You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > witch hunts
November 22 2026 1.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

witch hunts


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 13 Sep 15 3.33pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.28pm

To play devils advocate, just because she was found not guilty it doesn't mean that he necessarily lied, but that reasonable doubt existed in the jurors minds - proving 'beyond reasonable doubt' is different from establishing a concrete proof. That of course doesn't mean that the guy was lying, only that he may have made it all up. That has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt as well.

What is beyond reasonable doubt is that the prosecution should never have been brought forward in the first place. Asking a jury to convict someone on the mere word of one person concerning alleged events that happened 20 years before.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 13 Sep 15 3.35pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.30pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 11 Sep 2015 6.49pm

Quote Kermit8 at 11 Sep 2015 10.27am

My guilt-o-meter says 'she is a very fortunate lady'

Your guilt-o-meter! Word of one person against another. On the one hand a teacher of many years with an unblemished record, on the other, a heroin addict who went off with 'travelers' when he was 15. You unerringly plump for the wrong'un - typical lefty.

Damn that statistical data that shows a positive correlation between abuse in childhood and addiction, as well as behaviours such as running away. I mean what's the world coming to when the facts support an scenario.


So you convict someone of sexual abuse based on the 'victim' being a heroin addict - indeed, what's the world coming to.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Sep 15 3.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.33pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.28pm

To play devils advocate, just because she was found not guilty it doesn't mean that he necessarily lied, but that reasonable doubt existed in the jurors minds - proving 'beyond reasonable doubt' is different from establishing a concrete proof. That of course doesn't mean that the guy was lying, only that he may have made it all up. That has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt as well.

What is beyond reasonable doubt is that the prosecution should never have been brought forward in the first place. Asking a jury to convict someone on the mere word of one person concerning alleged events that happened 20 years before.

Was that the only evidence offered, his word? The actual outcome seems to be that the jury could not reach a majority verdict. In reality she's been bailed for a week for the prosecution to decide whether it wishes to pursue a retrial.

So I'd say its not quite as clear cut as people seem to think.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 13 Sep 15 3.43pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.33pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.28pm

To play devils advocate, just because she was found not guilty it doesn't mean that he necessarily lied, but that reasonable doubt existed in the jurors minds - proving 'beyond reasonable doubt' is different from establishing a concrete proof. That of course doesn't mean that the guy was lying, only that he may have made it all up. That has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt as well.

What is beyond reasonable doubt is that the prosecution should never have been brought forward in the first place. Asking a jury to convict someone on the mere word of one person concerning alleged events that happened 20 years before.

Was that the only evidence offered, his word? The actual outcome seems to be that the jury could not reach a majority verdict. In reality she's been bailed for a week for the prosecution to decide whether it wishes to pursue a retrial.

So I'd say its not quite as clear cut as people seem to think.


It doesn't surprise me at all that the prosecution will waste yet more time and money trying to conjure up a case out of nothing - it is the fashion.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Sep 15 3.47pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.35pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.30pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 11 Sep 2015 6.49pm

Quote Kermit8 at 11 Sep 2015 10.27am

My guilt-o-meter says 'she is a very fortunate lady'

Your guilt-o-meter! Word of one person against another. On the one hand a teacher of many years with an unblemished record, on the other, a heroin addict who went off with 'travelers' when he was 15. You unerringly plump for the wrong'un - typical lefty.

Damn that statistical data that shows a positive correlation between abuse in childhood and addiction, as well as behaviours such as running away. I mean what's the world coming to when the facts support an scenario.


So you convict someone of sexual abuse based on the 'victim' being a heroin addict - indeed, what's the world coming to.

Is that what I said? No, I said that assuming someone is lying about being abused because they are now a heroin addict is unfounded. You seem to be the one happy to clear someone if 'they're from a better employment background' and have an 'unblemished record'.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Sep 15 3.51pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.43pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.33pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.28pm

To play devils advocate, just because she was found not guilty it doesn't mean that he necessarily lied, but that reasonable doubt existed in the jurors minds - proving 'beyond reasonable doubt' is different from establishing a concrete proof. That of course doesn't mean that the guy was lying, only that he may have made it all up. That has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt as well.

