You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are the HOL/BBS architects of the club's 'unrest'?
November 16 2026 1.24pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are the HOL/BBS architects of the club's 'unrest'?


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Midlands Eagle Flag 28 Jan 14 6.38am

Quote NEILLO at 27 Jan 2014 10.25pm

A lot of the debate on HOL has been fuelled by the newspaper ( well, The Mirror mainly ) reporting on our struggles in the transfer window. The extension of that is to report that Pulis is unhappy as a result. Until such time as we hear to the contrary, then of course we are going to do what this site is for - discuss, speculate, rant, whatever !

We all have our own views on how the club is run. This is a place where we can share those views, no matter how extreme some of them are.

So to answer the original question - it's a '' no '' from me.

What you say is true and much of the lively debate here has been fuelled by various Mirror stories. I must admit that I don't really understand what is going on as I don't believe that it is down to lazy journalism so that means that either someone is feeding them snippets for their own ends or else the Mirror are printing blatant lies and I'm not sure which one it is.

The board are well aware of what is said on these boards and they do often use them as well as social media for putting across their views.

They also know that many supporters are interested in their views otherwise why would Steve Parish have over 16,500 followers on his Twitter account.

There is no doubt that robust debate on the forums does get the Board's attention and perhaps we do influence some of their thinking otherwise why would Steve Parish have said that they wouldn't be employing Chris Coleman as so many of the fans were against the idea.

The board and Steve Parish in particular understand the power of the fan and know how important forums and social media is nowadays in formulating and spreading opinion and there is no doubt that it was the unrest here that forced Tony Pulis to state that he wouldn't be walking away but it's just a shame that Steve Parish and Steve Browett didn't come out and issue unequivocal denials straight away to kill off the story before it gained legs

 

FinchleyEagle Flag 28 Jan 14 8.11am

Quote Ian J at 28 Jan 2014 6.38am

Quote NEILLO at 27 Jan 2014 10.25pm

A lot of the debate on HOL has been fuelled by the newspaper ( well, The Mirror mainly ) reporting on our struggles in the transfer window. The extension of that is to report that Pulis is unhappy as a result. Until such time as we hear to the contrary, then of course we are going to do what this site is for - discuss, speculate, rant, whatever !

We all have our own views on how the club is run. This is a place where we can share those views, no matter how extreme some of them are.

So to answer the original question - it's a '' no '' from me.

What you say is true and much of the lively debate here has been fuelled by various Mirror stories. I must admit that I don't really understand what is going on as I don't believe that it is down to lazy journalism so that means that either someone is feeding them snippets for their own ends or else the Mirror are printing blatant lies and I'm not sure which one it is.

The board are well aware of what is said on these boards and they do often use them as well as social media for putting across their views.

They also know that many supporters are interested in their views otherwise why would Steve Parish have over 16,500 followers on his Twitter account.

There is no doubt that robust debate on the forums does get the Board's attention and perhaps we do influence some of their thinking otherwise why would Steve Parish have said that they wouldn't be employing Chris Coleman as so many of the fans were against the idea.

The board and Steve Parish in particular understand the power of the fan and know how important forums and social media is nowadays in formulating and spreading opinion and there is no doubt that it was the unrest here that forced Tony Pulis to state that he wouldn't be walking away but it's just a shame that Steve Parish and Steve Browett didn't come out and issue unequivocal denials straight away to kill off the story before it gained legs

Yes mate you keep telling yourself how relevant this load of utter nonsense and ignorance is in the grand scheme of things. What you post here IS important. Bless.

I'm sure journalists do come and have a look and then use it to back up the phrase 'the fans think...' But take a look at a thread, any thread. So many unresearched things stated as 'fact', hyperbole, vitriol, opinions and egos - anyone who genuinely takes anything seriously on here needs a reality check.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

silvertop Flag Portishead 28 Jan 14 9.19am

When we get to work I think we are noticed. However, it would have to be an almighty hoo hah such as the Cookie backlash or the Nugent Affair for the matter to get reported and to then have some influence.

You never know, perhaps Coleman chose not to come here and take the Wales job as the message boards [including this one] went into melt-down at the prospect?

However, you would have to be the most dillusional teenage smurf if you thought some implausible rant in semi-text will have any impact on anything.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Jan 14 9.31am

People are always the source of unrest and discord. Essentially we pick up on rumours that make it onto news sources, and because they are news sources we validate them as such, because for the most part news sources are trusted to contain a degree of truth.

However sports reporting isn't like News. Information is tightly controlled by clubs, and unlike most other environments, a club can restrict information easily to one or two reliable individuals. Consequently actual news in football is generally

press released and controlled, so actual news is rare, as a consequence papers and news media for football will publish any old unsubstanciated rumour and it gets circulated as news, because otherwise football journalism would be limited to the occassional expose, match reports and press releases.

