You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > best atmosphere
November 16 2026 12.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

best atmosphere


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
goodersgold Flag Hastings 28 Apr 14 12.28am

Quote bubble wrap at 27 Apr 2014 8.35pm

Quote adrian b at 27 Apr 2014 8.30pm


It was constant and loud. The days whole stadia chanted are no longer. Average fan age has seen to that, along with the prawn sandwich brigade.

Was that your opinion formed from the radio or the ground. we were s***e today regarding atmosphere. best fans?? what a load of bollicks.


This^^^
We really have a high opinion of ourselves and as for those rushing off early to go and have a micro wave roast .piss poor

 


The world was a mess but his hair was perfect!

Mangopablo Flag south LONDON 28 Apr 14 8.56am

Quote Kosowski at 27 Apr 2014 9.24pm

Today was poor, the early goal didn't help. It's been a long old season and I think today was a bit of an anticlimax mixed with relief.

Loved the 'we're proud of you' chant, the boys deserved it.

The 4th minute goal and the complete dominance of Man City made it unlikely that the atmosphere would hit Chelsea levels. Being safe in mid-table had an effect on both team and fans, but both can bounce back for the Liverpool game. Yesterday was a bit like the Swansea home game, which was killed off early as well.

 


"The course of true love never did run smooth"

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 28 Apr 14 9.29am

The atmosphere was pretty quiet compared to normal. I think the match was decided with the Liverpool result, had they won then city would've been massively deflated, as it happened it was the best team talk they could have had. For us, team and fans, it was basically a game that meant nothing after a hard slog throughout the season.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

goodersgold Flag Hastings 28 Apr 14 9.30am

Quote Mangopablo at 28 Apr 2014 8.56am

Quote Kosowski at 27 Apr 2014 9.24pm

Today was poor, the early goal didn't help. It's been a long old season and I think today was a bit of an anticlimax mixed with relief.

Loved the 'we're proud of you' chant, the boys deserved it.

The 4th minute goal and the complete dominance of Man City made it unlikely that the atmosphere would hit Chelsea levels. Being safe in mid-table had an effect on both team and fans, but both can bounce back for the Liverpool game. Yesterday was a bit like the Swansea home game, which was killed off early as well.


You are right,
However that is where we claim to be different to other fans other than the HF is was pretty bad yesterday and there was a lot of comments and sarcasm aimed at those leaving early in the lower holmesdale

 


The world was a mess but his hair was perfect!

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 28 Apr 14 9.30am

Quote Skinster at 27 Apr 2014 8.47pm

oy oy bubbles , did you hear it son..... who the f*** is laughing now.....thought that was reserved for the clowns

Yes, heard it mate, but thought we that was still sang at the Clowns.

 

Proper_Gander Flag Anerley 28 Apr 14 9.50am

Was it really that much worse? It was quieter for some periods, but I really enjoyed the majority stadium singing "We Love You". Even if it was only for a short time.

Thinking back, people where was sitting were quieter, the crowd was different. The guy to my right was wearing a Palace top but didn't make a peep all game. (Not everybody is a cheery type of person, fair enough) The 2 guys to my left were Belgian tourists who clearly came to see Kompany, even if they seemed to want Palace to do well.

In the end, the game wasn't important because we're safe, we conceded in the first 4 minutes, and the players weren't at their best (they have been for 5 games in a row so it's understandable...).

I find threads like this having a go at other Palace supporters far more disheartening. Give your fellow supporters the benefit of the doubt.

Or do you think bullying other supporters is going to improve the atmosphere?

 

Mstrobez Flag 28 Apr 14 10.02am

Quote Proper_Gander at 28 Apr 2014 9.50am

Was it really that much worse? It was quieter for some periods, but I really enjoyed the majority stadium singing "We Love You". Even if it was only for a short time.

Thinking back, people where was sitting were quieter, the crowd was different. The guy to my right was wearing a Palace top but didn't make a peep all game. (Not everybody is a cheery type of person, fair enough) The 2 guys to my left were Belgian tourists who clearly came to see Kompany, even if they seemed to want Palace to do well.

In the end, the game wasn't important because we're safe, we conceded in the first 4 minutes, and the players weren't at their best (they have been for 5 games in a row so it's understandable...).

I find threads like this having a go at other Palace supporters far more disheartening. Give your fellow supporters the benefit of the doubt.

