Quote ghosteagle at 09 Jun 2015 4.31pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Jun 2015 11.42am
Quote ghosteagle at 09 Jun 2015 11.35am
Quote dannyh at 09 Jun 2015 11.28am
Moral of the story ?
Don't wave a gun a about on Facebook threatining all and sundry.
Thing is Hoof, he was a known arsehole, with witness reports confirming and laterly confirmed by Police that he was in possession of a firearm.
It situations like this where you have split seconds to make a choice (that could mean your life, or worse the life of a colleague or civilian)you have to operate on the balance of probability and all the evidence available at the time would point to him being armed and dangerous.
At what point then do you suggest that police marksmen open fire, only when fired upon ? That’s to late Hoof, the law has to be on the balance of probability did the officer that fired believe his life or the life of others to be at risk, if the answer is yes, and the Jury seem to agree with me on this, then it has to be classed as lawful.
I also loved the fact the programme (as did his mouthy cow of a mother) managed to gloss over the fact he was in possession/owned an illegal firearm, did he deserve to die because of this, no, he should’ve spent a long time in jail, should he have bragged about it on social media, I think we know the answer to that one.
This really is a case of don’t play with fire and you won’t get burnt.
When they see a gun? When they are threatened? etc etc
Given the heat of the moment, the fear and the need to act quickly, that's very hard to do. Ultimately, you don't want a shoot out that risks the life of bystanders from stray rounds (or police officers).
Perception is a funny thing, especially in tense moments, we often see what fits our expectations, rather than what is there.
Training only goes so far, the reality of making split second decisions, its unreasonable to expect police officers to take excessive risks to their own lives when confronting armed suspects.
Duggan probably shouldn't have been shot, and maybe both sides could have done a better job in assuring he wasn't shot.
But this isn't Jean Charles de Menezes, either. This is a man who had purchased a firearm, to explicitly kill someone else. Its not about whether he deserved what happened, but whether the actions of the officers who fired were reasonable force.
Shooting an unarmed man dead is reasonable force? Pull the other one. Excuses aside, they made a serious mistake and got off scot-free. If a civilian kills someone by accident its manslaughter, if the police do it they walk. Sounds fair.
You seem to be forgetting that the officer who fired the shots believed that Duggan was in possession of a firearm. He didn't think 'ah an unarmed man, I'll just shoot him dead'
This was confusing people at the time of the verdict. Yes the majority of the jury were satisfied that Duggan had thrown the gun prior to being shot. This meant that THEY were satisfied.. not that the Police knew he had thrown the gun.
The officer responsible still thought that Duggan was in possession of a firearm, which seeing as they knew 100% he did have due to the surveillance operation was not an unrealistic assumption to make. He did not see it being thrown by Duggan (something that we now know did happen and the jury were satisfied happened.... That wonderful word called hindsight springs to mind) and had an honest held belief it was in his hand, lives were at risk and shot him.
I was a firearms officer myself for a few years. Glock and MP5.. The training is very intense but as JamieM pointed out it can never substitute a real life scenario. The 'split second' saying is banded around a lot but it's so true, that's all the time you have to make a potentially devastating decision.
Tough job and all that do it would be happy if they spent their entire career not having to fire a single shot.
Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!
|