You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jedi the Weak Link
November 16 2026 12.53pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jedi the Weak Link


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
screaming alice Flag 09 Mar 14 6.30pm

Eastend Palace unfortunately you are correct..!!!

 

Palace_Guard Flag Kyiv 09 Mar 14 6.33pm

weak link my a$$ !

 


Live in Melbourne or Victoria, Australia?
Support Crystal Palace?

Well join the Crystal Palace Melbourne Supporters Club:
[Link]

Adelaide, South Australia? Join here:
[Link]

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 09 Mar 14 6.33pm

Quote screaming alice at 09 Mar 2014 6.30pm

Eastend Palace unfortunately you are correct..!!!


Like I said I am not hundred percent sure myself. A few months ago the thought would not even cross my mind but I have been thinking about more and more and everyone in the pub thought the same thing.

 

FinchleyEagle Flag 09 Mar 14 6.34pm

Oh my not this again.

Can we set up a new section on the HOL entitled 'don't really understand football talk' then rubbish like that can be posted there.

No-one should be immune from fair analysis of what they do, but seriously if anyone thinks that jedi is the weak link then maybe we should have a game without him and just see what the difference is.

Staggering.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

tonymikejoe Flag UK 09 Mar 14 7.29pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 09 Mar 2014 3.42pm

Discuss. I know he has great tackling stats but we wouldn't need to tackle so much if he was in the side.


He is in the side.

A bloody good job he is to, our most important player.

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 09 Mar 14 7.35pm

Quote tonymikejoe at 09 Mar 2014 7.29pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 09 Mar 2014 3.42pm

Discuss. I know he has great tackling stats but we wouldn't need to tackle so much if he was in the side.


If he did all these extra things you want, pass, dribble, take free kicks, score goals then he would be YaYa Toure and cost about £40m.

Unfortunately he isn't, live with it..............


 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 09 Mar 14 7.58pm

I think that the phrase 'weak link' is wrong, as previously mentioned he has a specific job to do in the team and that isn't to be a box to box dynamo who can spray Steven Gerrard passes around. Personally feel that he would be better complimented with either Bannan or O'Keefe alongside him. Both Imo can feel hard done by at present. Don't forget also that he is our Captain and a bloody good one, with outstanding leadership qualities. Something that will be needed more than ever in the weeks to come. Finally, he had an Australia game in the past week (and scored) I believe and as such has done a huge amount of travelling which, may have taken the edge off his game.

 


Bring back Brolin

FinchleyEagle Flag 09 Mar 14 8.00pm

Quote dynamicdick at 09 Mar 2014 7.58pm

I think that the phrase 'weak link' is wrong, as previously mentioned he has a specific job to do in the team and that isn't to be a box to box dynamo who can spray Steven Gerrard passes around. Personally feel that he would be better complimented with either Bannan or O'Keefe alongside him. Both Imo can feel hard done by at present. Don't forget also that he is our Captain and a bloody good one, with outstanding leadership qualities. Something that will be needed more than ever in the weeks to come. Finally, he had an Australia game in the past week (and scored) I believe and as such has done a huge amount of travelling which, may have taken the edge off his game.

Totally with you DD, however they played the Aussie game at the new Den which is probably the closest football pitch in the world to Selhurst Park...

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 09 Mar 14 8.03pm

Instead of focusing on what he did wrong yesterday why not concentrate on what he did right?

Put in a great shift and was all over the park and yes he made mistakes, better that than be anonymous like KG.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

superbeagle Flag Vauxhall 09 Mar 14 8.20pm

Don't forget, he is the one that pinged the cross field pass to Zaha during the Watford final...the rest is history. Pretty good "pass" as I recall.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 09 Mar 14 8.23pm

Response to Finchley Eagle...

I didn't realise it was played at The New Den but it has made me chuckle. Must do my homework next time! Perhaps the traffic was bad!!

 


Bring back Brolin

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 09 Mar 14 8.27pm

Of course he isn't a weak link but I thought that yesterday was the worst I have ever seen him play..he, KG and Puncheon were simply appalling

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 09 Mar 14 8.28pm

Response to Superbeagle

Yes remember the pass to Zaha but then a pro footballer should be expected to ping the occasional accurate pass! If you were asked to describe the attributes of Jedi I don't think you would include his passing abilities.

 


Bring back Brolin

Jordan555x Flag Bromley 09 Mar 14 8.33pm

Brilliant player at interceptions, tackling and winning aerial balls, crap at passing and doesn't seem to score many headers.

But to suggest he is the weak link is nothing more than pure insanity!

 

merganser Flag 09 Mar 14 9.11pm


He's good when we win corners - makes a real nuisance of himself in the box.

 

james03 Flag Bangkok 10 Mar 14 1.33am

Now people are on Jedi's back - amazing!

Jedi is our destroyer, the man who breaks up opposition attacks, puts the fear of god in to opposing forwards and midfielders who look to run at the heart of our defence. The man who reads the game better than most and whose number of intreceptions in midfield and defence are second to none.

