You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What makes us ... us?
November 16 2026 12.53pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What makes us ... us?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 05 Mar 14 8.37pm

Instead of loosing their cool on The Web why don't they go to a socialist political meeting and download on those present!.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 05 Mar 14 8.47pm

Quote est1905 at 05 Mar 2014 6.50pm

Quote Mapletree at 05 Mar 2014 11.59am

I have noticed a theme recently about the effects of new or returning supporters, the desire to get rid of idiots and songs that make many uncomfortable

I have also noticed many people commenting that HOL isn't like it was, we seem to be turning in on ourselves and there is an unhealthy negativity.

So I raise the question 'what do we want to be?' and a second question 'do we have any choice, can we really influence who we are?'.

And I have a view to start us off. I have always felt that if you get enough tightly aligned people together with powerful voices you can make a difference, you can control your future and influence others. The old Bolshevik point of it only takes one man armed with a machine gun on each street corner to take a country.

I therefore feel our bickering on this site is perfectly healthy and a part of establishing a culture and keeping it aligned. And that we should not be scared to be critical, it is what we are not that defines us as much as what we are. But we do need to have a core consensus if we want to have any impact whatsoever on our environment.

So, are we anything special and anything different from other teams' supporters and other sites? And if so in what way?


I have a question, Why is it you are so dull?


Why get on this thread? Looks like you are only on HOL for entertainment so find an entertaining thread.

 

beagle Flag pom tiddly om pom pom 05 Mar 14 8.49pm

Quote est1905 at 05 Mar 2014 6.50pm

Quote Mapletree at 05 Mar 2014 11.59am

I have noticed a theme recently about the effects of new or returning supporters, the desire to get rid of idiots and songs that make many uncomfortable

I have also noticed many people commenting that HOL isn't like it was, we seem to be turning in on ourselves and there is an unhealthy negativity.

So I raise the question 'what do we want to be?' and a second question 'do we have any choice, can we really influence who we are?'.

And I have a view to start us off. I have always felt that if you get enough tightly aligned people together with powerful voices you can make a difference, you can control your future and influence others. The old Bolshevik point of it only takes one man armed with a machine gun on each street corner to take a country.

I therefore feel our bickering on this site is perfectly healthy and a part of establishing a culture and keeping it aligned. And that we should not be scared to be critical, it is what we are not that defines us as much as what we are. But we do need to have a core consensus if we want to have any impact whatsoever on our environment.

So, are we anything special and anything different from other teams' supporters and other sites? And if so in what way?


I have a question, Why is it you are so dull?

Dull thread?

Looking forward to your next fascinatingly interesting thread then.

Actually, thinking about your response, I think the op may have an interesting point.

 


When the time comes, I want die just like my Dad - at peace and asleep.
Not screaming and terrified.
Like his passengers.

beagle Flag pom tiddly om pom pom 05 Mar 14 9.03pm

Quote Mapletree at 05 Mar 2014 11.59am

I have noticed a theme recently about the effects of new or returning supporters, the desire to get rid of idiots and songs that make many uncomfortable

I have also noticed many people commenting that HOL isn't like it was, we seem to be turning in on ourselves and there is an unhealthy negativity.

So I raise the question 'what do we want to be?' and a second question 'do we have any choice, can we really influence who we are?'.

And I have a view to start us off. I have always felt that if you get enough tightly aligned people together with powerful voices you can make a difference, you can control your future and influence others. The old Bolshevik point of it only takes one man armed with a machine gun on each street corner to take a country.

I therefore feel our bickering on this site is perfectly healthy and a part of establishing a culture and keeping it aligned. And that we should not be scared to be critical, it is what we are not that defines us as much as what we are. But we do need to have a core consensus if we want to have any impact whatsoever on our environment.

So, are we anything special and anything different from other teams' supporters and other sites? And if so in what way?

Peaks and troughs is my answer.

Pompey were lauded as 'fans fans' when they were in the prem...

I suspect every team has its 'moment' when the whole club fan base collectively charges the atmosphere. And then it ebbs. Palace are no different as, not so long ago, our 'support' was shyte.