Or do you think bullying other supporters is going to improve the atmosphere?

Dont think bullying is the point - the thing that frustrates me is so called die hard fans who make alot of noise when we're winning against Chelsea but when it's City and we're 2-0 down (but safe anyway) they wanna complain.. At the start of the season, when no1 wanted to know the atmosphere at Selhurst was electric - and I'm talking about the times we were not winning anything at all. I remember taking an Arsenal fan to Selhurst with me for the Arsenal game. At this point, theoretically, we were down already but the atmosphere was incredible despite the 2-0 loss. If I took someone non Palace with me yesterday, they would've laughed at the amount I've boasted and preached our tremendous support this season.

I've also said a number of times that I actually think the atmosphere was much better at Selhurst last season (home + away), but I guess that's expected when you go Prem.

It's just concerning that next season we don't know what will happen, we could get over confident and be in a right relegation scrap or it could be mediocre all season (and could stay like that for a while until we progress) and the one thing that will keep Palace magic is the atmosphere and pride on match days.

If that goes, will be very, very sad IMO.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

si_1967 Flag Surrey 28 Apr 14 10.06am

One massive improvement would be to stop singing the "we're the boys from SE25".

I don't mind the words, but the tune and tone create no volume at all. Its just a murmuring dirge.

Compare that to the "We love you, we follow" chant, you get so much more from that one.

 


... what

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Apr 14 10.13am

Quote si_1967 at 28 Apr 2014 10.06am

One massive improvement would be to stop singing the "we're the boys from SE25".

I don't mind the words, but the tune and tone create no volume at all. Its just a murmuring dirge.

Compare that to the "We love you, we follow" chant, you get so much more from that one.


Absolutely dog sh1t song. Means f*** all really, especially to 95% of the people who sing it.

 


COYP

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 28 Apr 14 10.13am

Quote goodersgold at 28 Apr 2014 12.28am

Quote bubble wrap at 27 Apr 2014 8.35pm

Quote adrian b at 27 Apr 2014 8.30pm
It was constant and loud. The days whole stadia chanted are no longer. Average fan age has seen to that, along with the prawn sandwich brigade.

Was that your opinion formed from the radio or the ground. we were s***e today regarding atmosphere. best fans?? what a load of bollicks.

This^^^
We really have a high opinion of ourselves and as for those rushing off early to go and have a micro wave roast .piss poor

Our high opinion of ourselves is hard fought and well deserved. People may feel that the atmosphere on Saturday was bad but this is only compared to some of the recent matches where we had everything to play for. The atmosphere on Saturday was probably way better than most Premiership clubs get at home even when they win.

I agree with you about those leaving 5 minutes early, now I know how Brighton feel with 15 minutes to go.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Apr 14 10.20am

Quote topcat at 28 Apr 2014 10.13am

People may feel that the atmosphere on Saturday was bad but this is only compared to some of the recent matches where we had everything to play for. The atmosphere on Saturday was probably way better than most Premiership clubs get at home even when they win.

I agree with you about those leaving 5 minutes early, now I know how Brighton feel with 15 minutes to go.


No wonder you thought the atmosphere was bad if you were there on Saturday with just Sainsbury's shoppers and trolley wheel noise. If Prem grounds are as quiet as that we might as well just have every game on tv and scrap crowds altogether.

 


COYP

Proper_Gander Flag Anerley 28 Apr 14 10.24am

Quote Mstrobez at 28 Apr 2014 10.02am

Dont think bullying is the point - the thing that frustrates me is so called die hard fans who make alot of noise when we're winning against Chelsea but when it's City and we're 2-0 down (but safe anyway) they wanna complain.. At the start of the season, when no1 wanted to know the atmosphere at Selhurst was electric - and I'm talking about the times we were not winning anything at all. I remember taking an Arsenal fan to Selhurst with me for the Arsenal game. At this point, theoretically, we were down already but the atmosphere was incredible despite the 2-0 loss. If I took someone non Palace with me yesterday, they would've laughed at the amount I've boasted and preached our tremendous support this season.

I've also said a number of times that I actually think the atmosphere was much better at Selhurst last season (home + away), but I guess that's expected when you go Prem.

It's just concerning that next season we don't know what will happen, we could get over confident and be in a right relegation scrap or it could be mediocre all season (and could stay like that for a while until we progress) and the one thing that will keep Palace magic is the atmosphere and pride on match days.