What is beyond reasonable doubt is that the prosecution should never have been brought forward in the first place. Asking a jury to convict someone on the mere word of one person concerning alleged events that happened 20 years before.

Was that the only evidence offered, his word? The actual outcome seems to be that the jury could not reach a majority verdict. In reality she's been bailed for a week for the prosecution to decide whether it wishes to pursue a retrial.

So I'd say its not quite as clear cut as people seem to think.


It doesn't surprise me at all that the prosecution will waste yet more time and money trying to conjure up a case out of nothing - it is the fashion.

The key phrase here is 'non-majority verdict' - The judge was willing to accept a 10-2 verdict, but that couldn't be reached. Which means at least 3 and possibly as many as 9 of the Jury returned a guilty verdict based on the prosecution and defences evidence.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 13 Sep 15 4.32pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.51pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.43pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.33pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.28pm

To play devils advocate, just because she was found not guilty it doesn't mean that he necessarily lied, but that reasonable doubt existed in the jurors minds - proving 'beyond reasonable doubt' is different from establishing a concrete proof. That of course doesn't mean that the guy was lying, only that he may have made it all up. That has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt as well.

What is beyond reasonable doubt is that the prosecution should never have been brought forward in the first place. Asking a jury to convict someone on the mere word of one person concerning alleged events that happened 20 years before.

Was that the only evidence offered, his word? The actual outcome seems to be that the jury could not reach a majority verdict. In reality she's been bailed for a week for the prosecution to decide whether it wishes to pursue a retrial.

So I'd say its not quite as clear cut as people seem to think.


It doesn't surprise me at all that the prosecution will waste yet more time and money trying to conjure up a case out of nothing - it is the fashion.

The key phrase here is 'non-majority verdict' - The judge was willing to accept a 10-2 verdict, but that couldn't be reached. Which means at least 3 and possibly as many as 9 of the Jury returned a guilty verdict based on the prosecution and defences evidence.

How on earth do you come up with the idea that 9 members of the jury found her guilty?

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 13 Sep 15 4.35pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.47pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.35pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.30pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 11 Sep 2015 6.49pm

Quote Kermit8 at 11 Sep 2015 10.27am

My guilt-o-meter says 'she is a very fortunate lady'

Your guilt-o-meter! Word of one person against another. On the one hand a teacher of many years with an unblemished record, on the other, a heroin addict who went off with 'travelers' when he was 15. You unerringly plump for the wrong'un - typical lefty.

Damn that statistical data that shows a positive correlation between abuse in childhood and addiction, as well as behaviours such as running away. I mean what's the world coming to when the facts support an scenario.


So you convict someone of sexual abuse based on the 'victim' being a heroin addict - indeed, what's the world coming to.

Is that what I said? No, I said that assuming someone is lying about being abused because they are now a heroin addict is unfounded. You seem to be the one happy to clear someone if 'they're from a better employment background' and have an 'unblemished record'.

It is what you imply, the usual weasel words. I clear someone because a jury has cleared them, you still think she is guilty because she is from a better employment background and has an 'unblemished record'.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

oldcodger Flag 13 Sep 15 4.39pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 4.32pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.51pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.43pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.33pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.28pm

To play devils advocate, just because she was found not guilty it doesn't mean that he necessarily lied, but that reasonable doubt existed in the jurors minds - proving 'beyond reasonable doubt' is different from establishing a concrete proof. That of course doesn't mean that the guy was lying, only that he may have made it all up. That has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt as well.

What is beyond reasonable doubt is that the prosecution should never have been brought forward in the first place. Asking a jury to convict someone on the mere word of one person concerning alleged events that happened 20 years before.

