This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Does Indiana Jones kill loads of people?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
cpfcbobby82 Leatherhead 01 Sep 15 9.29pm |
|
|
I must have seen the Indy films like 600 times each but one thing has always bothered me… when he punches bad guys do they die? They certainly seem to be out for the count but are they dead? And if they are does this make Indy a mass murderer??
|
GlaziertoEagle Coventry 01 Sep 15 9.49pm |
|
|
If he punches them into a plane rotor then they are definitely dead
|
cpfcbobby82 Leatherhead 01 Sep 15 10.02pm |
|
Quote GlaziertoEagle at 01 Sep 2015 9.49pm
If he punches them into a plane rotor then they are definitely dead
He doesn't punch that guy he's just clumsy and walks into it
|
sitdownstandup 03 Sep 15 12.08am |
|
|
good question bobby82... In a lot of movies you are left wondering whether the good guys kill the bad guys or just leave them seriously injured. Those stormtroopers in star wars... when they get shot do they just die, end up in hospital or are they left rolling around on the floor dying in agony? Who knows? In the tv series of the A team (showing me age here) I remember they made a point of not killing anyone on the show so after every explosion or car crash you'd always see the guys or gals rolling around shaking their head in a daze wondering how they managed to stay alive... great stuff 
Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible Nature. Unaware that this Nature he’s destroying is this God he’s worshipping.
Hubert Reeves
|
Superfly The sun always shines in Catford 03 Sep 15 9.12am |
|
|
I dunno why the A Team bothered with guns. You could paint the Forth bridge in the time they take to finish a darts match.
Lend me a Tenor
31 May to 3 June 2017
John McIntosh Arts Centre London Oratory School SW6 1RX
with Superfly in the chorus [Link]
|
Ray in Houston Houston 03 Sep 15 3.53pm |
|
|
John Wick definitely left his antagonists dead. No matter how many times he'd shot them already, he always put one in the brain.
He is a disciple of Johnny Casper. [Link]
As an aside, I think this is why Saving Private Ryan was such a powerful movie. The horrors of more recent wars had been well-explored in movies over the years, Vietnam in particular. But WW2 had been documented in movies that had "clean", one shot / no blood, deaths while the heroes got wounds in the arm and required merely a bandage. That war was also at a time when those who'd suffered it horrors, when they came home, just sucked it up and got on with it (I say this as a credit to those who served, not to denigrate at all those who served later).
So here comes squeaky clean Tom Hanks and "E.T's" Stephen Speilberg with a feel-good WW2 movie in which they save the lovable Matt Damon. It's all there in the title. Then the landing craft close in on the beach...
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.
|
indianapalace85 Bromley 03 Sep 15 4.05pm |
|
|
Let's be honest. Most of the people Indy kills are in self-defence. The people he sneeks up on to disarm, for example, are just to knock them out.
In Temple of Doom, he actually tries to save the big guard on the rock crusher, who tries to kill him.
|
Jamesrichards8 03 Sep 15 4.38pm |
|
Quote sitdownstandup at 03 Sep 2015 12.08am
good question bobby82... In a lot of movies you are left wondering whether the good guys kill the bad guys or just leave them seriously injured. Those stormtroopers in star wars... when they get shot do they just die, end up in hospital or are they left rolling around on the floor dying in agony? Who knows? In the tv series of the A team (showing me age here) I remember they made a point of not killing anyone on the show so after every explosion or car crash you'd always see the guys or gals rolling around shaking their head in a daze wondering how they managed to stay alive... great stuff 
The stormtroopers are clones, so who cares
When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...
|
oldcodger 03 Sep 15 5.26pm |
|
|
It was like this on A Team as well. Someone would get sprayed with bullets and just sort of fall over a bit.
