You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Union bashing
November 22 2026 1.57am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Union bashing


Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 15 May 15 12.16pm

I thought the Thread Title was a job offer ....Disapointed.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

legaleagle Flag 15 May 15 12.35pm

Quote derben at 15 May 2015 12.10pm

Quote imbored at 14 May 2015 7.06pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 6.11pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 6.01pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm

Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.

Cunds

Impossible? Why impossible?

50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike.
So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.

Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.

Not Communist block suppression. No. But still suppression. We already have among the harshest anti union laws in the western world as it is.


Edited by nickgusset (14 May 2015 6.03pm)

Lucky you are not in South Africa, they shoot striking workers there.

This is basically the equivalent of slapping your wife then telling her to be thankful she's not in the middle east being stoned to death?


Edited by imbored (14 May 2015 7.08pm)

No it is not. It is merely pointing out that Britain supposedly having 'the harshest anti union laws' is nonsense when regimes like South Africa (that gussett no doubt generally supports) shoots striking workers dead. Where were the protest marches and denunciations of it from the left by the way?


Do at least try not to let your knee jerk prejudices and tunnel vision analysis evidence themselves so manifestly?.

From the "Unite" union website,as an example.

"As the world becomes smaller Unite members are becoming increasingly engaged in action to support workers and communities across borders and continents. Unite is affiliated to the following campaigning organisations.

ACTSAAction for Southern Africa

...ACTSA has longstanding and close ties with many organisations, including unions, across southern Africa and in the UK. Unite is affiliated to ACTSA and has supported many of its campaigns, including work on Zimbabwe, Swaziland and justice for South African miners."

Edited by legaleagle (15 May 2015 12.35pm)

 

npn Flag Crowborough 15 May 15 12.48pm

I've always found it amazing that retired workers who are still members of the union get to vote on strike action. They won't have to walk out and lose a day's pay (must be some sort of power trip to be able to insist on people who actually stand to lose out by strike action when you won't personally be affected).

The comparisons with elections are, of course, fallacious (as I'm sure those making them are well aware). Expecting a decent majority in a yes/no decision seems far more reasonable than expecting it in a Con/Lab/LD/Green/UKIP/SNP/PC/Other choice.

If you get a quarter of the votes in an upwards of 6 horse race, you're doing pretty well.

Anyone who is still working and fails to vote is a bit spineless in my opinion (I can understand the whole "none of the above, they are all weasels" attitude in an election, but "I don't know whether to strike or not so I'll just leave it to others to decide" seems an indication of indifference to the issue)

 

Stuk Flag Top half 15 May 15 12.52pm

Quote npn at 15 May 2015 12.48pm

I've always found it amazing that retired workers who are still members of the union get to vote on strike action. They won't have to walk out and lose a day's pay (must be some sort of power trip to be able to insist on people who actually stand to lose out by strike action when you won't personally be affected).

The comparisons with elections are, of course, fallacious (as I'm sure those making them are well aware). Expecting a decent majority in a yes/no decision seems far more reasonable than expecting it in a Con/Lab/LD/Green/UKIP/SNP/PC/Other choice.

If you get a quarter of the votes in an upwards of 6 horse race, you're doing pretty well.

Anyone who is still working and fails to vote is a bit spineless in my opinion (I can understand the whole "none of the above, they are all weasels" attitude in an election, but "I don't know whether to strike or not so I'll just leave it to others to decide" seems an indication of indifference to the issue)

Can't disagree with any of that.

 


Optimistic as ever

derben Flag 15 May 15 1.03pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 12.35pm

Quote derben at 15 May 2015 12.10pm

Quote imbored at 14 May 2015 7.06pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 6.11pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 6.01pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm

Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.

Cunds

Impossible? Why impossible?

50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike.
So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.

Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.

Not Communist block suppression. No. But still suppression. We already have among the harshest anti union laws in the western world as it is.


Edited by nickgusset (14 May 2015 6.03pm)

Lucky you are not in South Africa, they shoot striking workers there.

This is basically the equivalent of slapping your wife then telling her to be thankful she's not in the middle east being stoned to death?


Edited by imbored (14 May 2015 7.08pm)

No it is not. It is merely pointing out that Britain supposedly having 'the harshest anti union laws' is nonsense when regimes like South Africa (that gussett no doubt generally supports) shoots striking workers dead. Where were the protest marches and denunciations of it from the left by the way?


Do at least try not to let your knee jerk prejudices and tunnel vision analysis evidence themselves so manifestly?.

From the "Unite" union website,as an example.

"As the world becomes smaller Unite members are becoming increasingly engaged in action to support workers and communities across borders and continents. Unite is affiliated to the following campaigning organisations.

ACTSAAction for Southern Africa

...ACTSA has longstanding and close ties with many organisations, including unions, across southern Africa and in the UK. Unite is affiliated to ACTSA and has supported many of its campaigns, including work on Zimbabwe, Swaziland and justice for South African miners."

