You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Woeful...
November 16 2026 12.53pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Woeful...


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
est1905 Flag 17 Mar 14 9.05pm

Quote PJH at 17 Mar 2014 9.41am

I've been stewing on this all weekend and it's time to face facts. We're going down. And we're going down bottom of the pile unless something changes.

What were the tactics for Saturday ? Bearing in mind we were playing a team in the bottom three with an awful home record (albeit better than ours away !). Surely this was a game where 3 points were there for the taking. I guess anyone can argue that 1 point is a means to an end but the simple truth is that if we don't score we're not going to get a point every time.Bannan not even on the bench ? Is he injured or is he sh*gging TP's daughter ?

Also :

Jedders : WTF is going on with him ? What is the point of having a 'ball winning' midfielder if he just gives it straight back to them to have another go ? The guy cannot pass for toffee whether it be 30 yards or three. It's got to be the worst passing performance I've seen in a Palace shirt since the days of Neil Emblen (yes, THAT bad !). I'm sorry but if by some miracle we stay up TP will be offloading him. You simply cannot have a player who gives the ball away so consistently.

Yannick : All bluster and pace but flatters to deceive and is quite frankly a liability when he get near their 18 yard box and is coming across to me as all mouth and trousers. To be fair, tackles back very well and puts in a proper shift.

KG : Have defended him for ages but I'm afraid after Saturday he's worn me down. Not good enough, and I was saying that before he blasted the ball wide from 2 yards out near the end.

Positives :

Jules : Outstanding as usual. two great saves (one was offside, but he wasn't to know that).

Defence. Outstanding also, especially as both full backs booked in the first 15 which could have made for a long afternoon if one of them had picked up another yellow. They must get well p*ssed off that they're doing their but but we can't create anything up the other end.

Answers ? No idea, but we have to treat each game differently surely. If it had been Anfield, fair enough, but we need to be more of a threat, and we'll need to be also at Cardiff, West Ham and Fulham or our season is just going to fade away.

You are in my heart Palace and I love you deeply. Always have, always will but jesus christ you make me sooo angry sometimes !.

Rant over.


I read the first couple of sentences and got bored. We are not necessarily going down. We might do but we are in a far better position than before TP came in.
People that think we have a god given right to win any game in this division know nothing of football. Our resources are the smallest in the division. We should be celebrating every single point earned as it is a point closer to our goal, survival and another £60m and the chance to strengthen our position in this division further like West Brom, Swansea, Southampton have done. We're punching above our weight with players that are learning as they go, many of which are tired now the adrenalin of playing in the Prem has worn off. Cut em some slack and get behind the team. Call yourself a supporter of the team? That is not supporting..
Rant over

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 17 Mar 14 9.30pm

Quote PJH at 17 Mar 2014 9.41am

I've been stewing on this all weekend and it's time to face facts. We're going down. And we're going down bottom of the pile unless something changes.

What were the tactics for Saturday ? Bearing in mind we were playing a team in the bottom three with an awful home record (albeit better than ours away !). Surely this was a game where 3 points were there for the taking. I guess anyone can argue that 1 point is a means to an end but the simple truth is that if we don't score we're not going to get a point every time.Bannan not even on the bench ? Is he injured or is he sh*gging TP's daughter ?

Also :

Jedders : WTF is going on with him ? What is the point of having a 'ball winning' midfielder if he just gives it straight back to them to have another go ? The guy cannot pass for toffee whether it be 30 yards or three. It's got to be the worst passing performance I've seen in a Palace shirt since the days of Neil Emblen (yes, THAT bad !). I'm sorry but if by some miracle we stay up TP will be offloading him. You simply cannot have a player who gives the ball away so consistently.

Yannick : All bluster and pace but flatters to deceive and is quite frankly a liability when he get near their 18 yard box and is coming across to me as all mouth and trousers. To be fair, tackles back very well and puts in a proper shift.

