You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We will go down without Joniesta
November 16 2026 12.53pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

We will go down without Joniesta


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 25 Mar 14 3.54pm

When ever I have an opinion I'm told The Boss knows best. Well he prefers big men and all I prefer is somebody who can show a twinkle of creativity now and again and can shoot. I must have missed the incident of creation that the big men put together but now we are desperate for someone to pull something out of the hat for us. Lets give Bannan a go and see if we can get Johnny back for Saturday.Also give Guediora a half up front. FFS lets do something different!.

 

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 25 Mar 14 3.56pm

Quote FinchleyEagle at 25 Mar 2014 1.26pm

As someone once said 'players who haven't been playing when you are losing suddenly look much better'

Starting every Ipswich game until the end if the season will be a great way to prepare him for a go in the prem next year


Now I can only go and cry in me beer!.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 25 Mar 14 4.00pm

Quote blind eagle at 25 Mar 2014 3.54pm

When ever I have an opinion I'm told The Boss knows best. Well he prefers big men and all I prefer is somebody who can show a twinkle of creativity now and again and can shoot. I must have missed the incident of creation that the big men put together but now we are desperate for someone to pull something out of the hat for us. Lets give Bannan a go and see if we can get Johnny back for Saturday.Also give Guediora a half up front. FFS lets do something different!.


So get someone back with 0 league goals in his career?

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 25 Mar 14 4.06pm

Quote maxipalace at 25 Mar 2014 12.38pm

Quote cheswickeagle at 23 Mar 2014 11.32am

What a stupid post.

I don't see why people rate him so highly. Yes he is a talented young player but he is very raw and is yet to prove himself in a big game or over a number of games. Looking back at last season, when he was fit, Jonny never really stood out that much. I can probably only count two or three games where he had a really good game.

It does seem that any fan hates it when a young player from the academy doesn't get played, as if the manager is damaging our academy.

They way we are playing under Pulis means Williams would not have seen a lot of the ball and he isn't the type of player to sit deep and defend so him going on loan doesn't mean that's why we may go down


Mate we are the lowest scores in the league. Anybody who dosent rate Williams knows nothing about football. When he went on loan i feared that we will be in big trouble. Im sticking to my belief we will go down without him.

I don't think there is anyone who doesn't rate Williams but most are aware that he is nowhere near the finished article and, at present, Bannan is a better option with his PL experience and all-round better game.
It's much better for him to be out on loan getting valuable game time rather than sit on our bench for the odd 10 minute cameo.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 25 Mar 14 4.17pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 25 Mar 2014 4.00pm

Quote blind eagle at 25 Mar 2014 3.54pm

When ever I have an opinion I'm told The Boss knows best. Well he prefers big men and all I prefer is somebody who can show a twinkle of creativity now and again and can shoot. I must have missed the incident of creation that the big men put together but now we are desperate for someone to pull something out of the hat for us. Lets give Bannan a go and see if we can get Johnny back for Saturday.Also give Guediora a half up front. FFS lets do something different!.


So get someone back with 0 league goals in his career?


Yes mate we need goals but you have to have somebody who might create the chances to score them.

 

BelfastEagle Flag 25 Mar 14 6.22pm

Quote maxipalace at 23 Mar 2014 8.07am

Was worried when he went on loan and thought we lack any creativity.

Most palace fans know how good he is but Pulis hansnt given him a chance. Ince is being given the same treatment

Kiss your 2m bonus goodbye TP

All this crap abt not being good enough for premier league is bollocks. How the fcuk do you know!?

What utter tripe what have you been smoking ?

 

Sienna1977 Flag Chichester 25 Mar 14 6.32pm

Quote Jordan555x at 23 Mar 2014 11.16am

While i rate joniesta, him going on loan doesnt affect us in the slightest. While he is a pretty amazing dribbler with a good bit of pace about him, he needs improvement on his passing, definitely needs huge improvement on shooting and crossing. Bannan is the carbon copy of Joniesta but better im afraid.

