You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Campana
November 16 2026 1.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Campana


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Jordan555x Flag Bromley 05 Feb 14 3.27pm

Quote bexleydave at 05 Feb 2014 8.00am

Palace Will Regret Not Harnessing Campana's Talent:

[Link]


That pass!

I think he'll become a brilliant player one day, not Spain National Team brilliant but a brilliant player none the less.

 

ElCapitan Flag 05 Feb 14 5.04pm

As a Palace fan living in Nuremberg I will be watching Campana closely over the coming months to see how he gets on. Will be at the game vs Bayern Munich this weekend, hopefully he'll make his debut!

 


I am nobody.....nobody is perfect......so I must be perfect

paperhat Flag croydon 05 Feb 14 5.10pm

Quote Jordan555x at 05 Feb 2014 3.27pm

Quote bexleydave at 05 Feb 2014 8.00am

Palace Will Regret Not Harnessing Campana's Talent:

[Link]


That pass!

I think he'll become a brilliant player one day, not Spain National Team brilliant but a brilliant player none the less.


As in 'cr@p' brilliant then ?

Edited by paperhat (05 Feb 2014 5.10pm)

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Eagles-Mad Flag Romford Essex 05 Feb 14 5.15pm

He never done anything to merit a place in our side. People just say he is great because he is Spanish. We look better without him.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 05 Feb 14 5.17pm

Quote ElCapitan at 05 Feb 2014 5.04pm

As a Palace fan living in Nuremberg I will be watching Campana closely over the coming months to see how he gets on. Will be at the game vs Bayern Munich this weekend, hopefully he'll make his debut!


Please let us all know how he gets on, if you don't mind, but don't be influenced by the fact that he's Spanish

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

BigTimeCharlie Flag Bogota 05 Feb 14 5.56pm

Quote Eagles-Mad at 05 Feb 2014 5.15pm

He never done anything to merit a place in our side. People just say he is great because he is Spanish. We look better without him.

You're ridiculously blinkered on this issue. When we debated it before, you even conceded his set piece delivery is excellent. We scored a couple of goals from his corners. I'll agree there were games when he was deservedly substituted, and he sometimes struggled to influence the game, but he's a young player (only 20) adjusting to a new league and culture. The fact that he can create goals at the top level (as he did with us and with Sevilla when he actually played) shows that he's got potential.

Yep, I agree we have definitely been better since Pulis came in and he hasn't played. But I don't think we're better BECAUSE he's not in the team - that's simply down to us appointing Pulis and getting rid of Holloway. He was hardly a regular before, and he never had a settled position. I definitely think he had something different to offer us though, and would be disappointed if we didn't try and keep him and develop him into a top quality player at our club. Disappointed he didn't go to a Championship club like Pulis had suggested previously.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 05 Feb 14 6.01pm

Quote BigTimeCharlie at 05 Feb 2014 5.56pm

Quote Eagles-Mad at 05 Feb 2014 5.15pm

He never done anything to merit a place in our side. People just say he is great because he is Spanish. We look better without him.

You're ridiculously blinkered on this issue. When we debated it before, you even conceded his set piece delivery is excellent. We scored a couple of goals from his corners. I'll agree there were games when he was deservedly substituted, and he sometimes struggled to influence the game, but he's a young player (only 20) adjusting to a new league and culture. The fact that he can create goals at the top level (as he did with us and with Sevilla when he actually played) shows that he's got potential.

Yep, I agree we have definitely been better since Pulis came in and he hasn't played. But I don't think we're better BECAUSE he's not in the team - that's simply down to us appointing Pulis and getting rid of Holloway. He was hardly a regular before, and he never had a settled position. I definitely think he had something different to offer us though, and would be disappointed if we didn't try and keep him and develop him into a top quality player at our club. Disappointed he didn't go to a Championship club like Pulis had suggested previously.


You could have left it there BTC, but you do go on to make some excellent points with which I agree.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Stuart Shave Flag Hampshire 06 Feb 14 10.21am

Would definetly like to see us try and keep him. Like Gayle, just don't think he's the type of player in terms of assets that is needed for the kind of season we were bound to endure this season.

He could well benefit from this loan spell but once we're able to be more creative and productive on the ball he would be a bonus. If we were to go down that could be next season, if we stay up it could be a couple of years until we see what a good and technically gifted player he is. Whether he wants to hang around that long is a different matter.

Edited by Stuart Shave (06 Feb 2014 10.22am)

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 Feb 14 11.42am

Quote seeweedhater at 05 Feb 2014 8.31am

This is a prime example of my dislike for pulis brand of team selection,and football.

