You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > EU Referendum - In or Out?
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

EU Referendum - In or Out?


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Stirlingsays Flag 09 May 15 9.46am

1) Without reform for the UK.....OUT...With reform IN.
2) OUT

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

eryr Flag Caerphillydelphia 09 May 15 9.49am

I'll be voting to stay in

 


Dulce et decorum est pro Palace mori

"Gee, you and I oughtta get on swell Mister Burton, as we're both Selts".
"No, I am a Selt. You are a Sunt."

"24 hours in a day, 24 beers in a case. Coincidence? I think not." ~ Stephen Wright

[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 09 May 15 9.49am

Quote Lyons550 at 09 May 2015 9.24am

I'd need to know more about the consequences of either action to give my thoughts


You can't really know the effect of an out vote for sure until the project itself is undertaken.

The consequences are opinion based. Both sides of the argument present different pictures and they both have an agenda to do so.

You have to use your own common sense....Or just believe one side of the narrative

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

stayloa Flag Beckenham 09 May 15 10.14am

1. In
2. Out

I'm not sure why people think our economy is strong enough on its own to survive against the super powers... We're not Switzerland...! It scares me...

 

legaleagle Flag 09 May 15 10.36am

Switzerland and Norway both have "freedom of movement" as a term of their association agreements with the EU.We would be unlikely to get better terms.

I'm interested to know,when posters says "in but with reforms",what reforms do they think would be enough for them and are realistically achievable in the next 2 years?

 

Lakeview Flag Lincoln 09 May 15 10.48am

1. In
2. Out
3.In
4. Out
5. Shake it all about

 

Hoof Hearted 09 May 15 11.46am

Mickey Flanagan.....

OUT OUT

 

xGeorgex Flag Oh South London 09 May 15 11.49am

1. OUT

2. IN; after Labour, Lib Dems, SNP and most of the main Tories put a lot of funding into staying in. Left with UKIP and some awkward squad Tories fighting with little funding to go out. Much like the AV referendum, everyone wanted a new system then they choose a s*** system and make people disinterested.

 


E Block - Win, Lose or Draw it’s about having a good day out

Stirlingsays Flag 09 May 15 8.45pm

Quote legaleagle at 09 May 2015 10.36am

Switzerland and Norway both have "freedom of movement" as a term of their association agreements with the EU.We would be unlikely to get better terms.

I'm interested to know,when posters says "in but with reforms",what reforms do they think would be enough for them and are realistically achievable in the next 2 years?

The EU could not survive a British exit in its current form......It's quite amusing really.

The EU has over twenty five members and only four of them are net contributors. We are one of those four.

Look at the EU's rather pathetic attempts to keep Greece in the Euro..Greece are a tiny economy. Yet the EU know that the shock to the credit line in the markets would be significant...Even with all this time for banks to insulate themselves over the inevitable.

The loss of confidence over losing Britain would cause major shakes in the project...Our economy size and hence payments are similar to France..Germany already have disquiet over the rising cost of being the top contributor.....If we did leave then EU would change and downsize that's probably a good thing long term......So for me a Brexit....It's a win win.

The corpse eaters in the markets are already waiting for the EU to collapse and think it's a dead cert and only a matter of time......The EU know this.

When push comes to shove, letting Britain go isn't going to be a risk they are willing to undergo. Their gravy train would be swifty derailed.

Freedom of movement and whatever would quickly become a price worth paying to keep a major net contributor.

Now if Cameron keeps his word on the referendum we finally get to find out.....After all these years of stalling.

Thank goodness for FPTP

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

derben Flag 09 May 15 8.48pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 09 May 2015 8.45pm

Quote legaleagle at 09 May 2015 10.36am

Switzerland and Norway both have "freedom of movement" as a term of their association agreements with the EU.We would be unlikely to get better terms.

I'm interested to know,when posters says "in but with reforms",what reforms do they think would be enough for them and are realistically achievable in the next 2 years?

The EU could not survive a British exit in its current form......It's quite amusing really.

The EU has over twenty five members and only four of them are net contributors. We are one of those four.

