This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Pulis makes official complaint about Howard Webb
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
jason7 croydon 14 Mar 14 3.23pm |
|
|
And if that means bringing our top ref in for a slating then so be it.He had a very bad day and this will sharpen him up.
|
beer man Kent 14 Mar 14 3.54pm |
|
Quote Mapletree at 14 Mar 2014 1.25pm
Quote adrian b at 14 Mar 2014 1.22pm
I wonder how many times TP will complain to the refereeing body when Palace get a bad decision in their favour? Like a player makes a mistake, what can anybody do about that afterwards. Sweet FA. Move on and win the next poor decision.
Plane is quite correct. When you have a very bad official do something about it. FFS, if I get crap service in a shop I talk to the manager, don't you? Why is a linesman immune? If you don't make a fuss things will never change.
No I don't, life's too short; I just don't go there again. Continual whinging just gets yourself wound up, no one else.
|
Sg Bilko Deurne Holland 14 Mar 14 4.05pm |
|
|
Wasted exercise, as the referees association has assessors at all games, and their report will be final.
So if Howard Webb was as bad as is said, "I have my doubts" the refs association would have already acted, and as he's ref at the Fulham v Newcastle match tomorrow they must consider he did ok.
|
Mapletree Croydon 14 Mar 14 4.07pm |
|
Quote beer man at 14 Mar 2014 3.54pm
Quote Mapletree at 14 Mar 2014 1.25pm
Quote adrian b at 14 Mar 2014 1.22pm
I wonder how many times TP will complain to the refereeing body when Palace get a bad decision in their favour? Like a player makes a mistake, what can anybody do about that afterwards. Sweet FA. Move on and win the next poor decision.
Plane is quite correct. When you have a very bad official do something about it. FFS, if I get crap service in a shop I talk to the manager, don't you? Why is a linesman immune? If you don't make a fuss things will never change.
No I don't, life's too short; I just don't go there again. Continual whinging just gets yourself wound up, no one else.
I see a logical flaw in your 'just go somewhere else' analogy with match officials, it's a monopoly.
And anyway, when does feedback become whingeing? The opposite to doing something about it is moaning but doing nothing. Which is worse, being a moaner or a whinger, there's only one way to find out ....
|
beer man Kent 14 Mar 14 4.55pm |
|
Quote Mapletree at 14 Mar 2014 4.07pm
Quote beer man at 14 Mar 2014 3.54pm
Quote Mapletree at 14 Mar 2014 1.25pm
Quote adrian b at 14 Mar 2014 1.22pm
I wonder how many times TP will complain to the refereeing body when Palace get a bad decision in their favour? Like a player makes a mistake, what can anybody do about that afterwards. Sweet FA. Move on and win the next poor decision.
Plane is quite correct. When you have a very bad official do something about it. FFS, if I get crap service in a shop I talk to the manager, don't you? Why is a linesman immune? If you don't make a fuss things will never change.
No I don't, life's too short; I just don't go there again. Continual whinging just gets yourself wound up, no one else.
I see a logical flaw in your 'just go somewhere else' analogy with match officials, it's a monopoly.
And anyway, when does feedback become whingeing? The opposite to doing something about it is moaning but doing nothing. Which is worse, being a moaner or a whinger, there's only one way to find out ....
QED
|
goodersgold Hastings 14 Mar 14 5.19pm |
|
|
I'm glad we have tony Pulis fighting our corner about time we stood up for ourselves, Bad decisions are often forgotten for the smaller premier league teams ,there is no question we have had more big calls go against us this season.Even Dermot Gallagher on sky said Webb got it badly wrong last week and that decision could of changed the outcome.
The world was a mess but his hair was perfect!
|
Percy of Peckham Eton Mess 14 Mar 14 5.21pm |
|
|
What's the point of complaining? The officials weren't responsible for the fact we were outplayed ...and if I'm not mistaken, we are allowed to have more than a couple of shots at the opposition's goal? Webb and linesman had a bad day at the office. It happens!!!!. Let's hope we don't have another bad day of our own making tomorrow.
