You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Hiroshima
November 22 2026 1.57am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hiroshima


Page 2 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
TheJudge Flag 06 Aug 15 3.50pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Aug 2015 3.44pm

Quote TheJudge at 06 Aug 2015 3.33pm

My position is this. To see human suffering on that scale is terrible but it has to be put in contest.
The US was attacked without reason or warning and defended itself. Ultimately Japan should have surrendered long before it did and certainly before the second Atomic bomb was dropped. The Americans were met with an enemy who put honour and victory before life and suffered many casualties on the ground and at sea through suicide attacks. They put American lives first.
ALso the Russians cold not be trusted and might have moved into Asia. As much the use of the bomb appalls me, it has to be seen in that context and history cannot be revised just because it suits current political correctness. The Japanese were ruthless cruel and fanatical and thought we were weak and cowardly. They were wrong.

Well arguably we were weak and cowardly, as we dropped the Atomic bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. As a result, the US probably avoided at least 100,000 casualties (probably closer to at least 500,000+).

The Japanese would of course have said they fought honorably and bravely, rather than ruthless and cruelly. But that's all irrelevant when you can vaporize an entire city (and to them it would have seemed 'almost at will'.

Probably less than 100 people knew what happened that day, and none of them were in Japan.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (06 Aug 2015 3.47pm)

How easy it is to adopt these attitudes when you are on the winning side.
I wonder if you or Ghostweazel would have hesitated to press the button if the Japanese had been at your gate.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Aug 15 3.56pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 06 Aug 2015 3.34pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Aug 2015 3.25pm

Quote ghosteagle at 06 Aug 2015 3.17pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Aug 2015 10.33pm

70 years ago. Always thought it was a necessary evil but not so sure now.

[Link]

Then again the Japanese still refused to surrender and of course the atrocities they committed were absolutely horrific.

Worryingly there is a significant movement within Japan trying to rewrite history.
[Link]

Considering that the japanese were trying to surrender before the bomb was even dropped i'd say it was pretty unnecessary.

That some of the Japanese government were talking about surrender doesn't necessarily mean that they were intending to surrender.

Even after Hiroshima, there was still discussion of surrender and continuation. Nagasaki pretty much cleared the argument up (although had the Japanese known the US only had maybe three more bombs, they might have held out).


I don't think they even had one more, let alone three.

Anyway, it's pointless trying to apply present day attitudes and moralise about it so long after the event. Point is, it shortened a war which the Japanese, a particularly nasty bunch of c*nts, had no hesitation in starting.

They had one more ready for production, that could have been deployed on the 19th August, and enough material to produce six more by the end of October.

Its quite likely that the act of deploying the bomb at Hiroshima and Nagasaki ultimately fed into the detent of the cold war. Had those two events not occurred, the worlds knowledge of the true horror of nuclear weapons would have been theoretical, rather than practical. The impact of that on the cold war was probably as much a factor in keeping the peace as anything else (even after the Soviets built and tested their own weapons).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Aug 15 4.07pm

Quote TheJudge at 06 Aug 2015 3.50pm

I wonder if you or Ghostweazel would have hesitated to press the button if the Japanese had been at your gate.

I'd probably have made the same decision as Trueman - I don't disagree with the decision. I probably would have selected Hiroshima as well (as it had largely been untouched by bombing, was an idea test target and contained about 20,000 troops). I like to think I'd have struggled to live with that decision for the rest of my life. I'd like to think I'd have waited more than three days to drop the bomb on Nagasaki.

It would be a mistake to assume the US weren't interested in 'researching the effectiveness of their new super weapon'.

Doesn't make it somehow right or good, but a regrettable necessity. I also think, if the Germans or Japanese had used such a weapon, and lost the war, then it would have been a war crime.

Also the Japanese were hardly at the American gate. It also was six days after Nagasaki that the Japanese surrendered, four days before the US could deploy a third bomb (Nagasaki, a port, was a target more of convenience, as Kyoto was obscured by cloud formations, so the target was switched).

Toyko was dismissed as a target due to having been hit heavily by bombers throughout the war, and lacked much in the way of suitable targets.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

TheJudge Flag 06 Aug 15 5.49pm

But what point are you trying to make ?

It was War. The Japanese were the aggressors and they seriously underestimated America. The Americans could have won that war at a canter if they had not committed most of their troops and resources to Europe. The Japanese would have fought to the last man with their government happy to sacrifice huge numbers in a lost cause.
Who is to say if the bombs actually saved net lives ?

These retrospective questions are pointless.
Let's ask if Britain would have been better of surrendering to the Germans. I bet I could present a rational argument, but what for ? What is done is done and the best thing to do is learn from history, not rewrite it over and over. The victors write history and that is the way it has always been.

 

Jamesrichards8 Flag 06 Aug 15 5.56pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 8.31am

It was a real life medical experiment without anaesthetic by the US.