Two holding m/f at home choosing K.G over flair players
such as Bannan,A.G. J.W.and SOk who tackle, make runs and stretch the opposition.

Felt sorry for Wardy last week,played here,there,and everywhere.


Jedinak and KG has been the preferred midfield pairing since the Freedman era. Both he and Holloway consistently picked the two, it's nothing to do with Pulis' 'brand'.

I do wonder if we didn't have this perception of Pulis' playing style shoved down our throats before his appointment, whether people would so harshly judge it. I think we play far better passing football under Pulis than we ever did under Holloway, who is widely considered as a manager who plays 'good' football.
The complaints regarding Pulis' team selections and tactics feel very forced, and I suspect stem from those who did not want him to take over initially, due to his apparent 'brand'.

If Pulis had taken over as a complete unknown, I suspect a lot of these complaints regarding style and selection would never be heard.

 

seeweedhater Flag London 06 Feb 14 12.53pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 06 Feb 2014 11.42am

Quote seeweedhater at 05 Feb 2014 8.31am

This is a prime example of my dislike for pulis brand of team selection,and football.

Two holding m/f at home choosing K.G over flair players
such as Bannan,A.G. J.W.and SOk who tackle, make runs and stretch the opposition.

Felt sorry for Wardy last week,played here,there,and everywhere.


Jedinak and KG has been the preferred midfield pairing since the Freedman era. Both he and Holloway consistently picked the two, it's nothing to do with Pulis' 'brand'.

I do wonder if we didn't have this perception of Pulis' playing style shoved down our throats before his appointment, whether people would so harshly judge it. I think we play far better passing football under Pulis than we ever did under Holloway, who is widely considered as a manager who plays 'good' football.
The complaints regarding Pulis' team selections and tactics feel very forced, and I suspect stem from those who did not want him to take over initially, due to his apparent 'brand'.

If Pulis had taken over as a complete unknown, I suspect a lot of these complaints regarding style and selection would never be heard.


O.k firstly you mentioned freedman, holloway playing K.g but surely we've moved on when has Sok let us down, his work rate tackles and drive even getting into the oppos box creating chances.


Look at Gayle last week was a perfect chance to play against a footballing side,but no C.J was preferred
yes he's got heart but he cant score,and why bring Gayle on for 8mins.

Also at home have we had more possession against lower half teams??

Can you describe this brand of football you mentioned that he's associated with.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 06 Feb 14 1.37pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 06 Feb 2014 11.42am

Quote seeweedhater at 05 Feb 2014 8.31am

This is a prime example of my dislike for pulis brand of team selection,and football.

Two holding m/f at home choosing K.G over flair players
such as Bannan,A.G. J.W.and SOk who tackle, make runs and stretch the opposition.

Felt sorry for Wardy last week,played here,there,and everywhere.


Jedinak and KG has been the preferred midfield pairing since the Freedman era. Both he and Holloway consistently picked the two, it's nothing to do with Pulis' 'brand'.

I do wonder if we didn't have this perception of Pulis' playing style shoved down our throats before his appointment, whether people would so harshly judge it. I think we play far better passing football under Pulis than we ever did under Holloway, who is widely considered as a manager who plays 'good' football.
The complaints regarding Pulis' team selections and tactics feel very forced, and I suspect stem from those who did not want him to take over initially, due to his apparent 'brand'.

If Pulis had taken over as a complete unknown, I suspect a lot of these complaints regarding style and selection would never be heard.


Good points.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 Feb 14 2.25pm

Quote seeweedhater at 06 Feb 2014 12.53pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 06 Feb 2014 11.42am

Quote seeweedhater at 05 Feb 2014 8.31am

This is a prime example of my dislike for pulis brand of team selection,and football.

Two holding m/f at home choosing K.G over flair players
such as Bannan,A.G. J.W.and SOk who tackle, make runs and stretch the opposition.

Felt sorry for Wardy last week,played here,there,and everywhere.


Jedinak and KG has been the preferred midfield pairing since the Freedman era. Both he and Holloway consistently picked the two, it's nothing to do with Pulis' 'brand'.

I do wonder if we didn't have this perception of Pulis' playing style shoved down our throats before his appointment, whether people would so harshly judge it. I think we play far better passing football under Pulis than we ever did under Holloway, who is widely considered as a manager who plays 'good' football.
The complaints regarding Pulis' team selections and tactics feel very forced, and I suspect stem from those who did not want him to take over initially, due to his apparent 'brand'.

