You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is this 1 on Pulis?
November 16 2026 1.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is this 1 on Pulis?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
slubglurge Flag welling 23 Feb 14 5.38pm

We need to change our gameplan against the big teams. Our tactics may seem to be the right ones but the truth is we haven't taken a single point unless you count Everton as one of the big'uns. All of our rivals have taken points off of the big teams. Im currently watching Norwich beating a lacklustre Spurs 1-0 and if they win they will go back above us courtesy of points they weren't expected to get. Our normal gameplan against anybody relies on us scoring the first goal, its like watching the same game over and over again, we spar with them well and then they knock us out. It could cost us in the end.

 

Eagle welder Flag 23 Feb 14 5.48pm

Just imagine if Murray's volley went in ! That would of been hell of a goal. Different game then after. No clumsy challenge from chamack? Could of been a different outcome. This one was on the players.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Feb 14 6.03pm

Quote slubglurge at 23 Feb 2014 5.38pm

We need to change our gameplan against the big teams. Our tactics may seem to be the right ones but the truth is we haven't taken a single point unless you count Everton as one of the big'uns. All of our rivals have taken points off of the big teams. Im currently watching Norwich beating a lacklustre Spurs 1-0 and if they win they will go back above us courtesy of points they weren't expected to get. Our normal gameplan against anybody relies on us scoring the first goal, its like watching the same game over and over again, we spar with them well and then they knock us out. It could cost us in the end.

A very good post.Well done.


 

girvinator Flag Poole 23 Feb 14 6.59pm

I think the game plan was good and working really well. You can't expect to concede a penalty. However I think we should have seen Gayle and Bolasie come on slightly earlier, they had a lot of energy and pace that could have exploited Ferdinand and Smalling for a longer time.

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 23 Feb 14 7.09pm

I think we showed them too much respect and didn't break quickly enough when we had the chance to.

And what about Parr swapping shirts with Rooney at the end? That p*ssed me off. They're supposed to be there to win points, not collect f*cking souvenirs.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Feb 14 7.17pm

Quote Seth at 23 Feb 2014 7.09pm

I think we showed them too much respect and didn't break quickly enough when we had the chance to.

.

In our position we have to show the top teams a significant amount of respect - we simply cannot have an open expansive game.


 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 23 Feb 14 7.51pm

Quote Willo at 23 Feb 2014 7.17pm


In our position we have to show the top teams a significant amount of respect - we simply cannot have an open expansive game.

Where did I argue for an open expansive game? My point is that we gave them too much time and space on the ball, didn't harry and hassle them enough and didn't break quickly when we had the chance to.

And swapping shirts at the end is what I'd expect Brighton to do if they ever got into the top flight. I'd be surprised if TP was very chuffed about that tbh.


Edited by Seth (23 Feb 2014 7.52pm)

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Feb 14 8.02pm

Quote Seth at 23 Feb 2014 7.51pm

Where did I argue for an open expansive game? My point is that we gave them too much time and space on the ball, didn't harry and hassle them enough and didn't break quickly when we had the chance to.

Our game was not a "Pressing one" where we chased and harried the player in possession.Our gameplan appeared to be to get behind the ball, sit deep, be nice and compact and not give much away.Because we sat deep it was not easy to support the forwards when the ball went up to them.
At the end of the day we just couldn't afford to throw players forward and play an expansive game against the likes of Man Utd.


 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 23 Feb 14 8.11pm

Quote Willo at 23 Feb 2014 8.02pm

Quote Seth at 23 Feb 2014 7.51pm

Where did I argue for an open expansive game? My point is that we gave them too much time and space on the ball, didn't harry and hassle them enough and didn't break quickly when we had the chance to.

Our game was not a "Pressing one" where we chased and harried the player in possession.Our gameplan appeared to be to get behind the ball, sit deep, be nice and compact and not give much away.Because we sat deep it was not easy to support the forwards when the ball went up to them.
At the end of the day we just couldn't afford to throw players forward and play an expansive game against the likes of Man Utd.

I'm fully aware of what the gameplan was.

Again, I never argued for an expansive game. Just wish we'd got in the faces a bit more and hadn't given them all day on the ball.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Feb 14 8.17pm

Quote Seth at 23 Feb 2014 8.11pm

Again, I never argued for an expansive game. Just wish we'd got in the faces a bit more and hadn't given them all day on the ball.

When I used the word "Expansive" this was as a result of my interpretation of your comments regarding breaking quickly.

IF we had "Got in their faces" we might have lost our compact 'Shape'which was obviously the gameplan.And if we hadn't conceded that penalty it would have worked.It changed the game entirely.

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 23 Feb 14 8.51pm

Quote Willo at 23 Feb 2014 8.17pm

Quote Seth at 23 Feb 2014 8.11pm

Again, I never argued for an expansive game. Just wish we'd got in the faces a bit more and hadn't given them all day on the ball.

When I used the word "Expansive" this was as a result of my interpretation of your comments regarding breaking quickly.

IF we had "Got in their faces" we might have lost our compact 'Shape'which was obviously the gameplan.And if we hadn't conceded that penalty it would have worked.It changed the game entirely.


That's not my understanding of the word "expansive" in relation to a style of football. Never mind though. I agree the gameplan was working up to a point, although I always felt they would score in the end because we were giving them too much time and space to pick their passes.

Yes, obviously goals change games. Maybe if we'd tried a little harder to get one of our own before conceding we might have got something from the match.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Feb 14 11.08pm

Quote Seth at 23 Feb 2014 7.51pm

Quote Willo at 23 Feb 2014 7.17pm


In our position we have to show the top teams a significant amount of respect - we simply cannot have an open expansive game.