I also think that, the longer a team in in the prem, the more people who can afford it (but don't nessessarily love the club) will buy season tickets. Which is the start of Roy Keans 'prawn sandwich' brigade. The are enough prem clubs who are now in this situation. Fans who watch their club as if they are watching MOD.

Finally, I have a few issues with the HF as a body (ie when they issue a 'statement' as if they're a political organisation), but there is no doubt in my mind they've been a monumental force for good in terms of support and atmosphere. Easy to mock the 'ultra' bit, but they sure as hell have made a difference.

 


When the time comes, I want die just like my Dad - at peace and asleep.
Not screaming and terrified.
Like his passengers.

jamwom1971eagle Flag west norwood 05 Mar 14 10.18pm

Quote Stuk at 05 Mar 2014 3.06pm

Quote Superfly at 05 Mar 2014 2.38pm

Quote Mapletree at 05 Mar 2014 11.59am

The old Bolshevik point of it only takes one man armed with a machine gun on each street corner to take a country.


Manhatten (being the only example I can Google) has approx 17,000 street corners. What d'you reckon for England then? Gotta be aroud the 1 million street corners sort of area?

So, to take over a country, you would need a record breakingly ginormous, well armed and thinly spread army


The index to my Greater London A-Z has 140 pages and approx 650 roads per page. If you say each road has 1 corner, as many roads will share them but not all, it's just under 100,000.


Hate to be picky,but every road has 4 corners,wether internal or external,apart from Cul-de-sacs with a turning circle,so that makes appx,390,00.Did i just be bothered to type that?.Time 4 bed.

 

Lombardinho Flag London 06 Mar 14 9.47am

What makes us Palace is our patience. Every couple of seasons we put in a masterful performance and take one of the big guns (or our bitterest rivals)to the cleaners. Matches like that keep us going for a while.

The rest of the time, most other fans think Palace are a poor football team.
We know different but sometimes the buggers are right! It's so annoying.

 

Palace_denizen Flag filed under " time wasters " 06 Mar 14 10.04am

Quote

I therefore feel our bickering on this site is perfectly healthy and a part of establishing a culture and keeping it aligned.


oh shut up, what would you know ? Probably not even a real Palace fan.

 


Laughing at Charlton - Every London Clyub's fourth or fifth most hated team -
[Link]

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 06 Mar 14 11.01am


The most dull thing I have read on this particular thread is that this thread is dull. Could be whoever wrote that didn't quite understand what's being discussed here. Hate to give advice, but for his ilk the place to be is with the oolighans at Millwall. They,re the same sort, not really getting it, being aggressive in what they think is a 'funny' way and attempting to look clever, which makes the point of this thread. No doubt he didn't realise his comments were proving the point he doesn't understand!

 

paperhat Flag croydon 06 Mar 14 11.12am

Quote Palace_denizen at 06 Mar 2014 10.04am

Quote

I therefore feel our bickering on this site is perfectly healthy and a part of establishing a culture and keeping it aligned.


oh shut up, what would you know ? Probably not even a real Palace fan.

P L A S T I C

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


est1905 Flag 06 Mar 14 5.50pm

Quote adrian b at 06 Mar 2014 11.01am


The most dull thing I have read on this particular thread is that this thread is dull. Could be whoever wrote that didn't quite understand what's being discussed here. Hate to give advice, but for his ilk the place to be is with the oolighans at Millwall. They,re the same sort, not really getting it, being aggressive in what they think is a 'funny' way and attempting to look clever, which makes the point of this thread. No doubt he didn't realise his comments were proving the point he doesn't understand!

That's quite presumptuous of you there. Especially when you have no idea who I am, what I think or anything about me really. I read the opening post and thought it was dull. Looked at the poster name and realised its not the first time this poster has bored me rigid. Intriguing title but (for me) substance full of pretentious claptrap. Each to their own. If you like it, go for it. I fully accept I probably should have just kept quiet-the polite thing to just really say nothing and move on. Apologies to any little egos that have been hurt by my response, but 'not getting it'? Really? Please explain the high brow intellectual depth that I don't get. You are obviously on a much higher academic plane than I. I'd really love to hear this one. Maybe you could PM me to spare everyone else the distraction from this topic (and you the embarrassment of course!)


