You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why does Moody have such a good rep?
November 16 2026 1.13pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why does Moody have such a good rep?


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
est1905 Flag 25 Jan 14 3.37pm

Quote jimmyc at 25 Jan 2014 1.48pm

And you should do your own research. Although you did a good job at finding the negative garbage the Mail spews out and posting it.


You are his wife aren't you!

 

Recto Flag London 25 Jan 14 3.39pm

.

Edited by Recto (25 Jan 2014 3.41pm)

 


Murray with the chest on HERE'S GAYLE!!!!3-3

[Link] - My Blog

- My Twitter

sydtheeagle Flag England 25 Jan 14 4.10pm

Good managers surround themselves with people who can execute their intentions. That's a polite way of saying "take orders". Successful managers in football recognise this; the Fergie template is to run the club at all levels with an iron fist and don't keep anyone around who might challenge your authority. Fergie is Malky's role model. Fact.

Malky, at Watford and then Cardiff, surrounded himself with people capable enough to get things done, young and unknown enough not to challenge his authority, and ambitious enough to be loyal and contribute to his success. Moody was one of these people. He competently did exactly what Malky told him needed to be done.

With no disrespect at all, though, Moody was as good as his brain (Malky) and his wallet (Tan, and before that the Watford fella) made him. Now, he's on his own, with a manager who didn't hand-pick him and an owner who may be expecting him to actually have the strategy, rather than just executing it. Basically, we signed a top notch oily rag bereft of his engineer.

All of which may partially explain the enduring inability of Palace to make headway in the transfer market, in spite of Moody's arrival.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 25 Jan 14 4.33pm

On the other hand we might not be an attractive proposition and we don't pay big wages, compared to other clubs.

People are so quick to attack others and with actually no evidence to back it up.

Let's throw caution to the wind, what's the worst that could happen? I'm all for a third spell of admin...........

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

sydtheeagle Flag England 25 Jan 14 5.13pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Jan 2014 4.33pm

On the other hand we might not be an attractive proposition and we don't pay big wages, compared to other clubs.

People are so quick to attack others and with actually no evidence to back it up.

Let's throw caution to the wind, what's the worst that could happen? I'm all for a third spell of admin...........

This would be a sensible post if the world was black and white and paying one or two key players bigger wages would be absolutely certain to end in administration. But, as we all know, that's not the case. Plenty of clubs -- Everton for one -- operate within a wage structure which, when it is sensible to do so, they adjust -- as they are about to do for Baines. The bottom line is that good owners DON'T impose limitations; they deliver success while at the same time mitigating risk. But we seem to think that zero risk, even if it means zero success, is a prudent operating model. And it's not.


Edited by sydtheeagle (25 Jan 2014 5.13pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Midlands Eagle Flag 25 Jan 14 5.14pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Jan 2014 4.33pm

Let's throw caution to the wind, what's the worst that could happen? I'm all for a third spell of admin...........

Is this going to be mentioned for the next ten years whenever someone suggests that perhaps we ought to pay the going rate if we want to attract the right calibre of players for the league that we are in.


 

elgrande Flag bedford 25 Jan 14 5.15pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 25 Jan 2014 5.13pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Jan 2014 4.33pm

On the other hand we might not be an attractive proposition and we don't pay big wages, compared to other clubs.

People are so quick to attack others and with actually no evidence to back it up.

Let's throw caution to the wind, what's the worst that could happen? I'm all for a third spell of admin...........

This would be a sensible post if the world was black and white and paying one or two key players bigger wages would be absolutely certain to end in administration. But, as we all know, that's not the case. Plenty of clubs -- Everton for one -- operate within a wage structure which, when it is sensible to do so, they adjust -- as they are about to do for Baines. The bottom line is that good owners DON'T impose limitations; they deliver success while at the same time mitigating risk. But we seem to think that zero risk, even if it means zero success, is a prudent operating model. And it's not.


Edited by sydtheeagle (25 Jan 2014 5.13pm)

How long has Everton been in the premier league.with all the Sky money.

