You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Leader's debates
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Leader's debates


Page 2 of 13 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 03 Feb 15 11.01am

Quote nickgusset at 22 Jan 2015 6.33pm

Quote The White Horse at 22 Jan 2015 6.26pm

If they were going to take the piss with the new proposals, why not get George Galloway involved? Opportunity missed.


Much as I think he can be a bit of a pillock at times, Galloway would wipe the floor with them all.


Angrily spouting populist bullsh*t is not winning a debate.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Feb 15 11.46am

Quote npn at 02 Feb 2015 4.15pm

Quote Bert the Head at 31 Jan 2015 12.30am

Quote Stuk at 22 Jan 2015 4.40pm

I can't remember where all the rest was posted so started a new thread.

The BBC and ITV have now gone OTT and invited the Greens and the regional nutters too.

[Link]

7 people on stage will be a pointless exercise.

Well if the Greens weren't invited Dave was going to take his oval Rugga shaped ball away

...basically because the Tories have the BBC (which is actually right of centre and not left wing) the Sun, The Daily Mail, the Telegraph and the Daily Express, the Tories worry that a real live shot of posh boy will be hammered by Ed Miliband who while admittedly a geek can actually debate very well. The Tory papers can't control that so they don't want it to happen.

The Greens always present themselves well too when out of the Tory Paper information monopoly too - so Bring it on.


Do you really think so?
I'm keen on the environmental policies of the Greens, and almost looking for an excuse to vote for them, but most of their people come across as just as clueless as most UKIP representatives.

This isn't necessarily a bad thing though, we presume that there is a relationship between oratory, debate and sophistry and being a good politician, but its actually bollocks. Politicians have gotten away with this since Socrates; the idea that sounding and looking capable are the same as being capable.

Being right, is better than winning. Its easy to win an argument, its much harder to be right.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Feb 15 11.50am

Quote We are goin up! at 03 Feb 2015 11.01am

Quote nickgusset at 22 Jan 2015 6.33pm

Quote The White Horse at 22 Jan 2015 6.26pm

If they were going to take the piss with the new proposals, why not get George Galloway involved? Opportunity missed.


Much as I think he can be a bit of a pillock at times, Galloway would wipe the floor with them all.


Angrily spouting populist bullsh*t is not winning a debate.

Actually that's exactly what debates in politics really are, winning buy echoing popularist nonsense and appealing to camera and crowd. Its as old as philosophy, the gulf between sophistry, oratory and philosophy.

Politics isn't about being right, its about being popular and 'giving the people' what they want, or selling them the idea. It doesn't generally involve being right, or accountable for being right.

Indeed, politics isn't about being right, its about sounding right.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Hoof Hearted 03 Feb 15 11.51am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Feb 2015 11.50am

Quote We are goin up! at 03 Feb 2015 11.01am

Quote nickgusset at 22 Jan 2015 6.33pm

Quote The White Horse at 22 Jan 2015 6.26pm

If they were going to take the piss with the new proposals, why not get George Galloway involved? Opportunity missed.


Much as I think he can be a bit of a pillock at times, Galloway would wipe the floor with them all.


Angrily spouting populist bullsh*t is not winning a debate.

Actually that's exactly what debates in politics really are, winning buy echoing popularist nonsense and appealing to camera and crowd. Its as old as philosophy, the gulf between sophistry, oratory and philosophy.

Politics isn't about being right, its about being popular and 'giving the people' what they want, or selling them the idea. It doesn't generally involve being right, or accountable for being right.

Indeed, politics isn't about being right, its about sounding right.


Booooooooooooo..... get off......... you suck Jamie!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Feb 15 12.44pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 03 Feb 2015 11.51am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Feb 2015 11.50am

Quote We are goin up! at 03 Feb 2015 11.01am

Quote nickgusset at 22 Jan 2015 6.33pm

Quote The White Horse at 22 Jan 2015 6.26pm

If they were going to take the piss with the new proposals, why not get George Galloway involved? Opportunity missed.


Much as I think he can be a bit of a pillock at times, Galloway would wipe the floor with them all.


Angrily spouting populist bullsh*t is not winning a debate.

Actually that's exactly what debates in politics really are, winning buy echoing popularist nonsense and appealing to camera and crowd. Its as old as philosophy, the gulf between sophistry, oratory and philosophy.

Politics isn't about being right, its about being popular and 'giving the people' what they want, or selling them the idea. It doesn't generally involve being right, or accountable for being right.

Indeed, politics isn't about being right, its about sounding right.


Booooooooooooo..... get off......... you suck Jamie!