Look at the EU's rather pathetic attempts to keep Greece in the Euro..Greece are a tiny economy. Yet the EU know that the shock to the credit line in the markets would be significant...Even with all this time for banks to insulate themselves over the inevitable.

The loss of confidence over losing Britain would cause major shakes in the project...Our economy size and hence payments are similar to France..Germany already have disquiet over the rising cost of being the top contributor.....If we did leave then EU would change and downsize that's probably a good thing long term......So for me a Brexit....It's a win win.

The corpse eaters in the markets are already waiting for the EU to collapse and think it's a dead cert and only a matter of time......The EU know this.

When push comes to shove, letting Britain go isn't going to be a risk they are willing to undergo. Their gravy train would be swifty derailed.

Freedom of movement and whatever would quickly become a price worth paying to keep a major net contributor.

Now if Cameron keeps his word on the referendum we finally get to find out.....After all these years of stalling.

Thank goodness for FPTP

Excellent post Stirling.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 09 May 15 8.50pm

Quote xGeorgex at 09 May 2015 11.49am

1. OUT

2. IN; after Labour, Lib Dems, SNP and most of the main Tories put a lot of funding into staying in. Left with UKIP and some awkward squad Tories fighting with little funding to go out. Much like the AV referendum, everyone wanted a new system then they choose a s*** system and make people disinterested.

There are plenty of rich private anti EU donators who will step in to fund the 'Out' campaign.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 09 May 15 8.53pm

Quote derben at 09 May 2015 8.48pm

Excellent post Stirling.


Tips hat.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 09 May 15 8.58pm

Quote OldFella at 08 May 2015 8.58pm

Assuming DC delivers on his promise of a 2017 referendum -

1. Who's in/who's out
2. What way do you think it will go?

I'm undecided on 1 at the moment. And really think it will be close.


Get out now man the rest of Europe are hangers on!.

 

imbored Flag UK 09 May 15 10.24pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 09 May 2015 8.45pm

Quote legaleagle at 09 May 2015 10.36am

Switzerland and Norway both have "freedom of movement" as a term of their association agreements with the EU.We would be unlikely to get better terms.

I'm interested to know,when posters says "in but with reforms",what reforms do they think would be enough for them and are realistically achievable in the next 2 years?

The EU could not survive a British exit in its current form......It's quite amusing really.

The EU has over twenty five members and only four of them are net contributors. We are one of those four.

Look at the EU's rather pathetic attempts to keep Greece in the Euro..Greece are a tiny economy. Yet the EU know that the shock to the credit line in the markets would be significant...Even with all this time for banks to insulate themselves over the inevitable.

The loss of confidence over losing Britain would cause major shakes in the project...Our economy size and hence payments are similar to France..Germany already have disquiet over the rising cost of being the top contributor.....If we did leave then EU would change and downsize that's probably a good thing long term......So for me a Brexit....It's a win win.

The corpse eaters in the markets are already waiting for the EU to collapse and think it's a dead cert and only a matter of time......The EU know this.

When push comes to shove, letting Britain go isn't going to be a risk they are willing to undergo. Their gravy train would be swifty derailed.

Freedom of movement and whatever would quickly become a price worth paying to keep a major net contributor.

Now if Cameron keeps his word on the referendum we finally get to find out.....After all these years of stalling.

Thank goodness for FPTP


Really? If the tories run a criminally skewed pro EU campaign, much like their PR one, with a biased question resulting in a resounding NO vote, will you feel the same way? This is short sighted. Under PR the tories would still have a very significant number of seats (240+), only UKIP would have 80+ too to hold them to an unbiased question and fair media representation of the facts either way. You're in for an unpleasant surprise if you really think the Tories are going to give you that.

I'm not even anti EU but I recognise that a Tory majority under FPTP is much, much less likely to result in an exit from the EU than if this particular election had PR in place. The numbers demonstrate that.


Edited by imbored (09 May 2015 10.26pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 09 May 15 11.09pm

Quote imbored at 09 May 2015 10.24pm

Really? If the tories run a criminally skewed pro EU campaign, much like their PR one, with a biased question resulting in a resounding NO vote, will you feel the same way? This is short sighted. Under PR the tories would still have a very significant number of seats (240+), only UKIP would have 80+ too to hold them to an unbiased question and fair media representation of the facts either way. You're in for an unpleasant surprise if you really think the Tories are going to give you that.

