You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Islam religion of peace?
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Islam religion of peace?


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
silvertop Flag Portishead 06 Mar 15 11.04am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 06 Mar 2015 11.00am

I heard this morning that ISIS are now destroying ancient art thousands of years old as they capture more land in Iraq.

That might be their undoing as people care more about artefacts than human suffering!

To the OP though, I agree with others who rightly state that pitting one religion against another is the cause of the world's problems.

Why do all you religious zealots insist on thrusting your beliefs on others?

I am enlightened enough thank you.


I doubt it. There is a roaring trade of smuggling said artefacts across the Turkish boarder. They need the money.

 

reborn 06 Mar 15 11.24am

Quote silvertop at 06 Mar 2015 11.02am

Quote ParchmoreEagle at 06 Mar 2015 8.42am

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Mar 2015 8.17am

1,200 million Muslims in the world. A few million are sect-based jihadi nutters and nothing like the others.

So if the other 99% are not engaged in nor sympathise with extreme religious violence then I suppose it is fair to say it can be classed as very peaceful overall - unlike plenty of politicians - and made up of people just like you and me more concerned with friends, food, sport and tv than Sharia.

according to Wiki:
As of 2014, over 2.08 billion or about 28.26% of the world population are Muslims. You obviously didn't watch the first link. 15 -25% of those are radical muslims: That's 400 million radicals devoted to destroying western society. Watch the video mate - it's informative - it will help you improve morally and mathematically.


Ah, the beauty of the word. Some Jews are orthodox and thus good; some Christians are evangelical and also good; but those who adhere to a stricter interpretation of Islam are radical and thus bad.

Adhere to any interpretation you like, fine by me, as long as it doesn't mean that you want to kill and harm people who don't believe the same as you.

Therein lies the key I think.

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

Hoof Hearted 06 Mar 15 11.35am

Quote silvertop at 06 Mar 2015 11.04am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 06 Mar 2015 11.00am

I heard this morning that ISIS are now destroying ancient art thousands of years old as they capture more land in Iraq.

That might be their undoing as people care more about artefacts than human suffering!

To the OP though, I agree with others who rightly state that pitting one religion against another is the cause of the world's problems.

Why do all you religious zealots insist on thrusting your beliefs on others?

I am enlightened enough thank you.


I doubt it. There is a roaring trade of smuggling said artefacts across the Turkish boarder. They need the money.


BBC News on Radio 4 this morning said they were bulldozing a historic town with 13th century architecture.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 06 Mar 15 11.38am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 06 Mar 2015 11.35am

Quote silvertop at 06 Mar 2015 11.04am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 06 Mar 2015 11.00am

I heard this morning that ISIS are now destroying ancient art thousands of years old as they capture more land in Iraq.

That might be their undoing as people care more about artefacts than human suffering!

To the OP though, I agree with others who rightly state that pitting one religion against another is the cause of the world's problems.

Why do all you religious zealots insist on thrusting your beliefs on others?

I am enlightened enough thank you.


I doubt it. There is a roaring trade of smuggling said artefacts across the Turkish boarder. They need the money.


BBC News on Radio 4 this morning said they were bulldozing a historic town with 13th century architecture.


Ah, nothing portable to sell.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 06 Mar 15 11.52am

Quote reborn at 06 Mar 2015 11.24am

Quote silvertop at 06 Mar 2015 11.02am

Quote ParchmoreEagle at 06 Mar 2015 8.42am

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Mar 2015 8.17am

1,200 million Muslims in the world. A few million are sect-based jihadi nutters and nothing like the others.

So if the other 99% are not engaged in nor sympathise with extreme religious violence then I suppose it is fair to say it can be classed as very peaceful overall - unlike plenty of politicians - and made up of people just like you and me more concerned with friends, food, sport and tv than Sharia.

according to Wiki:
As of 2014, over 2.08 billion or about 28.26% of the world population are Muslims. You obviously didn't watch the first link. 15 -25% of those are radical muslims: That's 400 million radicals devoted to destroying western society. Watch the video mate - it's informative - it will help you improve morally and mathematically.


Ah, the beauty of the word. Some Jews are orthodox and thus good; some Christians are evangelical and also good; but those who adhere to a stricter interpretation of Islam are radical and thus bad.

Adhere to any interpretation you like, fine by me, as long as it doesn't mean that you want to kill and harm people who don't believe the same as you.

Therein lies the key I think.

