This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Joel Ward - best RB since...?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
alaneagle1 Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 23 Feb 14 8.51pm |
|
Quote curlyeagle at 23 Feb 2014 7.54pm
What about David Payne??
Played in Midfield.
Palace 13th 2017/18.
|
alaneagle1 Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 23 Feb 14 8.52pm |
|
Quote IH at 21 Feb 2014 7.40pm
Does anyone else remember John Sewell? He was making errors towards the end but at his peak he was sound. Otherwise I would go along with Humphrey and Clyne as possibly being ahead of Ward at the moment.
I think his nickname was 'SHOVELL'.
Palace 13th 2017/18.
|
Bert's Boys 23 Feb 14 9.15pm |
|
|
1.Paul Hinshelwood 2.John Sewell 3.Nathaniel Clyne 4.Peter Wall 5.John Pemberton 6.John Humphrey
|
curlyeagle crowborough 23 Feb 14 9.16pm |
|
Quote alaneagle1 at 23 Feb 2014 8.51pm
Quote curlyeagle at 23 Feb 2014 7.54pm
What about David Payne??
Played in Midfield.
Not sure what Palace team you have followed Mr alaneagle but in fact David Payne was a defender (right back)
As for you post re John Sewell he was infact a centre half and his nickname was The Duke
Curly eagles dad, 45 years of Palace. Never ever a dull moment, Oh Happy Days
|
timmyb Banstead 23 Feb 14 9.34pm |
|
|
So where did Billy Gilbert play? If the Team of the Eighties' back four was along the lines of Sansom (LB), Cannon & Fenwick at CB and Hinchelwood at RB...
Apols if some now think this should be filed under "Nostalgia."
In the original post I didn't bother asking who our best full-back was, assuming KS to have been peerless.
|
alaneagle1 Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 23 Feb 14 9.34pm |
|
Quote curlyeagle at 23 Feb 2014 9.16pm
Quote alaneagle1 at 23 Feb 2014 8.51pm
Quote curlyeagle at 23 Feb 2014 7.54pm
What about David Payne??
Played in Midfield.
Not sure what Palace team you have followed Mr alaneagle but in fact David Payne was a defender (right back)
As for you post re John Sewell he was infact a centre half and his nickname was The Duke
Payne was No 4 Old fashioned Defender/Wing Half.? Sewell was No 2.Fullback ? Shovell was Bert Howe ?No 3 Fullback.?
Palace 13th 2017/18.
|
alaneagle1 Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 23 Feb 14 9.44pm |
|
Quote timmyb at 23 Feb 2014 9.34pm
So where did Billy Gilbert play? If the Team of the Eighties' back four was along the lines of Sansom (LB), Cannon & Fenwick at CB and Hinchelwood at RB...
Apols if some now think this should be filed under "Nostalgia."
In the original post I didn't bother asking who our best full-back was, assuming KS to have been peerless.
In those days the formation was more 2-3-5
The 2 were Hinshelwood and Samsom.Fullbacks. The 3 were Nicholas,Cannon and Billy Gilbert. Gilbert was No 6.So a Centre Half like Delaney.
Palace 13th 2017/18.
|
glazedallover Allier 23 Feb 14 9.48pm |
|
Quote alaneagle1 at 23 Feb 2014 9.34pm
Quote curlyeagle at 23 Feb 2014 9.16pm
Quote alaneagle1 at 23 Feb 2014 8.51pm
Quote curlyeagle at 23 Feb 2014 7.54pm
What about David Payne??
Played in Midfield.
Not sure what Palace team you have followed Mr alaneagle but in fact David Payne was a defender (right back)
As for you post re John Sewell he was infact a centre half and his nickname was The Duke
Payne was No 4 Old fashioned Defender/Wing Half.? Sewell was No 2.Fullback ? Shovell was Bert Howe ?No 3 Fullback.?
No idea of sewell's nickname but definitely RB. When we went up back then CB's were McCormick and Blythe with I think a Taylor at LB - was it Colin?
|
palace chick South Croydon 23 Feb 14 10.00pm |
|
Quote glazedallover at 23 Feb 2014 9.48pm
Quote alaneagle1 at 23 Feb 2014 9.34pm
Quote curlyeagle at 23 Feb 2014 9.16pm
Quote alaneagle1 at 23 Feb 2014 8.51pm
Quote curlyeagle at 23 Feb 2014 7.54pm
What about David Payne??
