont damage the current team spirit and will give ourselves a great chance at staying up.
This is the same Jones that refused to play for Stoke.? Earns big wages.? Would be surprised if he joined.
My understanding is that he refused to play for Stoke because of differences with Hughes, but Pulis and him get on I believe.
Also his wages cant be a lot different than Jeromes who I believe we are currently covering in full. Even if he is on 5-10 thousand more than Jerome, surely that isnt much to pay for someone who is likely to score more goals.
Jones appears to score 1 goal every 6 Games so i would not sign him.
Not sure where you are getting your stas from
He has scored 1 in every 2 games this season and most of those games have been midway through the second half appearances as a sub. I know his 5 goals have come in the cup but as I said he does not get any game time in the prem which would change with us.
I dont rate Kenwyn Jones as a striker compared to most, but compared to Jerome who has scored 1 goal in far far more game time I rate Jones much higher.
If you believe the papers we are interested or were interested in Crouch......his score rate is worse than Jones and he is older.
I cant off the top of my head think of anyone better that JOnes who we have a chance of landing
|
Only one Salako London 22 Jan 14 1.23pm |
|
|
What about when Stoke take CamJam back from us at the 11th hour on deadline day? Unless Murray comes back firing (unlikely after such a serious injury) then we are really going to be struggling up top. We need a striker and a centre back would be nice too.
"they gave it everything, every ounce of blood, sweat and guts. They battled, they never ducked a challenge and, as their fans ripped their T-shirts off in the stands, creating the kind of heady atmosphere that has turned Selhurst Park into an amphitheatre" Matthew Syed
|
I'mPalace Till I Die 22 Jan 14 2.11pm |
|
|
They can only have Jerome back if we give them permission to just to let you know
Quote Only one Salako at 22 Jan 2014 1.23pm
What about when Stoke take CamJam back from us at the 11th hour on deadline day? Unless Murray comes back firing (unlikely after such a serious injury) then we are really going to be struggling up top. We need a striker and a centre back would be nice too.
|
EagleRider Seasalter, Kent 22 Jan 14 2.46pm |
|
|
In light of the daily mail article titled "Huge blow for Martinez as Wigan defender Ramis is sidelined for season with cruciate injury" can I suggest that we don't count on picking up Ivan Ramis from Wigan?
|
slubglurge welling 22 Jan 14 8.00pm |
|
|
It would not surprise me at all if nobody comes in. Moody is out there at the moment trying to find affordable players but Pulis is not going to accept anybody just because he fits into the budget. He likes players who he has worked with before and who he can trust when the chips are down, hence the interest in Crouch. With all these foreign names being bandied about hes not going to want anyone not willing to run through a brick wall for the cause, any possible signing from the overseas bargain basement is going to be a gamble and there is no way that TP is a maverick manager.
|