What I was trying to say, is that it is an error to say that those who practise at the more dogmatic, orthodox end of Islam are also hell bent on destroying the West, murdering those of other religions or ethnicity and so on. They may want a society based on a strict interpretation of Sharia law, their views on women may remain in the dark ages, but the inference that there are 400 million terrorists out there is ludicrous. The Qur'an is very clear on murder and strict application of Sharia law means that the vast majority of those 400 million Muslims abhor ISIS, Al Qaeda and the rest of that happy bunch.

It is all in the branding - "radical" is a very loaded word created to suit a purpose. Would Western countries acquiesce so easily with the diversion of scarce resources and the loss of liberties acquired over centuries if it involved taking the fight to evangelical Muslims?

 

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 06 Mar 15 12.05pm

I think the fact that the Koran is seen as the true unfailing word of God by many Muslims is a problem. This means that radical preachers can be highly influential on young men and women because they present the word of God in the Koran as being unfailing and clear. Who is to argue with that?!

Also, there is no real big dog figure in Islam to tell these guys to stop. Am I wrong? All I hear is local Imams in London and normal Muslims condemning it. That's not enough. Where is a big time religious worldwide figure in Islam to condemn this activity?!

Either there is no Pope/Archbishop of Canterbury/Dalai Lama equivalent, or the big dogs support ISIS. And to say that there are Sunnis and Shias and smaller Muslim groups isn't a real excuse. After all, look at the division in Christianity. These groups should have leaders who are respected. And they should speak out if Islam really is being misinterpreted surely?

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

MileFan Flag 06 Mar 15 12.19pm

religion sucks but I think Jews are a lot more dangerous than Muslims.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Mar 15 12.36pm

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 06 Mar 2015 12.05pm

I think the fact that the Koran is seen as the true unfailing word of God by many Muslims is a problem. This means that radical preachers can be highly influential on young men and women because they present the word of God in the Koran as being unfailing and clear. Who is to argue with that?!

Also, there is no real big dog figure in Islam to tell these guys to stop. Am I wrong? All I hear is local Imams in London and normal Muslims condemning it. That's not enough. Where is a big time religious worldwide figure in Islam to condemn this activity?!

Either there is no Pope/Archbishop of Canterbury/Dalai Lama equivalent, or the big dogs support ISIS. And to say that there are Sunnis and Shias and smaller Muslim groups isn't a real excuse. After all, look at the division in Christianity. These groups should have leaders who are respected. And they should speak out if Islam really is being misinterpreted surely?

I don't think that's a specific issue of just Islam, people who accept anything as a literal unequivicable unfaltering truth are a) stupid b) dangerous, everything is subjective in human existence (demonstrated in neurological and philosophical basis) - So consequently all truths really stem either from a simplification / removal of assumptions that define the context or from the subjective experience of the individual.

You do realize that Sunni muslims, Kurd Muslims and Shia muslims are at the for front of fighting IS in Iraq and Syria. Most of the core Islamic faith groups do have key Imams and leaders.

What you have to bear in mind is that IS isn't really a faith, its a collective group of Muslims 'fighting' togeather as a mujahaden - Although it does have its basis in Wabbism (the key Islamic faith dominant in Saudi Arabia (which is officially on our side).

IS a bit of a mongrel of Sunni tribes from the Syrian and Iraq border areas and volunteers jyhadists drawn from other muslim groups.

Incidently, the Pope only has sway over the Catholic Church and the Arch Bishop of Cantabury over the Church of England (and to a degree the international Anglican Church).

There are a lot of Muslim leaders of faiths, its just that we tend to lump everyone into Muslim (which is the equivilant of saying Christian and Christian Sect - which would be as varied as the Quakers and the Christian Militias - ie nothing in common other than the word Christ).

Even when you say Sunni, you have different types of Sunni islam.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Mar 15 12.40pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 06 Mar 2015 11.00am

I heard this morning that ISIS are now destroying ancient art thousands of years old as they capture more land in Iraq.

That might be their undoing as people care more about artefacts than human suffering!

To the OP though, I agree with others who rightly state that pitting one religion against another is the cause of the world's problems.

Why do all you religious zealots insist on thrusting your beliefs on others?

I am enlightened enough thank you.

IS - they're no longer ISIS as they 'declared' they territory in Syria and Iraq as a combined Islamic State / Calaphate.

They've had a lot of names over the years, ever since they were Al-Qaeda in Iraq - they tend to change name every time as major event occurs, or they change policy - they're good a media and propaganda.

They've become the new 'Al Qaeda' brand for Islamist movements.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 06 Mar 15 1.59pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Mar 2015 12.36pm

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 06 Mar 2015 12.05pm

I think the fact that the Koran is seen as the true unfailing word of God by many Muslims is a problem. This means that radical preachers can be highly influential on young men and women because they present the word of God in the Koran as being unfailing and clear. Who is to argue with that?!