Of course some rumours are true, but largely they'll relate to transfers, and its usually down to clubs and agents angling for either publicity and value control

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

wainesworld Flag west wickham 28 Jan 14 9.33am

Quote beagle at 27 Jan 2014 9.11pm

Are the HOL/BBS architects of the club's 'unrest'?

I put the word 'unrest' in inverted commas as Pullis has come out to the press to say not only is he going nowhere, but the board are/have been doing a top job.

Which is a strange coincidence give that both Palace boards have been a fury of speculation, whispers, information, mis-information and passionate debate on both subjects.

Extraordinarily Palace are fairly unique in having two 'thriving' (and that aint the half of it) boards.

And we all know the football press keeps a close eye on the two sites for 'stories' (A case in point is someone like The Adder editor who is a regular in terms posting links to his paper's latest Palace 'scoop'- and there's no way he aint checking out the gossip and arguments we post). The boards are a barometer and an easy newsfeed.

So if Pullis, as he says, genuinely has no problem with the board and isnt off anywhere then are we the architects of the club becomes a 'backpage story'? Pullis is fending off questions. The board is. The players will have their fingers on every media pulse and wondering if there are 'issues' etc etc and the whole 'non-story' gets ratcheted up.

On the other hand, I thoroughly enjoy the ebb and flow of the debate, but I do wonder if the popularity of both boards has a negative side and we are, unwittingly, the architects of some of the 'unrest' (which, according to TP, is non-existant btw )

Edited by beagle (27 Jan 2014 9.14pm)

No.


 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 28 Jan 14 9.36am

Hol and BBS represent a small percentage of Palace fans. The amount of bulls*** that is spouted on here is beyond belief and only a very poor journo would come on our forums for stories/info.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 28 Jan 14 9.46am

Quote bubble wrap at 28 Jan 2014 9.36am

Hol and BBS represent a small percentage of Palace fans. The amount of bulls*** that is spouted on here is beyond belief and only a very poor journo would come on our forums for stories/info.


but the advertiser said they DON'T come on here for stories.....

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


beagle Flag pom tiddly om pom pom 28 Jan 14 9.46am

Quote wainesworld at 28 Jan 2014 9.33am

Quote beagle at 27 Jan 2014 9.11pm

Are the HOL/BBS architects of the club's 'unrest'?

I put the word 'unrest' in inverted commas as Pullis has come out to the press to say not only is he going nowhere, but the board are/have been doing a top job.

Which is a strange coincidence give that both Palace boards have been a fury of speculation, whispers, information, mis-information and passionate debate on both subjects.

Extraordinarily Palace are fairly unique in having two 'thriving' (and that aint the half of it) boards.

And we all know the football press keeps a close eye on the two sites for 'stories' (A case in point is someone like The Adder editor who is a regular in terms posting links to his paper's latest Palace 'scoop'- and there's no way he aint checking out the gossip and arguments we post). The boards are a barometer and an easy newsfeed.

So if Pullis, as he says, genuinely has no problem with the board and isnt off anywhere then are we the architects of the club becomes a 'backpage story'? Pullis is fending off questions. The board is. The players will have their fingers on every media pulse and wondering if there are 'issues' etc etc and the whole 'non-story' gets ratcheted up.

On the other hand, I thoroughly enjoy the ebb and flow of the debate, but I do wonder if the popularity of both boards has a negative side and we are, unwittingly, the architects of some of the 'unrest' (which, according to TP, is non-existant btw )

Edited by beagle (27 Jan 2014 9.14pm)

No.



 


When the time comes, I want die just like my Dad - at peace and asleep.
Not screaming and terrified.
Like his passengers.

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 28 Jan 14 9.49am

Quote paperhat at 28 Jan 2014 9.46am

Quote bubble wrap at 28 Jan 2014 9.36am

Hol and BBS represent a small percentage of Palace fans. The amount of bulls*** that is spouted on here is beyond belief and only a very poor journo would come on our forums for stories/info.


but the advertiser said they DON'T come on here for stories.....

Not sure they do,Probably get their stories from the Daily Mirror..

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Jan 14 10.29am

The papers are the architects, some of the forum can at times lap up whatever is served to them. One thing about Palace that's unique is that the percentage of Palace fans with accounts on HOL or the BBS is pretty high. How many Palace fans are there? 40,000? How many account holders? How many non-account holders speak to an account very soon after something like this comes out?

How many Palace fans buy/read/log onto The Mirror unless there's a click through on HOL or the BBS? Very few.

