Quote serial thriller at 28 May 2015 1.29pm
Quote derben at 28 May 2015 1.10pm
Quote serial thriller at 28 May 2015 12.40pm
Quote derben at 28 May 2015 12.32pm
Quote serial thriller at 28 May 2015 12.09pm
Quote derben at 28 May 2015 11.48am
So if was not for the evil USA, all these attempts to build Socialism would succeed? It is not that is just doesn't work then?
Are the 'Kurds in Northern Syria' a Socialist country then? Are immigrants flooding in to share in the largese of the Kurdish region and the Spanish communes and South American Socialist states? Or are their populations in fact clamouring to get out.
Successful Capitalist countries, the majority of them - top ten most prosperous countries are thought to be: Norway, Denmark, Finland, Australia, New Zealand, Sweden, Canada, Switzerland, Netherlands, USA.
That first point suggests you haven't read my original post. I am sceptical of many Socialist projects, many are very discriminatory and corrupt and thus regardless of American interference I wouldn't personally deem them as successful - if Cuba is locking up homosexuals then they are not worth any egalitarian status. BUT to ignore the role that American covert intervention has played, particularly in South America is to be blinded by your Capitalist ideology.
Point 2. Of course people aren't flooding in to Rojava and neighbouring areas, they're being bombed the f*ck out of by people who want to butcher them! They are an autonomous region based on the principles of Anarchist-Communism, which is really f*cking incredible given the situation they are in, but they are fighting a war, and while many Kurds from surrounding areas are supporting them, being in a war zone is not conducive to welcoming in many refugees! As far as I'm aware though, migration from South American nations and Spanish towns like Marinaleda are as you would expect. These are incredibly impoverished areas, not really capable of housing migrants on a mass scale, although the proliferation of their ideology in local areas is encouraging.
This really brings me on to your last point. If you're going to judge a nation's success on their financial prosperity then you not only exclude most Socialist nations whose focus on egalitarianism supersedes economic growth, but you are also ignoring the systematic vices of nations like Australia and America. Until the 1970s, Australians classified Aboriginies among plants and animals, thus condoning the woeful murder of much of the native population. Even now, one only has to look at their record on taking in migrants from the pacific to see how racist a nation it is. America has similar records on both counts, committing genocide on the Native Americans, having a quarter of the world's prison population which is 80% black doing unpaid labour (which, let's make no bones about it, is slavery) while having the most hideous and contemptible foreign policies since the British empire.
Can I also say how ironic it is that of the successful countries you chose, you point to so many social democracies despite having said previously that you'd vote for UKIP!
Don't know what gay rights has to with Socialism - did Marx cover it?
lol I bet the workers appreciate that.
The core of Socialism is state control of all means of production, distribution and exchange. When attempts to run an economy on this basis inevitably start to fail, the state becomes increasing oppressive in order to control the elements (ie: the majority of ordinary people) that is sees as the causes of their failure (and the wicked USA too of course). In some cases they then abandon their failed Socialist 'economics' and revert to Capitalism (as in the Peoples Republic of China, often while retaining their non-democratic, one-party, oppression of the people they supposedly want to help.
Of course the numbers involved in the likes of the Australian aboriginie atrocities are a drop in the ocean of blood and mountains of corpses generated by the likes of Socialists, Stalin, Mao Tse-Tung and Pol Pot.
I wish the Kurds luck with their Anarchist-Communism set-up (I expect frying pans and fires must be in the thoughts of ordinary working Kurds).
Inaccurate understanding of what Socialism is, confusing it with authoritarianism - check.
A general defence of Capitalist atrocity by playing the 'how many people did each ideology kill?' game - check.
And as a surprise bonus point, a suggestion that any form of anti-Capitalist society is worse than ISIS - check.
Edited by serial thriller (28 May 2015 12.41pm)
Most Socialist states have been authoritarian and non-democratic, oppressing the very people they say they are 'liberating'.
Defending Capitalist atrocities am I? Lol, I called the Aborigine genocide an atrocity.
Certainly it is reasonable to compare body counts.
Worse than ISIS? lol, just as well that I did not say that. What I am suggesting is that the ordinary Kurd in the street is probably just longing for a normal life free from Islamic extremists, totalitarian dictators, foreign armies and far-left experimentalists - I expect he would prefer a form of Western-style Capitalist democracy.
'Most socialist states'. Have you actually got anything to back that up? Look up the Paris commune or the many different examples of socialism and anarchism in Spain in the 30s. Socialism doesn't just start and end with the Soviet Union...
Even the Socialist states of South America are democratically elected. That means, and I know this will be tough to take, that the 'average working man' is the person instigating socialist ideology. Going back to Venezuela, it's actually the middle- and upper-classes who have been far more prevalent critics of the Maduro government.
The Kurds are very anti-authoritarian, which is unsurprising considering they have one of the most didactic ideologies in the world on their doorstep. All decisions are made in regional assemblies, meaning that again the 'average working Kurd' is an active member of their political community. They actually have greater democratic rights than we do in this country!
China, Cuba, Laos, Vietnam, Albania, Cambodia, USSR, East Germany, Hungrary, Bulgaria, Angola, Congo, Czechoslovakia, Ethiopia, Mozambique, Poland, Romania, Somalia, North Korea, Yugoslavia are a few that immediately spring to mind, no doubt there are others people might like to add.
Wow, if this Kurdish commune is as you say Anarchist-Communist, I would think they risk being thrown out of the 'Association of Anarchist-Communist Communes' for embracing bourgeois democratic practices. Mind you, being Anarchists, I imagine their committee and procedures are pretty chaotic?
|