Also, there is no real big dog figure in Islam to tell these guys to stop. Am I wrong? All I hear is local Imams in London and normal Muslims condemning it. That's not enough. Where is a big time religious worldwide figure in Islam to condemn this activity?!

Either there is no Pope/Archbishop of Canterbury/Dalai Lama equivalent, or the big dogs support ISIS. And to say that there are Sunnis and Shias and smaller Muslim groups isn't a real excuse. After all, look at the division in Christianity. These groups should have leaders who are respected. And they should speak out if Islam really is being misinterpreted surely?

I don't think that's a specific issue of just Islam, people who accept anything as a literal unequivicable unfaltering truth are a) stupid b) dangerous, everything is subjective in human existence (demonstrated in neurological and philosophical basis) - So consequently all truths really stem either from a simplification / removal of assumptions that define the context or from the subjective experience of the individual.

You do realize that Sunni muslims, Kurd Muslims and Shia muslims are at the for front of fighting IS in Iraq and Syria. Most of the core Islamic faith groups do have key Imams and leaders.

What you have to bear in mind is that IS isn't really a faith, its a collective group of Muslims 'fighting' togeather as a mujahaden - Although it does have its basis in Wabbism (the key Islamic faith dominant in Saudi Arabia (which is officially on our side).

IS a bit of a mongrel of Sunni tribes from the Syrian and Iraq border areas and volunteers jyhadists drawn from other muslim groups.

Incidently, the Pope only has sway over the Catholic Church and the Arch Bishop of Cantabury over the Church of England (and to a degree the international Anglican Church).

There are a lot of Muslim leaders of faiths, its just that we tend to lump everyone into Muslim (which is the equivilant of saying Christian and Christian Sect - which would be as varied as the Quakers and the Christian Militias - ie nothing in common other than the word Christ).

Even when you say Sunni, you have different types of Sunni islam.


I was very much aware of the Pope's sway over only Catholicism and the Archbishop of Canterbury over the C of E. I mentioned them because they are two of the most influential and well known leaders to Britons. I know that isn't the main point though.

I must say that sometimes your reductionist approach of psychology, science and the philosophy of truth in relation to this is far too generalised. Is what you're saying is that everyone will have their turn? Will every little subsection of faith and belief group at some point become as destructive and horrible as these guys?

Obviously we can look at history and say yes and list off atrocity after atrocity and link it all back to each and every religion (look at murderous Buddhist monks in Thailand at the moment) and then pat ourselves on the head and stem it all back to microbiology. You're a clever bloke but I think you get too caught up in a wider superinclusive illustration of humanity and its foibles.

That is not the point here. We are looking at a certain case study. During my non-extensive research, a seemingly normal website describes the Koran as 'the unaltered and direct words of God, which were revealed through the Angel Gabriel to Muhammad'.

That is a fundamental of Islam, not some weird interpretation of it like the Westboro Baptist Church but the whole faith of Islam as a whole. A minuscule proportion of Christians see the Bible in this way.

I realise that ISIS isn't a faith but a terror group. But it draws its roots from the Muslim faith and is far more religiously based than the IRA. Everything is done for Allah. And yeah there are loads of Sunnis and Shias fighting ISIS because the group's creating political instability and they're opposed to ISIS as they don't support terrorism.

But you've hit the nail on the head! There are heaps of Sunni tribes, Shia tribes. But the fact is that although we shove everything together, there doesn't seem to be a concerted effort to my eyes at least in the Muslim world to speak out against the ideology! Maybe the actions but not the ideology. And people like Jihadi John go to normal mosques in London and become really influenced by radical preachers! Is this just a normal thing in Muslim communities!?

Parent: "Beware of the murderous preachers, they're wrong".
Child: "OK, I'll try, but I can't help it if their interpretation of the unaltered word of God is convincing".

There's no one major bigdog out there to instruct these guys on moral doctrine or actions, just Imams and radical preachers with their own interpretations of the Koran, which probably contains a whole lot of good, honest stuff (I haven't read it).

There is no 'real Islam' because no human can be sure exactly what the true unaltered word of God exactly suggests. Unfortunately, in the case of ISIS, the problem is with the setup of the faith but not, I stress with the majority of its followers.

Edited by EaglesEaglesEagles (06 Mar 2015 2.04pm)

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Mar 15 2.49pm

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 06 Mar 2015 1.59pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Mar 2015 12.36pm

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 06 Mar 2015 12.05pm

I think the fact that the Koran is seen as the true unfailing word of God by many Muslims is a problem. This means that radical preachers can be highly influential on young men and women because they present the word of God in the Koran as being unfailing and clear. Who is to argue with that?!

