You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Nuclear power - no thanks
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Nuclear power - no thanks


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
imbored Flag UK 02 May 15 1.10pm

Quote grumpymort at 02 May 2015 11.41am

Sounds good but it's not.

1) Batteries how is that good for the environment if all these large batteries need to be produced then as it is with batteries they degrade so you wont get a great deal of life out of them 1-2 years and then needs replacing.

2) Next is you will need a lot of solar panels to produce enough to be able to use the power and store it this is tough and will add to cost.

3) The government/councils do not even use solar power now which I do find strange they push for this and we hear about its better/cheaper but then why are new schools/hospital not using it then?

Tesla have always come out with stuff like this but rarely it converts to practical world application.

The batteries are guaranteed for ten years. That doesn't mean that they will be near full capacity of course, but they certainly won't be useless after 1-2. As for solar, it's getting cheaper all of the time. Economy of scale and all that.

This is the way we're inevitably heading so I'm pleased to see Musk pushing things forward.

 

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 02 May 15 5.13pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 02 May 2015 10.20am

Quote serial thriller at 02 May 2015 10.03am

All sounds good, but I still don't think it's as efficient a system as invading a country, bombing its people, digging miles in to that land's core, blowing up rocks, extracting some oil and selling it in big buildings on the side of motorways.


Change the record!!!

-.-'


I'll change the record when you stop being a racist

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 02 May 15 5.37pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 11.00am

Nuclear is cleaner than fossil fuel and means you can be secure in your energy supply, as you don't need to import hydrocarbons.

Rubbish as I have said on other threads it would max give 30-40 years supply with the increased demand.

I believe there are other battery storage breakthroughs either happening or just announced including British research.

One thing, probably the only thing, I agree with Clarkson on is that the height of technologic aspiration, especially, in the UK was 1968, and it has been a slow decline since.


Edited by pefwin (02 May 2015 5.41pm)

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

chris123 Flag hove actually 02 May 15 5.48pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 5.37pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 11.00am

Nuclear is cleaner than fossil fuel and means you can be secure in your energy supply, as you don't need to import hydrocarbons.

Rubbish as I have said on other threads it would max give 30-40 years supply with the increased demand.

I believe there are other battery storage breakthroughs either happening or just announced including British research.

One thing, probably the only thing, I agree with Clarkson on is that the height of technologic aspiration, especially, in the UK was 1968, and it has been a slow decline since.


Edited by pefwin (02 May 2015 5.41pm)


Not just me

[Link]

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 02 May 15 6.02pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 5.48pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 5.37pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 11.00am

Nuclear is cleaner than fossil fuel and means you can be secure in your energy supply, as you don't need to import hydrocarbons.

Rubbish as I have said on other threads it would max give 30-40 years supply with the increased demand.

I believe there are other battery storage breakthroughs either happening or just announced including British research.

One thing, probably the only thing, I agree with Clarkson on is that the height of technologic aspiration, especially, in the UK was 1968, and it has been a slow decline since.


Edited by pefwin (02 May 2015 5.41pm)


Not just me

[Link]

I did not say don't use it, I stated it was not a medium or long term solution.

I do disagree with article on safety and additionally on price; however, this resonates "The nuclear power issue is “so polarized that people who oppose nuclear power will immediately dispute the numbers”

I find this true with both the pro and anti lobbies.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

chris123 Flag hove actually 02 May 15 6.12pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 6.02pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 5.48pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 5.37pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 11.00am

Nuclear is cleaner than fossil fuel and means you can be secure in your energy supply, as you don't need to import hydrocarbons.

Rubbish as I have said on other threads it would max give 30-40 years supply with the increased demand.

I believe there are other battery storage breakthroughs either happening or just announced including British research.

One thing, probably the only thing, I agree with Clarkson on is that the height of technologic aspiration, especially, in the UK was 1968, and it has been a slow decline since.


Edited by pefwin (02 May 2015 5.41pm)


Not just me

[Link]

I did not say don't use it, I stated it was not a medium or long term solution.

