You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Will our fantastic support continue if relegated?
November 16 2026 1.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Will our fantastic support continue if relegated?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
eagle184 Flag Sutton 10 Feb 14 11.56am

Quote Beastie at 10 Feb 2014 11.39am
I would say the longer we stay in the premier league, the worse our amosphere will be. Look at the other sets of supporters in the division, even the away fans don't sing.

It's embarrassing the amount of plaudits our support gets. It says much more about the typical premiership atmosphere than about how noisey we are.
--------------------------------------------------------

That is more to do with proper fans being out priced with ticket costs.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 10 Feb 14 12.00pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Feb 2014 11.10am

Quote EagleRider at 10 Feb 2014 10.18am

a guy started talking to me in the queue for toilets at half time last game saying "it's really great to be able to get tickets to the premier league so close to home"

When I tried to talk team with him, he had no idea who Wilfried Zaha, Ian Holloway, or Kevin Phillips were!

People who are only interested because it's a prem. league team aren't real fans to worry about losing, like it's been said...they're not contributing anything to the atmosphere.

Yeah, but they're contributing to the income of the club. There are a tranch of people who just like football. That doesn't preclude them becoming future Palace fans.


Indeed and that is how I became a Palace fan many years ago.

Was a fan of Coppell the player, and when I moved down here, with Palace being local I used to go to games sporadically. Over a period of time I became a Palace supporter, wasn't a conscious decision and I can't even tell you when it happened, it just did.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 10 Feb 14 12.19pm

Quote eagle184 at 10 Feb 2014 11.56am

Quote Beastie at 10 Feb 2014 11.39am
I would say the longer we stay in the premier league, the worse our amosphere will be. Look at the other sets of supporters in the division, even the away fans don't sing.

It's embarrassing the amount of plaudits our support gets. It says much more about the typical premiership atmosphere than about how noisey we are.
--------------------------------------------------------

That is more to do with proper fans being out priced with ticket costs.


Rubbish.

Are you saying that to be a proper fan you have to be poor?

 

Beastie Flag 10 Feb 14 12.25pm

Quote Southampton_Eagle at 10 Feb 2014 12.19pm

Quote eagle184 at 10 Feb 2014 11.56am

Quote Beastie at 10 Feb 2014 11.39am
I would say the longer we stay in the premier league, the worse our amosphere will be. Look at the other sets of supporters in the division, even the away fans don't sing.

It's embarrassing the amount of plaudits our support gets. It says much more about the typical premiership atmosphere than about how noisey we are.
--------------------------------------------------------

That is more to do with proper fans being out priced with ticket costs.


Rubbish.

Are you saying that to be a proper fan you have to be poor?


Poor, not necessarily - but working class, yes.

 

eagle184 Flag Sutton 10 Feb 14 12.29pm

NO I am saying it can be a contributing factor! How many life long Palace would attend more games if costs where kept low?

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 10 Feb 14 12.38pm

Quote eagle184 at 10 Feb 2014 12.29pm

NO I am saying it can be a contributing factor! How many life long Palace would attend more games if costs where kept low?

Its funny though that those who couldn't afford it last season have suddenly found the cash to attend Premier League games.

 

goodersgold Flag Hastings 10 Feb 14 12.41pm

Quote silvertop at 10 Feb 2014 11.42am

Quote bubble wrap at 10 Feb 2014 9.37am

Quote eagle184 at 10 Feb 2014 9.16am

Our support has been awesome for a few seasons now, but this season has pushed on even further, with recognition for other fans, players, managers, plaudits, etc., etc. We have also attracted new supports, which is a good thing, But will this continue next season if we do get relegated?

I don't think our support at home has been better than it was last season, Bigger crowds yes but the atmosphere isn't better. Arthur has got much louder but the Holmsdale is quieter in my opinion. To many day trippers that have gone into Block C&D to soak up the HF atmosphere but not add anything to it. Our away support has been better,We are obviously taking more away than last season and the vast majority get behind the team throughout.It is all getting a bit cringe that we keep banging on about how great our support is.


I'm pretty sure those blocks are all season ticket holders Bubble.

As you brought up the Arthur, since I had to give my ST up a few years back I have been doing a tour of the ground. I was at the back of Block W for the Albion game. First time in the Arthur since Wimbledon "away". While the view was panned and scanned by the media gantry, the atmosphere was indeed cracking.


Block C is a completely different atmosphere to last year and it's nowhere near as good for instance about 4 or 5 lads who stood in front of me have moved or stopped going (maybe that's my fault)they always got behind the team and sung .
The people who have replaced them barely even clap but stand throughout and every week it's a different friend taken along with them .Thats not a problem at all the problem I see is a lot of people who are vocal or want to join in are now sat in Blocks away from A B C because they can't get tickets.
I love my seat in Block C but will probably try to move into B next year

 


The world was a mess but his hair was perfect!

eagle184 Flag Sutton 10 Feb 14 12.41pm

I agree but that is to be expected. I just hope we do gain new fans because of it, and they stay even if we do get relegated.

