This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| derben |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 4.16pm
This is appalling.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote matt_himself at 15 May 2015 6.58am
Given that the typical migrant you're discussing is employed, working and functionally active within society they aren't forming an underclass. Underclasses generally are groups outside of the operational structures of a class system and operation - such as travelers, gypsies, the homeless and maybe potentially the long term unemployed and unemployable. However, there is definitely an issue regarding the last part of that list. The use of migrant labour, which essentially is temporary labour has restricted the growth of wages in relation to the cost of living resulting in forcing people into a position where working isn't viable (governments maintain as much responsibility in this for not linking the minimum wage to a real cost of living (whilst benefits were). This meant that welfare payments rose, whilst the minimum wage didn't. A resultant problem of this, is that it becomes more viable in certain situations to retain welfare than to work. The migrant workers aren't actually the problem, its the fact that coming from countries with lower costs and suitable exchange rates, the income earned here translates much more significantly back in say Poland - Plus the need to maintain dependency costs such as family are negligible in the UK so they can rent bedsits shared housing etc (something that's not an option if you have a family). Being a migrant worker long term, has little value, because the reality is that if you settle here long term, you get caught in the same trap that affects the unemployed here (the fact that wages in low skill work are actually below the proposed living wage). There are probably some areas that have, as a result become say, European worker ghettos, but in my experience, those areas were hardly prestigious zones of social wonder. The problems of South London, Norwood etc isn't down to migration, its the death of industry. These were areas which typically fed into the large scale industry and employment, that died off through the 80s and 90s, and has seen well paid working class low and no skill work, replaced with service industry jobs or McJobs to borrow a phrase. My family from Norwood and Crystal Palace, all worked in assorted working class jobs that have in my life time shrunk down the scale of the work force, and the opportunities of employment, due to large scale rationalization of services and technological developments within industrial jobs
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 12.21pm
Quote matt_himself at 15 May 2015 11.23am
I think you are taking a far too romantic view of the life of an immigrant in Britain. I do not dispute that there is a thin number that are 'highly skilled professionals' who enjoy the benefits of London & all that comes with it. Good on them. Then there is the rest and life isn't that romantic. Living in run down areas, doing crap jobs and living on the margins. It is a system that we have created and are perpetuating. It is tantamount to modern slavery, in many ways. However, as long as we romanticise the issue, it can be swept under the carpet and arguments & labels used against those seeking to discuss this. I will ignore the comment about the foreign languages and stick to the question. Why does the left appear to endorse this system whereby people are shipped in to do rubbish jobs, in rubbish conditions? They don't even question it and it has serious effects, not least creating an unemployment pool of nigh on 2 million in this country. Do bear in mind that statistics indicate c.32% of recent EU immigrants have a degree (a figure about 50% higher than that within the general UK population). The comment about foreign languages was made only because you suggested immigrants don't speak English! Would you agree many people in the UK over the past 100-150 years prior to the year 2000 ended up doing "rubbish jobs" in "rubbish conditions" living in "run down" areas? Why was this the case? Would a solution to having loads of people doing "rubbish jobs" in "rubbish conditions" be to have a higher minimum hourly wage,greater legal restrictions on having inadequate working conditions, and to enforce this extremely vigorously,with very strong sanctions against employers who ignored this and exploited those who work for them? If not,why not? Edited by legaleagle (15 May 2015 12.22pm) This is generally my experience. When I was at FJU we had a Slovak receptionist, who had a degree in Physics and two Polish women running the cafeteria, one had a masters in Economics and the other a PhD in Psychology. All of them were fluent in English, Russian, German and their home languages. We also had a cleaner who was a qualified lecturer in his home country, but was cleaning in the UK, whilst awaiting the chance to sit his 'teaching qualification' that would allow him to teach at GCSE and A-Level - But he was a technically a citizen, having been granted asylum from Iran.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote matt_himself at 15 May 2015 1.19pm
Quote Kermit8 at 15 May 2015 1.04pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 1.00pm
Quote legaleagle at 15 May 2015 12.21pm
Quote matt_himself at 15 May 2015 11.23am
I think you are taking a far too romantic view of the life of an immigrant in Britain. I do not dispute that there is a thin number that are 'highly skilled professionals' who enjoy the benefits of London & all that comes with it. Good on them. Then there is the rest and life isn't that romantic. Living in run down areas, doing crap jobs and living on the margins. It is a system that we have created and are perpetuating. It is tantamount to modern slavery, in many ways. However, as long as we romanticise the issue, it can be swept under the carpet and arguments & labels used against those seeking to discuss this. I will ignore the comment about the foreign languages and stick to the question. Why does the left appear to endorse this system whereby people are shipped in to do rubbish jobs, in rubbish conditions? They don't even question it and it has serious effects, not least creating an unemployment pool of nigh on 2 million in this country. Do bear in mind that statistics indicate c.32% of recent EU immigrants have a degree (a figure about 50% higher than that within the general UK population). The comment about foreign languages was made only because you suggested immigrants don't speak English! Would you agree many people in the UK over the past 100-150 years prior to the year 2000 ended up doing "rubbish jobs" in "rubbish conditions" living in "run down" areas? Why was this the case? Would a solution to having loads of people doing "rubbish jobs" in "rubbish conditions" be to have a higher minimum hourly wage,greater legal restrictions on having inadequate working conditions, and to enforce this extremely vigorously,with very strong sanctions against employers who ignored this and exploited those who work for them? If not,why not? Edited by legaleagle (15 May 2015 12.22pm) This is generally my experience. When I was at FJU we had a Slovak receptionist, who had a degree in Physics and two Polish women running the cafeteria, one had a masters in Economics and the other a PhD in Psychology. All of them were fluent in English, Russian, German and their home languages. We also had a cleaner who was a qualified lecturer in his home country, but was cleaning in the UK, whilst awaiting the chance to sit his 'teaching qualification' that would allow him to teach at GCSE and A-Level - But he was a technically a citizen, having been granted asylum from Iran.
I don't think the guys dropped off by the construction companies vans drinking Tennants Super in Thornton Heath pond of an evening have such lofty titles or qualifications. I don't think the guys driving the minicabs or operating the car washes in Purley Way have the same titles or qualifications. However, as this is obviously something you, Jamie and Legal have not encountered, nor wish to encounter or address, shall we say that whilst you think all immigrants to this country are having a ball (as highly skilled, upwardly social individuals) and I don't agree that this & think most are being taken advantage of & are living on the fringes of society, we should agree to disagree? Edited by matt_himself (15 May 2015 1.21pm) Just not my experience, I don't doubt they exist. But I wouldn't assume that they don't either just because they're doing a non-skilled job. Most of the Indian Call center staff are highly educated. They're generally here for the work and the fact that the money goes a lot further back home than here. I wouldn't assume just because someone is driving a minicab or working at a car wash that they're uneducated. Driving a cab can be quite lucrative, even a minicab.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.