I'm not even anti EU but I recognise that a Tory majority under FPTP is much, much less likely to result in an exit from the EU than if this particular election had PR in place. The numbers demonstrate that.


Edited by imbored (09 May 2015 10.26pm)

I detest and detested coalition ....And it was only a tiny taste of PR style politics.

You can be a PR fanboy if you like but for me...While I recognise that PR is a fairer system....In the end I look at the practical results of the PR system.

This is the result: poor governance.

You can desire the Italian political system all you like but FPTP has the advantages of being able to really judge a party upon its decisions in power.

Not a mish mash of compromises that rarely achieves any direction at all.

Yes, FPTP was unfair on Ukip just like it was in the past to the Lib Dems......But Ukip are a protest party anyway and while I'm happy with the votes total they achieved....For me it's not about actual power....It's about pressure....And that's been achieved. Despite what some on the left say Ukip's votes won't be ignored.

I vote for principles I believe in...Like most...I'm not tied to a party.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 09 May 15 11.16pm

As for the question on the In/Out paper.....This issue has been so significant in the public's conscience....I can't see the wool being pulled over anyone's eyes.

If Cameron goes back on his word he won't last the term....The Tory party itself isn't exactly pro EU and it wouldn't countenance any underhand tactics from its own leadership.

I actually think it will be rather a fair shake for both pro and anti camps.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

imbored Flag UK 09 May 15 11.23pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 09 May 2015 11.09pm

Quote imbored at 09 May 2015 10.24pm

Really? If the tories run a criminally skewed pro EU campaign, much like their PR one, with a biased question resulting in a resounding NO vote, will you feel the same way? This is short sighted. Under PR the tories would still have a very significant number of seats (240+), only UKIP would have 80+ too to hold them to an unbiased question and fair media representation of the facts either way. You're in for an unpleasant surprise if you really think the Tories are going to give you that.

I'm not even anti EU but I recognise that a Tory majority under FPTP is much, much less likely to result in an exit from the EU than if this particular election had PR in place. The numbers demonstrate that.


Edited by imbored (09 May 2015 10.26pm)

I detest and detested coalition ....And it was only a tiny taste of PR style politics.

You can be a PR fanboy if you like but for me...While I recognise that PR is a fairer system....In the end I look at the practical results of the PR system.

This is the result: poor governance.

You can desire the Italian political system all you like but FPTP has the advantages of being able to really judge a party upon its decisions in power.

Not a mish mash of compromises that rarely achieves any direction at all.

Yes, FPTP was unfair on Ukip just like it was in the past to the Lib Dems......But Ukip are a protest party anyway and while I'm happy with the votes total they achieved....For me it's not about actual power....It's about pressure....And that's been achieved. Despite what some on the left say Ukip's votes won't be ignored.

I vote for principles I believe in...Like most...I'm not tied to a party.


It's not a matter of being a fan of something or not. It's the stone cold facts, that if this election had been PR there would've been a much more 'locked in' unbiased EU vote based on the numbers. We all know that UKIP are a one issue party and success on that front would've been more certain under PR this time around. As farage himself knows. Since this is the issue you blessed FPTP for I just thought I'd highlight the facts.

If the tories f*** people over with this, that's another five years of waiting. As for pressure, the Conservatives got to see for themselves the vote ceiling that UKIP hit, and that momentum took a real body blow with Nigel losing his seat, and only achieving one seat in total. This impacts the 'pressure'. And when a biased yes/no question is presented ans fails, where on earth is the motivation to do anything about it going to come from. As with any major party the tories know what to do to press the right buttons, and by the sounds of it it seems like they've duped people in this one.


Edited by imbored (09 May 2015 11.34pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 09 May 15 11.33pm

Quote imbored at 09 May 2015 11.23pm


It's not a matter of being a fan of something or not. It's the stone cold facts, that if this election had been PR there would've been a much more 'locked in' unbiased EU vote based on the numbers. We all know that UKIP are a one issue party and success on that front would've been more certain under PR this time around. As farage himself knows. Since this is the issue you blessed FPTP for I just thought I'd highlight the facts.

