You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tube strike
November 22 2026 1.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Tube strike


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 10 Feb 15 8.26pm

'False result'

The transport authority said it had explored in detail the suggestion that diabetes could affect the breathalyser result, but concluded that the type of test it used was not affected by acetone, which is produced in the bloodstream of people with the condition.

RMT Regional Organiser John Leach said the union was asking for further testing to be carried out when a breathalyzer gave a positive result.

"The current system is unfair because it doesn't offer safeguards to those with disabilities or who are on certain diets," he said.

Does that mean "alcoholic poisoning" condition?

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Feb 15 8.50pm

Quote Mapletree at 10 Feb 2015 8.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Feb 2015 8.04pm

Told by a friend of an rmt member that the story is because of his health the breath test gave a false reading. And rather than test his urine as well for alcohol this was not done. Lu then destroyed the test results. The reason for the strike is procedures put in place by London underground was not followed.

Not sure how true this is. But if London underground havent followed procedures, they've left themselves open...

Edited by nickgusset (10 Feb 2015 8.06pm)


If they didn't follow their own processes then it's likely the employee would win at a Tribunal.

So why should the Union members set themselves up as judge and jury when there is a serviceable process available to this employee?

And no TUX, it won't inconvenience me in the slightest. I don't catch the underground. But it will inconvenience over a million people, some of whom aren't in a position to easily cope.


From the RMT London calling website...
[Link]


Three reasons why a yes vote for the Alex McGuigan Case is essential

1 - We believe Alex is innocent

Alex has diabetes which we believe has given a false positive in a random breath test he took when booking on for duty. The RMT has seen evidence that this is possible. If the police breath test you and you fail, they take you back to the police station and you are tested again using much more robust equipment. At LUL once you fail a breath test that is it - sacked after 29 years unblemished service.

Alex could have had a urine sample privately tested to demonstrate his innocence, however this sample was destroyed before he had a chance.

2 - Peter Hendy has already apologised for giving out false information and it keeps coming

London Transport commissioner Peter Hendy stated on an interview with LBC that Alex McGuigan had been drinking on duty. Not long after newspaper front pages were reporting that the RMT was striking for somebody who was drinking whilst at work. However this was totally untrue. Peter Hendy wrote to the RMT to apologise for this error - but by that point the damage was largely done.

Now London Underground bosses are saying that Alex ‘admitted drinking before booking on for duty’ but what they omit is that he drank alcohol the night before - and an amount well within London Underground guidelines. Imagine this: You go for dinner with your partner and have a glass of wine and are home by 11pm. the next day you book on for a 10am duty, are drug tested and a false reading is returned. London Underground sack you and claim on national radio that you were drinking on duty. They then claim that you admitted ‘drinking before you booked on.’ How would you feel? Bosses are doing it now and if we don’t fight back they will do it again.

3 - The RMT have told LUL that they would call off the industrial action if bosses agreed to abide by an employment tribunal decision - but they refused

This issue is bigger than the Alex McGuigan dispute - it is about whether when London Underground sacks you they will listen if an independent Employment Tribunal says that the decision was wrong and the person should be reinstated.

If London Underground are so confident that the sacking of Alex Mcguigan was fair - and that their drugs and alcohol testing process is robust - why would they refuse to abide by an employment tribunal decision? They claim that our industrial action is wrong, but refuse to be led by an independent employment tribunal. this has happened in the past. Employment tribunals have said lUl should reinstate somebody and they have refused to do it. Only RMT industrial action - or the threat of it - ensures drivers jobs are safe from unfair dismissal.


Has any of this appeared in the papers?

Edited by nickgusset (10 Feb 2015 8.52pm)

 

TUX Flag redhill 10 Feb 15 8.55pm

Quote Mapletree at 10 Feb 2015 8.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Feb 2015 8.04pm

Told by a friend of an rmt member that the story is because of his health the breath test gave a false reading. And rather than test his urine as well for alcohol this was not done. Lu then destroyed the test results. The reason for the strike is procedures put in place by London underground was not followed.

Not sure how true this is. But if London underground havent followed procedures, they've left themselves open...

Edited by nickgusset (10 Feb 2015 8.06pm)


If they didn't follow their own processes then it's likely the employee would win at a Tribunal.

So why should the Union members set themselves up as judge and jury when there is a serviceable process available to this employee?

And no TUX, it won't inconvenience me in the slightest. I don't catch the underground. But it will inconvenience over a million people, some of whom aren't in a position to easily cope.[/quote]

So they can make their way 'underground' but can't make their way 'over ground'? I never saw that coming tbh.


 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 10 Feb 15 8.58pm

Interesting post Nick

But I don't understand the point. LU would have no choice but to accept an Employment Tribunal decision.

Is this in fact wrong and what the RMT was asking for was binding arbitration?

I still don't understand why, if the LU management really did mess up, the individual doesn't go to Tribunal. I also don't understand why LU's own appeals procedure did not reverse the decision if it was unfair.

