You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Dave Whelan
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dave Whelan


Page 2 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Hoof Hearted 21 Nov 14 11.20am

We all hate Semantics.... quibbling over petty stuff!

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 21 Nov 14 11.25am

The only thing worse than what Whelan mayhave said (I believe it's still open to debate) is the holier than thou attitude of people jumping on any old bandwagon that's passing.

What is acceptable and what isn't has changed over the years, e.g. Only Fools and the **** shop.

When I first moved to London in 85 I said to a new friend that I was going to the **** shop, he was Anglo Indian and asked me not to use that term. I apologised and never did again. If he hadn't had said anything I would have carried on as i didn't see anything derogative at all with the term.

What about the amount of people who are happy to call Welsh sheepshaggers or Scottish tight fisted etc yet no one bats an eye?

Whelan has undoubtedly dropped a bollock, but for me the actions of the man speak far louder than a clumsy ill thought out interview.

I do wish that people would look beyond words used and try to listen to the sentiment (Given he is defending Malky perhaps not the ideal scenario to back my view)

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Hoof Hearted 21 Nov 14 11.41am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 21 Nov 2014 11.25am

The only thing worse than what Whelan mayhave said (I believe it's still open to debate) is the holier than thou attitude of people jumping on any old bandwagon that's passing.

What is acceptable and what isn't has changed over the years, e.g. Only Fools and the **** shop.

When I first moved to London in 85 I said to a new friend that I was going to the **** shop, he was Anglo Indian and asked me not to use that term. I apologised and never did again. If he hadn't had said anything I would have carried on as i didn't see anything derogative at all with the term.

What about the amount of people who are happy to call Welsh sheepshaggers or Scottish tight fisted etc yet no one bats an eye?

Whelan has undoubtedly dropped a bollock, but for me the actions of the man speak far louder than a clumsy ill thought out interview.

I do wish that people would look beyond words used and try to listen to the sentiment (Given he is defending Malky perhaps not the ideal scenario to back my view)


You've now offended me with that term!

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Nov 14 1.05pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 21 Nov 2014 11.25am

Whelan has undoubtedly dropped a bollock, but for me the actions of the man speak far louder than a clumsy ill thought out interview.

I do wish that people would look beyond words used and try to listen to the sentiment


Those with longer memories might recall that our very own Ron Noades was accused of being a racist after some comments he made were dissected by the chattering classes and this was despite the fact that Ian Wright lived in his house for a while when he first signed for us

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 21 Nov 14 1.44pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Nov 2014 11.41am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 21 Nov 2014 11.25am

The only thing worse than what Whelan mayhave said (I believe it's still open to debate) is the holier than thou attitude of people jumping on any old bandwagon that's passing.

What is acceptable and what isn't has changed over the years, e.g. Only Fools and the **** shop.

When I first moved to London in 85 I said to a new friend that I was going to the **** shop, he was Anglo Indian and asked me not to use that term. I apologised and never did again. If he hadn't had said anything I would have carried on as i didn't see anything derogative at all with the term.

What about the amount of people who are happy to call Welsh sheepshaggers or Scottish tight fisted etc yet no one bats an eye?

Whelan has undoubtedly dropped a bollock, but for me the actions of the man speak far louder than a clumsy ill thought out interview.

I do wish that people would look beyond words used and try to listen to the sentiment (Given he is defending Malky perhaps not the ideal scenario to back my view)


You've now offended me with that term!


 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 21 Nov 14 1.52pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Nov 2014 1.05pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 21 Nov 2014 11.25am

Whelan has undoubtedly dropped a bollock, but for me the actions of the man speak far louder than a clumsy ill thought out interview.

I do wish that people would look beyond words used and try to listen to the sentiment


Those with longer memories might recall that our very own Ron Noades was accused of being a racist after some comments he made were dissected by the chattering classes and this was despite the fact that Ian Wright lived in his house for a while when he first signed for us

Ron Noades said:

Quote
"The black players at this club lend the side a lot of skill and flair, but you also need white players in there to balance things up and give the team some brains and some common sense."

Ron Noades wasn't a racist but that is a racist remark. Similarly Dave Whelan is not a racist, but at the very least he has publically supported racist remarks.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 21 Nov 14 2.20pm

I'm always amused by people who get offended on others behalf.

From my experience the Chinese are the most racist lot going, closely followed by the Japanese.

To a degree what he says is true, I bet the vast majority of people here have used the word chink, paddy, kraut or **** etc. down the pub or at home with their mates. I personally wouldn't take ant offense to being called a cracker or a honkey especially if there is no malice intended in it.

Was it inappropriate? Probably, but thats not to say he set out to be offensive which is totally different.

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Nov 14 2.23pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Nov 2014 1.52pm

Dave Whelan is not a racist, but at the very least he has publically supported racist remarks.

