You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Bali Nine
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bali Nine


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
npn Flag Crowborough 30 Apr 15 2.03pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Apr 2015 10.57am

Quote npn at 30 Apr 2015 10.41am

1. I oppose the death penalty, but it exists for drug offences in some countries

2. I believe justice in some of those countries is not fairly administered

3. They knew both 1&2 and decided to give it a go anyway - therefore the net result is "unlucky"

Problem with these countries, guilt is often determined by the same people being paid off by the primary drug traffickers. Their 'hardline' really is about protecting the monopoly of the trade, rather than any kind of justice, and frequently their trials involve questionable evidence, forced confessions and limited 'view of what constitutes' guilt. Trials can often be a farce of justice as well, along with the appeals process, and then the whole thing is generally utilized to serve political ambitions.

Reasonable doubt, for example, is rarely a consideration.

And of course usually they're the middle men, between the exporters and the importers. Often 'given up' to make it look like the country is 'doing its bit' - ie expendable costs of doing business. A variation on the Colombian 'Sacrifical Mule' (where in you send two mules on the same flight, and sacrifice one so as to reduce the risk to the primary mule).



In this case, the only one to protest her innocence is the one who got a last minute reprieve, as I understand it. So the fact that the law might be a bit corrupt is completely irrelevant (at least for the two we're hearing the most about - primarily because they're Australian - who have admitted their guilt)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Apr 15 2.25pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 30 Apr 2015 11.41am

I think it's a bit f*cking rich, frankly, for Western so-called liberal nations to go round condemning other countries.

If it wasn't for the demand for drugs that so-called liberal countries tolerate then poorer countries who supply them wouldn't be riddled with crime and corruption.

If a country wants to send a strong deterrent message then it's up to them. I'm a bit ambivalent on the death penalty in principle, but I think this example acts as a pretty big warning. I bet spoilt Western kids will think twice before trafficking drugs through Indonesia again.

Excepting the Aussies, the other shot were mostly it seems involved in smuggling drugs into the country (cocaine). Heroin tends to go out of Indonesia.

That said a number of those executed or to be executed were sentenced first to life, then had that knocked down to 20 years, and now back up to a death penalty.

Arguably if the Australian government didn't want them executed maybe they shouldn't have provided the information that lead to the their arrest and instead issued proceedings in Australia and extradited them.

Suspiciously absent of conviction or arrest is the 22 year old Thai woman who provided them with 8.3kg of heroin who goes by the name Cherry Likit.

By contrast Abu Bakar Bashir (a known terrorist, Al-Qaeda affiliate and now IS supporter) who was behind the three terrorist attacks, resulting in 220 deaths received 2.5 years, and had five months struck from his sentence as clemency

He was then later convicted of new terrorism charges and sentenced to 15 years, reduced to 9 on appeal.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Apr 15 2.31pm

Quote npn at 30 Apr 2015 2.03pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Apr 2015 10.57am

Quote npn at 30 Apr 2015 10.41am

1. I oppose the death penalty, but it exists for drug offences in some countries

2. I believe justice in some of those countries is not fairly administered

3. They knew both 1&2 and decided to give it a go anyway - therefore the net result is "unlucky"

Problem with these countries, guilt is often determined by the same people being paid off by the primary drug traffickers. Their 'hardline' really is about protecting the monopoly of the trade, rather than any kind of justice, and frequently their trials involve questionable evidence, forced confessions and limited 'view of what constitutes' guilt. Trials can often be a farce of justice as well, along with the appeals process, and then the whole thing is generally utilized to serve political ambitions.

Reasonable doubt, for example, is rarely a consideration.

And of course usually they're the middle men, between the exporters and the importers. Often 'given up' to make it look like the country is 'doing its bit' - ie expendable costs of doing business. A variation on the Colombian 'Sacrifical Mule' (where in you send two mules on the same flight, and sacrifice one so as to reduce the risk to the primary mule).



In this case, the only one to protest her innocence is the one who got a last minute reprieve, as I understand it. So the fact that the law might be a bit corrupt is completely irrelevant (at least for the two we're hearing the most about - primarily because they're Australian - who have admitted their guilt)

I don't doubt they're guilty. As is usual in these cases the person who sold them the heroin wasn't arrested, or even named in what was a very well operated sting operation targeted 'at the scourge of drugs in Indonesia.

So whoever it was in Indonesia, who just happened to sell them the heroin, wasn't even named or seen or identified, only those who paid for it and were going to smuggle it out of the country.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Apr 15 2.35pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 30 Apr 2015 11.41am

I think it's a bit f*cking rich, frankly, for Western so-called liberal nations to go round condemning other countries.

If it wasn't for the demand for drugs that so-called liberal countries tolerate then poorer countries who supply them wouldn't be riddled with crime and corruption.

If a country wants to send a strong deterrent message then it's up to them. I'm a bit ambivalent on the death penalty in principle, but I think this example acts as a pretty big warning. I bet spoilt Western kids will think twice before trafficking drugs through Indonesia again.