I do disagree with article on safety and additionally on price; however, this resonates "The nuclear power issue is “so polarized that people who oppose nuclear power will immediately dispute the numbers”

I find this true with both the pro and anti lobbies.

So what bit of what I wrote is rubbish?

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 02 May 15 6.39pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 6.12pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 6.02pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 5.48pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 5.37pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 11.00am

Nuclear is cleaner than fossil fuel and means you can be secure in your energy supply, as you don't need to import hydrocarbons.

Rubbish as I have said on other threads it would max give 30-40 years supply with the increased demand.

I believe there are other battery storage breakthroughs either happening or just announced including British research.

One thing, probably the only thing, I agree with Clarkson on is that the height of technologic aspiration, especially, in the UK was 1968, and it has been a slow decline since.


Edited by pefwin (02 May 2015 5.41pm)


Not just me

[Link]

I did not say don't use it, I stated it was not a medium or long term solution.

I do disagree with article on safety and additionally on price; however, this resonates "The nuclear power issue is “so polarized that people who oppose nuclear power will immediately dispute the numbers”

I find this true with both the pro and anti lobbies.

So what bit of what I wrote is rubbish?

It is not a solution, not sustainable, and you need to import fuel.

The article also forgot the cost of build and decommission, waste storage, and the fact that there from a risk management point of view, that there is a small likelihood of a massive pollution event.

The scope of the report is extremely narrow. However, It does recognise that global warming is a human made event, it does recognise that nuclear power has advantages over fossil fuels in terms of reducing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. My 6 year could tell you that it is the one area where it has an advantage. It was deliberately written to highlight the benefit, what if they had compared half -life of waste as the only factor.

Their data seems pretty, sparse, the assumptions around causal rates of cancer would be very interesting etc.. HOWEVER, I would not dispute at present the estimates (and depending on how you estimate) would be 2.8 - 32.7 deaths per 10 billion kilowatt hours for coal compared to 0.2 - 1.2 for nuclear. For me, Most interesting deaths due to hydroelectricity generation would be between 1.0 -54.7 due to whether include dam collapse

To be honest, I can't believe that they have not even mentioned the radio-activity of coal ash waste or "acid rain" in such a dissertation, if you truly want draw up negatives of fossil fuel, but then how would they quantify it and what the impact would have been.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

chris123 Flag hove actually 02 May 15 6.58pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 6.39pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 6.12pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 6.02pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 5.48pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 5.37pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 11.00am

Nuclear is cleaner than fossil fuel and means you can be secure in your energy supply, as you don't need to import hydrocarbons.

Rubbish as I have said on other threads it would max give 30-40 years supply with the increased demand.

I believe there are other battery storage breakthroughs either happening or just announced including British research.

One thing, probably the only thing, I agree with Clarkson on is that the height of technologic aspiration, especially, in the UK was 1968, and it has been a slow decline since.


Edited by pefwin (02 May 2015 5.41pm)


Not just me

[Link]

I did not say don't use it, I stated it was not a medium or long term solution.

I do disagree with article on safety and additionally on price; however, this resonates "The nuclear power issue is “so polarized that people who oppose nuclear power will immediately dispute the numbers”

I find this true with both the pro and anti lobbies.

So what bit of what I wrote is rubbish?

It is not a solution, not sustainable, and you need to import fuel.

The article also forgot the cost of build and decommission, waste storage, and the fact that there from a risk management point of view, that there is a small likelihood of a massive pollution event.

The scope of the report is extremely narrow. However, It does recognise that global warming is a human made event, it does recognise that nuclear power has advantages over fossil fuels in terms of reducing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. My 6 year could tell you that it is the one area where it has an advantage. It was deliberately written to highlight the benefit, what if they had compared half -life of waste as the only factor.