If Pulis had taken over as a complete unknown, I suspect a lot of these complaints regarding style and selection would never be heard.


O.k firstly you mentioned freedman, holloway playing K.g but surely we've moved on when has Sok let us down, his work rate tackles and drive even getting into the oppos box creating chances.


Look at Gayle last week was a perfect chance to play against a footballing side,but no C.J was preferred
yes he's got heart but he cant score,and why bring Gayle on for 8mins.

Also at home have we had more possession against lower half teams??

Can you describe this brand of football you mentioned that he's associated with.


I'd suggest us 'moving on' is one of the main factors in our use of two defensive midfielders. We are trying to establish ourselves in a higher league, that's more easily done with a solid foundation. Should we successfully make the transition, a few seasons in, I would expect to see more creative players gradually introduced to the side.

Similarly, Jerome's inclusion over Gayle is more based around playing styles than ability to score goals. I agree that Gayle would score more goals given the same amount of time, but I also feel that's a very simplistic way to judge a forward. Jerome offers a lot more to the side IMO.

For me, the correlation between possession and what is considered 'good football' is overstated. We are set up as a counter attacking side, hence our lower possession, but we also string together some superb passing moves on the break, far superior to any I saw under Holloway. The home game to Hull was a good example of this, they certainly controlled the game in terms of possession, but we looked a far more dangerous side in the final third, and consequently won the game.

The very brand you eluded to in your first post, long ball football based around a team of giants, but from what I've seen of this Pulis team so far, I consider that as big a myth as the suggestion that Holloway's sides play good football.

 

seeweedhater Flag London 06 Feb 14 3.36pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 06 Feb 2014 2.25pm

Quote seeweedhater at 06 Feb 2014 12.53pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 06 Feb 2014 11.42am

Quote seeweedhater at 05 Feb 2014 8.31am

This is a prime example of my dislike for pulis brand of team selection,and football.

Two holding m/f at home choosing K.G over flair players
such as Bannan,A.G. J.W.and SOk who tackle, make runs and stretch the opposition.

Felt sorry for Wardy last week,played here,there,and everywhere.


Jedinak and KG has been the preferred midfield pairing since the Freedman era. Both he and Holloway consistently picked the two, it's nothing to do with Pulis' 'brand'.

I do wonder if we didn't have this perception of Pulis' playing style shoved down our throats before his appointment, whether people would so harshly judge it. I think we play far better passing football under Pulis than we ever did under Holloway, who is widely considered as a manager who plays 'good' football.
The complaints regarding Pulis' team selections and tactics feel very forced, and I suspect stem from those who did not want him to take over initially, due to his apparent 'brand'.

If Pulis had taken over as a complete unknown, I suspect a lot of these complaints regarding style and selection would never be heard.


O.k firstly you mentioned freedman, holloway playing K.g but surely we've moved on when has Sok let us down, his work rate tackles and drive even getting into the oppos box creating chances.


Look at Gayle last week was a perfect chance to play against a footballing side,but no C.J was preferred
yes he's got heart but he cant score,and why bring Gayle on for 8mins.

Also at home have we had more possession against lower half teams??

Can you describe this brand of football you mentioned that he's associated with.


I'd suggest us 'moving on' is one of the main factors in our use of two defensive midfielders. We are trying to establish ourselves in a higher league, that's more easily done with a solid foundation. Should we successfully make the transition, a few seasons in, I would expect to see more creative players gradually introduced to the side.

Similarly, Jerome's inclusion over Gayle is more based around playing styles than ability to score goals. I agree that Gayle would score more goals given the same amount of time, but I also feel that's a very simplistic way to judge a forward. Jerome offers a lot more to the side IMO.

For me, the correlation between possession and what is considered 'good football' is overstated. We are set up as a counter attacking side, hence our lower possession, but we also string together some superb passing moves on the break, far superior to any I saw under Holloway. The home game to Hull was a good example of this, they certainly controlled the game in terms of possession, but we looked a far more dangerous side in the final third, and consequently won the game.

The very brand you eluded to in your first post, long ball football based around a team of giants, but from what I've seen of this Pulis team so far, I consider that as big a myth as the suggestion that Holloway's sides play good football.