I doubt it, given the value of 8 kilos of heroin (here that's worth 3,200,000 on the street).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 30 Apr 15 4.48pm

Seems a bit harsh but don't smuggle drugs in/out of place where it's punishable by death. Very harsh on the Brazilian bloke who wasn't all there.

I wonder what we'll do with the Turks found smuggling £500m of cocaine into Scotland? (that's put a spanner in the SNP's planned celebrations!)

 


Optimistic as ever

Hoof Hearted 30 Apr 15 5.35pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Apr 2015 10.58am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 30 Apr 2015 10.34am

Quote Pawson Palace at 30 Apr 2015 8.30am

f*** them. They knew the risks and they accepted them when tried it. You can't play the game knowing the rules and then cry because you lost.

The dear old "grandma" tried taking 1.6kg of heroin that's not exactly personal use is it?

Just because she has a British passport does not exonerate her from what she did. They should handle her as they see fit on the grounds she had a fair trial.


Exactly.

People that deal in drugs have no welfare concerns for those addicted to their poison.... why should we be concerned that they have died?

Hopefully it will be a deterrent to others although I somehow doubt it.

More scum off our streets.

Well none of them are actually on our street, and most of the UK's heroin doesn't come via the far east anyhow (it comes from Afghanistan, via pakistan, Turkey and Italy).


When I say off our streets, I was talking globally.

I don't give a fcuk where the drugs are produced or sold.... they cause misery and mayhem.

The firing squad is too good for this evil scum peddling drugs.

 

legaleagle Flag 30 Apr 15 8.08pm

I wouldn't have a clue whether those executed this week all did or didn't do exactly what they were executed for.

But, as another poster pointed out,a life sentence is hardly an easy stretch,so to the extent punishment is a deterrent (against the temptation for some of taking high risks in return for perceived "easy" money),a life sentence in Indonesia might be reasonably high as effective deterrents go and/or satisfy the desire to inflict strong punishment for involvement with drugs.

I do know not everyone who makes a "confession" for Court purposes has necessarily actually done the deed in question...history is littered with examples of that.As has also been said,once you're dead,you're dead and its no consolation if it later emerges you shouldn't have been found guilty.

People may feel the firing squad "is too good for this evil scum".I wonder if they also feel they should have a good prospect of having had a fair trial (including sentencing) first in a situation where punishment is meted out equally across the board,particularly if,heaven forbid and purely hypothetically for example,they ever found themselves arrested at an airport after someone had (unknown to them) planted drugs in their bags?If a person got none (or even not all) of these,would they definitely still be "scum" for whom the firing squad is too good?

The link below is IMO worth reading as a point of view (I can't say if contains any accuracy or not and no doubt others have suggested the opposite to be the case of what is suggested in the link) on some aspects of the approach to the law,getting the same outcome across the board, and drug-related matters in Indonesia.

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (30 Apr 2015 11.40pm)

 

Hoof Hearted 01 May 15 9.29am

it's amazing how many drug smugglers that are caught that didn't realise they were carrying drugs and their trials were corrupt and unfair.

 

legaleagle Flag 01 May 15 9.39am

Nothing like ducking the point,Hoof!

Lets hope something like the below never happens to a member of your family..

Anyway,if it did,perhaps you'd just regard them as "scum" for whom the firing squad was too good...

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (01 May 2015 10.23am)

 

Hoof Hearted 01 May 15 10.48am

Quote legaleagle at 01 May 2015 9.39am

Nothing like ducking the point,Hoof!

Lets hope something like the below never happens to a member of your family..

Anyway,if it did,perhaps you'd just regard them as "scum" for whom the firing squad was too good...

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (01 May 2015 10.23am)


Haven't bothered reading the links.

Me and my family would never get involved with drugs or be stupid enough to let someone plant drugs on us in any situation.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 01 May 15 10.49am

I have mixed feelings about this. There's an element of you know the risks v the reward and if you get caught tough s*** deal with it.

However I do think people should by and large have the chance to redeem themselves.

I can't stand the bleating by those caught but firing squad?

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 01 May 15 12.40pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 01 May 2015 10.48am

Quote legaleagle at 01 May 2015 9.39am

Nothing like ducking the point,Hoof!

Lets hope something like the below never happens to a member of your family..

Anyway,if it did,perhaps you'd just regard them as "scum" for whom the firing squad was too good...

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (01 May 2015 10.23am)


Haven't bothered reading the links.

Me and my family would never get involved with drugs or be stupid enough to let someone plant drugs on us in any situation.

Indeed Hoof. I knew people who used to smuggle Khat to The USA, Canada, South America & (for some strange reason Norway)they all knew the risks albeit none of these countries you would get the firing squad, but in The USA you'd get deported. Canada was usually six weeks jail time, but one guy who smuggled some stuff into Peru got a 14 year jail sentence.