Their data seems pretty, sparse, the assumptions around causal rates of cancer would be very interesting etc.. HOWEVER, I would not dispute at present the estimates (and depending on how you estimate) would be 2.8 - 32.7 deaths per 10 billion kilowatt hours for coal compared to 0.2 - 1.2 for nuclear. For me, Most interesting deaths due to hydroelectricity generation would be between 1.0 -54.7 due to whether include dam collapse

To be honest, I can't believe that they have not even mentioned the radio-activity of coal ash waste or "acid rain" in such a dissertation, if you truly want draw up negatives of fossil fuel, but then how would they quantify it and what the impact would have been.


All I said was nuclear was cleaner and you don't need to import hydrocarbons if you go nuclear, which gives you security over supply risk. I still don't see what is rubbish about any this.

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 02 May 15 7.23pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 6.58pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 6.39pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 6.12pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 6.02pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 5.48pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 5.37pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 11.00am

Nuclear is cleaner than fossil fuel and means you can be secure in your energy supply, as you don't need to import hydrocarbons.

Rubbish as I have said on other threads it would max give 30-40 years supply with the increased demand.

I believe there are other battery storage breakthroughs either happening or just announced including British research.

One thing, probably the only thing, I agree with Clarkson on is that the height of technologic aspiration, especially, in the UK was 1968, and it has been a slow decline since.


Edited by pefwin (02 May 2015 5.41pm)


Not just me

[Link]

I did not say don't use it, I stated it was not a medium or long term solution.

I do disagree with article on safety and additionally on price; however, this resonates "The nuclear power issue is “so polarized that people who oppose nuclear power will immediately dispute the numbers”

I find this true with both the pro and anti lobbies.

So what bit of what I wrote is rubbish?

It is not a solution, not sustainable, and you need to import fuel.

The article also forgot the cost of build and decommission, waste storage, and the fact that there from a risk management point of view, that there is a small likelihood of a massive pollution event.

The scope of the report is extremely narrow. However, It does recognise that global warming is a human made event, it does recognise that nuclear power has advantages over fossil fuels in terms of reducing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. My 6 year could tell you that it is the one area where it has an advantage. It was deliberately written to highlight the benefit, what if they had compared half -life of waste as the only factor.

Their data seems pretty, sparse, the assumptions around causal rates of cancer would be very interesting etc.. HOWEVER, I would not dispute at present the estimates (and depending on how you estimate) would be 2.8 - 32.7 deaths per 10 billion kilowatt hours for coal compared to 0.2 - 1.2 for nuclear. For me, Most interesting deaths due to hydroelectricity generation would be between 1.0 -54.7 due to whether include dam collapse

To be honest, I can't believe that they have not even mentioned the radio-activity of coal ash waste or "acid rain" in such a dissertation, if you truly want draw up negatives of fossil fuel, but then how would they quantify it and what the impact would have been.


All I said was nuclear was cleaner and you don't need to import hydrocarbons if you go nuclear, which gives you security over supply risk. I still don't see what is rubbish about any this.

You will import hydro-carbons, nuclear is un-sustainable. There are not the uranium resources.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

chris123 Flag hove actually 02 May 15 7.33pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 7.23pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 6.58pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 6.39pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 6.12pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 6.02pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 5.48pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 5.37pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 11.00am

Nuclear is cleaner than fossil fuel and means you can be secure in your energy supply, as you don't need to import hydrocarbons.

Rubbish as I have said on other threads it would max give 30-40 years supply with the increased demand.

I believe there are other battery storage breakthroughs either happening or just announced including British research.

One thing, probably the only thing, I agree with Clarkson on is that the height of technologic aspiration, especially, in the UK was 1968, and it has been a slow decline since.


Edited by pefwin (02 May 2015 5.41pm)


Not just me

[Link]

I did not say don't use it, I stated it was not a medium or long term solution.

I do disagree with article on safety and additionally on price; however, this resonates "The nuclear power issue is “so polarized that people who oppose nuclear power will immediately dispute the numbers”

I find this true with both the pro and anti lobbies.

So what bit of what I wrote is rubbish?