No he hasn't. He has employed someone that has admitted sending some inappropriate texts which is completely different to supporting someone


 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Nov 14 2.31pm

Quote Pawson Palace at 21 Nov 2014 2.20pm

I'm always amused by people who get offended on others behalf.

From my experience the Chinese are the most racist lot going, closely followed by the Japanese.

I used to have a Chinese secretary who lived in fear that her father would find out that she was seeing an English lad

The worst example of racism (if you use the term in it's broadest sense to include religion) that I have come across recently was in the summer when England were playing cricket against India and Moeen Ali (British born pakistani) came out to bat for us and all of the (British born) Indians in the crowd started booing.

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 21 Nov 14 2.33pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Nov 2014 2.23pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Nov 2014 1.52pm

Dave Whelan is not a racist, but at the very least he has publically supported racist remarks.

No he hasn't. He has employed someone that has admitted sending some inappropriate texts which is completely different to supporting someone


Yes he has.
[Link]

He has employed someone who has admitted sending inapproriate texts, of which the content of some are undeniably racist.

Quote
Whelan said he saw neither as offensive, nor did he consider offensive the other text for which he said Mackay was responsible, which referred to there being “enough dogs in Cardiff for us all to go round”, when Mackay signed the South Korea international Kim Bo-kyung
...
Asked whether he did not think what Mackay said was offensive, because the claim Jews “love money” has been used as a negative stereotype, Whelan said: “Do you think Jewish people chase money a little bit more than we do? I think they are very shrewd people.”

Asked if he himself believed that, Whelan, the 77-year-old multimillionaire and former owner of JJB Sports, said: “I think Jewish people do chase money more than everybody else. I don’t think that’s offensive at all.”

Whelan said he did not think there was “a lot wrong” with anything Mackay said, and there was no malice or disrespect in the statement about Smith. He added: “It’s telling the truth. Jewish people love money, English people love money; we all love money.” His remarks were condemned by Simon Johnson, a former FA and Premier League executive who is Jewish and is the chief executive at the Jewish Leadership Council.
...
“Mackay used offensive language to insult a fellow participant in football using a tawdry racial stereotype.” Whelan said “we’re all against racism in football,” and that it was right that Mackay has attended diversity education courses since his acrimonious exit from Cardiff.

However, he said the word chink is not offensive, and that he used to say it of Chinese people when he was young. “If any Englishman said he has never called a Chinaman a chink he is lying,” Whelan said. “There is nothing bad about doing that. It is like calling the British Brits, or the Irish paddies.” Wong, director of the Manchester Chinese Centre an organisation devoted to Chinese community cultural understanding, said chink “is an insult, racist”.

He has actively supported the comments on the basis that they were not offensive.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 21 Nov 14 2.39pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Nov 2014 2.31pm

Quote Pawson Palace at 21 Nov 2014 2.20pm

I'm always amused by people who get offended on others behalf.

From my experience the Chinese are the most racist lot going, closely followed by the Japanese.

I used to have a Chinese secretary who lived in fear that her father would find out that she was seeing an English lad

The worst example of racism (if you use the term in it's broadest sense to include religion) that I have come across recently was in the summer when England were playing cricket against India and Moeen Ali (British born pakistani) came out to bat for us and all of the (British born) Indians in the crowd started booing.


I didn't think the Chinese were so against the whites and deemed the lesser of the "foreign devils" which is one of my favourite labels I've ever been called haha.

For me the worst was watching Valencia play Real Betis years back and Patrick Klivert came on on Valencia and the crowd made really bad monkey noises. Now I can "understand" abusing an opposition player but your own? Bet they would have been cheering if he scored the winner. As it happened Pablo Aimar got the goal in a s***e game lol.

Hand on heart, I've never heard one piece of racist chanting at football in the UK. I do believe we are one, if not the most tolerant countries in Europe.

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 21 Nov 14 2.48pm

I'm offended by all this faux offence.

So anyone who criticises or comments on the behaviour of a Jew is anti Semitic ? How convenient.

 

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 21 Nov 14 2.51pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 21 Nov 2014 2.48pm

I'm offended by all this faux offence.

So anyone who criticises or comments on the behaviour of a Jew is anti Semitic ? How convenient.

I find it funny chap.

It ok though because the Spurs fans can all them yids without any recourse!

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

buzby1 Flag Devon 21 Nov 14 3.02pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 21 Nov 2014 2.48pm

I'm offended by all this faux offence.

So anyone who criticises or comments on the behaviour of a Jew is anti Semitic ? How convenient.

If what was reported is accurate Whelan was not commenting on the behaviour of a Jew but of all Jews. It's not faux offence or fake offence that myself and others feel, it's genuine offence at nasty racial stereotyping. I'm amazed how deeply ingrained anti-semitism is in some people. I'd have hoped we'd have learnt something from the past.