|
MPE Maidstone 03 Sep 15 5.48pm |
|
|
2 of you beat me to The A Team, your Army buggy would get blown up, do 20 rolls, and the passengers would get out rub their heads and run off
Edited by MPE (03 Sep 2015 5.49pm)
Just when I thought that I was out...........they pull me back in
|
oldcodger 03 Sep 15 5.55pm |
|
Quote MPE at 03 Sep 2015 5.48pm
2 of you beat me to The A Team, your Army buggy would get blown up, do 20 rolls, and the passengers would get out rub their heads and run off
Edited by MPE (03 Sep 2015 5.49pm)
It must have been set in a parallel universe were bones were made out of rubber :-D
|
sitdownstandup 05 Sep 15 12.20am |
|
Quote Jamesrichards8 at 03 Sep 2015 4.38pm
Quote sitdownstandup at 03 Sep 2015 12.08am
good question bobby82... In a lot of movies you are left wondering whether the good guys kill the bad guys or just leave them seriously injured. Those stormtroopers in star wars... when they get shot do they just die, end up in hospital or are they left rolling around on the floor dying in agony? Who knows? In the tv series of the A team (showing me age here) I remember they made a point of not killing anyone on the show so after every explosion or car crash you'd always see the guys or gals rolling around shaking their head in a daze wondering how they managed to stay alive... great stuff 
The stormtroopers are clones, so who cares
not me now that i know they're clones.
Edited by sitdownstandup (05 Sep 2015 6.27pm)
Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible Nature. Unaware that this Nature he’s destroying is this God he’s worshipping.
Hubert Reeves
|
bertshead Castlederg 05 Sep 15 12.26am |
|
|
I've always thought the name Harrison Ford sounds like a village in Dorset with a trickle of water running through the middle of it, between the post office and the local pub.
|
cpfcbobby82 Leatherhead 05 Sep 15 4.07pm |
|
Quote sitdownstandup at 03 Sep 2015 12.08am
good question bobby82... In a lot of movies you are left wondering whether the good guys kill the bad guys or just leave them seriously injured. Those stormtroopers in star wars... when they get shot do they just die, end up in hospital or are they left rolling around on the floor dying in agony? Who knows? In the tv series of the A team (showing me age here) I remember they made a point of not killing anyone on the show so after every explosion or car crash you'd always see the guys or gals rolling around shaking their head in a daze wondering how they managed to stay alive... great stuff 
Haha I remember it too!! What was with BA Baracus and his fear of flying anyway?? They'd just tell him to "drink some milk" which would knock him out and get him on the plane anyway! Hardly a genius but I pity the fool that tells him that! (Is he an Eagle?? Will he be reading the very thread?? If you are Mr T good day to you my address is the Falmer Stadium Brighton)
|
bunter Staines 05 Sep 15 4.13pm |
|
|
I thought only the first wave of storm troopers are clones. by the time of the original trilogy they were recruiting humans from all over?
|
cpfcbobby82 Leatherhead 05 Sep 15 4.17pm |
|
Quote bunter at 05 Sep 2015 4.13pm
I thought only the first wave of storm troopers are clones. by the time of the original trilogy they were recruiting humans from all over?
I thought the original stormtroopers were human too but what about the women? How do they have kids and the next batch of naughty little troopers?? So must be cloning going on surely??
|
bunter Staines 05 Sep 15 4.23pm |
|
|
a quick google reveals the original stormtroopers in episode 2 were clones of janjo fett. Palpatine cloned him so he could create an army really quick. by episode 4 though they have allowed other recruits into the army.
|
cpfcbobby82 Leatherhead 05 Sep 15 4.26pm |
|
Quote bunter at 05 Sep 2015 4.23pm
a quick google reveals the original stormtroopers in episode 2 were clones of janjo fett. Palpatine cloned him so he could create an army really quick. by episode 4 though they have allowed other recruits into the army.
Thank you google!! Leads to another question though... Did the Death Star have an HR department? And payroll? Finance?
|
MPE Maidstone 10 Sep 15 5.38pm |
|
Quote cpfcbobby82 at 05 Sep 2015 4.26pm
Quote bunter at 05 Sep 2015 4.23pm
a quick google reveals the original stormtroopers in episode 2 were clones of janjo fett. Palpatine cloned him so he could create an army really quick. by episode 4 though they have allowed other recruits into the army.
Thank you google!! Leads to another question though... Did the Death Star have an HR department? And payroll? Finance?
No! but it had a fantastic final salary pension, which was out of this world..
Just when I thought that I was out...........they pull me back in
|