Denial is not just a river in Egypt!
|
est1905 14 Mar 14 5.52pm |
|
Quote Mapletree at 14 Mar 2014 11.57am
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 14 Mar 2014 11.42am
Mixed feelings about this, Webb was fecking useless and there should be some sort of consequence for him but at the same time I can;t help thinking it makes us look a bit small minded.
I don't, the linesman was more of a problem overall and was absolutely awful. He needs to be removed from Prem games. But Webb should certainly have used the red card too.
The Linesman was atrocious. Got more decisions wrong than right. He gave throw in to us which should've been to them, off sides when they were on, gave Southampton a goal kick when it was blatantly a corner to us. I could go on and on. I said to a pal I sit with during the game, if no one makes a complaint about this clown it'll be a miracle!
|
peterg Anerley 14 Mar 14 6.28pm |
|
|
I was shocked at how poor the officials were. I had rated Webb because he had reffed a world cup final. He made a big mistake over the Bolasie foul and he was inconsistent too. I also thought he was up himself with his tight shorts. The lino at the Holmesdale end in the first half had a shocker. I was certain the Murray offside call was wrong even from where I was sitting and that has been confirmed. I wasn't so sure about the Ledley offside. But we could have scored from either of those. That and the Bolasie call tipped the match. We were outplayed by Southampton for much of the match and we didn't have much upfront - but that's why these incidents could prove decisive. It's about time we had a break against one of the top-half teams.
The right place at the right time
|
peterg Anerley 14 Mar 14 6.36pm |
|
|
More evidence that Webb is up himself [Link] Charging £4000 for an after-dinner speech! I saw him give a talk to an umpires' AGM at Lords. He was pretty feeble and I just hope Lords didn't pay him £4000.
The right place at the right time
|
wainesworld west wickham 14 Mar 14 6.58pm |
|
Quote peterg at 14 Mar 2014 6.28pm
I was shocked at how poor the officials were. I had rated Webb because he had reffed a world cup final. He made a big mistake over the Bolasie foul and he was inconsistent too. I also thought he was up himself with his tight shorts. The lino at the Holmesdale end in the first half had a shocker. I was certain the Murray offside call was wrong even from where I was sitting and that has been confirmed. I wasn't so sure about the Ledley offside. But we could have scored from either of those. That and the Bolasie call tipped the match. We were outplayed by Southampton for much of the match and we didn't have much upfront - but that's why these incidents could prove decisive. It's about time we had a break against one of the top-half teams.
I can't see how you rated Webb at all after his performance in the world cup final, he was shocking in that game. As others have said if no one complains then he will carry on being s***. If people point these things out it gives him a chance to improve.
|
Jordan555x Bromley 14 Mar 14 7.31pm |
|
Quote peterg at 14 Mar 2014 6.36pm
More evidence that Webb is up himself [Link] Charging £4000 for an after-dinner speech! I saw him give a talk to an umpires' AGM at Lords. He was pretty feeble and I just hope Lords didn't pay him £4000.
Think that's bad look at f***ing Hilary Devey! [Link]
15k-20k for a f***ing after-dinner speech!!!!!!
|
Mangopablo south LONDON 14 Mar 14 7.54pm |
|
Quote Mapletree at 14 Mar 2014 11.57am
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 14 Mar 2014 11.42am
Mixed feelings about this, Webb was fecking useless and there should be some sort of consequence for him but at the same time I can;t help thinking it makes us look a bit small minded.
I don't, the linesman was more of a problem overall and was absolutely awful. He needs to be removed from Prem games. But Webb should certainly have used the red card too.
Webb was too busy giving it the big'un with the big names to do his job properly. The problem with referees is they develop ego problems. They start to believe that they are stars, when really they are just jealous and sad blokes who never got picked for the school team.
