You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pulis or Brendan Rodgers? manager of the year..
November 16 2026 12.07pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pulis or Brendan Rodgers? manager of the year..


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Plane Flag Bromley 01 May 14 10.37am

Quote paperhat at 01 May 2014 10.22am

Could one argue that Poyet (if he keeps them up) has done as good a job with Sunderland as Tone has with us?


NO. Because he's ex-Brigh20n scum.

Seriously, he's a good manager but the rise he's had at S'land isn't as meteoric as Tone's.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 May 14 10.45am

Quote Plane at 01 May 2014 10.37am


Seriously, he's a good manager but the rise he's had at S'land isn't as meteoric as Tone's.

Lets compare the respective records :

When Poyet took charge, Sunderland were bottom of the table with 1 point after 8 games.
During his 28 games in charge they have accrued 31 pts and are now 4th from bottom.Not done badly at all !!!!

When Pulis took charge of his first game at Norwich, We were 2nd from bottom with 7 pts after 12 games.
During his 24 games in charge, we have accrued 36 pts and are now we are now 10th from bottom.Well done Sir Anthony !


 

billtheglazier Flag twickenham 04 May 14 9.06pm

Just seen TP's interview with Jeff Shrieve of Sky..He came across as a modest, humble,intelligent man who shares his success as manager with the team and gives the cautious impression he may well be with us for some time.I have changed my view from when he first took over and hope he will stay for at least a few seasons.I cannot think of a better option.Can you?

 


[Link]
Following The Palace since 1956,
Rocking the Blues since 68.!!

billtheglazier Flag twickenham 05 May 14 11.04pm

Surely POINT Proven eh?

 


[Link]
Following The Palace since 1956,
Rocking the Blues since 68.!!

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 05 May 14 11.13pm

Quote Plane at 01 May 2014 9.45am

Quote Seth at 30 Apr 2014 4.03pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Apr 2014 3.36pm

Tony Pulis - Because Rodgers did it with a squad he's built over a few transfer windows, that was a decent competing team. Suarez cost Liverpool 22.5m plus a fortune in wages and an established world class player.

Pulis did it with a team that was bottom, comprised of players who no other premiership team were interested in, and over months rather than years. Jason Puncheon, top goal scorer, was on loan from Southampton and largely regarded as a failure.

Rodgers has done well, but the impact of the manager was only to turn a good team, that had been poorly managed by his predessors, into a really good one with a few very good additions (into a squad that featured noted internationals).

Pulis deserves it because he took a s**t team, with aboslutely no hope of staying up, and is currently sitting pretty at 11th in the table, with 44 points.

Had they had the same resources and capacity to attract players. All Rodgers has done is get Liverpool to compete at the level they should be competing at, and had been competing at. He's done well, but if done as well as Pulis has with Palace, then he'd already have lifted the Premier League.

Pulis achievement at Palace won't win, but all Liverpool have really achieved is to return to where they were five or six years or so ago. But they're 'footballing royalty' and every c**t will bang on about how they're great again - but they never should have gotten so s**t in the first place.

Where as Palace, who the f**k are Palace!


I fully concur with your post jamie, but in the interests of pedantry I am obliged to point out that we're currently on 43 points not 44

Sorry to be a pedant but you don't fully concur with his post!!

Psychic post, as we're on 44 points and proven who is really the manager of the season. Its the one who's team can defend and score goals, never give up and have the best fans.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 05 May 14 11.25pm

Pulis easy now.

Brendan Rodgers , naïve against Chelsea , and against us 3-0 up and did not shut up shop . Thought they were good enough to match City's goal difference.

Brendan , You know nothing .

 

Palace_denizen Flag filed under " time wasters " 05 May 14 11.33pm

the only question now is "what colour shoes Pulis wears to the Manager of the Season Award ?" I reckon, red cos he received such a nice present from Brendan Rogers.

 


Laughing at Charlton - Every London Clyub's fourth or fifth most hated team -
[Link]

Dan Theolmesdaleroad Flag Up north 05 May 14 11.46pm

Respect to Brendan Rodgers for all he's done this season, he's a fine manager and a good man, but to give him the MOTY award ahead of Tony Pulis after tonight's events would seem absolutely farcical.

 

reginald_maudling Flag 06 May 14 12.21am

too many ex-Liverpool tv pundits have been talking up Rodgers for MOTY when it just has to be Pulis -

I would still say this even if they had won the league as they have only improved a few places

another example of the media hype around the richest 5 or 6 clubs

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pulis or Brendan Rodgers? manager of the year..