Where did I argue for an open expansive game? My point is that we gave them too much time and space on the ball, didn't harry and hassle them enough and didn't break quickly when we had the chance to.

And swapping shirts at the end is what I'd expect Brighton to do if they ever got into the top flight. I'd be surprised if TP was very chuffed about that tbh.


Edited by Seth (23 Feb 2014 7.52pm)

Fair enough, I feel we didn't pressure them and get tight, in order to minimise space behind the player for them to play through. We seemed to close down the space for them to play freely in, and for the most part it worked.

As for swapping shirts, some players simply like to collect mementos of a big match. I'd say for most of our squad playing in the premiership is a big deal and they want mementos of big days. Imagine you are Gayle, playing in non-leagues over a season ago, now you're playing against arguably one of the most famous clubs in the world.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 24 Feb 14 1.53am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Feb 2014 11.08pm

As for swapping shirts, some players simply like to collect mementos of a big match. I'd say for most of our squad playing in the premiership is a big deal and they want mementos of big days. Imagine you are Gayle, playing in non-leagues over a season ago, now you're playing against arguably one of the most famous clubs in the world.


I don't care about how amazing it is for Gayle or anyone else - they are premier league footballers and should carry themselves like that. The message swapping shirts sends out is that we're a little club and we're really glad just to be here on the same pitch as Man Utd. Next they'll be asking for an bleedin' autograph.

It's the wrong mindset imo.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Pikester Flag Worthing 24 Feb 14 8.53am

Quote Seth at 24 Feb 2014 1.53am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Feb 2014 11.08pm

As for swapping shirts, some players simply like to collect mementos of a big match. I'd say for most of our squad playing in the premiership is a big deal and they want mementos of big days. Imagine you are Gayle, playing in non-leagues over a season ago, now you're playing against arguably one of the most famous clubs in the world.


I don't care about how amazing it is for Gayle or anyone else - they are premier league footballers and should carry themselves like that. The message swapping shirts sends out is that we're a little club and we're really glad just to be here on the same pitch as Man Utd. Next they'll be asking for an bleedin' autograph.

It's the wrong mindset imo.

Disagree entirely Seth. Had we won would it have been a big issue for you?
If it was joking around before the game then fair enough but once the match has finished there's nothing you can do to change the result.
TP and Moyes may have shared a glass of wine - doesn't make TP any less focussed on winning.

I don't want to patronise but I suspect, like me, you fine EVERYTHING annoying when we lose and gloss over it when we win!

 


You fed me, you bred me, I'll remember your name.

jcreedy Flag 24 Feb 14 10.38am

I was a bit annoyed at the shirt swapping too to be honest. I felt the same when SOK did it with John Terry at Chelsea.

If I was Wayne Rooney, I'd love someone asking me for my shirt after a game. Not only would I have won the match, I'd have won the mental battle too. It just shows an inferiority complex on our part.

If a Palace player really needs to ask another guy for his shirt, at least swap them down the tunnel so that we don't have to see it.

 


It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else.

- John Bostock (Nov 2007)

Leicestershireeagle Flag South Leicestershire 24 Feb 14 11.42am

Quote Seth at 23 Feb 2014 7.09pm

I think we showed them too much respect and didn't break quickly enough when we had the chance to.

And what about Parr swapping shirts with Rooney at the end? That p*ssed me off. They're supposed to be there to win points, not collect f*cking souvenirs.

It did seem a bit naive of Parr, but I can somewhat understand it. That said, Pulis should give Parr the hairdryer for thinking that he wont get another opportunity to swap shirts with him! No one in the team should be feeling like a tourist in this league.

Tactically, I was actually suprised by how forward and attacking we were! Refreshing, and definately an insight into how TP might continue to develope the team given the opportunity.


 


RED AND BLUE ARMY!

Eagle_SA Flag Just outside Cape Town 24 Feb 14 1.27pm

Aside from a dodgy penalty and a single moment oc class from Shrek we were in the game the whole way. We played bloomin well and were very good value for a point!

Sadly the b@stards beat us.

 


And I see signs of half remembered days, I hear bells that chime in strange familiar ways

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 24 Feb 14 1.44pm

thought we were pretty poor and not much of a game plan with the two big boys up top. Vidic and Ferdinand - probably their easiest game this season. Ince unsure what or where he was meant to be. One we were not expected to win and one we did not. on to the next one.

 


@sxp55555

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 24 Feb 14 2.31pm

Quote burtmacp at 23 Feb 2014 7.58am

Since Nov. 30 we are top 8 in the league.
Timid and too respectful until 0-2.
We should have put pressure from the start.
The welcoming from the fans was amazing!


Yes, I thought Palace should have put more pressure on Manure from the off. A bit like against Spurs, we let them off a bit. The difference between the teams can only be their skill v our fight. But really fight we didn't. Funny thing (here we go) I think Olly is the better manager at getting the palyers up and at 'em. Great respect for the guile and dignity of TP still. The result was probably foregone before kick-off on Saturday so TP may have used it for making time to try out formations, hence Murray starts. And I'm glad TP did!

 

jcreedy Flag 25 Feb 14 9.31am

Quote sxp55 at 24 Feb 2014 1.44pm

thought we were pretty poor and not much of a game plan with the two big boys up top. Vidic and Ferdinand - probably their easiest game this season. Ince unsure what or where he was meant to be. One we were not expected to win and one we did not. on to the next one.


Vidic looked rattled through most of the game. I thought he was very poor.

 


It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else.

- John Bostock (Nov 2007)

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is this 1 on Pulis?