"The course of true love never did run smooth"
|
cols123 beckenham 14 Mar 14 8.03pm |
|
Quote NEILLO at 14 Mar 2014 11.59am
Maybe - using the Bolasie / Fonte incident as an example - it's the rules that need looking at.
Webb didn't issue a red card because he felt that Clyne was getting into a position as the ' last man '.
However, if you look at the trip by Fonte in isolation, he clearly didn't believe that to be case, or he wasn't even aware of Clyne's position. Therefore his intention was to take Bolasie out as he believed Bolasie was through on goal, which is what he did. So the punishment didn't really fit the crime.
All said and done, if that is the top ref in England it only highlights how poor the standard is at the moment.
No such thing as last man... Its "preventing a goal scoring opportunity" which happened ergo it should have been red
|
EastEndPalace WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 14 Mar 14 8.34pm |
|
|
We were clean through on goal a through times with perfectly timed through balls only for the linesman to flag offside even though on many occasions it was on. The one shot on target stat is deceiving seeing as all our chances were stopped by dirty Southampton challenges and dodgy reffing and flagging. We were by no means great but we were not as bad and the whole result could of been different if not for the officials decision making.
|
Palace_denizen filed under " time wasters " 14 Mar 14 8.54pm |
|
|
well done Pulis. In tony we trust. . Howard Webb is always seen on telly joking and laughing with famous people from wealthy clubs. Impartial ? you must be having a laugh !!!
Laughing at Charlton - Every London Clyub's fourth or fifth most hated team - [Link]
|
NEILLO Shoreham-by-Sea 15 Mar 14 9.59am |
|
Quote cols123 at 14 Mar 2014 8.03pm
Quote NEILLO at 14 Mar 2014 11.59am
Maybe - using the Bolasie / Fonte incident as an example - it's the rules that need looking at.
Webb didn't issue a red card because he felt that Clyne was getting into a position as the ' last man '.
However, if you look at the trip by Fonte in isolation, he clearly didn't believe that to be case, or he wasn't even aware of Clyne's position. Therefore his intention was to take Bolasie out as he believed Bolasie was through on goal, which is what he did. So the punishment didn't really fit the crime.
All said and done, if that is the top ref in England it only highlights how poor the standard is at the moment.
No such thing as last man... Its "preventing a goal scoring opportunity" which happened ergo it should have been red
But that is how the rule is applied, is it not ? And the reason why Webb didn't issue a red card ?
Old, Ungifted and White
|
The Sash Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 15 Mar 14 10.50am |
|
|
Webb wasn't the reason we lost but he was truly awful all afternoon..hugely inconsistent in his decision making, some bizarre calls on what constitutes a foul and what doesnt and his linesmen weren't much cop either - plan of, wait for Howard to blow THEN put the flag up
If he is the 'best' we have then heaven help us
As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014
|
FinchleyEagle 15 Mar 14 11.03am |
|
|
Pulis is focusing his ire in the wrong place with this. It's just whinging and won't make any difference because football needs refs.
It's incredibly rare that a referee is the reason that a team loses a game - he's pulling a 'Mourinho' here and attempting to deflect the criticism away from his players.
Prefer he didn't but it has it's benefits - as long as he's giving them hell on the training pitch and working on ways to get the performances back up.
You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue Yours sincerely Mile Jedinak
|
The Sash Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 15 Mar 14 11.55am |
|
Quote FinchleyEagle at 15 Mar 2014 11.03am
Pulis is focusing his ire in the wrong place with this. It's just whinging and won't make any difference because football needs refs.
It's incredibly rare that a referee is the reason that a team loses a game - he's pulling a 'Mourinho' here and attempting to deflect the criticism away from his players.
Prefer he didn't but it has it's benefits - as long as he's giving them hell on the training pitch and working on ways to get the performances back up.
Indeed Finchers
Last week was a combination of wrong game plan and too many midfield players turning performances that would make a pub side blush
Webb was still appalling though
Last weekend was the worst game of the season for me by miles - although thankfully I did miss Fulham
As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014
|