KG : Have defended him for ages but I'm afraid after Saturday he's worn me down. Not good enough, and I was saying that before he blasted the ball wide from 2 yards out near the end.

Positives :

Jules : Outstanding as usual. two great saves (one was offside, but he wasn't to know that).

Defence. Outstanding also, especially as both full backs booked in the first 15 which could have made for a long afternoon if one of them had picked up another yellow. They must get well p*ssed off that they're doing their but but we can't create anything up the other end.

Answers ? No idea, but we have to treat each game differently surely. If it had been Anfield, fair enough, but we need to be more of a threat, and we'll need to be also at Cardiff, West Ham and Fulham or our season is just going to fade away.

You are in my heart Palace and I love you deeply. Always have, always will but jesus christ you make me sooo angry sometimes !.

Rant over.

Hope you feel better for that, dread to think how negative you would have been had we have lost and actually gone into the bottom three.

 

Gyro1780 Flag Leatherhead, Surrey 17 Mar 14 10.23pm

Quote Mstrobez at 17 Mar 2014 9.45am

We got a point away against a team who on paper is stronger than us.

Rant over.

This

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 17 Mar 14 11.09pm

Quote PJH at 17 Mar 2014 9.41am

I've been stewing on this all weekend and it's time to face facts. We're going down. And we're going down bottom of the pile unless something changes.

What were the tactics for Saturday ? Bearing in mind we were playing a team in the bottom three with an awful home record (albeit better than ours away !). Surely this was a game where 3 points were there for the taking. I guess anyone can argue that 1 point is a means to an end but the simple truth is that if we don't score we're not going to get a point every time.Bannan not even on the bench ? Is he injured or is he sh*gging TP's daughter ?

Also :

Jedders : WTF is going on with him ? What is the point of having a 'ball winning' midfielder if he just gives it straight back to them to have another go ? The guy cannot pass for toffee whether it be 30 yards or three. It's got to be the worst passing performance I've seen in a Palace shirt since the days of Neil Emblen (yes, THAT bad !). I'm sorry but if by some miracle we stay up TP will be offloading him. You simply cannot have a player who gives the ball away so consistently.

Yannick : All bluster and pace but flatters to deceive and is quite frankly a liability when he get near their 18 yard box and is coming across to me as all mouth and trousers. To be fair, tackles back very well and puts in a proper shift.

KG : Have defended him for ages but I'm afraid after Saturday he's worn me down. Not good enough, and I was saying that before he blasted the ball wide from 2 yards out near the end.

Positives :

Jules : Outstanding as usual. two great saves (one was offside, but he wasn't to know that).

Defence. Outstanding also, especially as both full backs booked in the first 15 which could have made for a long afternoon if one of them had picked up another yellow. They must get well p*ssed off that they're doing their but but we can't create anything up the other end.

Answers ? No idea, but we have to treat each game differently surely. If it had been Anfield, fair enough, but we need to be more of a threat, and we'll need to be also at Cardiff, West Ham and Fulham or our season is just going to fade away.

You are in my heart Palace and I love you deeply. Always have, always will but jesus christ you make me sooo angry sometimes !.

Rant over.


Bubble,

You may as well stew on it until the end of next season, IF, we stay up, £60m for staying up is hardly going to buy us a team to keep us up with comfort, let alone compete with the top six.

I agree Jedi has had a couple of bad games, but he never could pass. Just tired maybe, through carrying the team???? You can't fault his break up play.

Bolasie is still developing. His skill is outstanding. Yet to find his finishing form.

KG I'm inclined to agree.

However, if you think that they are the only improvements we need, we should be mid table. We are not, as we all see.

I don't think that we can improve very much with a mere £6om. That only buys one quality player when you factor in wages for the season.

So... either support what we have or stop whingeing.

Rant ove.......

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (17 Mar 2014 11.34pm)

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 17 Mar 14 11.31pm

PJH, if you want to bitch, whine, rant or dance naked in your living room while singing along to Cliff Richard, you do just that.
You're entitled to your opinion and the right to express it, just don't stew on it for a weekend, your head might explode.
Before the old interweb thingy started my missus had to just sit there nodding while I had a rant, moan or enthuse about CPFC. If you now can't come on here and do it, then what exactly is the point of this medium?