Also, there is no real big dog figure in Islam to tell these guys to stop. Am I wrong? All I hear is local Imams in London and normal Muslims condemning it. That's not enough. Where is a big time religious worldwide figure in Islam to condemn this activity?!

Either there is no Pope/Archbishop of Canterbury/Dalai Lama equivalent, or the big dogs support ISIS. And to say that there are Sunnis and Shias and smaller Muslim groups isn't a real excuse. After all, look at the division in Christianity. These groups should have leaders who are respected. And they should speak out if Islam really is being misinterpreted surely?

I don't think that's a specific issue of just Islam, people who accept anything as a literal unequivicable unfaltering truth are a) stupid b) dangerous, everything is subjective in human existence (demonstrated in neurological and philosophical basis) - So consequently all truths really stem either from a simplification / removal of assumptions that define the context or from the subjective experience of the individual.

You do realize that Sunni muslims, Kurd Muslims and Shia muslims are at the for front of fighting IS in Iraq and Syria. Most of the core Islamic faith groups do have key Imams and leaders.

What you have to bear in mind is that IS isn't really a faith, its a collective group of Muslims 'fighting' togeather as a mujahaden - Although it does have its basis in Wabbism (the key Islamic faith dominant in Saudi Arabia (which is officially on our side).

IS a bit of a mongrel of Sunni tribes from the Syrian and Iraq border areas and volunteers jyhadists drawn from other muslim groups.

Incidently, the Pope only has sway over the Catholic Church and the Arch Bishop of Cantabury over the Church of England (and to a degree the international Anglican Church).

There are a lot of Muslim leaders of faiths, its just that we tend to lump everyone into Muslim (which is the equivilant of saying Christian and Christian Sect - which would be as varied as the Quakers and the Christian Militias - ie nothing in common other than the word Christ).

Even when you say Sunni, you have different types of Sunni islam.


I was very much aware of the Pope's sway over only Catholicism and the Archbishop of Canterbury over the C of E. I mentioned them because they are two of the most influential and well known leaders to Britons. I know that isn't the main point though.

I must say that sometimes your reductionist approach of psychology, science and the philosophy of truth in relation to this is far too generalised. Is what you're saying is that everyone will have their turn? Will every little subsection of faith and belief group at some point become as destructive and horrible as these guys?

Obviously we can look at history and say yes and list off atrocity after atrocity and link it all back to each and every religion (look at murderous Buddhist monks in Thailand at the moment) and then pat ourselves on the head and stem it all back to microbiology. You're a clever bloke but I think you get too caught up in a wider superinclusive illustration of humanity and its foibles.

That is not the point here. We are looking at a certain case study. During my non-extensive research, a seemingly normal website describes the Koran as 'the unaltered and direct words of God, which were revealed through the Angel Gabriel to Muhammad'.

That is a fundamental of Islam, not some weird interpretation of it like the Westboro Baptist Church but the whole faith of Islam as a whole. A minuscule proportion of Christians see the Bible in this way.

I realise that ISIS isn't a faith but a terror group. But it draws its roots from the Muslim faith and is far more religiously based than the IRA. Everything is done for Allah. And yeah there are loads of Sunnis and Shias fighting ISIS because the group's creating political instability and they're opposed to ISIS as they don't support terrorism.

But you've hit the nail on the head! There are heaps of Sunni tribes, Shia tribes. But the fact is that although we shove everything together, there doesn't seem to be a concerted effort to my eyes at least in the Muslim world to speak out against the ideology! Maybe the actions but not the ideology. And people like Jihadi John go to normal mosques in London and become really influenced by radical preachers! Is this just a normal thing in Muslim communities!?

Parent: "Beware of the murderous preachers, they're wrong".
Child: "OK, I'll try, but I can't help it if their interpretation of the unaltered word of God is convincing".

There's no one major bigdog out there to instruct these guys on moral doctrine or actions, just Imams and radical preachers with their own interpretations of the Koran, which probably contains a whole lot of good, honest stuff (I haven't read it).

There is no 'real Islam' because no human can be sure exactly what the true unaltered word of God exactly suggests. Unfortunately, in the case of ISIS, the problem is with the setup of the faith but not, I stress with the majority of its followers.

Edited by EaglesEaglesEagles (06 Mar 2015 2.04pm)

I think its fairly normal for a minority of youth, particually young, men, to become enamoured with extremist views, there is nothing new in that - The lure of adventure coupled with the righteousness of youth, tends to be the foundation of terrorist and rebel groups cannon fodder across the world. It probably doesn't help that we as a society place such an emphasis on the idea of standing up for what you believe in etc (a nationally shared value that kind of invites trouble).

