You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Proportional Representation
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Proportional Representation


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
imbored Flag UK 10 May 15 11.37pm

A graph illustrating the percentage of the vote both parties have gained each election. Based on this alone it's easy to see how our governments are becoming less representative over time.

conlab.png Attachment: conlab.png (21.70Kb)

 

derben Flag 11 May 15 9.38am


Ironically, the EU elections are by PR and we have lots of UKIP MEPs. There even used to be two BNP MEPs. Presumably those who clamour for PR are happy with that?

 

DanH Flag SW2 11 May 15 9.46am

Quote derben at 11 May 2015 9.38am


Ironically, the EU elections are by PR and we have lots of UKIP MEPs. There even used to be two BNP MEPs. Presumably those who clamour for PR are happy with that?


Even for someone who has nothing aligned with either of the aboves ideologies or policies I think it's only fair. The fact that UKIP got so many votes and only 1 MP just shows the flaws with the current system.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 11 May 15 10.40am

What I find most worrying about this argument is that it seems to have only become an issue because of the parties involved.

The nature of the SNP with wanting to break up the country and the uncertainty surrounds them makes people not like them.

The Conservatives are being slammed by a more vocal left before they have even started is concerning. In terms of the Government (which seems to have attracted a lot of disdain), this Government is more representative than 2005 when there was no clamour for reform:

2015 Government: Conservatives: 36.9% vote and 50.9% seats

2005 Government: Labour: 35.2% vote and 55.1% seats

Had the Lib Dems got the same votes that the SNP did in Scotland and had Labour got the Conservatives' votes in England, I do not believe that this would be an issue.

Moreover, had the Conservatives and UKIP teamed up and formed a majority (would be around 50%) under PR, I get the impression that there would still be protesting.

Very dangerous to change a system when judgment is clouded by personal opinion of specific parties for some.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 11 May 15 10.45am

Also, under PR this year the Conservatives + UKIP would have 50%.

Labour would have less votes than the Conservatives but add up all the left wing parties and they also make pretty much bang on 50%.

Prime Minister/Chancellor etc. would still be Labour or Conservative but how do you decide which? It's just another false majority when you eventually get down to it.

It's also the end of independent candidates, some of whom have secured election on the basis that their community wants them to represent them.

Neither system is perfect, but PR has a lot of problems that need to be properly considered.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

corkery Flag Cork City 11 May 15 6.24pm

First Past the Post

A- 30%
B- 30%
C- 40%

60% of people don't want C but he's elected anyway.

 


We'll never die

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 May 15 8.44pm

Quote ambrose7 at 11 May 2015 10.45am

Also, under PR this year the Conservatives + UKIP would have 50%.

Labour would have less votes than the Conservatives but add up all the left wing parties and they also make pretty much bang on 50%.

Prime Minister/Chancellor etc. would still be Labour or Conservative but how do you decide which? It's just another false majority when you eventually get down to it.

It's also the end of independent candidates, some of whom have secured election on the basis that their community wants them to represent them.

Neither system is perfect, but PR has a lot of problems that need to be properly considered.

Too much I suppose to expect these over paid Oxford boys to actually co-operate, rather than just bicker at one another across party lines, and do what they paid to do.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 May 15 8.45pm

Quote derben at 09 May 2015 11.04am


We had a referendum on changing first-past-the-post and it was overwhelmingly rejected by the electorate.

For a system that made even less sense and was even less democratic, and just about the same in representation

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 May 15 8.47pm

Quote npn at 09 May 2015 4.21pm

Quote derben at 09 May 2015 11.26am

Quote JL85 at 09 May 2015 11.18am

Quote derben at 09 May 2015 11.04am


We had a referendum on changing first-past-the-post and it was overwhelmingly rejected by the electorate.


That was a vote for AV, though. Not PR.

Yes, but I very much suspect a referendum on full PR would give a similar result. The issue is very low on most voter's list of priorities.

Minority parties can get elected via fptp. In 1945 there were loads: 6 Independents; 2 National; 1 Common Wealth; 2 Communists; 2 Nationalists; 2 National Independents; 2 Independent Labour; 2 Independent Conservative; 3 Ind Labour Party; 1 Independent Progressive; 2 Independent Liberals.


I don't agree - I voted against AV, because it's a steaming pile of camel sh*t, but would have voted for true PR in a heartbeat. I don't imagine I'm the only one

Me to, I want a democratic system that represents as many people as possible, not just one of two increasing similar flavours of government.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 May 15 8.47pm

Quote derben at 11 May 2015 9.38am


Ironically, the EU elections are by PR and we have lots of UKIP MEPs. There even used to be two BNP MEPs. Presumably those who clamour for PR are happy with that?

Yes.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 12 May 15 8.14am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 11 May 2015 8.47pm

Quote derben at 11 May 2015 9.38am


Ironically, the EU elections are by PR and we have lots of UKIP MEPs. There even used to be two BNP MEPs. Presumably those who clamour for PR are happy with that?

Yes.


Not exactly happy, but it is an acceptable consequence because it is balanced by re-enfranchising all those people, including me, who live in "safe" seats whose votes are meaningless. I can't vote for the party I want, all I can do is vote for whoever might get the incumbent out. PR would make the electoral process relevant for millions of people like those Tory voters in Scotland or Labour voters in the leafy shires.