 


Pro USA & Israel

legaleagle Flag 02 May 15 12.49pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 01 May 2015 10.48am

Quote legaleagle at 01 May 2015 9.39am

Nothing like ducking the point,Hoof!

Lets hope something like the below never happens to a member of your family..

Anyway,if it did,perhaps you'd just regard them as "scum" for whom the firing squad was too good...

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (01 May 2015 10.23am)


Haven't bothered reading the links.

Me and my family would never get involved with drugs or be stupid enough to let someone plant drugs on us in any situation.


Well,no one could say you don't live up to expectations

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 02 May 15 1.46pm

pathetic anyone who says drug dealing scum deserve to die without knowing the ins and outs. No matter how you look at it drug dealing is not a crime that is worthy of the death penalty. Junkie's existed before these guys and will continue to exist after these executions. They didn't hold a syringe to anyone and make them use it.

Edited by Brentmiester_General (02 May 2015 1.59pm)

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Hoof Hearted 03 May 15 11.03am

Quote legaleagle at 02 May 2015 12.49pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 01 May 2015 10.48am

Quote legaleagle at 01 May 2015 9.39am

Nothing like ducking the point,Hoof!

Lets hope something like the below never happens to a member of your family..

Anyway,if it did,perhaps you'd just regard them as "scum" for whom the firing squad was too good...

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (01 May 2015 10.23am)


Haven't bothered reading the links.

Me and my family would never get involved with drugs or be stupid enough to let someone plant drugs on us in any situation.


Well,no one could say you don't live up to expectations

Touche'

Seriously I have a life to lead... and don't want to waste time reading fiction.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 03 May 15 1.11pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 03 May 2015 11.03am

Quote legaleagle at 02 May 2015 12.49pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 01 May 2015 10.48am

Quote legaleagle at 01 May 2015 9.39am

Nothing like ducking the point,Hoof!

Lets hope something like the below never happens to a member of your family..

Anyway,if it did,perhaps you'd just regard them as "scum" for whom the firing squad was too good...

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (01 May 2015 10.23am)


Haven't bothered reading the links.

Me and my family would never get involved with drugs or be stupid enough to let someone plant drugs on us in any situation.


Well,no one could say you don't live up to expectations

Touche'

Seriously I have a life to lead... and don't want to waste time reading fiction.


trip advisor dishonest?

 

suicideatselhurst Flag crawley 03 May 15 2.08pm

Quote nickgusset at 03 May 2015 1.11pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 03 May 2015 11.03am

Quote legaleagle at 02 May 2015 12.49pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 01 May 2015 10.48am

Quote legaleagle at 01 May 2015 9.39am

Nothing like ducking the point,Hoof!

Lets hope something like the below never happens to a member of your family..

Anyway,if it did,perhaps you'd just regard them as "scum" for whom the firing squad was too good...

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (01 May 2015 10.23am)


Haven't bothered reading the links.

Me and my family would never get involved with drugs or be stupid enough to let someone plant drugs on us in any situation.


Well,no one could say you don't live up to expectations

Touche'

Seriously I have a life to lead... and don't want to waste time reading fiction.


trip advisor dishonest?


from people being shot by firing squad to trip advisor ..... only on the HOL

 


Theres someone in my head ... But its not me

X/Box game Tag bazcpfc1961, clan (HMS)

meatpienz Flag brisbane 04 May 15 1.36am

Quote legaleagle at 01 May 2015 9.39am

Nothing like ducking the point,Hoof!

Lets hope something like the below never happens to a member of your family..

Anyway,if it did,perhaps you'd just regard them as "scum" for whom the firing squad was too good...

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (01 May 2015 10.23am)


Why would you go to Bali anyway good place to stay away from

 


Zaha has some green grass in front of him here. Finds Ambrose
not a bad effort ooooooooooh! what a goal by Darren Ambrose absolutely stunning strike!!! And, Crystal Palace lead @ Old Trafford.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 May 15 10.28am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 01 May 2015 10.48am

Quote legaleagle at 01 May 2015 9.39am

Nothing like ducking the point,Hoof!

Lets hope something like the below never happens to a member of your family..

Anyway,if it did,perhaps you'd just regard them as "scum" for whom the firing squad was too good...

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (01 May 2015 10.23am)


Haven't bothered reading the links.

Me and my family would never get involved with drugs or be stupid enough to let someone plant drugs on us in any situation.

Course you are, because you have special powers


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 May 15 10.32am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 01 May 2015 9.29am

it's amazing how many drug smugglers that are caught that didn't realise they were carrying drugs and their trials were corrupt and unfair.

Its not that unusual, as unknowing couriers make for much better mules, plus if they get caught, no one believes them and they don't know who put it there.

Put it this way, a lot of peoples luggage goes missing or gets lost, only to turn up somewhere else. The ones that get caught tend to be the most obvious ones, but in reality all you need is to pay off people in the baggage handling teams, and you can put what you like in any case, and then have someone pick it up the other end.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Bali Nine