Quite a lot of stories recently have come out of the British Muslim communities about familys reacting to relatives who've gone to fight for IS, along with a conviction today, in which the judge praised the lengths that the family had gone to to prevent someone leaving the UK.

Of course in places like Iraq, Syria etc you do have countries and people to whom the idea of cruelty and violence as a means of control are the norm, they grew up with that, as did their parents, under the previous regime. Also, given they're Sunni Iraqi's, the favoured under Saddams Regime, its hardly surprising they've got an issue with the US and UK - as we have been arguably responsible, from their perspective, for their fall from power, reduced circumstances, the deaths of friends and family etc (its worth noting that Kurdish Muslims look quite favourably on the West - because of the opposite).

Its important to look into the politics of the middle east, and its history, to see that being an Islamist and being a Muslim are two very different things - Islamists are a political movement of Muslims first and foremost - In very much the same way the PIRA and Sinn Feinn had close ties with the catholic community, but were not strictly speaking a catholic movement, but a movement largely formed from catholics.

Interestingly, the origins of Islamic fundermentalism lie not in the Koran, but in the suppression of political dispute and the collapse of the soviet union. Prior to the 80s, most of the radicalized movements active were Paramilitary Left Wing Radical Muslims, such as the PLO and PFLP, as well as national liberation movements. Over time the failure of these to topple, typically western back regimes, resulted in the rise of groups like Islamic Jyhad and Hamas, which stem from peaceful movements, radicalized by the suppression of political dissent in the middle east (ironically Islamic Jyhad were originally a non-violent movement in Egypt. The consequent arrest, execution of its leadership and wholesale torture demonstrated to Islamic Jyhad that peaceful wasn't going to work.

These regimes across the middle east are fairly brutal, its unsurprising that they have bred and raised a generation of equally brutal dissenters.

Hopefully, the UK and US have learned from their 'experiences' in Iraq, that 'just because someone says they're Taliban, it doesn't meant that they aren't just 'tribal rivals'.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Mar 15 2.57pm

You can't help but get trouble when you mix religion, politics, explosives, a gospel of truth and the righteousness of youth.

Young men are generally stupid and looking for excitement, stimulation and something that gives their life meaning and belonging, beyond the humdrum mundane existence.

Only in this case its much more violent, than raves, football hooliganism, street gangs etc.

The upper working and lower middle class youth, is the prime problem area. They've escape the hardship of their parents generation, but are alienated and to an extent entitled.

In that way the youth that flee the UK to join Jyhad with IS, aren't any different than those who joined the Red Army Faction or Weather Underground etc.

The only real thing to take from that is that its not just white young males that are stupid.

The consequences are lost with the 'invulnerability' of youth.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 06 Mar 15 3.13pm

Quote silvertop at 06 Mar 2015 11.38am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 06 Mar 2015 11.35am

Quote silvertop at 06 Mar 2015 11.04am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 06 Mar 2015 11.00am

I heard this morning that ISIS are now destroying ancient art thousands of years old as they capture more land in Iraq.

That might be their undoing as people care more about artefacts than human suffering!

To the OP though, I agree with others who rightly state that pitting one religion against another is the cause of the world's problems.

Why do all you religious zealots insist on thrusting your beliefs on others?

I am enlightened enough thank you.


I doubt it. There is a roaring trade of smuggling said artefacts across the Turkish boarder. They need the money.


BBC News on Radio 4 this morning said they were bulldozing a historic town with 13th century architecture.


Ah, nothing portable to sell.

[Link]

They're destroying portable items too, as well as selling them.

No religion is one of peace. They all draw radicals who firstly believe the nonsense they spout, and then carve out their own, even more bizarre, interpretation of them.

 


Optimistic as ever

deflemonkid Flag 06 Mar 15 3.30pm

Quote ParchmoreEagle at 06 Mar 2015 6.30am

Quote deflemonkid at 06 Mar 2015 2.10am

Quote ParchmoreEagle at 05 Mar 2015 11.55pm

Jihad/Crusades [Link]
Response to a muslim [Link]
Treatise on islams true agenda [Link]


What exactly is the question?


Can't you read?

I can read and "Islam Religion of Peace?", followed by three youtube links is not really a coherent question now is it. Are you asking is it a religion of peace and for us to discuss? or are you saying you don't agree with the statement that its a religion of peace and you're fobbing off three youtube videos as your proof? or are you asking something entirely different? I honestly dont know as I can only read as well as you write.