Ithink u will find that the whole bloody team needs to improve their passing and shooting !! At least when williams got the ball he took players on and went in the right direction for goal .

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 25 Mar 14 6.46pm

Quote Sienna1977 at 25 Mar 2014 6.32pm

Quote Jordan555x at 23 Mar 2014 11.16am

While i rate joniesta, him going on loan doesnt affect us in the slightest. While he is a pretty amazing dribbler with a good bit of pace about him, he needs improvement on his passing, definitely needs huge improvement on shooting and crossing. Bannan is the carbon copy of Joniesta but better im afraid.

Ithink u will find that the whole bloody team needs to improve their passing and shooting !! At least when williams got the ball he took players on and went in the right direction for goal .


yes I remember well, all those stonking goals he's scored.
JW is not for this season.
later.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 25 Mar 14 6.54pm

Jonny would make no difference as he would of been deployed as a holding midfielder in our ultra defensive set up. Really don't see him coming back for long until he is sold to a Championship team next season.
I know he's just signed a four and a half year deal, but we all know relevant they are in this day and age.

On another note, it's sad to see so many dissing him on this thread. Some maybe doing it to get back at maxi, but it's not nice to see.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 25 Mar 14 6.56pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Mar 2014 6.54pm

Jonny would make no difference as he would of been deployed as a holding midfielder in our ultra defensive set up. Really don't see him coming back for long until he is sold to a Championship team next season.
I know he's just signed a four and a half year deal, but we all know relevant they are in this day and age.

On another note, it's sad to see so many dissing him on this thread. Some maybe doing it to get back at maxi, but it's not nice to see.


So Pulis signed him on a long term deal, stating he has a massive future at the club, to sell him? Makes sense.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 25 Mar 14 7.31pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 25 Mar 2014 6.56pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Mar 2014 6.54pm

Jonny would make no difference as he would of been deployed as a holding midfielder in our ultra defensive set up. Really don't see him coming back for long until he is sold to a Championship team next season.
I know he's just signed a four and a half year deal, but we all know relevant they are in this day and age.

On another note, it's sad to see so many dissing him on this thread. Some maybe doing it to get back at maxi, but it's not nice to see.


So Pulis signed him on a long term deal, stating he has a massive future at the club, to sell him? Makes sense.

When did football make sense?
Billy Davies signed a big extension in Oct last year.
Rene Meulenstein was given about 9 games, quite sure he wasn't given a 9 game contract.
Tom Ince was signed at great expense on loan to give us a goal threat, then was played so deep he could actually hear Jules sweating.
Anything a manager says should be taken with a pinch of salt, because circumstances change all the time.
Finally, it's just my opinion, doesn't mean I'm right.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 25 Mar 14 7.33pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 25 Mar 2014 6.56pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Mar 2014 6.54pm

Jonny would make no difference as he would of been deployed as a holding midfielder in our ultra defensive set up. Really don't see him coming back for long until he is sold to a Championship team next season.
I know he's just signed a four and a half year deal, but we all know relevant they are in this day and age.

On another note, it's sad to see so many dissing him on this thread. Some maybe doing it to get back at maxi, but it's not nice to see.


So Pulis signed him on a long term deal, stating he has a massive future at the club, to sell him? Makes sense.


I honestly think some people want Pulis to f*** this club up just to say I told you so, they are getting increasingly frustrated because there are no signs of him f***ing us up and if anything taking us forward. People made their minds up about Pulis, we play well the whole time under him then we have a tough run against better sides with our best player out injured and they return with the "I told you this is what it will be like the whole time" Some people need to get a grip, I wish we were anywhere near as good as Stoke were under him. Interesting Stat as well as having 0ne of the best defensive records they scored more goals then anyone in the bottom half each season, if this is the negative tripe Pulis turns us into then I am looking forward to it.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 25 Mar 14 7.34pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Mar 2014 7.31pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 25 Mar 2014 6.56pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Mar 2014 6.54pm

Jonny would make no difference as he would of been deployed as a holding midfielder in our ultra defensive set up. Really don't see him coming back for long until he is sold to a Championship team next season.
I know he's just signed a four and a half year deal, but we all know relevant they are in this day and age.