 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 06 Mar 14 5.52pm

Quote est1905 at 06 Mar 2014 5.50pm

Quote adrian b at 06 Mar 2014 11.01am


The most dull thing I have read on this particular thread is that this thread is dull. Could be whoever wrote that didn't quite understand what's being discussed here. Hate to give advice, but for his ilk the place to be is with the oolighans at Millwall. They,re the same sort, not really getting it, being aggressive in what they think is a 'funny' way and attempting to look clever, which makes the point of this thread. No doubt he didn't realise his comments were proving the point he doesn't understand!

That's quite presumptuous of you there. Especially when you have no idea who I am, what I think or anything about me really. I read the opening post and thought it was dull. Looked at the poster name and realised its not the first time this poster has bored me rigid. Intriguing title but (for me) substance full of pretentious claptrap. Each to their own. If you like it, go for it. I fully accept I probably should have just kept quiet-the polite thing to just really say nothing and move on. Apologies to any little egos that have been hurt by my response, but 'not getting it'? Really? Please explain the high brow intellectual depth that I don't get. You are obviously on a much higher academic plane than I. I'd really love to hear this one. Maybe you could PM me to spare everyone else the distraction from this topic (and you the embarrassment of course!)



Nice to see you came back est1905.

 

est1905 Flag 06 Mar 14 5.59pm

Quote Mapletree at 06 Mar 2014 5.52pm

Quote est1905 at 06 Mar 2014 5.50pm

Quote adrian b at 06 Mar 2014 11.01am


The most dull thing I have read on this particular thread is that this thread is dull. Could be whoever wrote that didn't quite understand what's being discussed here. Hate to give advice, but for his ilk the place to be is with the oolighans at Millwall. They,re the same sort, not really getting it, being aggressive in what they think is a 'funny' way and attempting to look clever, which makes the point of this thread. No doubt he didn't realise his comments were proving the point he doesn't understand!

That's quite presumptuous of you there. Especially when you have no idea who I am, what I think or anything about me really. I read the opening post and thought it was dull. Looked at the poster name and realised its not the first time this poster has bored me rigid. Intriguing title but (for me) substance full of pretentious claptrap. Each to their own. If you like it, go for it. I fully accept I probably should have just kept quiet-the polite thing to just really say nothing and move on. Apologies to any little egos that have been hurt by my response, but 'not getting it'? Really? Please explain the high brow intellectual depth that I don't get. You are obviously on a much higher academic plane than I. I'd really love to hear this one. Maybe you could PM me to spare everyone else the distraction from this topic (and you the embarrassment of course!)



Nice to see you came back est1905.

What can I say, I did actually regret my rudeness yesterday. I apologise.
Wanted to see if there were any angry responses, and yours to be fair was pretty dignified. I'm not such a bad bloke, you'll just have to take my word for that!
From now on I will try to refrain from throwing my two penneth worth in unless its constructive.


 

blanksight Flag Thornton heath 06 Mar 14 6.21pm

I think the Hol is such a tiny subsection of the entire Palace fanbase that there is no way it can have a bearing on the culture of the club. There are so many very different people at Palace that it's hard to define us at all really.

 


I'd rather be a FREE MAN in my grave
than living as a PUPPET or a SLAVE

Selhurstboys Flag Basel 06 Mar 14 6.32pm

There is one significant difference to many clubs, especially in the Premier League, and that's we're owned and managed by avid long term Palace fans. That gives us a stronger sense of identity and, for me, identity is what it's all about.
We've all got our stories about how we became Palace fans and many of us don't even live near Selhurst anymore. But that identity never goes away, it stays with you and satisfies that sense of belonging we all crave.
This year I've come back as a season ticket holder partly because we're in the Prem but also because of a deep down feeling this could be our time. A couple of years ago when we were really at the bottom, four Palace fans were determined to rescue the club and save it from going under. That's given us all new hope and determination to put SE25 properly on the map once and for all.
We'll never go quietly into that night!