It is not a solution, not sustainable, and you need to import fuel.

The article also forgot the cost of build and decommission, waste storage, and the fact that there from a risk management point of view, that there is a small likelihood of a massive pollution event.

The scope of the report is extremely narrow. However, It does recognise that global warming is a human made event, it does recognise that nuclear power has advantages over fossil fuels in terms of reducing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. My 6 year could tell you that it is the one area where it has an advantage. It was deliberately written to highlight the benefit, what if they had compared half -life of waste as the only factor.

Their data seems pretty, sparse, the assumptions around causal rates of cancer would be very interesting etc.. HOWEVER, I would not dispute at present the estimates (and depending on how you estimate) would be 2.8 - 32.7 deaths per 10 billion kilowatt hours for coal compared to 0.2 - 1.2 for nuclear. For me, Most interesting deaths due to hydroelectricity generation would be between 1.0 -54.7 due to whether include dam collapse

To be honest, I can't believe that they have not even mentioned the radio-activity of coal ash waste or "acid rain" in such a dissertation, if you truly want draw up negatives of fossil fuel, but then how would they quantify it and what the impact would have been.


All I said was nuclear was cleaner and you don't need to import hydrocarbons if you go nuclear, which gives you security over supply risk. I still don't see what is rubbish about any this.

You will import hydro-carbons, nuclear is un-sustainable. There are not the uranium resources.

Well Uranium from sea water one day and there is always Thorium.

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 02 May 15 8.46pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 7.33pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 7.23pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 6.58pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 6.39pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 6.12pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 6.02pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 5.48pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 5.37pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 11.00am

Nuclear is cleaner than fossil fuel and means you can be secure in your energy supply, as you don't need to import hydrocarbons.

Rubbish as I have said on other threads it would max give 30-40 years supply with the increased demand.

I believe there are other battery storage breakthroughs either happening or just announced including British research.

One thing, probably the only thing, I agree with Clarkson on is that the height of technologic aspiration, especially, in the UK was 1968, and it has been a slow decline since.


Edited by pefwin (02 May 2015 5.41pm)


Not just me

[Link]

I did not say don't use it, I stated it was not a medium or long term solution.

I do disagree with article on safety and additionally on price; however, this resonates "The nuclear power issue is “so polarized that people who oppose nuclear power will immediately dispute the numbers”

I find this true with both the pro and anti lobbies.

So what bit of what I wrote is rubbish?

It is not a solution, not sustainable, and you need to import fuel.

The article also forgot the cost of build and decommission, waste storage, and the fact that there from a risk management point of view, that there is a small likelihood of a massive pollution event.

The scope of the report is extremely narrow. However, It does recognise that global warming is a human made event, it does recognise that nuclear power has advantages over fossil fuels in terms of reducing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. My 6 year could tell you that it is the one area where it has an advantage. It was deliberately written to highlight the benefit, what if they had compared half -life of waste as the only factor.

Their data seems pretty, sparse, the assumptions around causal rates of cancer would be very interesting etc.. HOWEVER, I would not dispute at present the estimates (and depending on how you estimate) would be 2.8 - 32.7 deaths per 10 billion kilowatt hours for coal compared to 0.2 - 1.2 for nuclear. For me, Most interesting deaths due to hydroelectricity generation would be between 1.0 -54.7 due to whether include dam collapse

To be honest, I can't believe that they have not even mentioned the radio-activity of coal ash waste or "acid rain" in such a dissertation, if you truly want draw up negatives of fossil fuel, but then how would they quantify it and what the impact would have been.


All I said was nuclear was cleaner and you don't need to import hydrocarbons if you go nuclear, which gives you security over supply risk. I still don't see what is rubbish about any this.

You will import hydro-carbons, nuclear is un-sustainable. There are not the uranium resources.

Well Uranium from sea water one day and there is always Thorium.

For sea water..........one day meh....needs to be soon.... the expense would be immense.

Thorium is interesting, I must admit I don't have stats on fuel availability.

