You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Do We Change The Team For Cardiff?
November 16 2026 12.39pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Do We Change The Team For Cardiff?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 01 Apr 14 3.48pm

TEAM AT NEWCASTLE.
SAME TEAM FOR CHELSEA
AND SAME TEAM FOR CARDIFF

Simples.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Sherlock Holmesdale Flag Milton Keynes 01 Apr 14 3.51pm

Quote EverybodyDannsNow at 01 Apr 2014 3.12pm

Quote adrian b at 01 Apr 2014 3.01pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 01 Apr 2014 2.55pm

If Cardiff throw the kitchen sink at us which they will I think we will be ok. I can see this being another kind of Chelsea games soak up the pressure and then break with pace and exploit the gaps in the back but FFS Palace put them away.


You don't think Cardiff will be clever and hold back, inviting Palace forward and exploiting the resulting gaps. With speedy players like Zaha and Bellingham up front, I would. After all, they must know Palace need to win as much as them. Or do Palace fall back to their old, misdirected ways of defending negatively and do a Newcastle etc?


There's no way Cardiff will hold back, this is make or break for them, their fans won't let them sit back.

And we don't need to win as much as them, their season is over if they don't win this, we're far from that stage.

I'd be very happy with a point.


I agree very much with this. Firstly I don't think Cardiff have the ability to hold back and defend in the way that we do. If they did, that would suit us just fine. As has been pointed out, it is make or break to some extent for them and the pressure is more on them than us, especially being at home.

We do not need to win this match. For Cardiff its must win, for us its must not lose. I would happily take a point from this game. That would leave Cardiff with just a handful of games from which to close a growing gap between us and them.

My main worry is that Cardiff are actually fairly good going forward and do seem to be scoring a lot of goals recently. I could well see us conceding at some point. Thankfully Cardiff do not seem to know how to defend but we are not renowned for our goalscoring exploits so I predict a close game lacking in quality.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 01 Apr 14 4.00pm

In a battle between Pulis and OGS tactically I am glad we have Pulis.

I hope we look to play as we did on Saturday and at Newcastle..looking to break when we cam rather than camp out as we did against Swansea 1st Half, Sunderland and Saints - we look so much better when we do

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

kersal Flag London 01 Apr 14 4.30pm

One advantage of having TP at the helm is that his gameplan changes only slightly from game to game. It doesn't matter if we're playing Chelsea H or Cardiff A. We have low ball possession and a hardworking compact team that opens wide during counter attacks. I expect (and want) us to do exactly what we did all season with TP against Cardiff.

Same team, same tactics, hopefully the same outcome.

It's not like he can tell the team to park the bus more than we normally do, so I don't anticipate any dangerous shifts in mentality which will invite Cardiff more than we normally invite other teams.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 01 Apr 14 4.58pm

Quote adrian b at 01 Apr 2014 3.01pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 01 Apr 2014 2.55pm

If Cardiff throw the kitchen sink at us which they will I think we will be ok. I can see this being another kind of Chelsea games soak up the pressure and then break with pace and exploit the gaps in the back but FFS Palace put them away.


You don't think Cardiff will be clever and hold back, inviting Palace forward and exploiting the resulting gaps. With speedy players like Zaha and Bellingham up front, I would. After all, they must know Palace need to win as much as them. Or do Palace fall back to their old, misdirected ways of defending negatively and do a Newcastle etc?


Have they produced a hybrid player combining Bellamy and Whittingham !?! I never trusted their new owner with his black leather gloves. Always looked like a James Bond villain to me. Now I know why they let him buy the club.

Edited by Booted Eagle (01 Apr 2014 5.15pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

deleted9 Flag 01 Apr 14 6.51pm

The longer the game goes on as a draw, the more nervous/desperate Cardiff will become. I imagine their fans will become vocal as well and we need to capitalise on this. They will inevitably push forward but we can just as easily hit them on the break. We have the quality to do so.