They could have quite easily have dropped the bombs 40 miles from Tokyo in a non-populated area and warned that the city would be next on the list if they didn't surrender.

The population of Hiroshima at the time was mostly kids, women and old people as the men were away soldiering. Something the US would also have obviously known.

A heinous act.


It's called war, kermie. Did Japan warn the US before they hit them below the belt and torpedoed pearl harbour? If you are going to wage war, you have to understand the penalty. Japan gambled, played stupidly, and lost big time.

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (06 Aug 2015 5.58pm)

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

Jamesrichards8 Flag 06 Aug 15 6.01pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 8.31am

It was a real life medical experiment without anaesthetic by the US.

They could have quite easily have dropped the bombs 40 miles from Tokyo in a non-populated area and warned that the city would be next on the list if they didn't surrender.

The population of Hiroshima at the time was mostly kids, women and old people as the men were away soldiering. Something the US would also have obviously known.

A heinous act.


I can't get over what a ridiculous argument this is. I wonder if you'd think differently if thousands of your country's soldiers were dying and you had a way to stop it immtediately? By the way Japan dragged the US into the war, should've thought twice.

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 06 Aug 15 6.06pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Aug 2015 3.47pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 06 Aug 2015 3.36pm

Quote TheJudge at 06 Aug 2015 3.33pm

My position is this. To see human suffering on that scale is terrible but it has to be put in contest.
The US was attacked without reason or warning and defended itself. Ultimately Japan should have surrendered long before it did and certainly before the second Atomic bomb was dropped. The Americans were met with an enemy who put honour and victory before life and suffered many casualties on the ground and at sea through suicide attacks. They put American lives first.
ALso the Russians cold not be trusted and might have moved into Asia. As much the use of the bomb appalls me, it has to be seen in that context and history cannot be revised just because it suits current political correctness. The Japanese were ruthless cruel and fanatical and thought we were weak and cowardly. They were wrong.


They already had with Germany defeated their eyes turned east

With some success. I suspect the Russians wouldn't really have balked at the idea of losing a million men in the invasion of Japan either. Compared to the Eastern front, those were fairly light casualties compared to Stalingrad, Moscow and Leningrad



I am not sure, the Soviets were late into the War against Japan, I think it may have been 1945 before they declared war against them, and they had ample chances before then to roll up Korea or China. Initially an earlier declaration of war would have been welcomed by GB and the US.

The original post smacks of revisionist history.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 06 Aug 15 6.15pm

the devastating effect of the 2 low yield(comparitively) bombs in 1945 has probably prevented the use since then of far more destructive weapons.

 

sa_eagle Flag Just outside Cape Town 06 Aug 15 6.16pm

Whatever views we hold on this we hold them in the relative comfort of hindsight with no grasp on the context of the day.

A nuclear bomb was always going to be used in anger, whether by the US (with UK complicity) or by the Germans who were in a clear race against the US to develop the technology, or by the Russians if neither of the others had got around to it. Sadly two bombs were dropped in anger but it's fair to say that the aftermath of them is what lead to the non-proliferation treaties and prevented any further bombs being used in anger.

 


Cynic or realist? It's a fine line!

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 06 Aug 15 7.05pm

Quote Jamesrichards8 at 06 Aug 2015 5.56pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 8.31am

It was a real life medical experiment without anaesthetic by the US.

They could have quite easily have dropped the bombs 40 miles from Tokyo in a non-populated area and warned that the city would be next on the list if they didn't surrender.

The population of Hiroshima at the time was mostly kids, women and old people as the men were away soldiering. Something the US would also have obviously known.

A heinous act.


It's called war, kermie. Did Japan warn the US before they hit them below the belt and torpedoed pearl harbour? If you are going to wage war, you have to understand the penalty. Japan gambled, played stupidly, and lost big time.

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (06 Aug 2015 5.58pm)


Yer right. We should have nuked Buenos Aires in '82 and saved 256 British lives.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


shaun57 Flag chislehurst 06 Aug 15 7.09pm

No we should nuke the middle east now....
and save thousands.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 06 Aug 15 7.12pm

Quote shaun57 at 06 Aug 2015 7.09pm

No we should nuke the middle east now....
and save thousands.


Any particular part? I propose Dubai first then maybe move inland.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


TheJudge Flag 06 Aug 15 7.49pm

There were people like the lefties on this thread who didn't want to fight and complained about everything during WW2. They didn't like Churchill of course.

Some things never change. Lucky they weren't in charge.

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 06 Aug 15 7.54pm

This contemporary poster sums up the US attitude to Japan during the WW2.