...as I said pro and anti nuclear both have their head in the clouds.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

chris123 Flag hove actually 02 May 15 9.34pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 8.46pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 7.33pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 7.23pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 6.58pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 6.39pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 6.12pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 6.02pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 5.48pm

Quote pefwin at 02 May 2015 5.37pm

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 11.00am

Nuclear is cleaner than fossil fuel and means you can be secure in your energy supply, as you don't need to import hydrocarbons.

Rubbish as I have said on other threads it would max give 30-40 years supply with the increased demand.

I believe there are other battery storage breakthroughs either happening or just announced including British research.

One thing, probably the only thing, I agree with Clarkson on is that the height of technologic aspiration, especially, in the UK was 1968, and it has been a slow decline since.


Edited by pefwin (02 May 2015 5.41pm)


Not just me

[Link]

I did not say don't use it, I stated it was not a medium or long term solution.

I do disagree with article on safety and additionally on price; however, this resonates "The nuclear power issue is “so polarized that people who oppose nuclear power will immediately dispute the numbers”

I find this true with both the pro and anti lobbies.

So what bit of what I wrote is rubbish?

It is not a solution, not sustainable, and you need to import fuel.

The article also forgot the cost of build and decommission, waste storage, and the fact that there from a risk management point of view, that there is a small likelihood of a massive pollution event.

The scope of the report is extremely narrow. However, It does recognise that global warming is a human made event, it does recognise that nuclear power has advantages over fossil fuels in terms of reducing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. My 6 year could tell you that it is the one area where it has an advantage. It was deliberately written to highlight the benefit, what if they had compared half -life of waste as the only factor.

Their data seems pretty, sparse, the assumptions around causal rates of cancer would be very interesting etc.. HOWEVER, I would not dispute at present the estimates (and depending on how you estimate) would be 2.8 - 32.7 deaths per 10 billion kilowatt hours for coal compared to 0.2 - 1.2 for nuclear. For me, Most interesting deaths due to hydroelectricity generation would be between 1.0 -54.7 due to whether include dam collapse

To be honest, I can't believe that they have not even mentioned the radio-activity of coal ash waste or "acid rain" in such a dissertation, if you truly want draw up negatives of fossil fuel, but then how would they quantify it and what the impact would have been.


All I said was nuclear was cleaner and you don't need to import hydrocarbons if you go nuclear, which gives you security over supply risk. I still don't see what is rubbish about any this.

You will import hydro-carbons, nuclear is un-sustainable. There are not the uranium resources.

Well Uranium from sea water one day and there is always Thorium.

For sea water..........one day meh....needs to be soon.... the expense would be immense.

Thorium is interesting, I must admit I don't have stats on fuel availability.

...as I said pro and anti nuclear both have their head in the clouds.

India is building a fast breeder reactor that uses Thorium as it's feedstock for producing Uranium 233.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 May 15 10.32am

Quote chris123 at 02 May 2015 11.00am

Nuclear is cleaner than fossil fuel and means you can be secure in your energy supply, as you don't need to import hydrocarbons.

Unless something goes wrong, in which case the effects can be fairly devastating. Its also very expensive to build and surprisingly inefficient although not so much in terms of long time.

The waste is a problem, and security is a bitch in the age of modern terrorism.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Hoof Hearted 03 May 15 10.48am

Quote serial thriller at 02 May 2015 5.13pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 02 May 2015 10.20am

Quote serial thriller at 02 May 2015 10.03am

All sounds good, but I still don't think it's as efficient a system as invading a country, bombing its people, digging miles in to that land's core, blowing up rocks, extracting some oil and selling it in big buildings on the side of motorways.


Change the record!!!

-.-'


I'll change the record when you stop being a racist


I'll assume that was a joke.........

 

Hoof Hearted 03 May 15 10.51am

My experience of life is that you never get something for nothing.

Sounds good nick, but there will be some major flaw/payback later down the line.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Nuclear power - no thanks