Pathetic comparison.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

Joeberto Flag Streatham Hill 25 Jan 14 5.21pm

Quote elgrande at 25 Jan 2014 5.15pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 25 Jan 2014 5.13pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Jan 2014 4.33pm

On the other hand we might not be an attractive proposition and we don't pay big wages, compared to other clubs.

People are so quick to attack others and with actually no evidence to back it up.

Let's throw caution to the wind, what's the worst that could happen? I'm all for a third spell of admin...........

This would be a sensible post if the world was black and white and paying one or two key players bigger wages would be absolutely certain to end in administration. But, as we all know, that's not the case. Plenty of clubs -- Everton for one -- operate within a wage structure which, when it is sensible to do so, they adjust -- as they are about to do for Baines. The bottom line is that good owners DON'T impose limitations; they deliver success while at the same time mitigating risk. But we seem to think that zero risk, even if it means zero success, is a prudent operating model. And it's not.


Edited by sydtheeagle (25 Jan 2014 5.13pm)

How long has Everton been in the premier league.with all the Sky money.

Pathetic comparison.

Quite right - plus Everton's current success has come at the end of around a decade of being cautious, not overspending and backing competent managers with enough to stay withing their means.

Closest comparisons for us at this point might be West Brom or Reading?

 

est1905 Flag 25 Jan 14 5.21pm

Quote elgrande at 25 Jan 2014 5.15pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 25 Jan 2014 5.13pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Jan 2014 4.33pm

On the other hand we might not be an attractive proposition and we don't pay big wages, compared to other clubs.

People are so quick to attack others and with actually no evidence to back it up.

Let's throw caution to the wind, what's the worst that could happen? I'm all for a third spell of admin...........

This would be a sensible post if the world was black and white and paying one or two key players bigger wages would be absolutely certain to end in administration. But, as we all know, that's not the case. Plenty of clubs -- Everton for one -- operate within a wage structure which, when it is sensible to do so, they adjust -- as they are about to do for Baines. The bottom line is that good owners DON'T impose limitations; they deliver success while at the same time mitigating risk. But we seem to think that zero risk, even if it means zero success, is a prudent operating model. And it's not.


Edited by sydtheeagle (25 Jan 2014 5.13pm)

How long has Everton been in the premier league.with all the Sky money.

Pathetic comparison.

You could turn that argument on its head and say Everton have been in the Premier league for so long because they know when to make adjustments to their budgets, etc.


 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 25 Jan 14 5.22pm

I take it you work at the club, closely with the owners and know exactly how they feel and operate.
I'm sure if they feel they can pay the wages they would, so I have to assume that they don't think it's worth the risk. Personally I will trust their judgement and if we go down, so be it. We bought and bought and bought in the last window and that was also wrong, apparently. Comparing us to a club that has never been relegated out of the top league is quite honestly laughable.
What actually is success for a club like Palace? Just being here could be considered success. We are Palace we've never been successful and in this modern day money laden football World, we never will, unless we get a billionaire in charge and lots of people don't want that either.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 25 Jan 14 5.26pm

Quote Ian J at 25 Jan 2014 5.14pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Jan 2014 4.33pm

Let's throw caution to the wind, what's the worst that could happen? I'm all for a third spell of admin...........

Is this going to be mentioned for the next ten years whenever someone suggests that perhaps we ought to pay the going rate if we want to attract the right calibre of players for the league that we are in.


Yes.
We have a history of f***in' it up financially, so why not again?
No one has said we won't pay the going rate, it would appear that we cannot afford to pay the going rate. Seriously 35k a week for Sissoko, you having a laugh?

Hopefully Vincent Tann has a brother who fancies taking us over.


 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Joeberto Flag Streatham Hill 25 Jan 14 5.28pm

Quote est1905 at 25 Jan 2014 5.21pm

Quote elgrande at 25 Jan 2014 5.15pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 25 Jan 2014 5.13pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Jan 2014 4.33pm

On the other hand we might not be an attractive proposition and we don't pay big wages, compared to other clubs.