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 17 Mar 14 11.43pm

Quote Dangermouse at 17 Mar 2014 11.31pm

PJH, if you want to bitch, whine, rant or dance naked in your living room while singing along to Cliff Richard, you do just that.
You're entitled to your opinion and the right to express it, just don't stew on it for a weekend, your head might explode.
Before the old interweb thingy started my missus had to just sit there nodding while I had a rant, moan or enthuse about CPFC. If you now can't come on here and do it, then what exactly is the point of this medium?


Agreed. Rant and moan as much as you like. Just be realistic though.

This used to be a palace supporters site once. Sad that it now seems to be a Premier League supporters site

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Barcelona Based Fan Flag No longer Barcelona, now living in... 18 Mar 14 3.27am

Normally id be moaning about the performance but I recall we went 9.games without a win last season!

I know that was a different team and all that but we're Palace and thats what we've come to expect
I was more than happy to take a point
V Sunderland, remember if we had one more
point in 04 we'd have stayed up!
Only Manure have beaten us latley so am remaining chilled
& praying it doesn't come down to the Cottage! ! 10 years on from one of the worst days of my life at the Valley! !

Ps that's 2 away points & no Chamy in the team.
We've missed him badly imho


Edited by Barcelona Based Fan (18 Mar 2014 3.42am)

 


TaxiMark
Sheffield Wednesday Fan
Posted 23 February 2013 - 07:49 PM
I don't mind palace to be fair. Much better club than tinpot Charlton and Brighton

n wales eagles Flag llandudno 18 Mar 14 6.45am

Quote Barcelona Based Fan at 18 Mar 2014 3.27am

Normally id be moaning about the performance but I recall we went 9.games without a win last season!

I know that was a different team and all that but we're Palace and thats what we've come to expect
I was more than happy to take a point
V Sunderland, remember if we had one more
point in 04 we'd have stayed up!
Only Manure have beaten us latley so am remaining chilled
& praying it doesn't come down to the Cottage! ! 10 years on from one of the worst days of my life at the Valley! !

Ps that's 2 away points & no Chamy in the team.
We've missed him badly imho


Edited by Barcelona Based Fan (18 Mar 2014 3.42am)

and southampton also beat us and dont know what difference your hero chamy will make reckon bannen and gayle better options.maybe saturday an attacking display at the toon would surprise them and could be a good tactical ploy.but dont hold your breath as sure it will be another back to the wall 30% possession game.

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 18 Mar 14 7.35am

Quote n wales eagles at 18 Mar 2014 6.45am

Quote Barcelona Based Fan at 18 Mar 2014 3.27am

Normally id be moaning about the performance but I recall we went 9.games without a win last season!

I know that was a different team and all that but we're Palace and thats what we've come to expect
I was more than happy to take a point
V Sunderland, remember if we had one more
point in 04 we'd have stayed up!
Only Manure have beaten us latley so am remaining chilled
& praying it doesn't come down to the Cottage! ! 10 years on from one of the worst days of my life at the Valley! !

Ps that's 2 away points & no Chamy in the team.
We've missed him badly imho


Edited by Barcelona Based Fan (18 Mar 2014 3.42am)

and southampton also beat us and dont know what difference your hero chamy will make reckon bannen and gayle better options.maybe saturday an attacking display at the toon would surprise them and could be a good tactical ploy.but dont hold your breath as sure it will be another back to the wall 30% possession game.


Chamakh is PROVEN quality you don't play for Arsenal for that long if your a mug. In fact it was only the emergence of Van glass ankles that got him dropped in the midst of a very rich vain of form for Le canonniers.

It is no coincidence that since his enforced absence we have been woeful up front and lacked any creativity what so bleedin ever. He holds up the ball brilliantly allowing our deep set midfield time to get around the ball and support, and his work rate is top notch closing down from the front whenever possible.