Edited by deflemonkid (06 Mar 2015 3.33pm)

 

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 06 Mar 15 3.40pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Mar 2015 2.49pm

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 06 Mar 2015 1.59pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Mar 2015 12.36pm

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 06 Mar 2015 12.05pm

I think the fact that the Koran is seen as the true unfailing word of God by many Muslims is a problem. This means that radical preachers can be highly influential on young men and women because they present the word of God in the Koran as being unfailing and clear. Who is to argue with that?!

Also, there is no real big dog figure in Islam to tell these guys to stop. Am I wrong? All I hear is local Imams in London and normal Muslims condemning it. That's not enough. Where is a big time religious worldwide figure in Islam to condemn this activity?!

Either there is no Pope/Archbishop of Canterbury/Dalai Lama equivalent, or the big dogs support ISIS. And to say that there are Sunnis and Shias and smaller Muslim groups isn't a real excuse. After all, look at the division in Christianity. These groups should have leaders who are respected. And they should speak out if Islam really is being misinterpreted surely?

I don't think that's a specific issue of just Islam, people who accept anything as a literal unequivicable unfaltering truth are a) stupid b) dangerous, everything is subjective in human existence (demonstrated in neurological and philosophical basis) - So consequently all truths really stem either from a simplification / removal of assumptions that define the context or from the subjective experience of the individual.

You do realize that Sunni muslims, Kurd Muslims and Shia muslims are at the for front of fighting IS in Iraq and Syria. Most of the core Islamic faith groups do have key Imams and leaders.

What you have to bear in mind is that IS isn't really a faith, its a collective group of Muslims 'fighting' togeather as a mujahaden - Although it does have its basis in Wabbism (the key Islamic faith dominant in Saudi Arabia (which is officially on our side).

IS a bit of a mongrel of Sunni tribes from the Syrian and Iraq border areas and volunteers jyhadists drawn from other muslim groups.

Incidently, the Pope only has sway over the Catholic Church and the Arch Bishop of Cantabury over the Church of England (and to a degree the international Anglican Church).

There are a lot of Muslim leaders of faiths, its just that we tend to lump everyone into Muslim (which is the equivilant of saying Christian and Christian Sect - which would be as varied as the Quakers and the Christian Militias - ie nothing in common other than the word Christ).

Even when you say Sunni, you have different types of Sunni islam.


I was very much aware of the Pope's sway over only Catholicism and the Archbishop of Canterbury over the C of E. I mentioned them because they are two of the most influential and well known leaders to Britons. I know that isn't the main point though.

I must say that sometimes your reductionist approach of psychology, science and the philosophy of truth in relation to this is far too generalised. Is what you're saying is that everyone will have their turn? Will every little subsection of faith and belief group at some point become as destructive and horrible as these guys?

Obviously we can look at history and say yes and list off atrocity after atrocity and link it all back to each and every religion (look at murderous Buddhist monks in Thailand at the moment) and then pat ourselves on the head and stem it all back to microbiology. You're a clever bloke but I think you get too caught up in a wider superinclusive illustration of humanity and its foibles.

That is not the point here. We are looking at a certain case study. During my non-extensive research, a seemingly normal website describes the Koran as 'the unaltered and direct words of God, which were revealed through the Angel Gabriel to Muhammad'.

That is a fundamental of Islam, not some weird interpretation of it like the Westboro Baptist Church but the whole faith of Islam as a whole. A minuscule proportion of Christians see the Bible in this way.

I realise that ISIS isn't a faith but a terror group. But it draws its roots from the Muslim faith and is far more religiously based than the IRA. Everything is done for Allah. And yeah there are loads of Sunnis and Shias fighting ISIS because the group's creating political instability and they're opposed to ISIS as they don't support terrorism.

But you've hit the nail on the head! There are heaps of Sunni tribes, Shia tribes. But the fact is that although we shove everything together, there doesn't seem to be a concerted effort to my eyes at least in the Muslim world to speak out against the ideology! Maybe the actions but not the ideology. And people like Jihadi John go to normal mosques in London and become really influenced by radical preachers! Is this just a normal thing in Muslim communities!?

Parent: "Beware of the murderous preachers, they're wrong".
Child: "OK, I'll try, but I can't help it if their interpretation of the unaltered word of God is convincing".

There's no one major bigdog out there to instruct these guys on moral doctrine or actions, just Imams and radical preachers with their own interpretations of the Koran, which probably contains a whole lot of good, honest stuff (I haven't read it).