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 06 Mar 14 7.05pm

The point of a site like this one is to discuss topics raised. To simply say 'how dull', discusses nothing and if a person were to just say that than that person must be answered soly on the post. Because I don't know the poster means I cannot suppose anything more. The chance of the poster to say what he wanted to say has been taken and if he's blown it with such an uninspiring post, than that's his fault and not those who chose to reply. The polite thing to have done is reply to the original thread with a good, balanced reasoning, not, as suggested. to politely be quiet and go away. That's not the point of this site either.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 06 Mar 14 7.37pm

Quote est1905 at 06 Mar 2014 5.59pm

Quote Mapletree at 06 Mar 2014 5.52pm

Quote est1905 at 06 Mar 2014 5.50pm

Quote adrian b at 06 Mar 2014 11.01am


The most dull thing I have read on this particular thread is that this thread is dull. Could be whoever wrote that didn't quite understand what's being discussed here. Hate to give advice, but for his ilk the place to be is with the oolighans at Millwall. They,re the same sort, not really getting it, being aggressive in what they think is a 'funny' way and attempting to look clever, which makes the point of this thread. No doubt he didn't realise his comments were proving the point he doesn't understand!

That's quite presumptuous of you there. Especially when you have no idea who I am, what I think or anything about me really. I read the opening post and thought it was dull. Looked at the poster name and realised its not the first time this poster has bored me rigid. Intriguing title but (for me) substance full of pretentious claptrap. Each to their own. If you like it, go for it. I fully accept I probably should have just kept quiet-the polite thing to just really say nothing and move on. Apologies to any little egos that have been hurt by my response, but 'not getting it'? Really? Please explain the high brow intellectual depth that I don't get. You are obviously on a much higher academic plane than I. I'd really love to hear this one. Maybe you could PM me to spare everyone else the distraction from this topic (and you the embarrassment of course!)



Nice to see you came back est1905.

What can I say, I did actually regret my rudeness yesterday. I apologise.
Wanted to see if there were any angry responses, and yours to be fair was pretty dignified. I'm not such a bad bloke, you'll just have to take my word for that!
From now on I will try to refrain from throwing my two penneth worth in unless its constructive.



Nice post est1905.

The reason I started this is what Blanksight says. Some people post on here just for fun but I have noticed that many post because they want to influence other people. Lots of people say 'I don't normally post but I have to have my say on ....'.

But also not many people really want to break ranks.

So my theory is that in having our constant debates we do get a kind of consensus going. And that puts a few ripples in the pond and may have just a tiny effect on other Palace fans. And probably it would be no bad thing if we had a bit more influence because, in the round, there is a lot of sense on this site.

Maybe even the support on here gives some people the bravery to do something new. But I suppose it also makes it tough for new posters that haven't yet tuned into the consensus.

 

est1905 Flag 06 Mar 14 8.57pm

Quote Mapletree at 06 Mar 2014 7.37pm

Quote est1905 at 06 Mar 2014 5.59pm

Quote Mapletree at 06 Mar 2014 5.52pm

Quote est1905 at 06 Mar 2014 5.50pm

Quote adrian b at 06 Mar 2014 11.01am


The most dull thing I have read on this particular thread is that this thread is dull. Could be whoever wrote that didn't quite understand what's being discussed here. Hate to give advice, but for his ilk the place to be is with the oolighans at Millwall. They,re the same sort, not really getting it, being aggressive in what they think is a 'funny' way and attempting to look clever, which makes the point of this thread. No doubt he didn't realise his comments were proving the point he doesn't understand!

That's quite presumptuous of you there. Especially when you have no idea who I am, what I think or anything about me really. I read the opening post and thought it was dull. Looked at the poster name and realised its not the first time this poster has bored me rigid. Intriguing title but (for me) substance full of pretentious claptrap. Each to their own. If you like it, go for it. I fully accept I probably should have just kept quiet-the polite thing to just really say nothing and move on. Apologies to any little egos that have been hurt by my response, but 'not getting it'? Really? Please explain the high brow intellectual depth that I don't get. You are obviously on a much higher academic plane than I. I'd really love to hear this one. Maybe you could PM me to spare everyone else the distraction from this topic (and you the embarrassment of course!)