I would very much like to see Gayle up top with Chamakh as the furthest forward in a midfield of Five:

Bolaisie Right
Ince Left
Jedinak Central
Ledley Central
Chamakh Attacking Central.

Back four picks itself as does Jules the legend.

If your going to play the way I have suggested then Pace up front is key, Murray has none. So it would have to be Gayle, I would use Murray if we went behind with say 25 to go, as the above system can easily be changed back to 442 with Murray and Chamakh up front Ledley Supporting the front two Jedi Holding.

Having said all that more than happy with where we are so far this season, we are hard to beat as Arsenal and Man United found out, and we are well in with a chance of staying up, ( I fancy Naaarich to drop into Sunderlands spot, and us to stay 4th from bottom) and that in itself would be fcuking massive achievement for a club like ours.

So for now, its a case of support shout sing your hearts out for the lads, cross your fingers and toes, pray to the lord god Hommer Simpson that we stay up.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

PJH Flag Colchester 18 Mar 14 8.53am

Quote Tim Gypsy Hill '64 at 17 Mar 2014 11.43pm

Quote Dangermouse at 17 Mar 2014 11.31pm

PJH, if you want to bitch, whine, rant or dance naked in your living room while singing along to Cliff Richard, you do just that.
You're entitled to your opinion and the right to express it, just don't stew on it for a weekend, your head might explode.
Before the old interweb thingy started my missus had to just sit there nodding while I had a rant, moan or enthuse about CPFC. If you now can't come on here and do it, then what exactly is the point of this medium?


Agreed. Rant and moan as much as you like. Just be realistic though.

This used to be a palace supporters site once. Sad that it now seems to be a Premier League supporters site


Hmmm not sure what that's supposed to mean...been going to Palace for 45 years. Don't think the prem's been going quite that long...have seen us alot more in the 2nd div (and Third !!) than the top one. But sorry, as someone pointed out in an earlier post, cos I haven't praised us to the skies in my original post I'm not a proper supporter.Funnily enough I just want us to do well whatever division we're in and my personal opinion is that we could/should have done better on Saturday.

 

essetwentyone Flag london 18 Mar 14 9.40am

PJH - I share your concern as do most Palace supporters but just imagine if we still had Holloway as manager - we would be relegated already !!!!! Pullis is playing a system to best suit the squad and the situation and nobody can doubt it's success. We have to plug away with this system because our home games are against the most dangerous counter attacking teams and our away games are against our relegation rivals who we cannot allow to beat us. So we defend deep and hope to nick a goal - Saturday would've worked a treat if KG wasn't wearing banana boots!! Keep the faith and even if we do go down it'll be a good season to look forward to in the Championship .

Oh and will those idiots who keep shouting " Get Out" whenever we clear the ball please realise that we don't do that under the Pullis system - we defend deep! It drives me mad every game !!!

 

20 Spaces Isnt Enoug Flag Bolton 18 Mar 14 9.57am

Quote JeffBourne at 17 Mar 2014 6.36pm

Have to agree with the OP.

The overall picture is to stay up, but Sunderland had to be one of our targets for 3 points as realistically we are not going to pick up too many other points until the end of the season.

By not attempting to get 3 points against a very poor Sunderland team, it means that we will most probably have to get 3 points against more difficult opposition to give ourselves a chance of staying up.

Many have defended the way we played saying that we are not as established as Sunderland, and we do not have such good players. I disagree with this and believe that our players should have been instilled with confidence and a game plan to attack Sunderland.

Instead we just sat back and let a terrible team come on to us.

I really don't think Pulis even contemplated any attacking, as the players had no idea what to do when they got over the half way line.

A point gained but 2 lost in my opinion.

UP THE PALACE!


Agree with Jeff, two points lost. Sunderland were terrible and if they continue to play like that they will certainly be relegated.
One of the worst opposition team performances I've seen this season, on a par with Cardiff's abject surrender.
Combined with our tactics made for awful viewing.
If I wasn't in such a hurry to get home, I would have gone to the box office to see if I could get a refund.