 

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 21 Nov 14 3.13pm

Quote buzby1 at 21 Nov 2014 3.02pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 21 Nov 2014 2.48pm

I'm offended by all this faux offence.

So anyone who criticises or comments on the behaviour of a Jew is anti Semitic ? How convenient.

If what was reported is accurate Whelan was not commenting on the behaviour of a Jew but of all Jews. It's not faux offence or fake offence that myself and others feel, it's genuine offence at nasty racial stereotyping. I'm amazed how deeply ingrained anti-semitism is in some people. I'd have hoped we'd have learnt something from the past.

I must admit I find it highly offensive when I am told that as a white person I have no rhythm, I cant dance and I can't jump....

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 21 Nov 14 3.19pm

Quote Pawson Palace at 21 Nov 2014 2.20pm

I'm always amused by people who get offended on others behalf.


I've seen this sentiment a few times on here and want to pick up on it.

If a white person is with a black friend and the black friend gets called a "n****r" by someone and the white person doesn't like it, is he being "offended on someone else's behalf"?

Were white people who campaigned against slavery being "offended on someone else's behalf"?

Was Oskar Schindler "offended on someone else's behalf"?

Was Nicholas Winton "offended on someone else's behalf"?

Were any non-Jews who fought against the Nazis "offended on someone else's behalf"?

If I object to my daughter being cat-called and leered at in the street am I "offended on someone else's behalf"?

My friend has a son who is gay. He was once beaten up in a club for his sexuality. I was angry at that. Am I "offended on someone else's behalf"?

If I campaign against animal cruelty am I "offended on someone else's behalf"?

If you donate to a charity which helps starving children, are you "offended on someone else's behalf"?

It seems that, according to the "offended on someone else's behalf" brigade, it's not right for anyone to empathise with or support someone who is suffering discrimination or violence. By this logic only Jews can protest at anti-semitism, only black people can fight racism and only gay people can campaign against homophobia. This is clearly a ridiculous position.

As for Whelan and Mackay, they are welcome to each other. I feel sorry for the ordinary Wigan fans who must be cringing at the thought of their club being associated with these kind of outdated and racist attitudes.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Stuk Flag Top half 21 Nov 14 3.19pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Nov 2014 2.31pm

Quote Pawson Palace at 21 Nov 2014 2.20pm

I'm always amused by people who get offended on others behalf.

From my experience the Chinese are the most racist lot going, closely followed by the Japanese.

I used to have a Chinese secretary who lived in fear that her father would find out that she was seeing an English lad

The worst example of racism (if you use the term in it's broadest sense to include religion) that I have come across recently was in the summer when England were playing cricket against India and Moeen Ali (British born pakistani) came out to bat for us and all of the (British born) Indians in the crowd started booing.

That's not racism, it's national rivalry. The (british born, or not) Indians were supporting India, not England and certainly not an Englishman with pakistani heritage.

A the Scotland v Ireland game last week, the Scots booed a Scottish born player representing Ireland instead.

Or England v Ghana, when Welbeck made his debut, for just general dislike of what feels like someone turning their back on the country and/or heritage.

Edited by Stuk (21 Nov 2014 3.25pm)

 


Optimistic as ever

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 21 Nov 14 3.38pm

Quote Seth at 21 Nov 2014 3.19pm

Quote Pawson Palace at 21 Nov 2014 2.20pm

I'm always amused by people who get offended on others behalf.


I've seen this sentiment a few times on here and want to pick up on it.

If a white person is with a black friend and the black friend gets called a "n****r" by someone and the white person doesn't like it, is he being "offended on someone else's behalf"?

Were white people who campaigned against slavery being "offended on someone else's behalf"?

Was Oskar Schindler "offended on someone else's behalf"?

Was Nicholas Winton "offended on someone else's behalf"?

Were any non-Jews who fought against the Nazis "offended on someone else's behalf"?

If I object to my daughter being cat-called and leered at in the street am I "offended on someone else's behalf"?

My friend has a son who is gay. He was once beaten up in a club for his sexuality. I was angry at that. Am I "offended on someone else's behalf"?

If I campaign against animal cruelty am I "offended on someone else's behalf"?

If you donate to a charity which helps starving children, are you "offended on someone else's behalf"?

It seems that, according to the "offended on someone else's behalf" brigade, it's not right for anyone to empathise with or support someone who is suffering discrimination or violence. By this logic only Jews can protest at anti-semitism, only black people can fight racism and only gay people can campaign against homophobia. This is clearly a ridiculous position.

As for Whelan and Mackay, they are welcome to each other. I feel sorry for the ordinary Wigan fans who must be cringing at the thought of their club being associated with these kind of outdated and racist attitudes.


