You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What makes Football so emotive
November 16 2026 1.24pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What makes Football so emotive


thommo1 Flag Peckham 20 Jan 14 1.43pm

It has a hold on me and for you I am sure and for people who just dont get it .... Well they just dont get it.. but what is IT...

There must be something in the Human psyche that a GAME where you kick a bag of air between two sticks gets people into such a frenzy and controls there thoughts and feelings.. Maybe a behaviorist could explain.. I feel its not just the game but a tribal need to belong to a group which gives us a sense of identity that in the modern world does not really exist.. Yes I have alot of time to think ;-)

 


DJ John Peel once said: "Supporting Palace has a certain cult value, like pretending that some Peruvian rock band is the best in the world."

andrewravesax Flag cowbridge 20 Jan 14 3.27pm

I have spent sixty years trying to understand my totally irrational feelings, given that nowadays virtually none of the players are "locals". But despite moving a dozen times, I have never been able to form a real attachment to any other club.

 

paulose17 Flag Sutton 20 Jan 14 3.44pm

Not sure of the answer but sometimes I think we all belong in a nuthouse sometimes

 


Want a thread killed? Don't delay, special offer on two threads killed at the same time. Just contact paulose17 at the usual address.

Part Time James Flag 20 Jan 14 3.47pm

Maybe it reverts us to a deep seated need to be tribal and face off against others.

I was reflecting the other day, if no one I ever encountered liked football, would I feel so up/down after a weekend of football results?

I follow the NHL Ice Hockey as well as football and when my chosen team loses I feel slightly miffed but because I know very few people who even know what the NHL is, it doesn't harm my mood so much.

 




cp forever Flag south london 20 Jan 14 4.46pm

Isn't it all to do with belonging, kind of family, I used to follow football without being attached to a club and did not experience the terrible ups and downs that happen now, except for some of the England campaigns of course.
I wouldn't change it as we have an amazing experience with Palace and I sometimes feel for those top team supporters who only know a dull kind of predictable success with the horrible arrogance that goes with it. I am quite amused but the MU "struggle" their family are just not equipped to deal with it.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 20 Jan 14 4.53pm

Crowd Psychology, its about the expression of aspects of self along shared identified lines. To an extent this may well be hardwired into us biologically, but Team sports generally tie into our need to belong to a tribe.

Its more emphasised in football than other sports because football has much strong emotional highs and lows, because chance dominates the outcome more than other sports, and the difference between a 'win and a loss' are very tight, making individuals tense, and thus the crowd tense, and then feeding back into the crowd. Unsurprisingly, its football not tennis or cricket that are associated with violence (itself tied to the tribalism, the tense atmosphere and the adoption of localised rivalries).

To some extent there is a primal element in us that is tribal, we need to belong to a group and be part of that group, and football really ties into this, for better and for worse.

Its also an atmosphere in which men can openly express their aggressive nature, safely, protected by the depersonalisation and comeradery of their fellows.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 20 Jan 14 4.55pm

Quote Part Time James at 20 Jan 2014 3.47pm

Maybe it reverts us to a deep seated need to be tribal and face off against others.

I was reflecting the other day, if no one I ever encountered liked football, would I feel so up/down after a weekend of football results?

I follow the NHL Ice Hockey as well as football and when my chosen team loses I feel slightly miffed but because I know very few people who even know what the NHL is, it doesn't harm my mood so much.

Indeed, and in Canada the reverse is probably true. They're quite tribal about their Ice Hockey and trouble between fans occurs.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

EagleRider Flag Seasalter, Kent 20 Jan 14 5.02pm

I don't think it's football but sports in general.
It's something we can grab onto and be a part of without actually having to be good enough to be out on the pitch competing. And we can form friendships and have conversations while literally only needing to have one thing in common. Anything else we find we have in common is always a pleasant surprise.

 

thommo1 Flag Peckham 20 Jan 14 5.06pm

Good answer Jamie,

 


DJ John Peel once said: "Supporting Palace has a certain cult value, like pretending that some Peruvian rock band is the best in the world."

SE9 EAGLE Flag 20 Jan 14 5.11pm

Quote EagleRider at 20 Jan 2014 5.02pm

I don't think it's football but sports in general.
It's something we can grab onto and be a part of without actually having to be good enough to be out on the pitch competing. And we can form friendships and have conversations while literally only needing to have one thing in common. Anything else we find we have in common is always a pleasant surprise.


Afraid I dont agree!There is something much more tribal in our game than other team sports like cricket and rugby.Nothing else in any other sport compares to a goal either for or against.And the there is the singing,extreme language and punch ups!

