You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Punch better than Wilf
November 16 2026 11.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Punch better than Wilf


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
EagleRider Flag Seasalter, Kent 02 May 14 11.34am

Bolasie's a guy who could shift up front if needed, like Michu did for Swansea last year.

It's all theoretical and moot anyway isn't it? I don't imagine ManU's new manager selling back a guy just because Moyes didn't find him useful before getting the sack.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 02 May 14 11.39am

Quote EagleRider at 02 May 2014 11.34am

Bolasie's a guy who could shift up front if needed, like Michu did for Swansea last year.

It's all theoretical and moot anyway isn't it? I don't imagine ManU's new manager selling back a guy just because Moyes didn't find him useful before getting the sack.


Thankyou,some common sense at last. There's more chance of Wright and Bright re-signing for us for next season.

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


silvertop Flag Portishead 02 May 14 11.44am

Give Wilf to Pulis for a full pre-season. IF he adapts to and thrives under the new regime he will be a force of nature. All the positives you see in Punch will be expressed with interest through Wilf.

Unfortunately, I can't see Man U wanting to sell; us being able to afford the buy-back cost; or Wilf wanting to come back.

 

manosdedios Flag 02 May 14 11.45am

What an absolutely ridiculous thread! 2 completely different players. I don't even know where to begin...Puncheon doesn't go missing!? F*** me I don't think I even realised we had a player called Puncheon until he put that penalty out the ground at White Hart Lane.

He has scored important goals of late, but let's not get carried away here. Wilf is in a completely different league.

 

madcap_v2 Flag SE25 / Ibiza 02 May 14 1.55pm

Quote miles18 at 02 May 2014 8.41am

Punch can do it in the Prem and Wilf can't yet. Punch at the moment is a better player.

agreed.

 


La la la your mum

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 02 May 14 2.07pm

FFS can we stop mentioning Wilf. Punch is proven in the top tier Wilf isn't therefore Wilf is not as good as Punch. Wilf to me is looking more and more like Scott Sinclair, exceptional talent but will gladly piss it away at the expense of the woman, money and flash motors unless Wilf pulls his finger out he will just be a journeyman winger. I will not make excuses for him just because he came from our academy and I am losing respect for Wilf more and more. People like Clyne and Moses are what I would call good footballers. Wilf just looks like a talented footballer with no interest of becoming a good footballer.

 

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 02 May 14 2.12pm

Quote manosdedios at 02 May 2014 11.45am

What an absolutely ridiculous thread! 2 completely different players. I don't even know where to begin...Puncheon doesn't go missing!? F*** me I don't think I even realised we had a player called Puncheon until he put that penalty out the ground at White Hart Lane.

He has scored important goals of late, but let's not get carried away here. Wilf is in a completely different league.


Yeah the league below Punch. You say that about Punch when he first started but ask any UTD or Cardiff fan Wilf is yet to turn up. f*** me Wilf was s*** for a while last year to. At least Puncheon has turned up and his goals have kept us up. Wilf is keeping f*** all up but his bank balance.

 

geoff Flag Midhurst 02 May 14 2.23pm

Wilf is a Man Ure player. I remember what he did for us and the potential he has. He is Man Ure's to worry about now as to how good or bad he is.
Puncheon is ours now and he has his faults agreed but we are a good side with him in it.
Two different players, only 1 plays for palace and that's all I'm interested in. Thanks Wilf, loved what you did for us but couldn't really give a rats arse as to what he does now.

 

Username Flag Horsham 02 May 14 3.24pm

Quote EagleRider at 02 May 2014 11.34am

Bolasie's a guy who could shift up front if needed, like Michu did for Swansea last year.


How on earth did you come to that conclusion?

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

paperhat Flag croydon 02 May 14 3.27pm

Quote EagleRider at 02 May 2014 11.34am

Bolasie's a guy who could shift up front if needed, like Michu did for Swansea last year.

It's all theoretical and moot anyway isn't it? I don't imagine ManU's new manager selling back a guy just because Moyes didn't find him useful before getting the sack.


I love him and his effort to bits but the only player we have who has less chance of scoring than Cameron Jerome and you'd be happy with him up front???

Edited by paperhat (02 May 2014 3.33pm)

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Midlands Eagle Flag 02 May 14 5.03pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 02 May 2014 2.12pm

At least Puncheon has turned up and his goals have kept us up. Wilf is keeping f*** all up but his bank balance.

