You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Puncheon
November 16 2026 12.25pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Puncheon


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
hdoust43 Flag Msidstone 09 Mar 14 5.03pm

Im sorry but what hell was puncheon doing, if you've got a ball like that you dont head it on, you put in touch or too a player, he did neither, I'd rather have tomas on the pitch as when he came on he beat his man every single time and put a good cross in, where as puncheon is only looking to cut inside.

 

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 09 Mar 14 5.28pm

Quote kennet at 09 Mar 2014 1.54am

I don't rate him one little bit, he's just not consistent enough for what we need at this point in our season!! Yea he can pop up with something good every now and again but I'd defo bring bannan back into the frame!! It might even liven punch up if he was dropped for bannan, bannan put 100% in every game he played and looked good but since punch got his contract he hasn't performed 1 little bit!! I'd drop to liven him up


There's a Southampton fan at work who said to me a while back that Puncheon would try his heart out to get a contract, then as soon as he did would take his foot off of the pedal. Looks like he was right, although I thought he was cack before he got his contract. I'd have Bannan in before him everyday of the week.

 

merganser Flag 09 Mar 14 9.06pm


It's apparently quite commonplace for players to pull out all the stops so as to secure a contract, then to ease off once it has been secured.

They tend to hop from club to club.

However, I wouldn't include Puncheon . IMO, he is a wholehearted player - it's just that things haven't clicked into place (yet).

I'd like him at least to start at Sunderland on Saturday - at the very least he is a handful for opponents. As I recall, he played well in the home match v S'land.

 

Percy of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 09 Mar 14 9.12pm

Quote gazzagoalie at 09 Mar 2014 2.35pm

Quote goodersgold at 09 Mar 2014 9.12am

Quote phillanth at 09 Mar 2014 9.08am

Quote merganser at 09 Mar 2014 12.05am

Unfair to blame puncheon for soton goal. He was entitled to expect better cover behind him. Where was the rest of the defence?

Wouldn't blame Jules either. He was a fractional inch away from making what would have been the best tackle ever made at selhurst park

IMO, Jules did well to make the challenge without getting himself sent off.

Disagree entirely with fowler 's motd comment.

But what does TP think? Will he use the incident as an excuse to replace speroni with Hennessy?

I agree with Fowler. Watching the game live I thought Jules was going to get to the ball first. Having just seen it again on MoTD I think that not only should he have got to the ball first but once he got there, he should have made sure he won it rather than making a powder puff challenge which left Rodrigues with an empty net to aim at. Unfair to blame Puncheon solely for the goal in my opinion.


That's how I saw it too ,once Jules has come he has get there

Not speronis fault imo. Maybe would have been better to stay in his area so he could use his hands, but the challenge could easily have gone wrong and he would have walked.

If it hadn't been a goal ...would Jules have walked???? He didn't get the ball after all

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt!

merganser Flag 09 Mar 14 9.16pm


No, he wouldn't have walked. You don't get a red card just for not winning a tackle.

No foul was committed

 

thosewerethedays Flag Taba 09 Mar 14 9.22pm

Bamnan!......cant understand his ommission.ok short so freakin what?
we will lose him if he doesnt play.tp likes big players.....hmmm would he leave messie on the sidelines?

 


Bring back The HF!

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 09 Mar 14 10.22pm

Don't rate Puncheon..nothing to do with yesterday but just don't think he is that good

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 09 Mar 14 11.29pm

It is a fact that Jerome Thomas is very injury prone, but except for his silly dive at Swansea he IS no matter what a good crosser of the ball and a lot quicker than JP. But unsure if he can last a whole game...

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 09 Mar 14 11.35pm

Dean Moxey is being let off lightly and can share much of the blame as his positioning was terrible and allowed Rodriguez to go.

 

Finchy Flag Kent 09 Mar 14 11.52pm

The fact is it was a horrendous mistake! cost us the game, he knows that! we know that! but that's football.

He's also won us many points along the way. we live to see another day and I see it going down to Fulham away last day.

That's my opinion and its gonna be a rocky ride! This is Palace after all

 

gazzagoalie Flag 09 Mar 14 11.59pm

Quote Percy of Peckham at 09 Mar 2014 9.12pm

Quote gazzagoalie at 09 Mar 2014 2.35pm

Quote goodersgold at 09 Mar 2014 9.12am

Quote phillanth at 09 Mar 2014 9.08am

Quote merganser at 09 Mar 2014 12.05am

Unfair to blame puncheon for soton goal. He was entitled to expect better cover behind him. Where was the rest of the defence?