Was that the only evidence offered, his word? The actual outcome seems to be that the jury could not reach a majority verdict. In reality she's been bailed for a week for the prosecution to decide whether it wishes to pursue a retrial.

So I'd say its not quite as clear cut as people seem to think.


It doesn't surprise me at all that the prosecution will waste yet more time and money trying to conjure up a case out of nothing - it is the fashion.

The key phrase here is 'non-majority verdict' - The judge was willing to accept a 10-2 verdict, but that couldn't be reached. Which means at least 3 and possibly as many as 9 of the Jury returned a guilty verdict based on the prosecution and defences evidence.

How on earth do you come up with the idea that 9 members of the jury found her guilty?


Nowhere did he say that 9 members of the jury found her guilty.

 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 13 Sep 15 4.41pm

Quote oldcodger at 13 Sep 2015 4.39pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 4.32pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.51pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.43pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.33pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.28pm

To play devils advocate, just because she was found not guilty it doesn't mean that he necessarily lied, but that reasonable doubt existed in the jurors minds - proving 'beyond reasonable doubt' is different from establishing a concrete proof. That of course doesn't mean that the guy was lying, only that he may have made it all up. That has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt as well.

What is beyond reasonable doubt is that the prosecution should never have been brought forward in the first place. Asking a jury to convict someone on the mere word of one person concerning alleged events that happened 20 years before.

Was that the only evidence offered, his word? The actual outcome seems to be that the jury could not reach a majority verdict. In reality she's been bailed for a week for the prosecution to decide whether it wishes to pursue a retrial.

So I'd say its not quite as clear cut as people seem to think.


It doesn't surprise me at all that the prosecution will waste yet more time and money trying to conjure up a case out of nothing - it is the fashion.

The key phrase here is 'non-majority verdict' - The judge was willing to accept a 10-2 verdict, but that couldn't be reached. Which means at least 3 and possibly as many as 9 of the Jury returned a guilty verdict based on the prosecution and defences evidence.

How on earth do you come up with the idea that 9 members of the jury found her guilty?


Nowhere did he say that 9 members of the jury found her guilty.

What does the bit I've highlighted mean then?

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

oldcodger Flag 13 Sep 15 4.44pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 4.41pm

Quote oldcodger at 13 Sep 2015 4.39pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 4.32pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.51pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.43pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.33pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.28pm

To play devils advocate, just because she was found not guilty it doesn't mean that he necessarily lied, but that reasonable doubt existed in the jurors minds - proving 'beyond reasonable doubt' is different from establishing a concrete proof. That of course doesn't mean that the guy was lying, only that he may have made it all up. That has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt as well.

What is beyond reasonable doubt is that the prosecution should never have been brought forward in the first place. Asking a jury to convict someone on the mere word of one person concerning alleged events that happened 20 years before.

Was that the only evidence offered, his word? The actual outcome seems to be that the jury could not reach a majority verdict. In reality she's been bailed for a week for the prosecution to decide whether it wishes to pursue a retrial.

So I'd say its not quite as clear cut as people seem to think.


It doesn't surprise me at all that the prosecution will waste yet more time and money trying to conjure up a case out of nothing - it is the fashion.

The key phrase here is 'non-majority verdict' - The judge was willing to accept a 10-2 verdict, but that couldn't be reached. Which means at least 3 and possibly as many as 9 of the Jury returned a guilty verdict based on the prosecution and defences evidence.

How on earth do you come up with the idea that 9 members of the jury found her guilty?


Nowhere did he say that 9 members of the jury found her guilty.

What does the bit I've highlighted mean then?

'possibly as many as' he's talking about what a non majority ruling means.

 

oldcodger Flag 13 Sep 15 4.45pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 4.35pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.47pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.35pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.30pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 11 Sep 2015 6.49pm

Quote Kermit8 at 11 Sep 2015 10.27am

My guilt-o-meter says 'she is a very fortunate lady'

Your guilt-o-meter! Word of one person against another. On the one hand a teacher of many years with an unblemished record, on the other, a heroin addict who went off with 'travelers' when he was 15. You unerringly plump for the wrong'un - typical lefty.