 

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 10 Feb 14 12.49pm

we won;t get the same volume of fans no. Unfortunately that is just life. I know people with season tickets this year that don't even support Palace!! Not sure they'd renew to go see Doncaster.

 


@sxp55555

Stuart_Eagle Flag Kent 10 Feb 14 12.52pm

Quote silvertop at 10 Feb 2014 11.42am

Quote bubble wrap at 10 Feb 2014 9.37am

Quote eagle184 at 10 Feb 2014 9.16am

Our support has been awesome for a few seasons now, but this season has pushed on even further, with recognition for other fans, players, managers, plaudits, etc., etc. We have also attracted new supports, which is a good thing, But will this continue next season if we do get relegated?

I don't think our support at home has been better than it was last season, Bigger crowds yes but the atmosphere isn't better. Arthur has got much louder but the Holmsdale is quieter in my opinion. To many day trippers that have gone into Block C&D to soak up the HF atmosphere but not add anything to it. Our away support has been better,We are obviously taking more away than last season and the vast majority get behind the team throughout.It is all getting a bit cringe that we keep banging on about how great our support is.


I'm pretty sure those blocks are all season ticket holders Bubble.

As you brought up the Arthur, since I had to give my ST up a few years back I have been doing a tour of the ground. I was at the back of Block W for the Albion game. First time in the Arthur since Wimbledon "away". While the view was panned and scanned by the media gantry, the atmosphere was indeed cracking.

Nice to hear some praise for the block, I personally think we were louder last season on the whole but its certainly a decent atmosphere, shame as you say about the scaffolding

 


we're the Arthur, we're the Arthur, we're the Arthur over here!

Positive! Proud & Palace - W block, AW

Mapletree Flag Croydon 10 Feb 14 12.58pm

As we get more established in the Prem it will get harder to buy seats at short notice. Hopefully that means that the very occasional supporters won't come so much. People coming regularly should get into the swing of things after a few matches.

What this thread does demonstrate is the importance of the HF. Not by any means because it is the source of most of the noise, in real terms when we are noisiest they are drowned out. But what they do is make it normal to sing and keep singing. Otherwise songs generally only do one round, they keep them going for 5 minutes plus sometimes.

I suspect without the HF we would just slowly become the same as the rest of the Prem, should we stay in it.

I had a debate with myself about whether we could have two Ultra groups, maybe even one in the Whitehorse. I am pretty sure that pre-Sainsburys the Whitehorse used to sing, although never like the Holmesdale or the Arthur. The answer has to be no, they would end up competing and just mess everything up.

It does annoy me sometimes - and certainly happened on Saturday - when the Arthur starts a song and the HF in the middle of it start a different one. I don't understand why that happens, maybe it's arrogance, maybe they have a song sheet, maybe they can't hear anything outside their area.

Isn't the best thing that could happen for the HF to grow bigger and spread into the Arthur? Got a feeling I am now going to get it in the neck from the proud Arthur massive. I also have absolutely no idea if the HF has some form of 'recruiting sergeant' and if it would even welcome growth.

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 10 Feb 14 1.15pm

Quote bubble wrap at 10 Feb 2014 12.38pm

Quote eagle184 at 10 Feb 2014 12.29pm

NO I am saying it can be a contributing factor! How many life long Palace would attend more games if costs where kept low?

Its funny though that those who couldn't afford it last season have suddenly found the cash to attend Premier League games.


Quite.

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 10 Feb 14 1.17pm

Quote Beastie at 10 Feb 2014 12.25pm

Quote Southampton_Eagle at 10 Feb 2014 12.19pm

Quote eagle184 at 10 Feb 2014 11.56am

Quote Beastie at 10 Feb 2014 11.39am
I would say the longer we stay in the premier league, the worse our amosphere will be. Look at the other sets of supporters in the division, even the away fans don't sing.

It's embarrassing the amount of plaudits our support gets. It says much more about the typical premiership atmosphere than about how noisey we are.
--------------------------------------------------------

That is more to do with proper fans being out priced with ticket costs.


Rubbish.

Are you saying that to be a proper fan you have to be poor?


Poor, not necessarily - but working class, yes.


Astounding.

This isn't the 1940s anymore!

 

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 10 Feb 14 1.22pm

Quote Beastie at 10 Feb 2014 12.25pm

Quote Southampton_Eagle at 10 Feb 2014 12.19pm

Quote eagle184 at 10 Feb 2014 11.56am

Quote Beastie at 10 Feb 2014 11.39am
I would say the longer we stay in the premier league, the worse our amosphere will be. Look at the other sets of supporters in the division, even the away fans don't sing.

It's embarrassing the amount of plaudits our support gets. It says much more about the typical premiership atmosphere than about how noisey we are.
--------------------------------------------------------

That is more to do with proper fans being out priced with ticket costs.


Rubbish.

