You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Due to go out on Loan
November 16 2026 1.13pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Due to go out on Loan


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 03 Feb 14 12.40pm

Quote ripleyeagle at 03 Feb 2014 12.23pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 02 Feb 2014 11.13pm

Are Blackburn that desperate to play in League One?

Idiot, show some respect for a loyal Palace player coming back from a serious injury.

He has been paid wages for the last 2 years. Loyalty shows both ways. If a better offer came in he would be off no doubt so all the loyalty stuff is bollocks and to be fair for the standard of player that McCarthy is Cucking is 100% correct.

 

Horsham_Eagle Flag London 03 Feb 14 12.53pm

I would be disappointed if we loaned Bannan, he always looks decent when he plays, he is no winger, but coming on to try and change a game - perhaps replacing one of the holding midfielders, he could be very effective.

I think its probably a good decision to loan Williams, he needs game time, and if Pulis doesnt think he will be getting it at Palace then its for the best. That said, because of his age and the fact that he is homegrown he doesnt have to be in the 25, he can still be played, so its also worth retaining him because he adds to the squad without taking up a space like Bannan would.

Its a difficult decision between the two

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 03 Feb 14 1.00pm

Quote bubble wrap at 03 Feb 2014 12.40pm

Quote ripleyeagle at 03 Feb 2014 12.23pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 02 Feb 2014 11.13pm

Are Blackburn that desperate to play in League One?

Idiot, show some respect for a loyal Palace player coming back from a serious injury.

He has been paid wages for the last 2 years. Loyalty shows both ways. If a better offer came in he would be off no doubt so all the loyalty stuff is bollocks and to be fair for the standard of player that McCarthy is Cucking is 100% correct.


Although every manager during his time at Palace has not agreed with your viewpoint on this. Got to be a reason. For me, that's because the team plays better when he plays, even though he isn't a great player.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 03 Feb 14 1.15pm

Hang on, pause, wasn't this story in the Mirror?

 

madcap_v2 Flag SE25 / Ibiza 03 Feb 14 1.20pm

Quote Arthur Blackpudding at 03 Feb 2014 9.31am

Understand sending Williams out on loan tbh, even though he is one of my favourite players and I'd love him to get more game time with us it does actually make sense.
However, I think we'd be silly to send Bannan out on loan, I thought we instantly improved when he came on yesterday and he gives us that little spark of creativity, has excellent deliviery into the box and is good at set pieces. Keep him and play him more!!

ditto this. I see no point in sending Bannan out on loan when he has something to offer to the team still

 


La la la your mum

Bangell Flag Oxford 03 Feb 14 1.24pm

I think Bannan has something to offer and should definitely be kept here this season. It's not as if he's particularly young so a loan move wouldn't be to develop him - it would presage a permanent transfer in the Summer. As for Williams, he desperately needs to get a long run in a Championship team. He's in real danger of his development stalling.

 

maddog Flag Wiltshire 03 Feb 14 1.37pm

Quote Mapletree at 03 Feb 2014 1.00pm

Quote bubble wrap at 03 Feb 2014 12.40pm

Quote ripleyeagle at 03 Feb 2014 12.23pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 02 Feb 2014 11.13pm

Are Blackburn that desperate to play in League One?

Idiot, show some respect for a loyal Palace player coming back from a serious injury.

He has been paid wages for the last 2 years. Loyalty shows both ways. If a better offer came in he would be off no doubt so all the loyalty stuff is bollocks and to be fair for the standard of player that McCarthy is Cucking is 100% correct.


Although every manager during his time at Palace has not agreed with your viewpoint on this. Got to be a reason. For me, that's because the team plays better when he plays, even though he isn't a great player.

Paddy may not be the best of our 4 CBs but it would be pretty wreckless to try to complete the rest of the season with only 3 of them.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 03 Feb 14 1.53pm

Quote maddog at 03 Feb 2014 1.37pm

Paddy may not be the best of our 4 CBs but it would be pretty wreckless to try to complete the rest of the season with only 3 of them.

Delaney, Gabbidon, Mariappa, Dann and Paddy make five


 

Sg Bilko Flag Deurne Holland 03 Feb 14 2.33pm

Quote bubble wrap at 03 Feb 2014 9.38am

Makes absolute sense to loan out players that are unlikely to play. As long as there is a clause to bring them back if we need them and that they do not go to Millwall,Charlton,Bolton to help in their relegation battle.

Short loans you don't need a clause to recall, they can be recalled at any time.

 

Sg Bilko Flag Deurne Holland 03 Feb 14 2.39pm

Quote Bangell at 03 Feb 2014 1.24pm

I think Bannan has something to offer and should definitely be kept here this season. It's not as if he's particularly young so a loan move wouldn't be to develop him - it would presage a permanent transfer in the Summer. As for Williams, he desperately needs to get a long run in a Championship team. He's in real danger of his development stalling.