Played in Midfield.
Not sure what Palace team you have followed Mr alaneagle but in fact David Payne was a defender (right back)
As for you post re John Sewell he was infact a centre half and his nickname was The Duke
Payne was No 4 Old fashioned Defender/Wing Half.? Sewell was No 2.Fullback ? Shovell was Bert Howe ?No 3 Fullback.?
No idea of sewell's nickname but definitely RB. When we went up back then CB's were McCormick and Blythe with I think a Taylor at LB - was it Colin?
Seem to remember John Sewell being called "the shovel". His partner at left back in 68/69 was John Loughlan a signing from Morton. The following season Peter Wall was left back. Tony Taylor was also signed from Morton as a winger but played later on in the 1st div (now prem) as a left back. Colin Taylor also a winger played for us also in 68/69 but never played the following season for us after being in our promotion winning team. Those were the days :-)
|
FinchleyEagle 23 Feb 14 10.01pm |
|
|
Best only since Clyne. Personally I'd have Pemberton ahead of Humphrey all day long.
You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue Yours sincerely Mile Jedinak
|
alaneagle1 Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 23 Feb 14 10.10pm |
|
Quote palace chick at 23 Feb 2014 10.00pm
Quote glazedallover at 23 Feb 2014 9.48pm
Quote alaneagle1 at 23 Feb 2014 9.34pm
Quote curlyeagle at 23 Feb 2014 9.16pm
Quote alaneagle1 at 23 Feb 2014 8.51pm
Quote curlyeagle at 23 Feb 2014 7.54pm
What about David Payne??
Played in Midfield.
Not sure what Palace team you have followed Mr alaneagle but in fact David Payne was a defender (right back)
As for you post re John Sewell he was infact a centre half and his nickname was The Duke
Payne was No 4 Old fashioned Defender/Wing Half.? Sewell was No 2.Fullback ? Shovell was Bert Howe ?No 3 Fullback.?
No idea of sewell's nickname but definitely RB. When we went up back then CB's were McCormick and Blythe with I think a Taylor at LB - was it Colin?
Seem to remember John Sewell being called "the shovel". His partner at left back in 68/69 was John Loughlan a signing from Morton. The following season Peter Wall was left back. Tony Taylor was also signed from Morton as a winger but played later on in the 1st div (now prem) as a left back. Colin Taylor also a winger played for us also in 68/69 but never played the following season for us after being in our promotion winning team. Those were the days :-)
Well I thought it was Sewell/Shovell but then thought of Bert Howe. Loughlan was the other fullback. McCormick and Blythe were the Centre Halfs. Both Taylors were at the Club in 68-69. Wall signed in 1970. And at 12 Years Old those were the days.!!!
Palace 13th 2017/18.
|
Bin Liner London , Southfields 23 Feb 14 10.12pm |
|
Quote FinchleyEagle at 23 Feb 2014 10.01pm
Best only since Clyne. Personally I'd have Pemberton ahead of Humphrey all day long.
close call that one, Pembo had that "Pearce/Dicks" style of a crunching tackling FB where as Humphrey had that football pureist quality about his game, where he would knock on a 30/40 yard pass onto the the touch line and then go and retrieve it, plus he was an excellent timer of the tackle , his downfall was being skinned by Giggs, I'd have Humphrey over all of them , just an opinion though.
Edited by Bin Liner (23 Feb 2014 10.13pm)
Portillo's teeth removed to boost pound
Boy roasts himself in sacrifice to Chris Kelly
|
collier row eagle romford essex via another galaxy 23 Feb 14 11.04pm |
|
Quote alaneagle1 at 23 Feb 2014 10.10pm
Quote palace chick at 23 Feb 2014 10.00pm
Quote glazedallover at 23 Feb 2014 9.48pm
Quote alaneagle1 at 23 Feb 2014 9.34pm
Quote curlyeagle at 23 Feb 2014 9.16pm
Quote alaneagle1 at 23 Feb 2014 8.51pm
Quote curlyeagle at 23 Feb 2014 7.54pm
What about David Payne??
Played in Midfield.
Not sure what Palace team you have followed Mr alaneagle but in fact David Payne was a defender (right back)
As for you post re John Sewell he was infact a centre half and his nickname was The Duke
Payne was No 4 Old fashioned Defender/Wing Half.? Sewell was No 2.Fullback ? Shovell was Bert Howe ?No 3 Fullback.?