The papers throw a pack of dogs one bone, sit back, laugh, and wait to see if it causes article number 2 they've got ready to go to print.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Jan 14 10.33am

The papers are the architects, we are the nimby's holding our 1st meeting.

 


COYP

paperhat Flag croydon 28 Jan 14 10.36am

I like the idea of reverse engineerng a story. Can we not meet before a game, contive something spectacular, then get someone to let slip on here and wait for the Mirror et al to release their "exclusive"?

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 28 Jan 14 10.38am

Quote Rudi Hedman at 28 Jan 2014 10.29am

The papers are the architects, some of the forum can at times lap up whatever is served to them. One thing about Palace that's unique is that the percentage of Palace fans with accounts on HOL or the BBS is pretty high. How many Palace fans are there? 40,000? How many account holders? How many non-account holders speak to an account very soon after something like this comes out?

How many Palace fans buy/read/log onto The Mirror unless there's a click through on HOL or the BBS? Very few.

The papers throw a pack of dogs one bone, sit back, laugh, and wait to see if it causes article number 2 they've got ready to go to print.

Sorry to disagree Rudi but I beleive the percentage of Palace fans on BBS and Hols is not that high I reckon 5% with the majority not active. BBS have far more than on here but the majority of fans I know do not go on here or will look but do not have accounts.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Jan 14 10.45am

Quote bubble wrap at 28 Jan 2014 10.38am

Quote Rudi Hedman at 28 Jan 2014 10.29am

The papers are the architects, some of the forum can at times lap up whatever is served to them. One thing about Palace that's unique is that the percentage of Palace fans with accounts on HOL or the BBS is pretty high. How many Palace fans are there? 40,000? How many account holders? How many non-account holders speak to an account very soon after something like this comes out?

How many Palace fans buy/read/log onto The Mirror unless there's a click through on HOL or the BBS? Very few.

The papers throw a pack of dogs one bone, sit back, laugh, and wait to see if it causes article number 2 they've got ready to go to print.

Sorry to disagree Rudi but I beleive the percentage of Palace fans on BBS and Hols is not that high I reckon 5% with the majority not active. BBS have far more than on here but the majority of fans I know do not go on here or will look but do not have accounts.


'Look' is good enough. I think there's a lot of people who set up accounts, especially in the earlier days of the BBS, but don't bother logging on. It's the best place to find news articles, all listed in one place.

 


COYP

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 28 Jan 14 12.18pm

Quote FinchleyEagle at 28 Jan 2014 8.11am

Quote Ian J at 28 Jan 2014 6.38am

Quote NEILLO at 27 Jan 2014 10.25pm

A lot of the debate on HOL has been fuelled by the newspaper ( well, The Mirror mainly ) reporting on our struggles in the transfer window. The extension of that is to report that Pulis is unhappy as a result. Until such time as we hear to the contrary, then of course we are going to do what this site is for - discuss, speculate, rant, whatever !

We all have our own views on how the club is run. This is a place where we can share those views, no matter how extreme some of them are.

So to answer the original question - it's a '' no '' from me.

What you say is true and much of the lively debate here has been fuelled by various Mirror stories. I must admit that I don't really understand what is going on as I don't believe that it is down to lazy journalism so that means that either someone is feeding them snippets for their own ends or else the Mirror are printing blatant lies and I'm not sure which one it is.

The board are well aware of what is said on these boards and they do often use them as well as social media for putting across their views.

They also know that many supporters are interested in their views otherwise why would Steve Parish have over 16,500 followers on his Twitter account.

There is no doubt that robust debate on the forums does get the Board's attention and perhaps we do influence some of their thinking otherwise why would Steve Parish have said that they wouldn't be employing Chris Coleman as so many of the fans were against the idea.

The board and Steve Parish in particular understand the power of the fan and know how important forums and social media is nowadays in formulating and spreading opinion and there is no doubt that it was the unrest here that forced Tony Pulis to state that he wouldn't be walking away but it's just a shame that Steve Parish and Steve Browett didn't come out and issue unequivocal denials straight away to kill off the story before it gained legs

Yes mate you keep telling yourself how relevant this load of utter nonsense and ignorance is in the grand scheme of things. What you post here IS important. Bless.

I'm sure journalists do come and have a look and then use it to back up the phrase 'the fans think...' But take a look at a thread, any thread. So many unresearched things stated as 'fact', hyperbole, vitriol, opinions and egos - anyone who genuinely takes anything seriously on here needs a reality check.