 

PJH Flag Colchester 18 Mar 14 10.00am

Quote essetwentyone at 18 Mar 2014 9.40am

PJH - I share your concern as do most Palace supporters but just imagine if we still had Holloway as manager - we would be relegated already !!!!! Pullis is playing a system to best suit the squad and the situation and nobody can doubt it's success. We have to plug away with this system because our home games are against the most dangerous counter attacking teams and our away games are against our relegation rivals who we cannot allow to beat us. So we defend deep and hope to nick a goal - Saturday would've worked a treat if KG wasn't wearing banana boots!! Keep the faith and even if we do go down it'll be a good season to look forward to in the Championship .

Oh and will those idiots who keep shouting " Get Out" whenever we clear the ball please realise that we don't do that under the Pullis system - we defend deep! It drives me mad every game !!!


Good points well made ! I can understand defending deep but think we just need to offer something (anything !!) to relieve the constant pressure our back four seem to be under, especially against teams that we have the players to cause problems against. And It's certainly not a dig at TP at all (well, except for not wanting to play Bannan !!) We'd be down already without him at the helm.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 18 Mar 14 10.25am

Did you ever consider that the 'outstanding' defence looks as such, because the system we play offers them a lot of protection? Let's be honest, of the back four that started on Saturday, probably only Ward is really Premiership level.

To replace KG (whom I don't rate either) with Bannan would completely upset the system (as Pulis eluded to in his pre-match press conference) and make the 'outstanding' defence look a hell of a lot weaker.

If you really believe we'll finish bottom of the league, get down to the bookies, you'd get some good odds on that.

 

PJH Flag Colchester 18 Mar 14 3.55pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 18 Mar 2014 10.25am

Did you ever consider that the 'outstanding' defence looks as such, because the system we play offers them a lot of protection? Let's be honest, of the back four that started on Saturday, probably only Ward is really Premiership level.

To replace KG (whom I don't rate either) with Bannan would completely upset the system (as Pulis eluded to in his pre-match press conference) and make the 'outstanding' defence look a hell of a lot weaker.

If you really believe we'll finish bottom of the league, get down to the bookies, you'd get some good odds on that.


Yep, fair comment, TP has set his stall out as to how he wants to play. It does still beg the question about where the points for survival are going to come from though.I don;t understand why so many people are so thrilled about a point at Sunderland nearing in mind where we are. If we only get over the halfway line a few times a game we aren't going to score, and we're not going to get 9 draws with the three big guns coming to Selhurst (heart says we can but let's be serious !).Everyone seems to think Villa and Fulham are a guaranteed 6 points and we'll get something at Cardiff and West Ham and everything will be alright. I hope so too..but not convinced it'll happen. Sorry, negative I know but I think it's more realistic that if we play like we have in the last three games we'll be lucky to get another 4 points.And the mustard that will not cut.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 18 Mar 14 4.12pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 18 Mar 2014 10.25am

Did you ever consider that the 'outstanding' defence looks as such, because the system we play offers them a lot of protection? Let's be honest, of the back four that started on Saturday, probably only Ward is really Premiership level.

To replace KG (whom I don't rate either) with Bannan would completely upset the system (as Pulis eluded to in his pre-match press conference) and make the 'outstanding' defence look a hell of a lot weaker.

If you really believe we'll finish bottom of the league, get down to the bookies, you'd get some good odds on that.