No idea of sewell's nickname but definitely RB. When we went up back then CB's were McCormick and Blythe with I think a Taylor at LB - was it Colin?
Seem to remember John Sewell being called "the shovel". His partner at left back in 68/69 was John Loughlan a signing from Morton. The following season Peter Wall was left back. Tony Taylor was also signed from Morton as a winger but played later on in the 1st div (now prem) as a left back. Colin Taylor also a winger played for us also in 68/69 but never played the following season for us after being in our promotion winning team. Those were the days :-)
Well I thought it was Sewell/Shovell but then thought of Bert Howe. Loughlan was the other fullback. McCormick and Blythe were the Centre Halfs. Both Taylors were at the Club in 68-69. Wall signed in 1970. And at 12 Years Old those were the days.!!!
Bert Howe was called "chopper"
|
Bert's Boys 24 Feb 14 10.59am |
|
|
McCormick and Roger Hoy were the CB's when we went up in 69 - Sewell (shovel) capt was RB Johnny Loughlan LB Mel Blyth didn't start to appear as a regular until well into the following season - Hoy was replaced by Roger Hynd (signed from Rangers) in the 1st division. Team of the 80's: Burridge Hinshelwood Sansom Nicholas Cannon Gilbert Murphy Francis Swindlehurst Flanagan Hilaire Res: Fenwick, Walsh, Kember
|
Kermit8 Hevon 24 Feb 14 11.12am |
|
Quote Bert's Boys at 24 Feb 2014 10.59am
McCormick and Roger Hoy were the CB's when we went up in 69 - Sewell (shovel) capt was RB Johnny Loughlan LB Mel Blyth didn't start to appear as a regular until well into the following season - Hoy was replaced by Roger Hynd (signed from Rangers) in the 1st division. Team of the 80's: Burridge Hinshelwood Sansom Nicholas Cannon Gilbert Murphy Francis Swindlehurst Flanagan Hilaire Res: Fenwick, Walsh, Kember
That hurts.
Flanagan was never part of that classic team was he? He was also incredibly sh11te. Was bought along with Gerry Francis in the close season after winning Division 1. We were good up until Xmas then we lost 0-3 at Liverpool and 0-3 in successive games. Freefall after that all the way to Steve Coppell turning up.
The winning team v Burnley was supposed to be the team of the eighties I thought? 6 youth players plus Cannon, Doris, Burridge and Swindles and Kember.
Edited by Kermit8 (24 Feb 2014 11.14am)
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
alaneagle1 Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 24 Feb 14 11.13am |
|
|
Bert, Blyth and Hoy were in the 68 Team.Blyth joined a few months before Hoy.
Palace 13th 2017/18.
|
Plane Bromley 24 Feb 14 11.23am |
|
Quote alaneagle1 at 23 Feb 2014 9.34pm
Quote curlyeagle at 23 Feb 2014 9.16pm
Quote alaneagle1 at 23 Feb 2014 8.51pm
Quote curlyeagle at 23 Feb 2014 7.54pm
What about David Payne??
Played in Midfield.
Not sure what Palace team you have followed Mr alaneagle but in fact David Payne was a defender (right back)
As for you post re John Sewell he was infact a centre half and his nickname was The Duke
Payne was No 4 Old fashioned Defender/Wing Half.? Sewell was No 2.Fullback ? Shovell was Bert Howe ?No 3 Fullback.?
Is correct.
Nat Clyne was the best for a long while and imo before him our best was Johnny Pemberton but Danny Butts will always have a special place in my heart.
I think Joel could eclipse Nat.
|
Kermit8 Hevon 24 Feb 14 11.32am |
|
|
If Pembo's distribution had been somewhat better he could have been a top player. Athletic, strong, great commitment and stamina but his passing out of defence was woeful at times.
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
Plane Bromley 24 Feb 14 11.34am |
|
Quote Kermit8 at 24 Feb 2014 11.32am
If Pembo's distribution had been somewhat better he could have been a top player. Athletic, strong, great commitment and stamina but his passing out of defence was woeful at times.
It's all relative Kerms.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Feb 14 11.36am |
|
Quote Nubes at 21 Feb 2014 8.58pm
I quite liked Marc Edworthy.
Sold him to Coventry for £850K rising to £1.2 Mill after 60 apps.
|