Damn that statistical data that shows a positive correlation between abuse in childhood and addiction, as well as behaviours such as running away. I mean what's the world coming to when the facts support an scenario.


So you convict someone of sexual abuse based on the 'victim' being a heroin addict - indeed, what's the world coming to.

Is that what I said? No, I said that assuming someone is lying about being abused because they are now a heroin addict is unfounded. You seem to be the one happy to clear someone if 'they're from a better employment background' and have an 'unblemished record'.

It is what you imply, the usual weasel words. I clear someone because a jury has cleared them, you still think she is guilty because she is from a better employment background and has an 'unblemished record'.

Again, nowhere did he say that she's guilty because she's from a better employment background and has an 'unblemished record'. This is simply something that hasn't occurred.


 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 13 Sep 15 4.50pm

Quote oldcodger at 13 Sep 2015 4.45pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 4.35pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.47pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.35pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.30pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 11 Sep 2015 6.49pm

Quote Kermit8 at 11 Sep 2015 10.27am

My guilt-o-meter says 'she is a very fortunate lady'

Your guilt-o-meter! Word of one person against another. On the one hand a teacher of many years with an unblemished record, on the other, a heroin addict who went off with 'travelers' when he was 15. You unerringly plump for the wrong'un - typical lefty.

Damn that statistical data that shows a positive correlation between abuse in childhood and addiction, as well as behaviours such as running away. I mean what's the world coming to when the facts support an scenario.


So you convict someone of sexual abuse based on the 'victim' being a heroin addict - indeed, what's the world coming to.

Is that what I said? No, I said that assuming someone is lying about being abused because they are now a heroin addict is unfounded. You seem to be the one happy to clear someone if 'they're from a better employment background' and have an 'unblemished record'.

It is what you imply, the usual weasel words. I clear someone because a jury has cleared them, you still think she is guilty because she is from a better employment background and has an 'unblemished record'.

Again, nowhere did he say that she's guilty because she's from a better employment background and has an 'unblemished record'. This is simply something that hasn't occurred.

Obviously I was merely parodying his statement that I considered her innocent because she was "from a better employment background and has an 'unblemished record'" (his words not mine).

As for the majority verdict issue. She was found not guilty by a majority verdict, how can that possibly mean that up to 9 jury members found her guilty?

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

oldcodger Flag 13 Sep 15 5.01pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 4.50pm

Quote oldcodger at 13 Sep 2015 4.45pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 4.35pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.47pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.35pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.30pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 11 Sep 2015 6.49pm

Quote Kermit8 at 11 Sep 2015 10.27am

My guilt-o-meter says 'she is a very fortunate lady'

Your guilt-o-meter! Word of one person against another. On the one hand a teacher of many years with an unblemished record, on the other, a heroin addict who went off with 'travelers' when he was 15. You unerringly plump for the wrong'un - typical lefty.

Damn that statistical data that shows a positive correlation between abuse in childhood and addiction, as well as behaviours such as running away. I mean what's the world coming to when the facts support an scenario.


So you convict someone of sexual abuse based on the 'victim' being a heroin addict - indeed, what's the world coming to.

Is that what I said? No, I said that assuming someone is lying about being abused because they are now a heroin addict is unfounded. You seem to be the one happy to clear someone if 'they're from a better employment background' and have an 'unblemished record'.

It is what you imply, the usual weasel words. I clear someone because a jury has cleared them, you still think she is guilty because she is from a better employment background and has an 'unblemished record'.

Again, nowhere did he say that she's guilty because she's from a better employment background and has an 'unblemished record'. This is simply something that hasn't occurred.

Obviously I was merely parodying his statement that I considered her innocent because she was "from a better employment background and has an 'unblemished record'" (his words not mine).

As for the majority verdict issue. She was found not guilty by a majority verdict, how can that possibly mean that up to 9 jury members found her guilty?