Edited by legaleagle (15 May 2015 12.35pm)

As I say, where were the protest marches and denunciations of it from the left? All I recall there were a few mumbled 'oh dears' and embarrassed shrugs. Imagine if a similar act was carried out by a regime that the left disapproves of. Imagine the number of marches, the calls for sanctions etc. Very similar to their reaction to Palestinian violence as opposed to Israeli violence. The left's level of outrage depends on who is involved.

Edited by derben (15 May 2015 1.06pm)

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 15 May 15 1.22pm

Quote derben at 15 May 2015 1.03pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 12.35pm

Quote derben at 15 May 2015 12.10pm

Quote imbored at 14 May 2015 7.06pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 6.11pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 6.01pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm

Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.

Cunds

Impossible? Why impossible?

50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike.
So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.

Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.

Not Communist block suppression. No. But still suppression. We already have among the harshest anti union laws in the western world as it is.


Edited by nickgusset (14 May 2015 6.03pm)

Lucky you are not in South Africa, they shoot striking workers there.

This is basically the equivalent of slapping your wife then telling her to be thankful she's not in the middle east being stoned to death?


Edited by imbored (14 May 2015 7.08pm)

No it is not. It is merely pointing out that Britain supposedly having 'the harshest anti union laws' is nonsense when regimes like South Africa (that gussett no doubt generally supports) shoots striking workers dead. Where were the protest marches and denunciations of it from the left by the way?


Do at least try not to let your knee jerk prejudices and tunnel vision analysis evidence themselves so manifestly?.

From the "Unite" union website,as an example.

"As the world becomes smaller Unite members are becoming increasingly engaged in action to support workers and communities across borders and continents. Unite is affiliated to the following campaigning organisations.

ACTSAAction for Southern Africa

...ACTSA has longstanding and close ties with many organisations, including unions, across southern Africa and in the UK. Unite is affiliated to ACTSA and has supported many of its campaigns, including work on Zimbabwe, Swaziland and justice for South African miners."

Edited by legaleagle (15 May 2015 12.35pm)

As I say, where were the protest marches and denunciations of it from the left? All I recall there were a few mumbled 'oh dears' and embarrassed shrugs. Imagine if a similar act was carried out by a regime that the left disapproves of. Imagine the number of marches, the calls for sanctions etc. Very similar to their reaction to Palestinian violence as opposed to Israeli violence. The left's level of outrage depends on who is involved.

Edited by derben (15 May 2015 1.06pm)


If you put an event in context, the regularity of it and the wider implications - if there are any - then why there is disparity in reactions compared to other nasty events is pretty clear and rational. You can't get angry at every worldwide misdemeanour just to balance one's repulsion at the IDF bulldozing tens of thousands of houses and shooting youngsters in cold blood. The human mind does not work like that.

Now if SA miners were being massacred every other year and were dispossessed and were held in ghettoes and were being tortured then obviously it would be comparable.

Your own reaction to murdering innocents depends, it appears, on who is doing the murdering.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Pussay Patrol Flag 15 May 15 2.04pm

It's also to ensure strikes are no longer called for frivolous reasons like protecting a train driver who was pissed while driving a train

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 15 May 15 2.39pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 6.01pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm

Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.

Cunds

Impossible? Why impossible?

50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike.
So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.

Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.

Not Communist block suppression. No. But still suppression. We already have among the harshest anti union laws in the western world as it is.


Edited by nickgusset (14 May 2015 6.03pm)

Not really surprising though seeing the unions ripped the absolute sh*t out of the public during the 70s & 80s.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 May 15 2.58pm

Quote Pussay Patrol at 15 May 2015 2.04pm

It's also to ensure strikes are no longer called for frivolous reasons like protecting a train driver who was pissed while driving a train

I'm sure that's exactly what the Conservatives agenda in going after the Unions is, making sure they don't do things like that.

Also the strike was over the use of only a breathaliser to determine whether someone was drunk, without corroborating evidence (urine sample or blood test). Breathalisers can produce false positive results in certain situations - Which is why the police don't rely entirely on just a breath test (they take a secondary sample to corroborate evidence in accordance with legal advice.

And I agree, before dismissing someone for an offence its best to be certain. I'd probably fail a drug test as my medication will give a false positive result in many tests for MDMA as it is a serotonin Specific Reuptake Inhibitor.

I'd object to being fired without a reliable second measure to eliminate a false positive.

But don't let the facts get in the way.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 May 15 3.01pm

Quote derben at 15 May 2015 12.10pm

Quote imbored at 14 May 2015 7.06pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 6.11pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 6.01pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm

Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.

Cunds

Impossible? Why impossible?

50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike.
So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.

Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.

Not Communist block suppression. No. But still suppression. We already have among the harshest anti union laws in the western world as it is.