Who knows, both sides have always been pretty unreasonable.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 10 Feb 15 9.00pm

Quote TUX at 10 Feb 2015 8.55pm

Quote Mapletree at 10 Feb 2015 8.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Feb 2015 8.04pm

Told by a friend of an rmt member that the story is because of his health the breath test gave a false reading. And rather than test his urine as well for alcohol this was not done. Lu then destroyed the test results. The reason for the strike is procedures put in place by London underground was not followed.

Not sure how true this is. But if London underground havent followed procedures, they've left themselves open...

Edited by nickgusset (10 Feb 2015 8.06pm)


If they didn't follow their own processes then it's likely the employee would win at a Tribunal.

So why should the Union members set themselves up as judge and jury when there is a serviceable process available to this employee?

And no TUX, it won't inconvenience me in the slightest. I don't catch the underground. But it will inconvenience over a million people, some of whom aren't in a position to easily cope.[/quote]

So they can make their way 'underground' but can't make their way 'over ground'? I never saw that coming tbh.


Ah, my mistake. The underground system is clearly not an important part of London's infrastructure and of course overground transport can cope without it. Silly me.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 10 Feb 15 9.11pm

Having had a bit of a read of this, I think what the RMT must have offered is that if a Tribunal found the driver was wrongly dismissed then would LU reinstate him rather than make a payment for wrongful dismissal.

That does seem pretty reasonable - although very uncommon - so on this occasion it may well be that management are the idiots. I just hate this constant bickering and the way both sides seem to live in a bygone age of industrial relations.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Feb 15 9.23pm

Quote Mapletree at 10 Feb 2015 9.11pm

Having had a bit of a read of this, I think what the RMT must have offered is that if a Tribunal found the driver was wrongly dismissed then would LU reinstate him rather than make a payment for wrongful dismissal.

That does seem pretty reasonable - although very uncommon - so on this occasion it may well be that management are the idiots. I just hate this constant bickering and the way both sides seem to live in a bygone age of industrial relations.


I hate the fact that virtually none of the media are being balanced about this. It's always bash the unions and people lap it up.

 

TUX Flag redhill 10 Feb 15 9.34pm

Quote Mapletree at 10 Feb 2015 9.00pm

Quote TUX at 10 Feb 2015 8.55pm

Quote Mapletree at 10 Feb 2015 8.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Feb 2015 8.04pm

Told by a friend of an rmt member that the story is because of his health the breath test gave a false reading. And rather than test his urine as well for alcohol this was not done. Lu then destroyed the test results. The reason for the strike is procedures put in place by London underground was not followed.

Not sure how true this is. But if London underground havent followed procedures, they've left themselves open...

Edited by nickgusset (10 Feb 2015 8.06pm)


If they didn't follow their own processes then it's likely the employee would win at a Tribunal.

So why should the Union members set themselves up as judge and jury when there is a serviceable process available to this employee?

And no TUX, it won't inconvenience me in the slightest. I don't catch the underground. But it will inconvenience over a million people, some of whom aren't in a position to easily cope.[/quote]

So they can make their way 'underground' but can't make their way 'over ground'? I never saw that coming tbh.


Ah, my mistake. The underground system is clearly not an important part of London's infrastructure and of course overground transport can cope without it. Silly me.

Calm down .

At no point have I said you've made a mistake.


 

Pussay Patrol Flag 10 Feb 15 11.36pm

It's obvious the Union are trying every angle to wriggle out of it, looking at technicalities.

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

Old Chap Flag Orpington 11 Feb 15 6.25am

Quote Mapletree at 10 Feb 2015 9.11pm

Having had a bit of a read of this, I think what the RMT must have offered is that if a Tribunal found the driver was wrongly dismissed then would LU reinstate him rather than make a payment for wrongful dismissal.

That does seem pretty reasonable - although very uncommon - so on this occasion it may well be that management are the idiots. I just hate this constant bickering and the way both sides seem to live in a bygone age of industrial relations.


That's the crux of the matter - a tribunal might find in favour of the employee & say he should be reinstated, but LU do no have to do thus

They might pay compensation, but that is normally 6 months pay

So the driver has lost his job, and with the stigma that he was fired for driving a train whilst drunk, has little chance of getting another half decent job. How much will that cost him up to retirement age?

Or how much will it cost us in paying him benefit?

Ask LU why they will not accept tribunal decision if they are sure they are right

 


Trivial fact - Palace used to win 5-1 at least once a season, maybe next season?

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 11 Feb 15 8.32am

Quote Mapletree at 10 Feb 2015 9.11pm

Having had a bit of a read of this, I think what the RMT must have offered is that if a Tribunal found the driver was wrongly dismissed then would LU reinstate him rather than make a payment for wrongful dismissal.

That does seem pretty reasonable - although very uncommon - so on this occasion it may well be that management are the idiots. I just hate this constant bickering and the way both sides seem to live in a bygone age of industrial relations.

Yep - progressive (both sides) they aren't. It always seems like a gunfight.