If that goes, will be very, very sad IMO.

I sympathise with what you say.

But we have to be realistic, Palace had nothing to play for, so obviously the atmosphere is going to be more relaxed, ie quieter.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 28 Apr 14 10.47am

Quote Proper_Gander at 28 Apr 2014 9.50am

Was it really that much worse? It was quieter for some periods, but I really enjoyed the majority stadium singing "We Love You". Even if it was only for a short time.

Thinking back, people where was sitting were quieter, the crowd was different. The guy to my right was wearing a Palace top but didn't make a peep all game. (Not everybody is a cheery type of person, fair enough) The 2 guys to my left were Belgian tourists who clearly came to see Kompany, even if they seemed to want Palace to do well.

In the end, the game wasn't important because we're safe, we conceded in the first 4 minutes, and the players weren't at their best (they have been for 5 games in a row so it's understandable...).

I find threads like this having a go at other Palace supporters far more disheartening. Give your fellow supporters the benefit of the doubt.

Or do you think bullying other supporters is going to improve the atmosphere?


Don't see it that way PG. The comments on here are merely observations. If we want to continue to be special we do have to look at ourselves and work out what we do that works well and think about why we sometimes have off days. Same as the team.

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 28 Apr 14 11.29am

At the start of the match was it a different version of Glad all Over as the crowd seemed to lose it a bit, if it was please bring back THe Dave Clark 5 original or maybe I need a hearing test??

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Apr 14 11.33am

Quote gerry theagle at 28 Apr 2014 11.29am

At the start of the match was it a different version of Glad all Over as the crowd seemed to lose it a bit, if it was please bring back THe Dave Clark 5 original or maybe I need a hearing test??


Nah. Holmesdale started singing 'Pride of South London, South London's Number 1' about 30 seconds before Jedinak led the team out and some carried on singing it as GAO started. So then there wasn't as many people starting off GAO with 'You say that you love me.'

 


COYP

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 28 Apr 14 12.16pm

Quote Rudi Hedman at 28 Apr 2014 10.20am

Quote topcat at 28 Apr 2014 10.13am

People may feel that the atmosphere on Saturday was bad but this is only compared to some of the recent matches where we had everything to play for. The atmosphere on Saturday was probably way better than most Premiership clubs get at home even when they win.

I agree with you about those leaving 5 minutes early, now I know how Brighton feel with 15 minutes to go.


No wonder you thought the atmosphere was bad if you were there on Saturday with just Sainsbury's shoppers and trolley wheel noise. If Prem grounds are as quiet as that we might as well just have every game on tv and scrap crowds altogether.


I did actually see someone wearing a Palace shirt on Saturday and had a mini panic thinking I had got the wrong day for the match.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Christhegolfer Flag Ashford 28 Apr 14 12.34pm

I don't get anyone moaning about the singing. The fans this season have been part of the reason the club has stayed up, I saw my first game in 1965 and the noise now is the loudest and most continuous ever - lets applaud those fans!

The game was quite odd though, it was the first game that the result was largely unimportant and the early goal didn't help. The fans, me included, did sit back a little and just watched a football masterclass.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 28 Apr 14 12.41pm

The noise is great but thats all it is is noise. The HF are great at starting things off but only if you want to join them. The lads at the back of the B block started several songs yesterday that were ignored and sung over by the guys at the front A) because they werent started by the HF and B) Because they cant drum to along to it.

It does seem that all they want to sing about is scum this, scum that, hate this, hate that. THAT is the reason the families dont join in, the older generation dont join in etc. not boredom etc. yesterday could have been a top celebratory atmosphere for nothing other than the team is safe, yet they still feel the need to sing about Brighton etc. Can't we sing about OUR club instead of everyone elses??

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Dixie Eagle Flag Chatham 28 Apr 14 1.13pm

Quote gerry theagle at 28 Apr 2014 11.29am

At the start of the match was it a different version of Glad all Over as the crowd seemed to lose it a bit, if it was please bring back THe Dave Clark 5 original or maybe I need a hearing test??

I think the DJ bloke must've leant on the crossfader by mistaken as GAO morphed into some banging dance tune after two lines.


 

highbury eagle Flag Islington 28 Apr 14 1.15pm

It was all because of the new drum.

 


Life is the same as it always will be,
Easy as picking foxes from a tree.
M Bolan

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > best atmosphere