Wouldn't blame Jules either. He was a fractional inch away from making what would have been the best tackle ever made at selhurst park

IMO, Jules did well to make the challenge without getting himself sent off.

Disagree entirely with fowler 's motd comment.

But what does TP think? Will he use the incident as an excuse to replace speroni with Hennessy?

I agree with Fowler. Watching the game live I thought Jules was going to get to the ball first. Having just seen it again on MoTD I think that not only should he have got to the ball first but once he got there, he should have made sure he won it rather than making a powder puff challenge which left Rodrigues with an empty net to aim at. Unfair to blame Puncheon solely for the goal in my opinion.


That's how I saw it too ,once Jules has come he has get there

Not speronis fault imo. Maybe would have been better to stay in his area so he could use his hands, but the challenge could easily have gone wrong and he would have walked.

If it hadn't been a goal ...would Jules have walked???? He didn't get the ball after all

If speroni had missed the ball and brought Rodriguez down, he would have been off. It is a very difficult situation to be in as a goalkeeper, and one that he shouldn't even have been in.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 10 Mar 14 12.10am

Quote Penge Eagle at 09 Mar 2014 11.35pm

Dean Moxey is being let off lightly and can share much of the blame as his positioning was terrible and allowed Rodriguez to go.


In what way. He was foolishly the only man left back at a corner. Slap bang in the middle of the field just inside our half is the correct position. He was sold short and unable to make a full solid challenge,as a red card was waiting for a mistimed tackle.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Selhurstboys Flag Basel 10 Mar 14 4.14am

At the end of the day it's a team effort. Yes, it was Puncheon's mistake which left Speroni with a 50/50 ball (actually, from where I was sitting at the half-way line, it was more like a 40/60 ball against him and he seemed to do well to get a chance to rescue it) but when you look at it overall, we weren't good enough to get something out of the game. I think Pulis is going to have to roll the dice a bit more, especially against the teams in and around us. Swansea was case in point, the first half he just went for containment and he knew he got it wrong. He has to release the players a bit more. Carries more risk of course but we need a couple more wins to be safe and you need to score to win.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 10 Mar 14 10.46am

Quote Selhurstboys at 10 Mar 2014 4.14am

Yes, it was Puncheon's mistake which left Speroni with a 50/50 ball

Looking on the bright side, the last time that Puncheon had a howler he scored in the next game


 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 10 Mar 14 11.08am

Simple peeps. Palace needs goals and Punchy has scored a few. It's the luck of teams at the bottom where confidence gets sapped and balls are only half played and touches are not full-on. TP has to keep the confidence up and we need to back that. Next game? watch out black cats, or should I should say, pussy?

 

Gallery3 Flag South Croydon 10 Mar 14 12.19pm

Quote south coast eagle at 09 Mar 2014 5.45am

What are these good games Puncheon has had ????

How he get s a start most weeks is beyond me, as much as i think Bannon is better in CM he is definitely better than Puncheon out wide.


I agree. If we go down by one point it is entirely due to that game. He is not my kind of player at all.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 10 Mar 14 12.33pm

Quote Gallery3 at 10 Mar 2014 12.19pm

Quote south coast eagle at 09 Mar 2014 5.45am

What are these good games Puncheon has had ????

How he get s a start most weeks is beyond me, as much as i think Bannon is better in CM he is definitely better than Puncheon out wide.


I agree. If we go down by one point it is entirely due to that game. He is not my kind of player at all.

Just as well for JP that you aren't the gaffer then isn't it?

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 12 Mar 14 7.24pm

Puncheon says he is sorry for screwing up against Southampton so am I. If we survive I will not invite him to my survival party,

 

manosdedios Flag 12 Mar 14 9.34pm

Quote merganser at 09 Mar 2014 9.06pm


It's apparently quite commonplace for players to pull out all the stops so as to secure a contract, then to ease off once it has been secured.

They tend to hop from club to club.

However, I wouldn't include Puncheon . IMO, he is a wholehearted player - it's just that things haven't clicked into place (yet).

I'd like him at least to start at Sunderland on Saturday - at the very least he is a handful for opponents. As I recall, he played well in the home match v S'land.

Is this post a joke!? He is definitely the type of player to do that!

Also, you stick up for him for the majority of the post but then say you can recall him having a good game against Sunderland at home....which was back in August!?

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 12 Mar 14 9.41pm

Footballer made a mistake

Must be hung drawn and quartered.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Puncheon