I'm sorry,where did i mention giants or long balls,thats you assuming in what i said.Also this transition might take a few seasons how many?I've seen on scfc forums it does your head in after a while.re-creative players we have still have,but there not a option now.Thats why i'm glad of new signing mainly ledley as a attacking m/f who can score. coyrab.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 Feb 14 5.15pm

Quote seeweedhater at 06 Feb 2014 3.36pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 06 Feb 2014 2.25pm

Quote seeweedhater at 06 Feb 2014 12.53pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 06 Feb 2014 11.42am

Quote seeweedhater at 05 Feb 2014 8.31am

This is a prime example of my dislike for pulis brand of team selection,and football.

Two holding m/f at home choosing K.G over flair players
such as Bannan,A.G. J.W.and SOk who tackle, make runs and stretch the opposition.

Felt sorry for Wardy last week,played here,there,and everywhere.


Jedinak and KG has been the preferred midfield pairing since the Freedman era. Both he and Holloway consistently picked the two, it's nothing to do with Pulis' 'brand'.

I do wonder if we didn't have this perception of Pulis' playing style shoved down our throats before his appointment, whether people would so harshly judge it. I think we play far better passing football under Pulis than we ever did under Holloway, who is widely considered as a manager who plays 'good' football.
The complaints regarding Pulis' team selections and tactics feel very forced, and I suspect stem from those who did not want him to take over initially, due to his apparent 'brand'.

If Pulis had taken over as a complete unknown, I suspect a lot of these complaints regarding style and selection would never be heard.


O.k firstly you mentioned freedman, holloway playing K.g but surely we've moved on when has Sok let us down, his work rate tackles and drive even getting into the oppos box creating chances.


Look at Gayle last week was a perfect chance to play against a footballing side,but no C.J was preferred
yes he's got heart but he cant score,and why bring Gayle on for 8mins.

Also at home have we had more possession against lower half teams??

Can you describe this brand of football you mentioned that he's associated with.


I'd suggest us 'moving on' is one of the main factors in our use of two defensive midfielders. We are trying to establish ourselves in a higher league, that's more easily done with a solid foundation. Should we successfully make the transition, a few seasons in, I would expect to see more creative players gradually introduced to the side.

Similarly, Jerome's inclusion over Gayle is more based around playing styles than ability to score goals. I agree that Gayle would score more goals given the same amount of time, but I also feel that's a very simplistic way to judge a forward. Jerome offers a lot more to the side IMO.

For me, the correlation between possession and what is considered 'good football' is overstated. We are set up as a counter attacking side, hence our lower possession, but we also string together some superb passing moves on the break, far superior to any I saw under Holloway. The home game to Hull was a good example of this, they certainly controlled the game in terms of possession, but we looked a far more dangerous side in the final third, and consequently won the game.

The very brand you eluded to in your first post, long ball football based around a team of giants, but from what I've seen of this Pulis team so far, I consider that as big a myth as the suggestion that Holloway's sides play good football.


I'm sorry,where did i mention giants or long balls,thats you assuming in what i said.Also this transition might take a few seasons how many?I've seen on scfc forums it does your head in after a while.re-creative players we have still have,but there not a option now.Thats why i'm glad of new signing mainly ledley as a attacking m/f who can score. coyrab.


Ok so what did you mean by "my dislike for pulis brand of team selection,and football." ?

 

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 06 Feb 14 6.20pm

I always thought that a football manager was pretty much an expert when it came to taming lions,getting youngsters to develop a football brain and to have the necessary patience to teach,foster and if necessary nurture the young and inexperienced. Obviously I was wrong as evidenced by Palace's attitude towards Campana. Just because Ollie did not have the common sense to know what to do with the Spanish youngster does not mean Campana does not have what it takes to become a very useful player. I suppose it can be said Pulis has his hands full in our fight to stay up but surely there is somebody else in the organization who could have picked up the ball and ran with it. Gold does not necessarily shine until its burnished and the same can be said for young footballers.

 

seeweedhater Flag London 06 Feb 14 8.40pm

O.k. EDN you was spot on,maybe that brand stuck with him.
Thinking about it Ronseal comes to mind.

Any way here's to 3 pts on sat.

 

CPFC-NAC Flag London 10 Feb 14 6.50pm

Any one know how Campana has been getting on if at all?

 

MikeT Flag Burlington (Toronto Area) 10 Feb 14 6.56pm

Quote CPFC-NAC at 10 Feb 2014 6.50pm

Any one know how Campana has been getting on if at all?

Unused substitute in Nurnberg's home loss to Bayern Munich.

[Link]

 

dougster Flag 10 Feb 14 7.10pm

This myth that he is some kind of world beater is beyond me.

Wasn't good enough and failed.

 

BelfastEagle Flag 10 Feb 14 7.53pm

He must of improved to make it onto the bench.

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Campana