I have been on both sides of the union coin - originally in one (POEU / CWU) and close to its local branch leadership and then more recently sitting opposite a real Dave Spart type from Unite shouting up the workers rhetoric that made Fred Kite look positively enlightened. The management meanwhile where actually being incredibly reasonable with their concessions and offers but he wasn't having any it even if the reps wanted to (it was the same reason I left the CWU)

Not really any difference in the outlook from those days in the mid eighties until now Union wise sadly in my experience

Shame as Unions are hugely important, probably more than ever, with the way big corporates seek to take the piss these days, but at times they just seem petty, outmoded and still just spoiling for a fight.

Edited by The Sash (11 Feb 2015 8.33am)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Mapletree Flag Croydon 11 Feb 15 9.12am

Me too Sash

Worked happily with National Officers and Shop Stewards. Had so much hassle with the guys in the middle, no skin in the game and highly political.

 

TUX Flag redhill 11 Feb 15 7.17pm

Quote The Sash at 11 Feb 2015 8.32am

Quote Mapletree at 10 Feb 2015 9.11pm

Having had a bit of a read of this, I think what the RMT must have offered is that if a Tribunal found the driver was wrongly dismissed then would LU reinstate him rather than make a payment for wrongful dismissal.

That does seem pretty reasonable - although very uncommon - so on this occasion it may well be that management are the idiots. I just hate this constant bickering and the way both sides seem to live in a bygone age of industrial relations.

Yep - progressive (both sides) they aren't. It always seems like a gunfight.

I have been on both sides of the union coin - originally in one (POEU / CWU) and close to its local branch leadership and then more recently sitting opposite a real Dave Spart type from Unite shouting up the workers rhetoric that made Fred Kite look positively enlightened. The management meanwhile where actually being incredibly reasonable with their concessions and offers but he wasn't having any it even if the reps wanted to (it was the same reason I left the CWU)

Not really any difference in the outlook from those days in the mid eighties until now Union wise sadly in my experience

Shame as Unions are hugely important, probably more than ever, with the way big corporates seek to take the piss these days, but at times they just seem petty, outmoded and still just spoiling for a fight.

Edited by The Sash (11 Feb 2015 8.33am)

Agreed but I think they maybe need slightly better representation, cough cough?

[Link]


Edited by TUX (11 Feb 2015 7.27pm)

 

Hoof Hearted 17 Feb 15 3.36pm

[Link]

Nick Ferrari v Steve Hedley (AGS to the RMT)

Interesting exchange...........

 

ghosteagle Flag 17 Feb 15 3.42pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 17 Feb 2015 3.36pm

[Link]

Nick Ferrari v Steve Hedley (AGS to the RMT)

Interesting exchange...........

Nick Ferrari is such a moran, as transparent as they come

And he never does answer the question about beating his wife.

Edited by ghosteagle (17 Feb 2015 3.44pm)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 17 Feb 15 3.44pm

Quote ghosteagle at 17 Feb 2015 3.42pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 17 Feb 2015 3.36pm

[Link]

Nick Ferrari v Steve Hedley (AGS to the RMT)

Interesting exchange...........

Nick Ferrari is such a moran, as transparent as they come

Is that like Kevin Moran?

images.jpg Attachment: images.jpg (3.73Kb)

 

ghosteagle Flag 17 Feb 15 3.45pm

Quote nickgusset at 17 Feb 2015 3.44pm

Quote ghosteagle at 17 Feb 2015 3.42pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 17 Feb 2015 3.36pm

[Link]

Nick Ferrari v Steve Hedley (AGS to the RMT)

Interesting exchange...........

Nick Ferrari is such a moran, as transparent as they come

Is that like Kevin Moran?

Doh!

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 17 Feb 15 3.47pm

Quote ghosteagle at 17 Feb 2015 3.45pm

Quote nickgusset at 17 Feb 2015 3.44pm

Quote ghosteagle at 17 Feb 2015 3.42pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 17 Feb 2015 3.36pm

[Link]

Nick Ferrari v Steve Hedley (AGS to the RMT)

Interesting exchange...........

Nick Ferrari is such a moran, as transparent as they come

Is that like Kevin Moran?

Doh!


 

Hoof Hearted 17 Feb 15 3.52pm

Quote ghosteagle at 17 Feb 2015 3.42pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 17 Feb 2015 3.36pm

[Link]

Nick Ferrari v Steve Hedley (AGS to the RMT)

Interesting exchange...........

Nick Ferrari is such a moran, as transparent as they come

And he never does answer the question about beating his wife.

Edited by ghosteagle (17 Feb 2015 3.44pm)


The irony is that Steve Hedley was the wife beater!

[Link]

 

suicideatselhurst Flag crawley 17 Feb 15 3.54pm

Quote Pussay Patrol at 10 Feb 2015 11.36pm

It's obvious the Union are trying every angle to wriggle out of it, looking at technicalities.


being a union rep Pussay, that's normally all you have when trying to keep someone in their job

 


Theres someone in my head ... But its not me

X/Box game Tag bazcpfc1961, clan (HMS)

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tube strike