People are so quick to attack others and with actually no evidence to back it up.

Let's throw caution to the wind, what's the worst that could happen? I'm all for a third spell of admin...........

This would be a sensible post if the world was black and white and paying one or two key players bigger wages would be absolutely certain to end in administration. But, as we all know, that's not the case. Plenty of clubs -- Everton for one -- operate within a wage structure which, when it is sensible to do so, they adjust -- as they are about to do for Baines. The bottom line is that good owners DON'T impose limitations; they deliver success while at the same time mitigating risk. But we seem to think that zero risk, even if it means zero success, is a prudent operating model. And it's not.


Edited by sydtheeagle (25 Jan 2014 5.13pm)

How long has Everton been in the premier league.with all the Sky money.

Pathetic comparison.

You could turn that argument on its head and say Everton have been in the Premier league for so long because they know when to make adjustments to their budgets, etc.


You could. But you'd still just be making it up, and you'd probably be wrong.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 25 Jan 14 5.29pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Jan 2014 5.22pm

I take it you work at the club, closely with the owners and know exactly how they feel and operate.
I'm sure if they feel they can pay the wages they would, so I have to assume that they don't think it's worth the risk. Personally I will trust their judgement and if we go down, so be it. We bought and bought and bought in the last window and that was also wrong, apparently.

You start off with a sarcastic comment then fall into the same trap yourself. You're sure that "if they feel they can pay the wages they would". I take it you work at the club , closely with the owners and know exactly how they feel and operate

If you cast your mind back to pre-season most people were asking that we improve the team with a few quality players. No-one asked for as many as they signed and in fact most of us wondered what the hell they were doing and wondered if they knew themselves.

You claim to trust in their judgement. Did you say that when they employed George Burley and Ian Holloway too?


 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Jan 14 5.34pm

Quote est1905 at 25 Jan 2014 5.21pm

You could turn that argument on its head and say Everton have been in the Premier league for so long because they know when to make adjustments to their budgets, etc.



So now Everton have never been relegated from the top flight of football because they know how to adjust their budget. Pffffft. Nothing to do with them being in the top flight for 60 years, always having 40,000 crowds no matter what condition the economy is in. Always having a sound scouting system in place at schoolboy and professional level due to their history in the top flight.

There is every chance that your player budget and revenue will decide roughly where in the table you will finish, and Everton are not in with the bottom 8 or so. It's no different for most, unless you're West Ham or QPR and you try to do it too quickly with that greasy pole from 11th to 18th.

 


COYP

Joeberto Flag Streatham Hill 25 Jan 14 5.39pm

Quote Ian J at 25 Jan 2014 5.29pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Jan 2014 5.22pm

I take it you work at the club, closely with the owners and know exactly how they feel and operate.
I'm sure if they feel they can pay the wages they would, so I have to assume that they don't think it's worth the risk. Personally I will trust their judgement and if we go down, so be it. We bought and bought and bought in the last window and that was also wrong, apparently.

You start off with a sarcastic comment then fall into the same trap yourself. You're sure that "if they feel they can pay the wages they would". I take it you work at the club , closely with the owners and know exactly how they feel and operate

If you cast your mind back to pre-season most people were asking that we improve the team with a few quality players. No-one asked for as many as they signed and in fact most of us wondered what the hell they were doing and wondered if they knew themselves.

You claim to trust in their judgement. Did you say that when they employed George Burley and Ian Holloway too?


I don't think George Burley seemed a bad option at the time, but turned out to be a disappointment.

Since then Dougie was backed to stabilise us, which he did before jumping ship.

Ollie was backed to get us promoted, which he did before losing the plot and jumping ship.

Pulis has been backed to keep us up. He's doing a good job so far, but with a long way to go.