Players are not just sent out on loan because their young, players like Bannan need game time to keep them match fit and up to speed, sitting on the bench and vegetating doesn't do that.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 03 Feb 14 4.31pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 03 Feb 2014 2.39pm

Quote Bangell at 03 Feb 2014 1.24pm

I think Bannan has something to offer and should definitely be kept here this season. It's not as if he's particularly young so a loan move wouldn't be to develop him - it would presage a permanent transfer in the Summer. As for Williams, he desperately needs to get a long run in a Championship team. He's in real danger of his development stalling.

Players are not just sent out on loan because their young, players like Bannan need game time to keep them match fit and up to speed, sitting on the bench and vegetating doesn't do that.

...And to get someone else to pay their wages. If Bannan gets loaned out I think he'll be sold in the summer.


 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Feb 14 5.01pm

Quote bubble wrap at 03 Feb 2014 12.40pm

Quote ripleyeagle at 03 Feb 2014 12.23pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 02 Feb 2014 11.13pm

Are Blackburn that desperate to play in League One?

Idiot, show some respect for a loyal Palace player coming back from a serious injury.

He has been paid wages for the last 2 years. Loyalty shows both ways. If a better offer came in he would be off no doubt so all the loyalty stuff is bollocks and to be fair for the standard of player that McCarthy is Cucking is 100% correct.

McCarthy was a very good championship defender and a good defensive organiser, but he needs games, and at best he's going to get 10 mins or so a game here.

Those who seem to have decided he's a league 1 player should try using their memory. His contributions were instrumental in assuring that we did not become a league 1 team.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Feb 14 5.02pm

Quote madcap_v2 at 03 Feb 2014 1.20pm

Quote Arthur Blackpudding at 03 Feb 2014 9.31am

Understand sending Williams out on loan tbh, even though he is one of my favourite players and I'd love him to get more game time with us it does actually make sense.
However, I think we'd be silly to send Bannan out on loan, I thought we instantly improved when he came on yesterday and he gives us that little spark of creativity, has excellent deliviery into the box and is good at set pieces. Keep him and play him more!!

ditto this. I see no point in sending Bannan out on loan when he has something to offer to the team still

I thought Bannan made a good contribution yesterday, but I would imagine he's behind Leadley and Ince as far as Pulis is concerned.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 03 Feb 14 5.10pm

Shipping Banan out is utter madness, when he came on yesterday the temp increased. Box to box midfielder. Wht more does have to do??

 


Bring back Brolin

Sienna1977 Flag Chichester 03 Feb 14 5.13pm

Complete madness if this is true both Johnny and Barry are two players who give it their all who in my opinion should always play we have too many players Jerome being one of them who are hopeless and never never give 100% or even want to get to a 50/50 ball yet play every week.

 

johnburgess888 Flag Caterham 03 Feb 14 5.19pm

There is no way I'd send Bannan or Williams out on loan. Both can come on and make a real difference to the team. They offer slnething different to anyone else in that they have real quality on the ball. That quality could be vital against teams around us in the table.

 


Tune in to Palace Radio for all your matchday action.

Palace Radio is available on 1278AM, Palace Player and visit the website [Link]

Call: 020 8653 5796 Text: 079 100 60 919

chandlem68 Flag Beckenham 03 Feb 14 5.25pm

I would send Williams and Gayle out on loan to top half championship teams.

This will increase their confidence and get them some game time.

They can then return to us for the vital survival run-in.

Edited by staffie (03 Feb 2014 5.49pm)

 

gegne78 Flag Wellingborough , Northants 03 Feb 14 5.25pm

Really hope that JW doesn't get loaned to Cardiff .... Can you imagine !!!!

 

Master Coin Flag 03 Feb 14 5.35pm

Quote gegne78 at 03 Feb 2014 5.25pm

Really hope that JW doesn't get loaned to Cardiff .... Can you imagine !!!!

He can't be. The window for PL clubs is proper closed. It re-opens for loans into the football league only next week.

 

Mangopablo Flag south LONDON 03 Feb 14 5.54pm

Quote Qwijibo at 02 Feb 2014 11.14pm

If we were established in the Prem I could see a benefit to loaning Williams, but as he's not even going to take up a valuable squad place surely we're better to keep him as an option? Look at what's happened to the Arsenal midfield. A bulk of midfielders can get injured at any point.

Bannan seems a shame but I don't think anyone's too surprised.

Surely we could recall Joniesta if we had an injury crisis? Might be good for him to get some game time?

 


"The course of true love never did run smooth"

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Due to go out on Loan