IMO the difference in all those scenarios is where malice is directly aimed at someone. Don't get me wrong, I'd be the first to jump into anyone of those situations to defend my friends and so forth.

Whelan saying chink in a generic context- where it's not specifically aimed at anyone person- and I think that is different. Had he said Ken Hom is a chink then that would be offensive.

Again, as above I've been told as a white guy I have no rhythm...are you going to accuse my black team mates and black coach as being racist?

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Nov 14 3.52pm

Quote Pawson Palace at 21 Nov 2014 2.39pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Nov 2014 2.31pm

Quote Pawson Palace at 21 Nov 2014 2.20pm

I'm always amused by people who get offended on others behalf.

From my experience the Chinese are the most racist lot going, closely followed by the Japanese.

I used to have a Chinese secretary who lived in fear that her father would find out that she was seeing an English lad

The worst example of racism (if you use the term in it's broadest sense to include religion) that I have come across recently was in the summer when England were playing cricket against India and Moeen Ali (British born pakistani) came out to bat for us and all of the (British born) Indians in the crowd started booing.


I didn't think the Chinese were so against the whites and deemed the lesser of the "foreign devils" which is one of my favourite labels I've ever been called haha.

For me the worst was watching Valencia play Real Betis years back and Patrick Klivert came on on Valencia and the crowd made really bad monkey noises. Now I can "understand" abusing an opposition player but your own? Bet they would have been cheering if he scored the winner. As it happened Pablo Aimar got the goal in a s***e game lol.

Hand on heart, I've never heard one piece of racist chanting at football in the UK. I do believe we are one, if not the most tolerant countries in Europe.


Spanish football supporters aren't very bright then and don't know their own history as a huge percentage of the Spanish population are descended from the Moors that invaded the country a few centuries ago

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 21 Nov 14 3.56pm

Quote Pawson Palace at 21 Nov 2014 3.38pm

Quote Seth at 21 Nov 2014 3.19pm

Quote Pawson Palace at 21 Nov 2014 2.20pm

I'm always amused by people who get offended on others behalf.


I've seen this sentiment a few times on here and want to pick up on it.

If a white person is with a black friend and the black friend gets called a "n****r" by someone and the white person doesn't like it, is he being "offended on someone else's behalf"?

Were white people who campaigned against slavery being "offended on someone else's behalf"?

Was Oskar Schindler "offended on someone else's behalf"?

Was Nicholas Winton "offended on someone else's behalf"?

Were any non-Jews who fought against the Nazis "offended on someone else's behalf"?

If I object to my daughter being cat-called and leered at in the street am I "offended on someone else's behalf"?

My friend has a son who is gay. He was once beaten up in a club for his sexuality. I was angry at that. Am I "offended on someone else's behalf"?

If I campaign against animal cruelty am I "offended on someone else's behalf"?

If you donate to a charity which helps starving children, are you "offended on someone else's behalf"?

It seems that, according to the "offended on someone else's behalf" brigade, it's not right for anyone to empathise with or support someone who is suffering discrimination or violence. By this logic only Jews can protest at anti-semitism, only black people can fight racism and only gay people can campaign against homophobia. This is clearly a ridiculous position.

As for Whelan and Mackay, they are welcome to each other. I feel sorry for the ordinary Wigan fans who must be cringing at the thought of their club being associated with these kind of outdated and racist attitudes.


IMO the difference in all those scenarios is where malice is directly aimed at someone. Don't get me wrong, I'd be the first to jump into anyone of those situations to defend my friends and so forth.

Whelan saying chink in a generic context- where it's not specifically aimed at anyone person- and I think that is different. Had he said Ken Hom is a chink then that would be offensive.

Again, as above I've been told as a white guy I have no rhythm...are you going to accuse my black team mates and black coach as being racist?


So by this reasoning would it would be ok for me to make a general remark about a group of people which is prejudiced, such as "black people are thieves" or "Jews are stingy", as long as it's not aimed at a particular individual? I can't agree with that. It's clearly still racist.

As for your last point, a couple of things come to mind: one definition of racism is "prejudice + power". Historically white people have had power over black people and have used that power to create a society based on discrimination. Some people therefore say that black people, being in a position of little power, cannot be racist. I don't agree with that in entirety, but do agree that anti-black racism from whites carries more weight in a historic and societal context than the other way round.

I would also ask: were you offended by it? If so, maybe you should take it up with your coach. If it's just banter and you genuinely don't mind, then I'd advise you to ignore it and get on with your life. But it's to do with how you experience it rather than whether it fits into your definition of racist or not. Much like the police count crimes as "hate crimes" depending on how the victim experienced it.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Page 2 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Dave Whelan