Edited by Catfish (12 May 2015 8.15am)

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

npn Flag Crowborough 12 May 15 8.21am

Quote Catfish at 12 May 2015 8.14am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 11 May 2015 8.47pm

Quote derben at 11 May 2015 9.38am


Ironically, the EU elections are by PR and we have lots of UKIP MEPs. There even used to be two BNP MEPs. Presumably those who clamour for PR are happy with that?

Yes.


Not exactly happy, but it is an acceptable consequence because it is balanced by re-enfranchising all those people, including me, who live in "safe" seats whose votes are meaningless. I can't vote for the party I want, all I can do is vote for whoever might get the incumbent out. PR would make the electoral process relevant for millions of people like those Tory voters in Scotland or Labour voters in the leafy shires.


Edited by Catfish (12 May 2015 8.15am)


Agreed.
It would make tactical voting much less necessary. No point voting Tory in Scotland, or Labour anywhere south of London. At least under PR your vote for the party with the policies you actually believe in counts for something

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 12 May 15 8.29am

Immediately after the election I thought it was a travesty and would have voted 'yes' if there had been a PR referendum.

Last night I heard an interview with an SNP backbencher and it made me grateful for FPTP! If parliament suddenly got filled with all kinds of jokers and charlatans from the Greens and UKIP... not sure that'd be great.

Mind you, you can argue that the parties would quickly become more professional under PR.

Anyway, I'm returning to my previous position. PR is good if we all want to vote along national lines. FPTP is better for the constituency link. Maybe there could be some kind of happy medium, a local MP based on FPTP and a second vote which gets counted proportionally.

Are there any countries who do something like that?

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 May 15 8.40am

Quote Johnny Eagles at 12 May 2015 8.29am

Immediately after the election I thought it was a travesty and would have voted 'yes' if there had been a PR referendum.

When in 2011 the electorate were asked in a referendum if they wanted to abandon the first past the post system for a more 'Proportional' system the answer was a clear NO.

And Farage's comments that the result leaves millions unrepresented is hogwash.


Edited by Willo (12 May 2015 8.42am)

 

imbored Flag UK 12 May 15 8.53am

Quote Willo at 12 May 2015 8.40am

Quote Johnny Eagles at 12 May 2015 8.29am

Immediately after the election I thought it was a travesty and would have voted 'yes' if there had been a PR referendum.

When in 2011 the electorate were asked in a referendum if they wanted to abandon the first past the post system for a more 'Proportional' system the answer was a clear NO.

And Farage's comments that the result leaves millions unrepresented is hogwash.


Edited by Willo (12 May 2015 8.42am)

That's not really the full picture though. A great many PR supporters on here and elsewhere hated AV too. Also, let us not forget how deplorable and manipulative the campaign to get a NO vote was.

ab.jpg Attachment: ab.jpg (57.86Kb)

 

npn Flag Crowborough 12 May 15 8.57am

Quote Willo at 12 May 2015 8.40am

Quote Johnny Eagles at 12 May 2015 8.29am

Immediately after the election I thought it was a travesty and would have voted 'yes' if there had been a PR referendum.

When in 2011 the electorate were asked in a referendum if they wanted to abandon the first past the post system for a more 'Proportional' system the answer was a clear NO.

And Farage's comments that the result leaves millions unrepresented is hogwash.


Edited by Willo (12 May 2015 8.42am)


How many times? What was offered in preference to FPTP was cr@p, and I voted against it on the grounds that "if they go with AV, then we'll never get PR because you won't be changing voting system twice in quick succession". It's like claiming kids don't prefer sweets to brussells sprouts because you asked if they'd like a bag of aniseed balls and they said no (because nobody likes aniseed balls).

Had they offered PR, I and many others would have gone for it.

Also, While I dislike Farage's views, he's spot on - 4 million (I think) people voted UKIP and got 1 MP. How can you possibly claim that those 4 million are represented? Ditto the Greens.

 

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 12 May 15 8.58am

Quote Percy of Peckham at 09 May 2015 11.45am

It just seems a shame that 'minority interests' remain so. They don't get a chance to develop any critical mass under fptp.


They said that about the SNP

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 May 15 9.03am

Quote imbored at 12 May 2015 8.53am

let us not forget how deplorable and manipulative the campaign to get a NO vote was.

I disagree.

I heard the arguments of the YES campaign that they were defeated by the Prime Minister's campaigning power, a largely hostile press and a tough opposing campaign.


 

imbored Flag UK 12 May 15 9.07am

Quote Willo at 12 May 2015 9.03am

Quote imbored at 12 May 2015 8.53am

let us not forget how deplorable and manipulative the campaign to get a NO vote was.

I disagree.

I heard the arguments of the YES campaign that they were defeated by the Prime Minister's campaigning power, a largely hostile press and a tough opposing campaign.



I've already given an example of how manipulative the campaign was. There is no other way to explain away an ad like that. 'Vote Yes and put critically ill babies at risk'. Using people like that. I mean come on. Politics gets low at times but we all sometimes have to call it as it is regardless of our affiliations.


Edited by imbored (12 May 2015 9.08am)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 May 15 9.07am

Quote npn at 12 May 2015 8.57am


Also, While I dislike Farage's views, he's spot on - 4 million (I think) people voted UKIP and got 1 MP. How can you possibly claim that those 4 million are represented? Ditto the Greens.

It is hogwash to say these people are "Unrepresented". Every elector in each constituency is represented by their MP.As an example, the Protestant fundamentalist Ian Paisley was assiduous in looking after the day-to-day concerns of his Catholic constituents and was hard working and vigorous in addressing their complaints.He certainly represented them !


 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Proportional Representation