If we were scoring goals and winning games nobody would be comenting negatively on Jedi. However, some are making him the scapegoat for our failings that are not his responsibility.

Yes his passing can be poor but he does not try to do too much he is forced to do too much. The number of passes he makes every game, whether they are good or bad, is probably three times higher than any other player wearing a Palace shirt.

For heavens sake the man has been immense this season and competed 100% in every game and for every minute of every game. Without him we would likely be on ten points and have a goal difference of minus fifty!

 


The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx

Mangopablo Flag south LONDON 10 Mar 14 7.42am

Quote skatman at 09 Mar 2014 4.17pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 09 Mar 2014 3.54pm

KG was better then Jedi yesterday. Just because it is Jedi does not make him immune to criticism the guy is a s*** footballer. When he takes set pieces that f***s me off to.


You do know who's who on the pitch right. KG's the big black fella, the one who's not as good as the funny haired white fella he plays next to. Just incase you're mixing the two up.


Jedi was not good on Saturday (and has not had a great season). He looks jaded to me. KG was absolutely abysmal: he offered us nothing. I would have subbed him after 25 mins.

 


"The course of true love never did run smooth"

ADW1988 Flag Bromley 10 Mar 14 8.41am

Quote Mangopablo at 10 Mar 2014 7.42am

Quote skatman at 09 Mar 2014 4.17pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 09 Mar 2014 3.54pm

KG was better then Jedi yesterday. Just because it is Jedi does not make him immune to criticism the guy is a s*** footballer. When he takes set pieces that f***s me off to.


You do know who's who on the pitch right. KG's the big black fella, the one who's not as good as the funny haired white fella he plays next to. Just incase you're mixing the two up.


Jedi was not good on Saturday (and has not had a great season). He looks jaded to me. KG was absolutely abysmal: he offered us nothing. I would have subbed him after 25 mins.

so you quite clearly didn't notice that our midfield went from - a minor presence to absolutely NOTHING when he came off. Easy scapegoat. Not the best player we have but answer me this.. why does EVERY manager we have start him when fit? Some people like STATS and we've seen his name pop up in the worst midfielders. Not denying that.. BUT If you want a proper stat - go and look at games won with KG in the team last season and this season, and games won when he's not - INTERESTING to say the least!
Brighton semi final playoff - he was immense and catalyst to victory.. Short memories around here, that is if indeed some were (not directed at anyone in particular btw before I'm misunderstood)

Jedi was tired after int'l 90 mins and hasn't been at his best all season imo.. BUT still we all know he's got it and break up play is still pretty decent... Just takes too long on the ball (as does KG!!).. I think Ledley looked lively and won a lot of tackles (when Webb didn't blow up for a foul)..

Anyway, we weren't at our best but even our performance wasn't as bad as Webb and his officials.. 2 onside off sides and (when you see it from the fan video from Main Stand touchline) certain red, Clyne was getting nowhere near Yannick..

That's my thoughts anyway

 

ADW1988 Flag Bromley 10 Mar 14 8.46am

And for the record, not 100% defending KG and personally think Barry Bannan gets stuck in and can pass and take set pieces.

Ledley, Jedi Bannan Midfield for me.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 10 Mar 14 9.13am

Quote ADW1988 at 10 Mar 2014 8.41am

Quote Mangopablo at 10 Mar 2014 7.42am

Quote skatman at 09 Mar 2014 4.17pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 09 Mar 2014 3.54pm

KG was better then Jedi yesterday. Just because it is Jedi does not make him immune to criticism the guy is a s*** footballer. When he takes set pieces that f***s me off to.


You do know who's who on the pitch right. KG's the big black fella, the one who's not as good as the funny haired white fella he plays next to. Just incase you're mixing the two up.


Jedi was not good on Saturday (and has not had a great season). He looks jaded to me. KG was absolutely abysmal: he offered us nothing. I would have subbed him after 25 mins.

so you quite clearly didn't notice that our midfield went from - a minor presence to absolutely NOTHING when he came off. Easy scapegoat. Not the best player we have but answer me this.. why does EVERY manager we have start him when fit? Some people like STATS and we've seen his name pop up in the worst midfielders. Not denying that.. BUT If you want a proper stat - go and look at games won with KG in the team last season and this season, and games won when he's not - INTERESTING to say the least!
Brighton semi final playoff - he was immense and catalyst to victory.. Short memories around here, that is if indeed some were (not directed at anyone in particular btw before I'm misunderstood)

Jedi was tired after int'l 90 mins and hasn't been at his best all season imo.. BUT still we all know he's got it and break up play is still pretty decent... Just takes too long on the ball (as does KG!!).. I think Ledley looked lively and won a lot of tackles (when Webb didn't blow up for a foul)..

Anyway, we weren't at our best but even our performance wasn't as bad as Webb and his officials.. 2 onside off sides and (when you see it from the fan video from Main Stand touchline) certain red, Clyne was getting nowhere near Yannick..

That's my thoughts anyway

It wasnt Clyne that tackled Yannick......

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jedi the Weak Link