One goal will be the difference in my opinion.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 01 Apr 14 6.57pm

Quote alexdyoung87 at 01 Apr 2014 6.51pm

The longer the game goes on as a draw, the more nervous/desperate Cardiff will become. I imagine their fans will become vocal as well and we need to capitalise on this. They will inevitably push forward but we can just as easily hit them on the break. We have the quality to do so.

One goal will be the difference in my opinion.

Could be right. But I really think Cardiff will sit back to invite Palace to attack and use their quicker players to use the ensuing space.

 

Baldfella Flag Wigan 01 Apr 14 7.04pm

Quote adrian b at 01 Apr 2014 6.57pm

Quote alexdyoung87 at 01 Apr 2014 6.51pm

The longer the game goes on as a draw, the more nervous/desperate Cardiff will become. I imagine their fans will become vocal as well and we need to capitalise on this. They will inevitably push forward but we can just as easily hit them on the break. We have the quality to do so.

One goal will be the difference in my opinion.

Could be right. But I really think Cardiff will sit back to invite Palace to attack and use their quicker players to use the ensuing space.


Do you really think they will sit back and invite Palace forward ? They'll have a really long wait ! I hope they do sit back because so will we and the game will end a dull 0-0 draw !

 

Rainforest Flag London England 01 Apr 14 7.37pm

Cardiff had scored, I think, 10 goals in the last 4 games - an average of 2 goals per game. It won't be a 0-0 game on Saturday. They are going to score at least 1 goal and we have to score to get a draw or win.

 

Leicestershireeagle Flag South Leicestershire 01 Apr 14 7.40pm

No, keep it the same.

Cardiff can be dangerous going forward, and we're at their place.

Solid at the back, and a quick counter to follow. Against Chelsea, whilst being very defensively sound, we also commuted forward a sensible amount and broke with intent. Too any times we've just done the defensive said, and have ended up looking toothless.

We are where we are because we've been solid at the back and countered when possible. Some games we've done that better than others.

 


RED AND BLUE ARMY!

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 01 Apr 14 10.03pm

Keep it the same then, with 25 to go, this really could be Ince's time to shine. It's not too dissimilar to their Championship team and with tired legs, he could make a real difference off the bench.

Whatever happens, we must not concede and that will be the philosophy. I back us to hold them out, we've held out much better sides, and I really don't rate their defence on our counter attack.

Here's hoping!

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 02 Apr 14 2.50pm


Please do not think Cardiff will 'fall' into our trap of inviting them forward and being caught on the break. They may be Welsh, but I think we'll all find them cleverer than that. It's a game of nerve and they will hold back to create the space they want. With the space available to Palace I'd expect Palace to go forward and then be susceptible to the counter. Their success in the goalscoring game is better than ours. Even if Palace then hold back and seem to settle for the inevitable draw, there will come a moment when a hole will appear in Palace defence 'enticed' forward. It's a common tactic among the Scandinavians, so remember who the Cardiff manager is.

 

Sherlock Holmesdale Flag Milton Keynes 02 Apr 14 3.06pm

Quote adrian b at 02 Apr 2014 2.50pm


Please do not think Cardiff will 'fall' into our trap of inviting them forward and being caught on the break. They may be Welsh, but I think we'll all find them cleverer than that. It's a game of nerve and they will hold back to create the space they want. With the space available to Palace I'd expect Palace to go forward and then be susceptible to the counter. Their success in the goalscoring game is better than ours. Even if Palace then hold back and seem to settle for the inevitable draw, there will come a moment when a hole will appear in Palace defence 'enticed' forward. It's a common tactic among the Scandinavians, so remember who the Cardiff manager is.