I'll get my hemlock


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 03 Feb 15 4.00pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Feb 2015 11.50am

Quote We are goin up! at 03 Feb 2015 11.01am

Quote nickgusset at 22 Jan 2015 6.33pm

Quote The White Horse at 22 Jan 2015 6.26pm

If they were going to take the piss with the new proposals, why not get George Galloway involved? Opportunity missed.


Much as I think he can be a bit of a pillock at times, Galloway would wipe the floor with them all.


Angrily spouting populist bullsh*t is not winning a debate.

Actually that's exactly what debates in politics really are, winning buy echoing popularist nonsense and appealing to camera and crowd. Its as old as philosophy, the gulf between sophistry, oratory and philosophy.

Politics isn't about being right, its about being popular and 'giving the people' what they want, or selling them the idea. It doesn't generally involve being right, or accountable for being right.

Indeed, politics isn't about being right, its about sounding right.


Crikey, and I thought I was cynical.

If that's the case, why are we still in the EU? Why do we not have the death penalty?

Obviously politicians have to respond to the popular will, but it is also about doing what's right often in the face of being popular.

Imagine a country governed by Twitter and then you'll have something to complain about.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Joe Bloggs Flag Nr Norwich 03 Feb 15 4.13pm

Whatever debate takes place the one certain fact is that it will never rival pmqs, the most unedifying and childish example of children pretending to be adults in the western world.

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 03 Feb 15 4.17pm

Quote Joe Bloggs at 03 Feb 2015 4.13pm

Whatever debate takes place the one certain fact is that it will never rival pmqs, the most unedifying and childish example of children pretending to be adults in the western world.


I quite like PMQs.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Stuk Flag Top half 03 Feb 15 4.19pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 03 Feb 2015 4.17pm

Quote Joe Bloggs at 03 Feb 2015 4.13pm

Whatever debate takes place the one certain fact is that it will never rival pmqs, the most unedifying and childish example of children pretending to be adults in the western world.


I quite like PMQs.

Same here. It's about the only time the standard, wishy washy, PC answers get put to one side.

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Feb 15 4.28pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 03 Feb 2015 4.00pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Feb 2015 11.50am

Quote We are goin up! at 03 Feb 2015 11.01am

Quote nickgusset at 22 Jan 2015 6.33pm

Quote The White Horse at 22 Jan 2015 6.26pm

If they were going to take the piss with the new proposals, why not get George Galloway involved? Opportunity missed.


Much as I think he can be a bit of a pillock at times, Galloway would wipe the floor with them all.


Angrily spouting populist bullsh*t is not winning a debate.

Actually that's exactly what debates in politics really are, winning buy echoing popularist nonsense and appealing to camera and crowd. Its as old as philosophy, the gulf between sophistry, oratory and philosophy.

Politics isn't about being right, its about being popular and 'giving the people' what they want, or selling them the idea. It doesn't generally involve being right, or accountable for being right.

Indeed, politics isn't about being right, its about sounding right.


Crikey, and I thought I was cynical.

If that's the case, why are we still in the EU? Why do we not have the death penalty?

Obviously politicians have to respond to the popular will, but it is also about doing what's right often in the face of being popular.

Imagine a country governed by Twitter and then you'll have something to complain about.

Well the EU employs lots of MPs and MEP's and Quangos and other assorted jollies, that line pockets nicely - Plus I think most MP's are actually scared that leaving the EU would have negative ramifications that they'll be blamed for.

Death Penalty - Because not that many people actually seem to want it, and among those who do, they're more in love with the idea than the reality. That s**t will soon come back to bite you politically - plus there is the s**t storm of trying to get the judiciary onside and how to get around European requirements.

Its a fiasco in the US. It would be just as bad here, except that the nation is far less moralistically behind the idea of killing people who are invariable poor, mentally impared, mentally ill or otherwise questionably competent.

You speak to people who want executions, and they're all about '100% certainity' and 'the worst crimes' - Which is impossible to achieve in reality.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Feb 15 4.32pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 03 Feb 2015 4.17pm

Quote Joe Bloggs at 03 Feb 2015 4.13pm

Whatever debate takes place the one certain fact is that it will never rival pmqs, the most unedifying and childish example of children pretending to be adults in the western world.


I quite like PMQs.

Indeed, it is.

What politics really needs, is 'a neutral party' rather than opposition parties, who's role is objectively pursue knowledge, possibly by the Socratic methods, on bills being introduced, without having to be forced to drink hemlock.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 04 Feb 15 4.28pm

Quote Stuk at 03 Feb 2015 4.19pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 03 Feb 2015 4.17pm

Quote Joe Bloggs at 03 Feb 2015 4.13pm

Whatever debate takes place the one certain fact is that it will never rival pmqs, the most unedifying and childish example of children pretending to be adults in the western world.