9/1 is the best at the moment (you can get 12 on Sunderland, 16 on Norwich, and 25 on WBA)

 

thegreatlardino Flag crawley/selsey 18 Mar 14 4.20pm

watching the motd highlights again...cant see how anyone can say that KG missed a sitter from 2 yards....he tried to put it past the keeper into the top corner and missed....do think kg does do a lot unseen work...he is quoting eric cantona the water-carrier in the team...do think bannan is a better player but he isnt being picked...woeful is the crap we put up with earlier in the season

Edited by thegreatlardino (18 Mar 2014 4.20pm)

 


Sometimes I set out for Ludlow
Sometimes I end up in Chepstow

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 18 Mar 14 4.29pm

Quote thegreatlardino at 18 Mar 2014 4.20pm

watching the motd highlights again...cant see how anyone can say that KG missed a sitter from 2 yards....he tried to put it past the keeper into the top corner and missed....do think kg does do a lot unseen work...he is quoting eric cantona the water-carrier in the team...do think bannan is a better player but he isnt being picked...woeful is the crap we put up with earlier in the season

Edited by thegreatlardino (18 Mar 2014 4.20pm)

He was unmarked from 6 yards out. If a professional footballer can't finish that on his stronger foot, there's something wrong.

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 18 Mar 14 4.29pm

Quote Tim Gypsy Hill '64 at 17 Mar 2014 11.09pm

Quote PJH at 17 Mar 2014 9.41am

I've been stewing on this all weekend and it's time to face facts. We're going down. And we're going down bottom of the pile unless something changes.

What were the tactics for Saturday ? Bearing in mind we were playing a team in the bottom three with an awful home record (albeit better than ours away !). Surely this was a game where 3 points were there for the taking. I guess anyone can argue that 1 point is a means to an end but the simple truth is that if we don't score we're not going to get a point every time.Bannan not even on the bench ? Is he injured or is he sh*gging TP's daughter ?

Also :

Jedders : WTF is going on with him ? What is the point of having a 'ball winning' midfielder if he just gives it straight back to them to have another go ? The guy cannot pass for toffee whether it be 30 yards or three. It's got to be the worst passing performance I've seen in a Palace shirt since the days of Neil Emblen (yes, THAT bad !). I'm sorry but if by some miracle we stay up TP will be offloading him. You simply cannot have a player who gives the ball away so consistently.

Yannick : All bluster and pace but flatters to deceive and is quite frankly a liability when he get near their 18 yard box and is coming across to me as all mouth and trousers. To be fair, tackles back very well and puts in a proper shift.

KG : Have defended him for ages but I'm afraid after Saturday he's worn me down. Not good enough, and I was saying that before he blasted the ball wide from 2 yards out near the end.

Positives :

Jules : Outstanding as usual. two great saves (one was offside, but he wasn't to know that).

Defence. Outstanding also, especially as both full backs booked in the first 15 which could have made for a long afternoon if one of them had picked up another yellow. They must get well p*ssed off that they're doing their but but we can't create anything up the other end.

Answers ? No idea, but we have to treat each game differently surely. If it had been Anfield, fair enough, but we need to be more of a threat, and we'll need to be also at Cardiff, West Ham and Fulham or our season is just going to fade away.

You are in my heart Palace and I love you deeply. Always have, always will but jesus christ you make me sooo angry sometimes !.

Rant over.


Bubble,

You may as well stew on it until the end of next season, IF, we stay up, £60m for staying up is hardly going to buy us a team to keep us up with comfort, let alone compete with the top six.

I agree Jedi has had a couple of bad games, but he never could pass. Just tired maybe, through carrying the team???? You can't fault his break up play.

Bolasie is still developing. His skill is outstanding. Yet to find his finishing form.

KG I'm inclined to agree.

However, if you think that they are the only improvements we need, we should be mid table. We are not, as we all see.

I don't think that we can improve very much with a mere £6om. That only buys one quality player when you factor in wages for the season.

So... either support what we have or stop whingeing.

Rant ove.......

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (17 Mar 2014 11.34pm)

Not me mate, Im all for Tony Pulis and what he is doing.

 

jamwom1971eagle Flag west norwood 18 Mar 14 4.40pm

The worry is we have now got so defensive minded we have forgotten how to attack,can understand Pulis tactics,but we don't look like we have a counter attack game plan,we seem to gain possession and not know what to do next,hence so many miss placed passes.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Woeful...