Are you saying that to be a proper fan you have to be poor?


Poor, not necessarily - but working class, yes.


What an absolutely ridiculous thing to say.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

madcap_v2 Flag SE25 / Ibiza 10 Feb 14 1.26pm

Quote Beastie at 10 Feb 2014 12.25pm

Quote Southampton_Eagle at 10 Feb 2014 12.19pm

Quote eagle184 at 10 Feb 2014 11.56am

Quote Beastie at 10 Feb 2014 11.39am
I would say the longer we stay in the premier league, the worse our amosphere will be. Look at the other sets of supporters in the division, even the away fans don't sing.

It's embarrassing the amount of plaudits our support gets. It says much more about the typical premiership atmosphere than about how noisey we are.
--------------------------------------------------------

That is more to do with proper fans being out priced with ticket costs.


Rubbish.

Are you saying that to be a proper fan you have to be poor?


Poor, not necessarily - but working class, yes.

This is also nonsense.

OP's question is irrelevant anyway as we're staying up.

 


La la la your mum

c_block_shedevil Flag London 10 Feb 14 1.31pm

Quote goodersgold at 10 Feb 2014 12.41pm

Quote silvertop at 10 Feb 2014 11.42am

Quote bubble wrap at 10 Feb 2014 9.37am

Quote eagle184 at 10 Feb 2014 9.16am

Our support has been awesome for a few seasons now, but this season has pushed on even further, with recognition for other fans, players, managers, plaudits, etc., etc. We have also attracted new supports, which is a good thing, But will this continue next season if we do get relegated?

I don't think our support at home has been better than it was last season, Bigger crowds yes but the atmosphere isn't better. Arthur has got much louder but the Holmsdale is quieter in my opinion. To many day trippers that have gone into Block C&D to soak up the HF atmosphere but not add anything to it. Our away support has been better,We are obviously taking more away than last season and the vast majority get behind the team throughout.It is all getting a bit cringe that we keep banging on about how great our support is.


I'm pretty sure those blocks are all season ticket holders Bubble.

As you brought up the Arthur, since I had to give my ST up a few years back I have been doing a tour of the ground. I was at the back of Block W for the Albion game. First time in the Arthur since Wimbledon "away". While the view was panned and scanned by the media gantry, the atmosphere was indeed cracking.


Block C is a completely different atmosphere to last year and it's nowhere near as good for instance about 4 or 5 lads who stood in front of me have moved or stopped going (maybe that's my fault)they always got behind the team and sung .
The people who have replaced them barely even clap but stand throughout and every week it's a different friend taken along with them .Thats not a problem at all the problem I see is a lot of people who are vocal or want to join in are now sat in Blocks away from A B C because they can't get tickets.
I love my seat in Block C but will probably try to move into B next year


I'm glad I'm not the only person that thinks this about block C. It's gone to the dogs. Last season many of season ticket holders around me would join in with block B. But now we are totally outnumbered by newbies who like to stand near the atmosphere in B, but do nothing to contribute to it.

 


I'm tough. I'm ambitious. I know exactly what I want. If that makes me a bitch, I'm OK with that.

silvertop Flag Portishead 10 Feb 14 2.03pm

And if you think: I'll sit a couple of rows away from blocks A/B - must have an atmosphere - think again. Where I used to live at the back of Block B, you took standing and singing for granted. However, Block E... ahem. Sit down and shut up was the clear message from the pensioner's collective around me. Good view but never again.

 

Beastie Flag 10 Feb 14 2.13pm

Like all clubs, our traditional support comes from young working class males with roots in the local area and the more football is taken away from these sorts of people, the worse the atmosphere’s will become. Not a popular view but it’s true.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 10 Feb 14 2.34pm

Quote madcap_v2 at 10 Feb 2014 1.26pm

Quote Beastie at 10 Feb 2014 12.25pm

Quote Southampton_Eagle at 10 Feb 2014 12.19pm

Quote eagle184 at 10 Feb 2014 11.56am

Quote Beastie at 10 Feb 2014 11.39am
I would say the longer we stay in the premier league, the worse our amosphere will be. Look at the other sets of supporters in the division, even the away fans don't sing.

It's embarrassing the amount of plaudits our support gets. It says much more about the typical premiership atmosphere than about how noisey we are.
--------------------------------------------------------

That is more to do with proper fans being out priced with ticket costs.


Rubbish.

Are you saying that to be a proper fan you have to be poor?


Poor, not necessarily - but working class, yes.

This is also nonsense.

OP's question is irrelevant anyway as we're staying up.


Fighting talk. I approve.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 10 Feb 14 4.41pm

Quote Beastie at 10 Feb 2014 2.13pm

Like all clubs, our traditional support comes from young working class males with roots in the local area and the more football is taken away from these sorts of people, the worse the atmosphere’s will become. Not a popular view but it’s true.


So what you're saying is that someone who is middle class is incapable of singing loudly?

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Will our fantastic support continue if relegated?