The caption says A war worker writes her navy boy friend a thank you note for the Jap skull he sent her.

womanandskull.jpg Attachment: womanandskull.jpg (54.16Kb)

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 06 Aug 15 8.00pm

Quote pefwin at 06 Aug 2015 6.06pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Aug 2015 3.47pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 06 Aug 2015 3.36pm

Quote TheJudge at 06 Aug 2015 3.33pm

My position is this. To see human suffering on that scale is terrible but it has to be put in contest.
The US was attacked without reason or warning and defended itself. Ultimately Japan should have surrendered long before it did and certainly before the second Atomic bomb was dropped. The Americans were met with an enemy who put honour and victory before life and suffered many casualties on the ground and at sea through suicide attacks. They put American lives first.
ALso the Russians cold not be trusted and might have moved into Asia. As much the use of the bomb appalls me, it has to be seen in that context and history cannot be revised just because it suits current political correctness. The Japanese were ruthless cruel and fanatical and thought we were weak and cowardly. They were wrong.


They already had with Germany defeated their eyes turned east

With some success. I suspect the Russians wouldn't really have balked at the idea of losing a million men in the invasion of Japan either. Compared to the Eastern front, those were fairly light casualties compared to Stalingrad, Moscow and Leningrad



I am not sure, the Soviets were late into the War against Japan, I think it may have been 1945 before they declared war against them, and they had ample chances before then to roll up Korea or China. Initially an earlier declaration of war would have been welcomed by GB and the US.

The original post smacks of revisionist history.

LOL. 'late' ! The USSR declared war on Japan on 8 August 1945 - two days after the first A-bombing. Do you think they may have thought they were on to a sure thing? Do you think Stalin was prepared to throw millions of men into the struggle Jamie?

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

suicideatselhurst Flag crawley 06 Aug 15 8.01pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 7.05pm

Quote Jamesrichards8 at 06 Aug 2015 5.56pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 8.31am

It was a real life medical experiment without anaesthetic by the US.

They could have quite easily have dropped the bombs 40 miles from Tokyo in a non-populated area and warned that the city would be next on the list if they didn't surrender.

The population of Hiroshima at the time was mostly kids, women and old people as the men were away soldiering. Something the US would also have obviously known.

A heinous act.


It's called war, kermie. Did Japan warn the US before they hit them below the belt and torpedoed pearl harbour? If you are going to wage war, you have to understand the penalty. Japan gambled, played stupidly, and lost big time.

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (06 Aug 2015 5.58pm)


Yer right. We should have nuked Buenos Aires in '82 and saved 256 British lives.


Yep we should ..and dont forget the handball by that dirty little cvnt maradonna

 


Theres someone in my head ... But its not me

X/Box game Tag bazcpfc1961, clan (HMS)

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 06 Aug 15 8.04pm

Sadly it was necessary as they wouldn't stop fighting. This is unfortunately the brutality of war. A dreadful thing to do but there was no other choice.
Dresden was also brutal but again the Nazis wouldn't stop fighting. The left of course cry about it now and say the likes of 'Bomber' Harris are war criminals, but then the left are stupid.

 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 06 Aug 15 8.07pm

Quote fed up eagle at 06 Aug 2015 8.04pm

Sadly it was necessary as they wouldn't stop fighting. This is unfortunately the brutality of war. A dreadful thing to do but there was no other choice.
Dresden was also brutal but again the Nazis wouldn't stop fighting. The left of course cry about it now and say the likes of 'Bomber' Harris are war criminals, but then the left are stupid.

Dresden was wrong. There were far more appropriate targets that were less risky to our crews for our bombers to attack anyway.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

Jamesrichards8 Flag 06 Aug 15 8.13pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 7.05pm

Quote Jamesrichards8 at 06 Aug 2015 5.56pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 8.31am

It was a real life medical experiment without anaesthetic by the US.

They could have quite easily have dropped the bombs 40 miles from Tokyo in a non-populated area and warned that the city would be next on the list if they didn't surrender.

The population of Hiroshima at the time was mostly kids, women and old people as the men were away soldiering. Something the US would also have obviously known.

A heinous act.


It's called war, kermie. Did Japan warn the US before they hit them below the belt and torpedoed pearl harbour? If you are going to wage war, you have to understand the penalty. Japan gambled, played stupidly, and lost big time.

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (06 Aug 2015 5.58pm)


Yer right. We should have nuked Buenos Aires in '82 and saved 256 British lives.


I don't really think the falklands were on the same scale as the second world war. Also we don't have any nukes

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (06 Aug 2015 8.13pm)

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

Mr Palaceman Flag 06 Aug 15 8.15pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Aug 2015 10.33pm

70 years ago. Always thought it was a necessary evil but not so sure now.

[Link]

Then again the Japanese still refused to surrender and of course the atrocities they committed were absolutely horrific.

Worryingly there is a significant movement within Japan trying to rewrite history.
[Link]

I was unnecessary but inevitable. Once it had been developed, They had to then use it.

The Japanese tried to surrender before the bomb was dropped after Russia declared war on Japan. The bomb was dropped to show the Russians what the Allies could do.

Secret papers released decades after the war show this. I remember seeing a documentry on the released papers in around 1990. I think it was reported on the BBC at the time.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Page 2 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Hiroshima