There is no 'real Islam' because no human can be sure exactly what the true unaltered word of God exactly suggests. Unfortunately, in the case of ISIS, the problem is with the setup of the faith but not, I stress with the majority of its followers.

Edited by EaglesEaglesEagles (06 Mar 2015 2.04pm)

I think its fairly normal for a minority of youth, particually young, men, to become enamoured with extremist views, there is nothing new in that - The lure of adventure coupled with the righteousness of youth, tends to be the foundation of terrorist and rebel groups cannon fodder across the world. It probably doesn't help that we as a society place such an emphasis on the idea of standing up for what you believe in etc (a nationally shared value that kind of invites trouble).

Quite a lot of stories recently have come out of the British Muslim communities about familys reacting to relatives who've gone to fight for IS, along with a conviction today, in which the judge praised the lengths that the family had gone to to prevent someone leaving the UK.

Of course in places like Iraq, Syria etc you do have countries and people to whom the idea of cruelty and violence as a means of control are the norm, they grew up with that, as did their parents, under the previous regime. Also, given they're Sunni Iraqi's, the favoured under Saddams Regime, its hardly surprising they've got an issue with the US and UK - as we have been arguably responsible, from their perspective, for their fall from power, reduced circumstances, the deaths of friends and family etc (its worth noting that Kurdish Muslims look quite favourably on the West - because of the opposite).

Its important to look into the politics of the middle east, and its history, to see that being an Islamist and being a Muslim are two very different things - Islamists are a political movement of Muslims first and foremost - In very much the same way the PIRA and Sinn Feinn had close ties with the catholic community, but were not strictly speaking a catholic movement, but a movement largely formed from catholics.

Interestingly, the origins of Islamic fundermentalism lie not in the Koran, but in the suppression of political dispute and the collapse of the soviet union. Prior to the 80s, most of the radicalized movements active were Paramilitary Left Wing Radical Muslims, such as the PLO and PFLP, as well as national liberation movements. Over time the failure of these to topple, typically western back regimes, resulted in the rise of groups like Islamic Jyhad and Hamas, which stem from peaceful movements, radicalized by the suppression of political dissent in the middle east (ironically Islamic Jyhad were originally a non-violent movement in Egypt. The consequent arrest, execution of its leadership and wholesale torture demonstrated to Islamic Jyhad that peaceful wasn't going to work.

These regimes across the middle east are fairly brutal, its unsurprising that they have bred and raised a generation of equally brutal dissenters.

Hopefully, the UK and US have learned from their 'experiences' in Iraq, that 'just because someone says they're Taliban, it doesn't meant that they aren't just 'tribal rivals'.

Answer me this and I'll respond in full:

1) Why is there such a rise in Muslim fundamentalist youths in Britain? - they get radicalised through worship groups not political oppression and have been brought up here. Look at the number of converts to Islam to be a fundamentalist too.

2) Do you not think the lack of control over what the Koran teaches in terms of the role of Muslim religious leaders has an impact? - You didn't mention this at all, only politics.

3) Why if the Koran isn't central to their beliefs, do these radicals stem everything back to Allah? - I think you're actually patronising and insulting to them and us to group them with any other political insurgent.


Also, the extent to which you link Sinn Fein and the IRA to 'the Catholic community' is overstated if you wish to draw a comparison to these ISIS guys and religious ties. ISIS are far more religiously motivated. Destroying precious statues in Syria because false idols are banned in the Koran. That's right the Koran, not the 'Political Dictionary of Terrorism and Insurgency Throughout The Ages' written by jamiemartin721. Though political motivation has certainly got a great deal to do with their movement, Allah is central to their lives and nefarious activities.

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

palace777 Flag belfast 06 Mar 15 3.52pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 06 Mar 2015 11.35am

Quote silvertop at 06 Mar 2015 11.04am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 06 Mar 2015 11.00am

I heard this morning that ISIS are now destroying ancient art thousands of years old as they capture more land in Iraq.

That might be their undoing as people care more about artefacts than human suffering!

To the OP though, I agree with others who rightly state that pitting one religion against another is the cause of the world's problems.

Why do all you religious zealots insist on thrusting your beliefs on others?

I am enlightened enough thank you.


I doubt it. There is a roaring trade of smuggling said artefacts across the Turkish boarder. They need the money.


BBC News on Radio 4 this morning said they were bulldozing a historic town with 13th century architecture.

if they need any roads tarmac`d there are a load of pikies in lewisham free!

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 06 Mar 15 6.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Mar 2015 9.25am

Quote reborn at 06 Mar 2015 9.21am

ISIS actually hate everyone. They would if they could kill 100% of Christians and ever Muslim that doesn't adhere to their insane interpretation of Islam.