As for Moody, the talk was that he was brought in after the last window when it became clear that Parish couldn't handle transfers & recruitment himself. If he is dealing with a large portion of the work involved, then that is working. I think it'll be a while before we can make a fair judgement of how successful he is.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 25 Jan 14 5.40pm

Quote Ian J at 25 Jan 2014 5.29pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Jan 2014 5.22pm

I take it you work at the club, closely with the owners and know exactly how they feel and operate.
I'm sure if they feel they can pay the wages they would, so I have to assume that they don't think it's worth the risk. Personally I will trust their judgement and if we go down, so be it. We bought and bought and bought in the last window and that was also wrong, apparently.

You start off with a sarcastic comment then fall into the same trap yourself. You're sure that "if they feel they can pay the wages they would". I take it you work at the club , closely with the owners and know exactly how they feel and operate

If you cast your mind back to pre-season most people were asking that we improve the team with a few quality players. No-one asked for as many as they signed and in fact most of us wondered what the hell they were doing and wondered if they knew themselves.

You claim to trust in their judgement. Did you say that when they employed George Burley and Ian Holloway too?


Why wouldn't I ? What have they done so wrong so far?

Burley was never given the time, so may of been a success if he'd stayed, then again he may of failed.
Holloway took us up and gave me bragging rights until the day I die over the weed, so I have no complaints over his appointment. No manager guarantees success.

In the summer we found out how unprepared for this division this club is after years of under investment and administration. We are the poorest team in the division and this is making it hard for us to match the packages other teams can offer.
The owners are learning as they go, it would seem, but it's really got f*** all to do with me, what they do and how they do it.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Jan 14 5.44pm

Quote Ian J at 25 Jan 2014 5.29pm

You claim to trust in their judgement. Did you say that when they employed George Burley and Ian Holloway too?


I did when they sacked Burley and I did when they hired IH. People conveniently forget we had no Garvan, Moritz or Williams for over 2 months. We were only ever going to reach the play offs. Luckily we did, granted, mainly because of the spread of points and DF bottling it 'Cardiff style', but please don't try and paint this picture of SP and 2010 lacking any football clout. Burley didn't work, it was corrected with DF preserving our marginal leads or draws, and IH knowing what it takes to go up.

We need players. They know it as much as we do, but there's more than one area that needs filling and a consequence of it failing badly. How many of the early January transfers would've accepted a relegation clause in their contract? Highly likely that none of them would. We are now also more vulnerable at LB.

I trust TP, but don't forget that most managers ultimately couldn't give a fook what happens to most clubs/employers after they've left.

 


COYP

crystalpark7 Flag London 25 Jan 14 7.00pm

Sadly have to agree with the OP. Tan may be a crazy owner, but he definitely had a right to question some of their buys. Medal was apparently offered for £6 million and Cardiff bought him for £11 million. His other buys seem overpriced. He was operating with a budget of a top 10 club not a Championship or newly promoted team. Time will tell, but I did not see why it was a particularly good appointment at the time and I still don't now.

 

sueagle2012 Flag 25 Jan 14 7.21pm

I dont think a club like ours needs a guy like Moody. Once we are better established in PL..and have more money to splash around..maybe.

As has been pointed out already there are major questionmarks over his track record at Cardiff..and although I am no fan of Tan(his PR is so bad)..he is right to say Moody and Mackay wasted a lot of his money...and hence right to sack them..esp Moody. OK ..to replace him with 21 year old who could not get a work permit was very bad PR.
But few can argue that signings like Cornelius and Medel can be regarded as success...esp with inflated wages and transfer fees involved.

At Palace..I am sure Pulis would prefer to work directly with the board on transfers. At best..Moody can be a European scout...Without big money to offer he will have difficulty in attracting suitable players.

I hope I am wrong but I would be very surprised if Moody will be regarded as a success in 12 months time.


Edited by sueagle2012 (25 Jan 2014 7.24pm)

 

Ljb Flag Sutton 25 Jan 14 7.48pm

Baffled as to what this guy actually does. We managed to sign 16 players in the summer, albeit over a longer time period, with no such staff. Now we have a 'specialist recruit' type guy who has so far (seemingly) done absolutely nothing!

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why does Moody have such a good rep?