Nice to see you came back est1905.

What can I say, I did actually regret my rudeness yesterday. I apologise.
Wanted to see if there were any angry responses, and yours to be fair was pretty dignified. I'm not such a bad bloke, you'll just have to take my word for that!
From now on I will try to refrain from throwing my two penneth worth in unless its constructive.



Nice post est1905.

The reason I started this is what Blanksight says. Some people post on here just for fun but I have noticed that many post because they want to influence other people. Lots of people say 'I don't normally post but I have to have my say on ....'.

But also not many people really want to break ranks.

So my theory is that in having our constant debates we do get a kind of consensus going. And that puts a few ripples in the pond and may have just a tiny effect on other Palace fans. And probably it would be no bad thing if we had a bit more influence because, in the round, there is a lot of sense on this site.

Maybe even the support on here gives some people the bravery to do something new. But I suppose it also makes it tough for new posters that haven't yet tuned into the consensus.


I suppose I'm a bit of a lone wolf on this board. I don't have any alliances or even acquaintances on here. I usually read posts without any participation. I mainly look on here because any bits of news are posted up before I hear about them elsewhere by those that trawl the news sites (which I don't have the time to do). I wouldn't really categorise myself or others who post on here. I offer my opinion and as with life in general, some people agree with you and some just don't matter.
For the record though I actually respect as many on here that I disagree with as those that I agree with. More so in some cases. It's easy to go along with popular opinion, sticking your head above the parapit for the simple reason that it's what you think deserves respect when you are pretty sure others will not agree and some jump on your comments. But arguing is healthy. It means we all have opinions, some of which differ. In my experience, it's good to argue as long as its constructive and doesn't become personal.
I've already acknowledged I was wrong to just negatively dismiss the original post. I don't feel the need to repeat myself

 

Firegut Flag Croydon 07 Mar 14 8.32am

In many ways we're just the same as fans of any other club but being in London, where all the big clubs are across the river and all the media attention goes to them, they get all the fans in north and South London etc, and the population is less static than other places - people moving here from all over with allegiances to other clubs already formed, all this gives a club like ours a bit of a cult value, people aren't supporting clubs like ours for the glory.

There is more opportunity for getting something like the HF going and having the impact on the wider atmosphere generally. It's no accident that has happened at Palace and not, for example, Spurs - whose own "ultras" style group has not been accommodated by their club in the same way and has clearly not improved their atmosphere generally.

But yeah, the longer we are in the prem, getting more successful, of course you get more fans who are only interested because of what league we're in. The spread of the atmosphere could become diluted then, but hopefully we won't end up like all the rest of the prem grounds - sterile apart from the biggest games.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 07 Mar 14 2.12pm

Of course we have the right to express an opinion. The point is to say something like 'why do I find you boring?' expresses an opinion but gives it no substance and is abusive too. Why is the thread boring? Nothing personal about asking that nor stating that the actual post (why do I find you boring?) is in itself boring! However, you have redeemed yourself with some great repartee. A bit self-defensive though, that suggest you may not have felt completely happy with your original post. But love you Est1950

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 07 Mar 14 2.31pm

Quote adrian b at 07 Mar 2014 2.12pm

Of course we have the right to express an opinion. The point is to say something like 'why do I find you boring?' expresses an opinion but gives it no substance and is abusive too. Why is the thread boring? Nothing personal about asking that nor stating that the actual post (why do I find you boring?) is in itself boring! However, you have redeemed yourself with some great repartee. A bit self-defensive though, that suggest you may not have felt completely happy with your original post. But love you Est1905

Changed the date. Found an old centenary scarf last night I didn't know I had. But aren't we trying to claim we were established in 1861?

Anyway, for someone aged 109 it's good to see that Est remains a very lucid poster.

Edited by Mapletree (07 Mar 2014 2.39pm)

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What makes us ... us?