According to David Moyes's daughter Wilf can also keep something else up too


 

EagleRider Flag Seasalter, Kent 02 May 14 5.20pm

Quote paperhat at 02 May 2014 3.27pm

Quote EagleRider at 02 May 2014 11.34am

Bolasie's a guy who could shift up front if needed, like Michu did for Swansea last year.

It's all theoretical and moot anyway isn't it? I don't imagine ManU's new manager selling back a guy just because Moyes didn't find him useful before getting the sack.


I love him and his effort to bits but the only player we have who has less chance of scoring than Cameron Jerome and you'd be happy with him up front???Edited by paperhat (02 May 2014 3.33pm)

Again...this is all theoretical, but if we had 5 indespensible midfielders, and considering the poor goal turnout up front all season anyway and yet our current place in the league, yes.

 

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 02 May 14 5.22pm

At the present time I think Punch is definitely better because Wilf is having a rough time at Utd and then being discarded to the dregs of British football at Cardiff. His confidence is shot!. There is no doubt Punch has a lot to offer but at this stage I would not write Wilf off because if he could get a decent club where somebody would encourage and direct him I think he could make a come back because he has the potential.I don't know whether Pulis would have the interest in nursing Wilf back to form but if somebody had the time and patience it could pay off.

 

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 02 May 14 6.01pm

Quote Ian J at 02 May 2014 5.03pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 02 May 2014 2.12pm

At least Puncheon has turned up and his goals have kept us up. Wilf is keeping f*** all up but his bank balance.

According to David Moyes's daughter Wilf can also keep something else up too



Until David found out and Wilf lost all confidence

 

wainesworld Flag west wickham 02 May 14 6.22pm

I don't think you can compare them at the moment. What you could compare is how good was/is each player whilst they played, or are playing for Palace.

If this is compared Wilf is miles better, some say he went missing at times but where was Jason for the majority of this season it's really only the last 12 games he's done very well.

Wilf plus Murray equalled promotion. If he was not with us last season we would not be in the prem. IMO

Edited by wainesworld (02 May 2014 6.23pm)

 

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 02 May 14 7.02pm

Quote wainesworld at 02 May 2014 6.22pm

I don't think you can compare them at the moment. What you could compare is how good was/is each player whilst they played, or are playing for Palace.

If this is compared Wilf is miles better, some say he went missing at times but where was Jason for the majority of this season it's really only the last 12 games he's done very well.

Wilf plus Murray equalled promotion. If he was not with us last season we would not be in the prem. IMO

Edited by wainesworld (02 May 2014 6.23pm)


Wilf at Palace=Championship ripping teams up like Barnsley and Bristol City.

Puncheon at Palace=Premier League ripping teams up like Everton and Chelsea.

 

Mstrobez Flag 02 May 14 7.09pm

The fact this is even up for discussion after some of the stuff Wilf did last season (play offs NOT included) really does show the amount people know about football on here.

And that's from someone who liked Punch from the START. Wilf went down hill as soon as Ollie came in whether people agree or disagree and he has been managed poorly since too. There's a huge reason why Sir Alex bought him for 15mil! He was unbelievable under Dougie last season and season before!

Some people just don't get football! Comparison between Punch and Wilf? Give me a f***ing break

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

xGeorgex Flag Oh South London 02 May 14 7.19pm

Puncheon's skills:
.Scoring Goals
.Composure on the ball

Zaha's skills:
.Pace
.Skills
.Agility
.Tracking back
.Runs
.Dribbling
.Creating somthing out of nothing

For me it is Zaha.

 


E Block - Win, Lose or Draw it’s about having a good day out

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 02 May 14 7.24pm

Quote xGeorgex at 02 May 2014 7.19pm

Puncheon's skills:
.Scoring Goals
.Composure on the ball

Zaha's skills:
.Pace
.Skills
.Agility
.Tracking back
.Runs
.Dribbling
.Creating somthing out of nothing

For me it is Zaha.

All of which he cant do in the premier league.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 02 May 14 7.30pm

Quote Mstrobez at 02 May 2014 7.09pm

The fact this is even up for discussion after some of the stuff Wilf did last season (play offs NOT included) really does show the amount people know about football on here.

And that's from someone who liked Punch from the START. Wilf went down hill as soon as Ollie came in whether people agree or disagree and he has been managed poorly since too. There's a huge reason why Sir Alex bought him for 15mil! He was unbelievable under Dougie last season and season before!

Some people just don't get football! Comparison between Punch and Wilf? Give me a f***ing break

Do you have your own dedicated turnstile at Selhurst as I'm sure that you couldn't manage to squeeze your huge ego through the turnstiles that us ordinary mortals use

 

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Punch better than Wilf