This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Blur v Oasis
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Kosowski Standing at the top of B Block 25 Aug 15 5.07pm |
|
|
Oasis.
Blur was for queers and girls.
Block B comment of 2011/2012 Season:
"That's better Palace, better...but still fucking shit!"
----------------------------------------------------------------
Dann to Much, Much to Yong.
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 25 Aug 15 5.12pm |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 25 Aug 2015 11.07am
Quote Pussay Patrol at 25 Aug 2015 10.13am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 25 Aug 2015 8.09am
The answer is Pulp or the Auteurs (Or Suede with Bernard Butler, who just about smashed everything Oasis and Blur did in one album).
I prefer Lush (or Echobelly) to either Blur or Oasis. Both are massively over rated on the basis of popularity - They're bands indicative of more talented musicians of their time, who never grew tired of stealing a ride on the bandwagon.
I wondered how long it would take before we had the 'let me throw in an obscure name to show what a deeper music knowledge I have' post came along.
Next we'll have the usual 'I saw them before they were famous' post
I'd hardly call Pulp, Suede or the Auteurs obscure.
I saw Pulp support the cult at Finsbury Park years before they were famous. They weren't very good then...
|
Canterbury Palace Whitstable 25 Aug 15 6.15pm |
|
Quote johnfirewall at 25 Aug 2015 12.57pm
Quote Canterbury Palace at 25 Aug 2015 12.15pm
I like Blur but it's Oasis by a million miles. Also, without meaning to take the debate in a different direction, I've never agreed with the whole 'Oasis ripped off The Beatles' argument which I found to be a lazy accusation.
There were only really lyrical nods to The Beatles. Although musically T Rex and others were ripped right off.
Possibly but I don't think there are many bands these days that don't sound like at least one other band that have come before them. I just thought it was a bit rich for everybody to accuse them of ripping off the Beatles when supposed groundbreakers Radiohead (who I love) basically used the music for Sexy Sadie and The Air That I Breathe for Karma Police and Creep.
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...
|
ricky s Hampshire 25 Aug 15 6.28pm |
|
|
I'm an oasis fan so slightly bias.. Although my first ever 7 inch vinal bought was blurs 'there's no other way'. Anyway, blur reformed and had a few headline gigs and stuff.. But if oasis ever reformed it would be massive! Even if it would probably be a disaster they would make millions and sell out every stadium they wanted to play at! You went to an oasis gig to get pissed and sing along not to enjoy the quality of songwriting and vocals. Good times!!
Edited by ricky s (25 Aug 2015 6.29pm)
|
newickeagle Newick, E Sussex 25 Aug 15 6.34pm |
|
|
Anyone bought "The Magic Whip" this year ?
Blur's latest and a real gem of an album, I think.
To answer the question, love them both but Blur have the edge.
|
martinb75 Tampere 25 Aug 15 6.35pm |
|
Quote Ketteridge at 24 Aug 2015 5.03pm
Real question menswe@r v northern uproar?
Oh don't open those old wounds again ,it'll be murder I tell ya !
|
martinb75 Tampere 25 Aug 15 6.38pm |
|
Quote newickeagle at 25 Aug 2015 6.34pm
Anyone bought "The Magic Whip" this year ?
Blur's latest and a real gem of an album, I think.
To answer the question, love them both but Blur have the edge.
Magic whip is a great album....the first Blur album i have liked since their album "Blur"
|