What I am trying to say and probably not going a good job of it, is that if or where a non majority verdict can't be reached this would mean that up to 9 members of the jury thought she was guilty.


 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 14 Sep 15 9.30am

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 4.32pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.51pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.43pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.33pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.28pm

To play devils advocate, just because she was found not guilty it doesn't mean that he necessarily lied, but that reasonable doubt existed in the jurors minds - proving 'beyond reasonable doubt' is different from establishing a concrete proof. That of course doesn't mean that the guy was lying, only that he may have made it all up. That has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt as well.

What is beyond reasonable doubt is that the prosecution should never have been brought forward in the first place. Asking a jury to convict someone on the mere word of one person concerning alleged events that happened 20 years before.

Was that the only evidence offered, his word? The actual outcome seems to be that the jury could not reach a majority verdict. In reality she's been bailed for a week for the prosecution to decide whether it wishes to pursue a retrial.

So I'd say its not quite as clear cut as people seem to think.


It doesn't surprise me at all that the prosecution will waste yet more time and money trying to conjure up a case out of nothing - it is the fashion.

The key phrase here is 'non-majority verdict' - The judge was willing to accept a 10-2 verdict, but that couldn't be reached. Which means at least 3 and possibly as many as 9 of the Jury returned a guilty verdict based on the prosecution and defences evidence.

How on earth do you come up with the idea that 9 members of the jury found her guilty?

I didn't say that, I said between 3 and 9 members of the jury found her guilty. The failure to return a 10-2 verdict.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 14 Sep 15 9.45am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Sep 2015 9.30am

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 4.32pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.51pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.43pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.33pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.28pm

To play devils advocate, just because she was found not guilty it doesn't mean that he necessarily lied, but that reasonable doubt existed in the jurors minds - proving 'beyond reasonable doubt' is different from establishing a concrete proof. That of course doesn't mean that the guy was lying, only that he may have made it all up. That has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt as well.

What is beyond reasonable doubt is that the prosecution should never have been brought forward in the first place. Asking a jury to convict someone on the mere word of one person concerning alleged events that happened 20 years before.

Was that the only evidence offered, his word? The actual outcome seems to be that the jury could not reach a majority verdict. In reality she's been bailed for a week for the prosecution to decide whether it wishes to pursue a retrial.

So I'd say its not quite as clear cut as people seem to think.


It doesn't surprise me at all that the prosecution will waste yet more time and money trying to conjure up a case out of nothing - it is the fashion.

The key phrase here is 'non-majority verdict' - The judge was willing to accept a 10-2 verdict, but that couldn't be reached. Which means at least 3 and possibly as many as 9 of the Jury returned a guilty verdict based on the prosecution and defences evidence.

How on earth do you come up with the idea that 9 members of the jury found her guilty?

I didn't say that, I said between 3 and 9 members of the jury found her guilty. The failure to return a 10-2 verdict.


You are referring to the first trial when they could not reach a verdict. Yet a few days later a jury hearing the very same 'evidence' finds her not guilty. Don't you think it highly likely that the first trial split was 9-3 in her favour?

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 14 Sep 15 10.01am

V

Quote leggedstruggle at 14 Sep 2015 9.45am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Sep 2015 9.30am

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 4.32pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.51pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.43pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.33pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.28pm

To play devils advocate, just because she was found not guilty it doesn't mean that he necessarily lied, but that reasonable doubt existed in the jurors minds - proving 'beyond reasonable doubt' is different from establishing a concrete proof. That of course doesn't mean that the guy was lying, only that he may have made it all up. That has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt as well.

What is beyond reasonable doubt is that the prosecution should never have been brought forward in the first place. Asking a jury to convict someone on the mere word of one person concerning alleged events that happened 20 years before.

Was that the only evidence offered, his word? The actual outcome seems to be that the jury could not reach a majority verdict. In reality she's been bailed for a week for the prosecution to decide whether it wishes to pursue a retrial.