I quite like PMQs.

Same here. It's about the only time the standard, wishy washy, PC answers get put to one side.

Quite a good line today.

[Cameron mocking Ed Balls' inability to remember the name of a business leader supporting labour]

"Bill Somebody isn't a person... it's Labour's policy!"

You definitely don't get gags like that in the tedious Bundestag semi-circle.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Stuk Flag Top half 04 Feb 15 4.45pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 04 Feb 2015 4.28pm

Quote Stuk at 03 Feb 2015 4.19pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 03 Feb 2015 4.17pm

Quote Joe Bloggs at 03 Feb 2015 4.13pm

Whatever debate takes place the one certain fact is that it will never rival pmqs, the most unedifying and childish example of children pretending to be adults in the western world.


I quite like PMQs.

Same here. It's about the only time the standard, wishy washy, PC answers get put to one side.

Quite a good line today.

[Cameron mocking Ed Balls' inability to remember the name of a business leader supporting labour]

"Bill Somebody isn't a person... it's Labour's policy!"

You definitely don't get gags like that in the tedious Bundestag semi-circle.


I read that this morning

Funniest part of that was it was Emily Maitless who caught him out. She can barely read autocue.

 


Optimistic as ever

matt_himself Flag Matataland 04 Feb 15 4.54pm

We all know Nige will walk this. Therefore what is the point of holding these?

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Hoof Hearted 05 Feb 15 11.00am

Quote Stuk at 04 Feb 2015 4.45pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 04 Feb 2015 4.28pm

Quote Stuk at 03 Feb 2015 4.19pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 03 Feb 2015 4.17pm

Quote Joe Bloggs at 03 Feb 2015 4.13pm

Whatever debate takes place the one certain fact is that it will never rival pmqs, the most unedifying and childish example of children pretending to be adults in the western world.


I quite like PMQs.

Same here. It's about the only time the standard, wishy washy, PC answers get put to one side.

Quite a good line today.

[Cameron mocking Ed Balls' inability to remember the name of a business leader supporting labour]

"Bill Somebody isn't a person... it's Labour's policy!"

You definitely don't get gags like that in the tedious Bundestag semi-circle.


I read that this morning

Funniest part of that was it was Emily Maitless who caught him out. She can barely read autocue.


[Link]

This is the Newsnight footage....

Balls... if ever a politician was more aptly named!

 

Stuk Flag Top half 19 Feb 15 4.04pm

The DUP want a judicial review as they claim they "will hold the balance of power" at the general election.

[Link]

I'd rather they knocked the whole thing on the head now.

 


Optimistic as ever

Stuk Flag Top half 06 Mar 15 4.24pm

TV companies say they're holding all 3, as planned.

[Link]

A) Will they change format again?

B) Will Cameron do all 3?

C) Will the DUP stamp their feet some more?

D) Will Sinn Fein then decide to do the same

 


Optimistic as ever

imbored Flag UK 06 Mar 15 4.31pm

I'm glad they're going ahead. This whole affair makes Cameron look like a right dickhead.

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 06 Mar 15 4.39pm

Cameron is in a bit of a lose-lose, as I have said before.

People already don't rate Ed Miliband. But he can perform in debates. The only thing stopping the Labour poll lead firming up and extending is that EdM is seen as a bad PM. If he performs decently or even outperforms Cameron in the debates then the Tories would be evicerated at the GE.

But not taking part seriously risks Cameron looking unstatemanlike and cowardly. Neither of which are traits the British public tend to take to their hearts in a future PM.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

imbored Flag UK 06 Mar 15 4.47pm

Quote OknotOK at 06 Mar 2015 4.39pm

Cameron is in a bit of a lose-lose, as I have said before.

People already don't rate Ed Miliband. But he can perform in debates. The only thing stopping the Labour poll lead firming up and extending is that EdM is seen as a bad PM. If he performs decently or even outperforms Cameron in the debates then the Tories would be evicerated at the GE.

But not taking part seriously risks Cameron looking unstatemanlike and cowardly. Neither of which are traits the British public tend to take to their hearts in a future PM.

I can understanding him trying to wriggle out of these debates, but he should've taken into account that broadcasters might not back down. Now even is he changes his mind it looks like it's only because he's been forced to, so the cowardly tag remains.

 

Page 2 of 13 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Leader's debates