IS aren't muslims, they're sectarian nationalists who use Islam as a means to an end. The Koran is pretty clear that killing innocents is unacceptable, especially when their muslims. The whole Apostasy thing is a convenience (and IS is the apostacsy).

IS is about power, control and domination. It has nothing to do with Islam.


One question, If it has nothing to do with Islam, why are IS all Muslims ? To be honest J thats a bollicks statement, a bit like the IRA had nothing to do with catholicism, the two are intrinsincly linked. No Islam no nut case extremists, same as no catholics no IRA in belfast, it really is that simple.

How they interpret/hide behind thier religion is open for conjecture, the fact that it is directly linked to thier chosen brand of sky fairy is not.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

johnfirewall Flag 06 Mar 15 7.14pm

Did they quote the bible during The Troubles?

 

kersal Flag London 06 Mar 15 8.48pm

Unfortunately the Muslim world experienced a rapid deceleration of progress and complacency during the Ottoman era where militaristic expansion ensured and became wrongly associated with the continuation of the glory of a religion. After the fall of the Empire, it created a void of power and later came anger, jealousy and a lack of competitiveness against Western countries. But, this is not to say that Islam is not a religion of peace.

In the emergence of Islam and later during the rise of the Ottoman Empire (700s-1600s), Muslim philosophers and scientists (such as Ibn-i Arabi, Ibn-i Sina, Omar Khayyam) were way ahead of their (Christian) peers, highly innovative, including an extremely peaceful variant in the form of Sufis, whose works were very well-received and endorsed for centuries.

It is also during this period that Christianity and its associated kingdoms were in a crisis that would last hundreds of years and reach a point of desperation in the form of the Crusades; which were hundreds of years of violation of sovereignty of the Muslim nations. The historical rivalry across the religions originate as early as this period and school teachings in Muslim countries are still full of the glorious defenses that Islam, the Seljuks and the Abbasids built against the Christian "barbarians" as to their interpretation.

The reason why I went deep into history was only to make the point that violence is not embedded in any religion's teaching inherently but that it depended on many other things and its openness to interpretation was manipulated by the powerful. Just as Christianity was perceived as a menace to the Muslim world in its heydays centuries ago, today the Muslim radicals are causing problems in the Christian world. Only this should be enough to show that religions are not to blame, but it is their interpreters that are to blame.

Also, any generalization of the Muslim community as extremists or even an utterance of a made up 25% is a very ignorant claim to make and very misleading. I saw in an earlier post the number, 400 million Muslim extremists - pure nonsense.

Anybody who talks in such broad statements should most certainly avoid any further discussions on the particular sects of Islam or minorities of the Middle East, as they would be clueless about their origins, their historical sources of peace and rivalry, and more importantly how they stand vis-a-vis one another in today's balance of affairs. Wikipedia will not be enough to teach this and neither will superficial Western interpretations of the crisis in the Middle East - you really need something scientific, anthropological and historically detailed.

I come from the region, went to quite a few of the countries and still do business with clients in the region on a regular basis. I've seen very harsh interpretations of Islam, which I disliked and I've seen moderate and mild interpretations where similarities with the Western world were vast.

The everyday lives of the citizens of the Arab countries are not shaped by the lenses of Al Qaida or IS - and this includes the Saudi Arabians, where interpretation of the religion is tough if you're not from there. But, I assure you that (outside the very obvious places of conflict) there is no place in the Arab world that you as a Westerner would go and be penalized for that, if you respect the local rules as they can be sensitive. Saudi Arabia is difficult but not more than that. Qatar and the UAE, same. Turkey and North African countries, the same. Lebanon and Jordan, the same.

I hope you will patiently continue to do what's harder and avoid the easy way out, which is sweeping generalizations. It is such blanketing and patronizing statements that cause further polarization. Many Muslims don't feel comfortable in their own skins in the Western world as their category of identity is continuously being diminished in value by violent idiots that they cannot control the actions of thousands of miles away. I know it's hard, but you should try to empathize with the innocent as much as you highlight the obviously guilty.

 

sitdownstandup Flag 06 Mar 15 9.21pm

why a christian would begin a thread by questioning the beliefs of those of another faith when his own religion has many questions to answer of its own based on its own questionable history is something to think about. Recent history too - George Bush began the Iraq war, as a christian, because God told him to.
Christians vs muslims, muslims vs christians, atheists vs religious people etc. Why can't we all just get along?

 


Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible Nature. Unaware that this Nature he’s destroying is this God he’s worshipping.

Hubert Reeves

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Islam religion of peace?