 

EagleRider Flag Seasalter, Kent 20 Jan 14 5.20pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 20 Jan 2014 5.11pm

Quote EagleRider at 20 Jan 2014 5.02pm

I don't think it's football but sports in general.
It's something we can grab onto and be a part of without actually having to be good enough to be out on the pitch competing. And we can form friendships and have conversations while literally only needing to have one thing in common. Anything else we find we have in common is always a pleasant surprise.


Afraid I dont agree!There is something much more tribal in our game than other team sports like cricket and rugby.Nothing else in any other sport compares to a goal either for or against.And the there is the singing,extreme language and punch ups!

Sorry mate, I grew up in America and therefore didn't even think of cricket as being a real sport when replying earlier. I may disagree about the rugby, though my knowledge of English rugby is not brilliant.

I'm not sure your level of experience with any of the following, but if you are or were better acquainted with ice hockey, american football, basketball, and yes...even baseball in some cities, you'd know fans gets pretty damn emotive and possibly even end up in a fist fight when the team scores an upset or even just beats the tar out of a team they were expected to beat.
In fact, ice hockey allows in-game fighting that isn't broken up until one of the guys has gone down.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 20 Jan 14 5.28pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 20 Jan 2014 4.53pm

Crowd Psychology, its about the expression of aspects of self along shared identified lines. To an extent this may well be hardwired into us biologically, but Team sports generally tie into our need to belong to a tribe.

Its more emphasised in football than other sports because football has much strong emotional highs and lows, because chance dominates the outcome more than other sports, and the difference between a 'win and a loss' are very tight, making individuals tense, and thus the crowd tense, and then feeding back into the crowd. Unsurprisingly, its football not tennis or cricket that are associated with violence (itself tied to the tribalism, the tense atmosphere and the adoption of localised rivalries).

I'm afraid that I don't agree with you. Any cricket fan who goes regularly to Test Matches or even One Day Internationals will tell you that they can be equally emotional with the same highs and lows that you get in football.

Unlike football though fans of opposing teams happily sit next to each other, talk to each other and congratulate each other and whilst winning in cricket is as important to the fan as it is in football you don't get the same sorts of aggravation and violence that you do in football.

Whilst I disagree with you I can't give an alternative reason for the difference as football seems to appeal to peoples' baser instincts but I don't know why

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 20 Jan 14 5.37pm

It is quite simple:
We are all stark, raving mad .....

 


Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 Jan 14 4.46pm

Quote Ian J at 20 Jan 2014 5.28pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 20 Jan 2014 4.53pm

Crowd Psychology, its about the expression of aspects of self along shared identified lines. To an extent this may well be hardwired into us biologically, but Team sports generally tie into our need to belong to a tribe.

Its more emphasised in football than other sports because football has much strong emotional highs and lows, because chance dominates the outcome more than other sports, and the difference between a 'win and a loss' are very tight, making individuals tense, and thus the crowd tense, and then feeding back into the crowd. Unsurprisingly, its football not tennis or cricket that are associated with violence (itself tied to the tribalism, the tense atmosphere and the adoption of localised rivalries).

I'm afraid that I don't agree with you. Any cricket fan who goes regularly to Test Matches or even One Day Internationals will tell you that they can be equally emotional with the same highs and lows that you get in football.

Unlike football though fans of opposing teams happily sit next to each other, talk to each other and congratulate each other and whilst winning in cricket is as important to the fan as it is in football you don't get the same sorts of aggravation and violence that you do in football.

Whilst I disagree with you I can't give an alternative reason for the difference as football seems to appeal to peoples' baser instincts but I don't know why

The difference I would posit is tension, football's most common score is 1-1 and 2-1, that can change in an instant, even if you're team has been s**te all game. Cricket, you generally know if your going to win after the fourth batsman. Plus you can see a recovery or collapse coming, generally speaking. Where as football is full of situations where you suddenly draw level in a mad five minutes. The rollercoaster effect is much more pronounced.

Also cricket doesn't really have the same level of local focus. The sport is a 'gentlemans sport' without the kind of inter-local rivalry you see in Football. Theres a correlation between the idea of rivalry and levels of violence in sport, especially where 'banter' among fans is common.

When you look at Cricket on a professional level, its county vs county level or international, football is against the team your c**t of a boss supports, or that loud mouth s**t in the pub. It is personal, local, changeable and very intense.

Cricket brings out the best in fans, because identification with a team is along very different group identity concepts than football, and that manifests differently.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Part Time James Flag 21 Jan 14 4.48pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 20 Jan 2014 4.55pm

Quote Part Time James at 20 Jan 2014 3.47pm

Maybe it reverts us to a deep seated need to be tribal and face off against others.