I don't think it is a case of luring them into our trap. We set up for every game not expecting to have much in the way of possession and trying to be hard to break down. That is not how Cardiff have approached games this season and with their desperation for points and possible confidence in beating us I would expect the usual possession stats to prevail. I do not believe Cardiff are defensively sound enough to sit back in a match and expect them to come at us.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 02 Apr 14 3.32pm

Quote Sherlock Holmesdale at 02 Apr 2014 3.06pm

Quote adrian b at 02 Apr 2014 2.50pm


Please do not think Cardiff will 'fall' into our trap of inviting them forward and being caught on the break. They may be Welsh, but I think we'll all find them cleverer than that. It's a game of nerve and they will hold back to create the space they want. With the space available to Palace I'd expect Palace to go forward and then be susceptible to the counter. Their success in the goalscoring game is better than ours. Even if Palace then hold back and seem to settle for the inevitable draw, there will come a moment when a hole will appear in Palace defence 'enticed' forward. It's a common tactic among the Scandinavians, so remember who the Cardiff manager is.


I don't think it is a case of luring them into our trap. We set up for every game not expecting to have much in the way of possession and trying to be hard to break down. That is not how Cardiff have approached games this season and with their desperation for points and possible confidence in beating us I would expect the usual possession stats to prevail. I do not believe Cardiff are defensively sound enough to sit back in a match and expect them to come at us.

Yes, very good points. Just nerves from me!

 

Eaglesnut Flag Waterford 02 Apr 14 4.50pm

Typical nerves and expectations after a great result Saturday. Think it will be a totally different game. Would not be surprised to see Wilf on the bench for Cardiff as he must have mixed feelings about the game - especially with rumours rife that we will try to get him back if we stay up (or should I say after we have guaranteed our safety).

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 02 Apr 14 4.50pm

Although Jerome was brilliant against Chelsea, we need to attack in numbers and convert our chances rather than just having someone to hold the ball up. So I'd put Murray or Chamakh in - depending on his fitness.

 

girvinator Flag Poole 02 Apr 14 4.54pm

A must not lose game similar to the Sunderland game too.

I think we will be unchanged but possibly Chamakh in for Jerome depending on his fitness and how he's trained this week.

 

Mangopablo Flag south LONDON 02 Apr 14 4.56pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 01 Apr 2014 12.05pm

Obviously that old adage, don't change a winning team but we will have a different ethos to the game vs Chelsea. Plus Chamakh is back and prior to the Chrlsea game most were in agreement that he was sorely missed. I personally think we will keep the same team. KG and Ledley deserve to retain their positions.

I do however believe that we will need more attacking instincts against Cardiff. If we invite them forward we will eventually get punished. Thoughts?


Team will be the same. Pulis is not a tinkerman.

 


"The course of true love never did run smooth"

est1905 Flag 02 Apr 14 4.57pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 01 Apr 2014 12.05pm

Obviously that old adage, don't change a winning team but we will have a different ethos to the game vs Chelsea. Plus Chamakh is back and prior to the Chrlsea game most were in agreement that he was sorely missed. I personally think we will keep the same team. KG and Ledley deserve to retain their positions.

I do however believe that we will need more attacking instincts against Cardiff. If we invite them forward we will eventually get punished. Thoughts?

I think its a must win game for Cardiff but a point would be acceptable to us. They have to attack us from the off. If we can soak up 90 minutes of pressure from Chelsea, 93 from Newcastle then I don't see Cardiff having anything to trouble us if we perform to our best. I would keep the same team except play Chamakh instead of CamJam. And I can see us nicking this one 0 1 (although I'd take a point right now if offered)


 

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 02 Apr 14 5.10pm

Quote PJH at 01 Apr 2014 1.20pm

Quote skj at 01 Apr 2014 1.05pm

I personally think it's a definate no lose match for Cardiff so they will be more inclined to be pushing forward more than usual. I think to adopt a similar strategy as the Chelsea game will hopefully provide us with a few chances.

I'd definately make sure Wardy covers Wilf and that should stop the supply of balls to Bellamy. That's my main concern.

This.We'd be delighted with a point, cardiff would feel they're doomed if they don't get all three so they will be all over us like a cheap suit which, as long as we don't concede early, will play right into our new counter-attacking with pace hands.


Agree - A draw would be a point won by us - two lost by Cardiff. They will go for a win so we must play to defend well and break when possible. could be a nervy one !

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Do We Change The Team For Cardiff?