Bangell Oxford 06 May 14 12.56pm |
|
|
Puncheon Dann Mariappa/Jerome
I put those last two over Chamakh because of the effort they put in every time they've played.
|
EagleRider Seasalter, Kent 06 May 14 1.28pm |
|
Quote Hansy at 06 May 2014 12.26pm
You can't put Gayle in there after last night. I judge it over the season.
3. Chamakh 2. Puncheon 1. Pulis
Last night is part of the season though, yeah?
...and on a lighter note, good shout on Pulis. If we're talking all signings and not just players, he should be all of our #1
|
sxp55 South Norwood 06 May 14 1.54pm |
|
|
1)Dann, 2)Ledley,3)Mariappa,
@sxp55555
|
Only one Salako London 06 May 14 1.59pm |
|
|
1) Punch 2) Ledley 3) Dann
"they gave it everything, every ounce of blood, sweat and guts. They battled, they never ducked a challenge and, as their fans ripped their T-shirts off in the stands, creating the kind of heady atmosphere that has turned Selhurst Park into an amphitheatre" Matthew Syed
|
EverybodyDannsNow SE19 06 May 14 2.04pm |
|
Quote Kermit8 at 06 May 2014 12.33pm
Quote Eager eagle at 06 May 2014 12.13pm
Quote Kermit8 at 06 May 2014 9.58am
A reminder - Puncheon, Ledley, Ince, Guediora, Campana, Hennessy, Dann, Mariappa, Gayle, Chamakh, Bannan, Kebe, Jerome, Dobbie, Hunt, Thomas.
I'll work out who comes out on top overall once we've had a fair few votes.
3)Chamakh
2)Dann
*drum roll......*
1)Puncheon
Was it you who said you didn't rate Dann that much,as your mate is a Blackburn fan who said he wasn't all that? Just asking.
He he 
I really thought he knew his football. He's been told.
To be fair, a Blackburn fan I know said the same thing. Described him as a pretty average defender with very limited ability. He's been anything but average since January.
I'd probably go:
Chamakh Puncheon Dann
Ledley, mariappa, jerome and Gayle have all made telling contributions as well. Oh and Grandin.
|
Gameover 06 May 14 2.49pm |
|
|
1) Puncheon
2) Chamakh
3) Dann
4) Ledley
5) Gayle
" AN AMAZING NIGHT AT SELHURST PARK LIVERPOOL HAVE CAVED IN"
|
dannyh wherever I lay my hat....... 06 May 14 2.59pm |
|
|
I was speaking to a liverpool fan I know last night and he admitted that three of our back four were better than theirs I wonder if can guess what three.

"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"
|
EagleRider Seasalter, Kent 06 May 14 3.26pm |
|
|
just curious which of their back four was he considering better than any of ours?
Edited by EagleRider (06 May 2014 3.26pm)
|
wainesworld west wickham 06 May 14 3.30pm |
|
|
1, Anthony
2, Richard
3, Pullis
The mans a marvel.
|
Bexley Eagle Bexley Kent 06 May 14 3.33pm |
|
|
Surely you are better off differentiating those that you would like to keep and those that should go. I would keep:
Puncheon, Ledley, Ince, Guediora, Hennessy, Dann, Mariappa, Gayle, Chamakh, Bannan, Jerome, Hunt.
So actually 12 of those signed I would retain. Not a bad return. However if Pulis believe he can improve I would be happy to stick with his judgement in trading up. Time still on the side of Gayle, Bannan and Hunt.
|
Qwijibo Bournemouth 06 May 14 3.33pm |
|
Quote EagleRider at 06 May 2014 1.28pm
Quote Hansy at 06 May 2014 12.26pm
You can't put Gayle in there after last night. I judge it over the season.
3. Chamakh 2. Puncheon 1. Pulis
Last night is part of the season though, yeah?
...and on a lighter note, good shout on Pulis. If we're talking all signings and not just players, he should be all of our #1
If Speroni signs a new deal does he count as a signing?
|
Happiness Stan Itchycoo Park 06 May 14 3.40pm |
|
|
Without Puncheons goals, how many points would we have dropped?
Has to JP. Match winner.
"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"
|
topcat Holmesdale / Surbiton 06 May 14 4.18pm |
|
|
1. Ledley 2. Puncheon 3. Dann
It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.
|
girvinator Poole 06 May 14 4.26pm |
|
|
1) Puncheon 2) Gayle 3) Chamakh
Those three contributed 17 of our 31 league goals.
|
DBCPFC 06 May 14 4.39pm |
|
|
1) Puncheon. Was decent as a loanee, then amazing as a full time player.
2) Gayle. Last night and Villa, definitely one for now and the future.
3) Hennessey. Look at what he's don't to Julian, he may not have played a minute...but look at how he affected him.
|
EagleinSF San Fransisco 06 May 14 4.51pm |
|
|
It's tough, there have been more than a few successes (as well as some abject failures!) I'll go with
1. Chamakh - Tireless and has a great touch 2. Puncheon - I didn't rate him but his goals and effort have been spectacular for the last quarter if the seasin 3. Dann - Solid, and one of the reasons we have such a tight defense.
|
TomThePalaceFanatic 06 May 14 7.37pm |
|
|
1. Dann 2. Chamakh 3. Puncheon
|