I was reflecting the other day, if no one I ever encountered liked football, would I feel so up/down after a weekend of football results?

I follow the NHL Ice Hockey as well as football and when my chosen team loses I feel slightly miffed but because I know very few people who even know what the NHL is, it doesn't harm my mood so much.

Indeed, and in Canada the reverse is probably true. They're quite tribal about their Ice Hockey and trouble between fans occurs.


Oh yeah, definitely. During the playoffs last year I developed a hatred for the Senators which I just sort of absorbed from the TV. But that disproves my point a bit and digresses from the thread. Sorry folks!

 




Midlands Eagle Flag 22 Jan 14 6.30am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 21 Jan 2014 4.46pm

Also cricket doesn't really have the same level of local focus. The sport is a 'gentlemans sport' without the kind of inter-local rivalry you see in Football. Theres a correlation between the idea of rivalry and levels of violence in sport, especially where 'banter' among fans is common.

The TV cameras tend to focus on the old boys in their blazers dozing off in the sunshine at test matches but they are in the minority as the vast majority of cricket spectators are ordinary working class people who probably go to the footie on Winter.

You are probably correct about the local rivalries being less intense in County Cricket but not so in certain international games as the rivalry between English and Australian is huge and if you want banter you only have to listen to the Barmy Army who are probably the country's leading banter experts but although some of their songs can be cutting and cruel they are always amusing.


 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 22 Jan 14 12.20pm

Many times I have wondered why I get so worked up about the fortunes of my team (Palace of course)

I have no say in the running of the club. I have never met any of the players. In a few years, or less, most will have moved on and there will be a different manager. So it's not down to any direct personal involvement.

The outcome of a Palace game will have no effect on my material well-being. It won't mean more or less money in my bank account at the end of the month.

So why should their performance on a Saturday affect my mood during the following week? Why should I care and get so worked up at a match, or find the tension almost unbearable when listening to a radio commentary. What is it about the entity we call Crystal Palace( or any other club) that engenders our slavish devotion?

Possibly it is some unresolved immaturity amongst us football fanatics whereby we are able to find fulfillment in the activities of a bunch of strangers kicking a ball around?

Perhaps it satisfies a need to feel part of something which we don't have satisfied in other realms of our day to day lives. Possibly it allows us emotionally constipated males a rare opportunity to let rip - to scream, shout and cry.

In the end I really don't know why the outcome of a football match can mean so much to me . It shouldn't do but by heck it does.

 

thommo1 Flag Peckham 22 Jan 14 12.39pm

Great post Pete, we all feel the same I am sure but we cant answer why either, I feel you are probably right on a few of your thoughts.. There must have been studys done as its not your stero typical person ie a 'football hooligan' who is caught in this trap. lol

 


DJ John Peel once said: "Supporting Palace has a certain cult value, like pretending that some Peruvian rock band is the best in the world."

Moose Flag In the sewer pipe... 22 Jan 14 12.47pm

Quote Ian J at 22 Jan 2014 6.30am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 21 Jan 2014 4.46pm

Also cricket doesn't really have the same level of local focus. The sport is a 'gentlemans sport' without the kind of inter-local rivalry you see in Football. Theres a correlation between the idea of rivalry and levels of violence in sport, especially where 'banter' among fans is common.

The TV cameras tend to focus on the old boys in their blazers dozing off in the sunshine at test matches but they are in the minority as the vast majority of cricket spectators are ordinary working class people who probably go to the footie on Winter.

You are probably correct about the local rivalries being less intense in County Cricket but not so in certain international games as the rivalry between English and Australian is huge and if you want banter you only have to listen to the Barmy Army who are probably the country's leading banter experts but although some of their songs can be cutting and cruel they are always amusing.



Exactly.

Try standing near Bay 13 at the MCG during an Ashes Test Match and then arguing that the rivalry is not intense.

 


Goodness is what you do. Not who you pray to.

hursteagle Flag 22 Jan 14 12.53pm

I've often thought about this... and have never got to the bottom of it!

It makes even less sense when you compare football to other 'forms of entertainment'.

Take films... if you went to see Harry Potter 1 at your local cinema and it wasn't very good then you might chance Harry Potter 2. But if that also wasn't very good, the offer of doing a 300 mile round trip on a Tuesday night to see Harry Potter 3 wouldn't be very attractive!

But Palace could lose 5-0 at home to Yeovil, lose 5-0 at home to Swindon, but that wouldn't stop me heading up to Walsall on a wet Tuesday night in December!!!

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What makes Football so emotive