If the tories f*** people over with this, that's another five years of waiting. As for pressure, the Conservatives got to see for themselves the vote ceiling that UKIP hit, and that momentum took a real body blow with Nigel losing his seat, and only achieving one seat in total. This impacts the 'pressure'. And when a biased yes/no question is presented ans fails, where on earth is the motivation to do anything about it going to come from. As with any major party the tories know what to do to press the right buttons, and by the sounds of it it seems like they've duped people in this one.

Like I say, I look at the practical result....Italian style politics over the last few decades is there for you to see.....PR is fairer but its practical result is a paraphrase of that old saying....'A donkey is a horse built by committee'.

I don't want that for Britain.....Whether the government is left or right....I want to judge them upon their programme in power....Not forced compromises.

As for Tories not regarding Ukip's votes seriously because they can't hurt them in many seats I think you are perhaps being short-sighted.....With a point I know the Tories certainly recognise.

If the Tories don't satisfy the Ukip question....Then all it takes is for Labour to sort themselves out and this time elect a leader who looks credible and the Tories will be in massive trouble....They will need those Ukip votes.

The Tories sort out the Ukip problem this parliament or they lose power.....Unless Labour elect another weak leader again.


Edited by Stirlingsays (09 May 2015 11.34pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 09 May 15 11.39pm

How the hell can the Tories hold a referendum when they don't want us to leave?The whole thing will be fixed beyond belief. They are even planning to let the EU immigrants who currently live here vote! for Fxxx sake, really?

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

imbored Flag UK 09 May 15 11.39pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 09 May 2015 11.33pm

Quote imbored at 09 May 2015 11.23pm


It's not a matter of being a fan of something or not. It's the stone cold facts, that if this election had been PR there would've been a much more 'locked in' unbiased EU vote based on the numbers. We all know that UKIP are a one issue party and success on that front would've been more certain under PR this time around. As farage himself knows. Since this is the issue you blessed FPTP for I just thought I'd highlight the facts.

If the tories f*** people over with this, that's another five years of waiting. As for pressure, the Conservatives got to see for themselves the vote ceiling that UKIP hit, and that momentum took a real body blow with Nigel losing his seat, and only achieving one seat in total. This impacts the 'pressure'. And when a biased yes/no question is presented ans fails, where on earth is the motivation to do anything about it going to come from. As with any major party the tories know what to do to press the right buttons, and by the sounds of it it seems like they've duped people in this one.

Like I say, I look at the practical result....Italian style politics over the last few decades is there for you to see.....PR is fairer but its practical result is a paraphrase of that old saying....'A donkey is a horse built by committee'.

I don't want that for Britain.....Whether the government is left or right....I want to judge them upon their programme in power....Not forced compromises.

As for Tories not regarding Ukip's votes seriously because they can't hurt them in many seats I think you are perhaps being short-sighted.....With a point I know the Tories certainly recognise.

If the Tories don't satisfy the Ukip question....Then all it takes is for Labour to sort themselves out and this time elect a leader who looks credible and the Tories will be in massive trouble....They will need those Ukip votes.

The Tories sort out the Ukip problem this parliament or they lose power.....Unless Labour elect another weak leader again.


Edited by Stirlingsays (09 May 2015 11.34pm)

It depends if we're talking about PR in this election alone or a system in general. Your previous reply seemed like you were thanking the current system for a potential EU vote. I was just stating that this time around a fair EU vote would've irrefutably been more likely under PR based on the numbers.

I definitely see there being a vote, but there's already a blueprint for how to skew that to high heaven. The EU doesn't want us to leave, the US doesn't want us to, and Cameron doesn't. Those in power get what they want. If we don't truly appreciate that already, we'll get to experience it in 2017.

As for Labour, unless David Miliband cuts his US stay short, I'm not sure I hold out much hope for them.

Edited by imbored (10 May 2015 12.32am)

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > EU Referendum - In or Out?