So I'd say its not quite as clear cut as people seem to think.


It doesn't surprise me at all that the prosecution will waste yet more time and money trying to conjure up a case out of nothing - it is the fashion.

The key phrase here is 'non-majority verdict' - The judge was willing to accept a 10-2 verdict, but that couldn't be reached. Which means at least 3 and possibly as many as 9 of the Jury returned a guilty verdict based on the prosecution and defences evidence.

How on earth do you come up with the idea that 9 members of the jury found her guilty?

I didn't say that, I said between 3 and 9 members of the jury found her guilty. The failure to return a 10-2 verdict.


You are referring to the first trial when they could not reach a verdict. Yet a few days later a jury hearing the very same 'evidence' finds her not guilty. Don't you think it highly likely that the first trial split was 9-3 in her favour?


Why would 9-3 be much more likely than 7-5 or 6-6. As we don't know the actual figures then as it is they have the same probability.

And I bet you a pound to a penny that if you found out it was 4-8 in favour of a guilty verdict your stance on the accuser still wouldn't change.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 14 Sep 15 11.54am

Quote leggedstruggle at 14 Sep 2015 9.45am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Sep 2015 9.30am

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 4.32pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.51pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.43pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.33pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.28pm

To play devils advocate, just because she was found not guilty it doesn't mean that he necessarily lied, but that reasonable doubt existed in the jurors minds - proving 'beyond reasonable doubt' is different from establishing a concrete proof. That of course doesn't mean that the guy was lying, only that he may have made it all up. That has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt as well.

What is beyond reasonable doubt is that the prosecution should never have been brought forward in the first place. Asking a jury to convict someone on the mere word of one person concerning alleged events that happened 20 years before.

Was that the only evidence offered, his word? The actual outcome seems to be that the jury could not reach a majority verdict. In reality she's been bailed for a week for the prosecution to decide whether it wishes to pursue a retrial.

So I'd say its not quite as clear cut as people seem to think.


It doesn't surprise me at all that the prosecution will waste yet more time and money trying to conjure up a case out of nothing - it is the fashion.

The key phrase here is 'non-majority verdict' - The judge was willing to accept a 10-2 verdict, but that couldn't be reached. Which means at least 3 and possibly as many as 9 of the Jury returned a guilty verdict based on the prosecution and defences evidence.

How on earth do you come up with the idea that 9 members of the jury found her guilty?

I didn't say that, I said between 3 and 9 members of the jury found her guilty. The failure to return a 10-2 verdict.


You are referring to the first trial when they could not reach a verdict. Yet a few days later a jury hearing the very same 'evidence' finds her not guilty. Don't you think it highly likely that the first trial split was 9-3 in her favour?

Which is why I described it as possibly 3 and as many as 9 jurors, rather than just decide she was not guilty because she had an unblemished record and the accuser was now a drug addict.

The point is I'm not basing my view on an opinion of either the accused or the defendant, but on the events. You seem to think the case should never have been brought and it was clearly obvious he was a liar, when in fact the jury in the first incidence wasn't unanimous at all.

She is not guilty, and now its down to the CPS and Police to establish if he is guilty of false testimony, perjury etc


Edited by jamiemartin721 (14 Sep 2015 11.56am)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 14 Sep 15 12.15pm

Quote Kermit8 at 14 Sep 2015 10.01am

V

Quote leggedstruggle at 14 Sep 2015 9.45am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Sep 2015 9.30am

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 4.32pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.51pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.43pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.33pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.28pm

To play devils advocate, just because she was found not guilty it doesn't mean that he necessarily lied, but that reasonable doubt existed in the jurors minds - proving 'beyond reasonable doubt' is different from establishing a concrete proof. That of course doesn't mean that the guy was lying, only that he may have made it all up. That has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt as well.

What is beyond reasonable doubt is that the prosecution should never have been brought forward in the first place. Asking a jury to convict someone on the mere word of one person concerning alleged events that happened 20 years before.