On another note, it's sad to see so many dissing him on this thread. Some maybe doing it to get back at maxi, but it's not nice to see.


So Pulis signed him on a long term deal, stating he has a massive future at the club, to sell him? Makes sense.

When did football make sense?
Billy Davies signed a big extension in Oct last year.
Rene Meulenstein was given about 9 games, quite sure he wasn't given a 9 game contract.
Tom Ince was signed at great expense on loan to give us a goal threat, then was played so deep he could actually hear Jules sweating.
Anything a manager says should be taken with a pinch of salt, because circumstances change all the time.
Finally, it's just my opinion, doesn't mean I'm right.


Manager changes aren't at all relevant here.

I'm glad you agree.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 25 Mar 14 7.38pm

Quote maxipalace at 23 Mar 2014 8.07am

Was worried when he went on loan and thought we lack any creativity.

Most palace fans know how good he is but Pulis hansnt given him a chance. Ince is being given the same treatment

Kiss your 2m bonus goodbye TP

All this crap abt not being good enough for premier league is bollocks. How the fcuk do you know!?

Williams went to Ipswich for match fitness after injury which he is getting, the loan is for a month, after which, hopefully he will be back and in the match day squad

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 25 Mar 14 7.56pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 25 Mar 2014 7.33pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 25 Mar 2014 6.56pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Mar 2014 6.54pm

Jonny would make no difference as he would of been deployed as a holding midfielder in our ultra defensive set up. Really don't see him coming back for long until he is sold to a Championship team next season.
I know he's just signed a four and a half year deal, but we all know relevant they are in this day and age.

On another note, it's sad to see so many dissing him on this thread. Some maybe doing it to get back at maxi, but it's not nice to see.


So Pulis signed him on a long term deal, stating he has a massive future at the club, to sell him? Makes sense.


I honestly think some people want Pulis to f*** this club up just to say I told you so, they are getting increasingly frustrated because there are no signs of him f***ing us up and if anything taking us forward. People made their minds up about Pulis, we play well the whole time under him then we have a tough run against better sides with our best player out injured and they return with the "I told you this is what it will be like the whole time" Some people need to get a grip, I wish we were anywhere near as good as Stoke were under him. Interesting Stat as well as having 0ne of the best defensive records they scored more goals then anyone in the bottom half each season, if this is the negative tripe Pulis turns us into then I am looking forward to it.


So we aren't playing an ultra defensive style in your opinion then?
If he only does it against better sides than us, then why will he change, seeing as at the moment, judging by the tactics it seems they are all better than us.
I don't want TP to fail, I have never said that, but I also know what we are going to get with him in charge. If you are happy with that kind of football, then fine, that's up to you. All I've ever said is that I do not enjoy watching the sort of football TP produces. I couldn't stand watching Stoke play that way, so why would I enjoy my team doing it?
Still "Swing Low" will be a welcome addition to the repetoire...............

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 25 Mar 14 8.33pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Mar 2014 7.56pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 25 Mar 2014 7.33pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 25 Mar 2014 6.56pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Mar 2014 6.54pm

Jonny would make no difference as he would of been deployed as a holding midfielder in our ultra defensive set up. Really don't see him coming back for long until he is sold to a Championship team next season.
I know he's just signed a four and a half year deal, but we all know relevant they are in this day and age.

On another note, it's sad to see so many dissing him on this thread. Some maybe doing it to get back at maxi, but it's not nice to see.


So Pulis signed him on a long term deal, stating he has a massive future at the club, to sell him? Makes sense.