You are so wrong Finchers the papers do take the internet ramblings of this board serioulsy ...we all remember The Mirrors 'DanH is a Bender' headlines

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Stuart_Eagle Flag Kent 28 Jan 14 1.21pm

Quote Manc_Palace at 27 Jan 2014 11.01pm

Quote Mapletree at 27 Jan 2014 9.59pm

Quote Manc_Palace at 27 Jan 2014 9.48pm

It's really difficult to come on this forum at the moment and take anything seriously.

I sincerely hope we don't have another world war and I'm not in the trenches with half of you as you'd be having breakdowns every five minutes.

Is there anything that can be said or done that can make you guys just have a little patience and wait until the 1st? Unfortunately none of us are privvy to the information that you desire and speculating is making some people really not cope very well. We need to look after these people and understand that conjecture in any form really affects their daily lives

Thank you

Strange post. Everyone on this thread is being reasonable. If the 'you' is aimed at Holers in general maybe I see your point.


Absolutely meant the HOL in general, should have made that clearer.


I'm in agreement, promotion has seen some real doom merchants join this site. Imagine if the 'world is over if we don't sign many players to satisfy my thirst' type fans were on here 3-4 years ago

 


we're the Arthur, we're the Arthur, we're the Arthur over here!

Positive! Proud & Palace - W block, AW

FinchleyEagle Flag 28 Jan 14 1.44pm

Quote The Sash at 28 Jan 2014 12.18pm

Quote FinchleyEagle at 28 Jan 2014 8.11am

Quote Ian J at 28 Jan 2014 6.38am

Quote NEILLO at 27 Jan 2014 10.25pm

A lot of the debate on HOL has been fuelled by the newspaper ( well, The Mirror mainly ) reporting on our struggles in the transfer window. The extension of that is to report that Pulis is unhappy as a result. Until such time as we hear to the contrary, then of course we are going to do what this site is for - discuss, speculate, rant, whatever !

We all have our own views on how the club is run. This is a place where we can share those views, no matter how extreme some of them are.

So to answer the original question - it's a '' no '' from me.

What you say is true and much of the lively debate here has been fuelled by various Mirror stories. I must admit that I don't really understand what is going on as I don't believe that it is down to lazy journalism so that means that either someone is feeding them snippets for their own ends or else the Mirror are printing blatant lies and I'm not sure which one it is.

The board are well aware of what is said on these boards and they do often use them as well as social media for putting across their views.

They also know that many supporters are interested in their views otherwise why would Steve Parish have over 16,500 followers on his Twitter account.

There is no doubt that robust debate on the forums does get the Board's attention and perhaps we do influence some of their thinking otherwise why would Steve Parish have said that they wouldn't be employing Chris Coleman as so many of the fans were against the idea.

The board and Steve Parish in particular understand the power of the fan and know how important forums and social media is nowadays in formulating and spreading opinion and there is no doubt that it was the unrest here that forced Tony Pulis to state that he wouldn't be walking away but it's just a shame that Steve Parish and Steve Browett didn't come out and issue unequivocal denials straight away to kill off the story before it gained legs

Yes mate you keep telling yourself how relevant this load of utter nonsense and ignorance is in the grand scheme of things. What you post here IS important. Bless.

I'm sure journalists do come and have a look and then use it to back up the phrase 'the fans think...' But take a look at a thread, any thread. So many unresearched things stated as 'fact', hyperbole, vitriol, opinions and egos - anyone who genuinely takes anything seriously on here needs a reality check.


You are so wrong Finchers the papers do take the internet ramblings of this board serioulsy ...we all remember The Mirrors 'DanH is a Bender' headlines


 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 28 Jan 14 8.23pm

Quote Rudi Hedman at 28 Jan 2014 10.45am

Quote bubble wrap at 28 Jan 2014 10.38am

Quote Rudi Hedman at 28 Jan 2014 10.29am

The papers are the architects, some of the forum can at times lap up whatever is served to them. One thing about Palace that's unique is that the percentage of Palace fans with accounts on HOL or the BBS is pretty high. How many Palace fans are there? 40,000? How many account holders? How many non-account holders speak to an account very soon after something like this comes out?

How many Palace fans buy/read/log onto The Mirror unless there's a click through on HOL or the BBS? Very few.

The papers throw a pack of dogs one bone, sit back, laugh, and wait to see if it causes article number 2 they've got ready to go to print.

Sorry to disagree Rudi but I beleive the percentage of Palace fans on BBS and Hols is not that high I reckon 5% with the majority not active. BBS have far more than on here but the majority of fans I know do not go on here or will look but do not have accounts.


'Look' is good enough. I think there's a lot of people who set up accounts, especially in the earlier days of the BBS, but don't bother logging on. It's the best place to find news articles, all listed in one place.


Agreed, and the fixture list and up coming events feed is the easiest and quickest to find online.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are the HOL/BBS architects of the club's 'unrest'?