Was that the only evidence offered, his word? The actual outcome seems to be that the jury could not reach a majority verdict. In reality she's been bailed for a week for the prosecution to decide whether it wishes to pursue a retrial.

So I'd say its not quite as clear cut as people seem to think.


It doesn't surprise me at all that the prosecution will waste yet more time and money trying to conjure up a case out of nothing - it is the fashion.

The key phrase here is 'non-majority verdict' - The judge was willing to accept a 10-2 verdict, but that couldn't be reached. Which means at least 3 and possibly as many as 9 of the Jury returned a guilty verdict based on the prosecution and defences evidence.

How on earth do you come up with the idea that 9 members of the jury found her guilty?

I didn't say that, I said between 3 and 9 members of the jury found her guilty. The failure to return a 10-2 verdict.


You are referring to the first trial when they could not reach a verdict. Yet a few days later a jury hearing the very same 'evidence' finds her not guilty. Don't you think it highly likely that the first trial split was 9-3 in her favour?


Why would 9-3 be much more likely than 7-5 or 6-6. As we don't know the actual figures then as it is they have the same probability.

And I bet you a pound to a penny that if you found out it was 4-8 in favour of a guilty verdict your stance on the accuser still wouldn't change.

What that he is a feckless drug addict? No it wouldn't.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

oldcodger Flag 14 Sep 15 12.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 14 Sep 2015 12.15pm

Quote Kermit8 at 14 Sep 2015 10.01am

V

Quote leggedstruggle at 14 Sep 2015 9.45am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Sep 2015 9.30am

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 4.32pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.51pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.43pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Sep 2015 3.33pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Sep 2015 3.28pm

To play devils advocate, just because she was found not guilty it doesn't mean that he necessarily lied, but that reasonable doubt existed in the jurors minds - proving 'beyond reasonable doubt' is different from establishing a concrete proof. That of course doesn't mean that the guy was lying, only that he may have made it all up. That has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt as well.

What is beyond reasonable doubt is that the prosecution should never have been brought forward in the first place. Asking a jury to convict someone on the mere word of one person concerning alleged events that happened 20 years before.

Was that the only evidence offered, his word? The actual outcome seems to be that the jury could not reach a majority verdict. In reality she's been bailed for a week for the prosecution to decide whether it wishes to pursue a retrial.

So I'd say its not quite as clear cut as people seem to think.


It doesn't surprise me at all that the prosecution will waste yet more time and money trying to conjure up a case out of nothing - it is the fashion.

The key phrase here is 'non-majority verdict' - The judge was willing to accept a 10-2 verdict, but that couldn't be reached. Which means at least 3 and possibly as many as 9 of the Jury returned a guilty verdict based on the prosecution and defences evidence.

How on earth do you come up with the idea that 9 members of the jury found her guilty?

I didn't say that, I said between 3 and 9 members of the jury found her guilty. The failure to return a 10-2 verdict.


You are referring to the first trial when they could not reach a verdict. Yet a few days later a jury hearing the very same 'evidence' finds her not guilty. Don't you think it highly likely that the first trial split was 9-3 in her favour?


Why would 9-3 be much more likely than 7-5 or 6-6. As we don't know the actual figures then as it is they have the same probability.

And I bet you a pound to a penny that if you found out it was 4-8 in favour of a guilty verdict your stance on the accuser still wouldn't change.

What that he is a feckless drug addict? No it wouldn't.

Clearly being accused of a crime you may not have committed is terrible. That's one side of the coin.

But what is your message to those who have actually been sexually abused as children and later become alcoholics or drug addicts to deal with the pain? That they are 'feckless', 'just some addict' making 'poor life choices' and should be considered liars by default? That's why the case went to court - to decide. The first jury was much less certain than you it seems, even though they were privy to the facts. You know better of course.


Edited by oldcodger (14 Sep 2015 1.03pm)

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > witch hunts