I honestly think some people want Pulis to f*** this club up just to say I told you so, they are getting increasingly frustrated because there are no signs of him f***ing us up and if anything taking us forward. People made their minds up about Pulis, we play well the whole time under him then we have a tough run against better sides with our best player out injured and they return with the "I told you this is what it will be like the whole time" Some people need to get a grip, I wish we were anywhere near as good as Stoke were under him. Interesting Stat as well as having 0ne of the best defensive records they scored more goals then anyone in the bottom half each season, if this is the negative tripe Pulis turns us into then I am looking forward to it.


So we aren't playing an ultra defensive style in your opinion then?
If he only does it against better sides than us, then why will he change, seeing as at the moment, judging by the tactics it seems they are all better than us.
I don't want TP to fail, I have never said that, but I also know what we are going to get with him in charge. If you are happy with that kind of football, then fine, that's up to you. All I've ever said is that I do not enjoy watching the sort of football TP produces. I couldn't stand watching Stoke play that way, so why would I enjoy my team doing it?
Still "Swing Low" will be a welcome addition to the repetoire...............


You couldn't stand watching Stoke embarrass big sides at the Brittania and did not think "If only we could do that". Give over please.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 25 Mar 14 8.41pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 25 Mar 2014 8.33pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Mar 2014 7.56pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 25 Mar 2014 7.33pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 25 Mar 2014 6.56pm

Quote Dangermouse at 25 Mar 2014 6.54pm

Jonny would make no difference as he would of been deployed as a holding midfielder in our ultra defensive set up. Really don't see him coming back for long until he is sold to a Championship team next season.
I know he's just signed a four and a half year deal, but we all know relevant they are in this day and age.

On another note, it's sad to see so many dissing him on this thread. Some maybe doing it to get back at maxi, but it's not nice to see.


So Pulis signed him on a long term deal, stating he has a massive future at the club, to sell him? Makes sense.


I honestly think some people want Pulis to f*** this club up just to say I told you so, they are getting increasingly frustrated because there are no signs of him f***ing us up and if anything taking us forward. People made their minds up about Pulis, we play well the whole time under him then we have a tough run against better sides with our best player out injured and they return with the "I told you this is what it will be like the whole time" Some people need to get a grip, I wish we were anywhere near as good as Stoke were under him. Interesting Stat as well as having 0ne of the best defensive records they scored more goals then anyone in the bottom half each season, if this is the negative tripe Pulis turns us into then I am looking forward to it.


So we aren't playing an ultra defensive style in your opinion then?
If he only does it against better sides than us, then why will he change, seeing as at the moment, judging by the tactics it seems they are all better than us.
I don't want TP to fail, I have never said that, but I also know what we are going to get with him in charge. If you are happy with that kind of football, then fine, that's up to you. All I've ever said is that I do not enjoy watching the sort of football TP produces. I couldn't stand watching Stoke play that way, so why would I enjoy my team doing it?
Still "Swing Low" will be a welcome addition to the repetoire...............


You couldn't stand watching Stoke embarrass big sides at the Brittania and did not think "If only we could do that". Give over please.

Sorry, but I can't write I don't enjoy football the way TP preaches in any other language than English. I'm sorry it upsets you, but I don't like watching football the way Tony Pulis sets his teams out to play it. I have never ever wanted my team to be Stoke.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Firegut Flag Croydon 25 Mar 14 9.01pm

Where would you play JW in this side Maxi? I don't disagree that it's a shame to see him loaned out, just not sure where you see him in this current side increasing our chances of goals.

At attacking mid/behind the striker, he isn't going to be tenacious enough for this side. There's too much of a gap between Jedinak and KG/Ledley. I could see Jonny getting isolated too much and not providing for the striker. For me, the best player we have for that position is Chamakh. Not his 'natural' position maybe, but he impresses me regularly with hold up play and ability to find a decent pass in a very pressurised part of the field.

 

seeweedhater Flag London 25 Mar 14 9.16pm

Cracking goal for ipswich tonight!

 

slubglurge Flag welling 25 Mar 14 9.19pm

Jonny's just brought the house down with a screamer.

 

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We will go down without Joniesta