Edited by nickgusset (14 May 2015 6.03pm)

Lucky you are not in South Africa, they shoot striking workers there.

This is basically the equivalent of slapping your wife then telling her to be thankful she's not in the middle east being stoned to death?


Edited by imbored (14 May 2015 7.08pm)

No it is not. It is merely pointing out that Britain supposedly having 'the harshest anti union laws' is nonsense when regimes like South Africa (that gussett no doubt generally supports) shoots striking workers dead. Where were the protest marches and denunciations of it from the left by the way?

South African Anti-Union laws don't actually permit shooting protesters to death, similarly Apathied law didn't legally allow extra judicial police murders of dissdents such as Steve Bilko.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 May 15 3.03pm

Quote Southampton_Eagle at 15 May 2015 2.39pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 6.01pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm

Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.

Cunds

Impossible? Why impossible?

50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike.
So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.

Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.

Not Communist block suppression. No. But still suppression. We already have among the harshest anti union laws in the western world as it is.


Edited by nickgusset (14 May 2015 6.03pm)

Not really surprising though seeing the unions ripped the absolute sh*t out of the public during the 70s & 80s.

Not really so much in the 80s, the Conservative party was fully intending to take on the Unions, specifically the Miners and Power workers and break them.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Fatherken Flag 15 May 15 3.45pm

I wonder what pay and conditions all those people who complain about unions and strikes would be working in now if it were not for unions

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 15 May 15 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 15 May 15 4.05pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable


Thanks for the recap

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

legaleagle Flag 15 May 15 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 15 May 15 4.27pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.


To be a fair comparator though the options would need to be on a spectrum which is more like (1) we are being treated like dogs (2) it's a bit unfair but I don't mind (3) I don't think it's that bad etc. with only option 1 counting as a strike.

It is far easier to achieve 40% on a yes/no basis than it is when there are sometimes up to 10 options. With that in mind, that the two figures are so close seems to make it fairly legitimate

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Stuk Flag Top half 15 May 15 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

 


Optimistic as ever

derben Flag 15 May 15 4.41pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 3.01pm

Quote derben at 15 May 2015 12.10pm

Quote imbored at 14 May 2015 7.06pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 6.11pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 6.01pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm

Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.

Cunds

Impossible? Why impossible?

50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike.
So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.

Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.

Not Communist block suppression. No. But still suppression. We already have among the harshest anti union laws in the western world as it is.


Edited by nickgusset (14 May 2015 6.03pm)

Lucky you are not in South Africa, they shoot striking workers there.

This is basically the equivalent of slapping your wife then telling her to be thankful she's not in the middle east being stoned to death?


Edited by imbored (14 May 2015 7.08pm)

No it is not. It is merely pointing out that Britain supposedly having 'the harshest anti union laws' is nonsense when regimes like South Africa (that gussett no doubt generally supports) shoots striking workers dead. Where were the protest marches and denunciations of it from the left by the way?

South African Anti-Union laws don't actually permit shooting protesters to death, similarly Apathied law didn't legally allow extra judicial police murders of dissdents such as Steve Bilko.

I think we might agree - both government are/were appalling. What also appalls me is that most of the left only sees the evil of the aparthied government and turns a blind eye to the racism and corruption of the new government. (Similar to Kermit's post on here about appalling Israeli acts while totally ignoring appalling acts of the Palestinians.)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 May 15 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

derben Flag 15 May 15 4.44pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 4.41pm

Quote Stuk at 15 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 4.20pm

Quote ambrose7 at 15 May 2015 3.58pm

There seems to be a lot of opposition on this thread stating why we should have trade unions and why they should be able to strike, and very few addressing why a 40% pass rate is so unreasonable

Perhaps we should link the % votes ability to strike to the % votes ability of a government to proclaim its legitimacy given the percentage of votes it got? At the moment,that would lower the % rate to 36.9%.

A general election is nothing like a strike ballot which is almost always a basic yes or no.

Stop comparing them, they're nothing like each other.

I think its the inconsistency of a government that has a 37% return, demanding that other systems of approval must represent a much higher figure.

The reality of the unions is that a strike ballot can only be conducted lawfully, by post. Which is about the most inconsistent and unreliable means by which to do so.

The idea that the number of votes necessary should be based on the number of members rather than the returns is absurd, because the returns include no votes as well and may well be related to a local rather than national matter.

But the whole thing is a strawman argument, because the actual reality of the Conservative position isn't about the percentages at all, its about reducing the power and influence of Unions and the capacity of unions to act against the interests of the Government and of Employers.

People who bang on about the percentages are missing the point, the people supporting the anti-union laws aren't interested in whether its 8% of the total membership, or 90% - they want to see the power of unions restricted, they'd support anti-union laws even if the strike actions were returning 100% of the members wishes for strike action.

No we wouldn't.

Edited by derben (15 May 2015 4.45pm)

 

Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Union bashing