You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 'Anti-British'
November 22 2026 1.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

'Anti-British'


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Oct 15 1.16pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.13pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 12.57pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 12.39pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 12 Oct 2015 11.16am

How is protesting in order to make your country what you believe to be a better place being anti your country? You might be wrong in terms of what you believe will make it better, but protest is almost the definition of patriotism since it demonstrates that you are committed enough to improving things to stand up and be counted. If anyone is anti-British (in this case) it's those who meekly accept the status quo and therefore contribute nothing (or little) to society. Corbyn, simply by dint of being a party leader, cannot be anti British. Nor can the leaders of any party, whether I agree with their ideology or not.


Protesting is one thing, spitting and planting eggs on peoples heads is quite another. And I wonder whether Jeremy Corbyn actually likes our country and our traditions.

Not sure he was actually spitting or throwing the eggs. What are these traditions that are ours, and what do you mean by 'likes our country'? I like the view of the New Forrest as Autumn claims the trees and the smell of salt on the air along the British coasts, but I don't like our political system which essentially is a biased two horse race that both winners manipulate to improve their chances - Am I still British?


Clearly not if your spelling is anything to go by!

Touche, although I think it sums up our wonderful comprehensive education system.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

chris123 Flag hove actually 12 Oct 15 1.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 1.16pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.13pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 12.57pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 12.39pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 12 Oct 2015 11.16am

How is protesting in order to make your country what you believe to be a better place being anti your country? You might be wrong in terms of what you believe will make it better, but protest is almost the definition of patriotism since it demonstrates that you are committed enough to improving things to stand up and be counted. If anyone is anti-British (in this case) it's those who meekly accept the status quo and therefore contribute nothing (or little) to society. Corbyn, simply by dint of being a party leader, cannot be anti British. Nor can the leaders of any party, whether I agree with their ideology or not.


Protesting is one thing, spitting and planting eggs on peoples heads is quite another. And I wonder whether Jeremy Corbyn actually likes our country and our traditions.

Not sure he was actually spitting or throwing the eggs. What are these traditions that are ours, and what do you mean by 'likes our country'? I like the view of the New Forrest as Autumn claims the trees and the smell of salt on the air along the British coasts, but I don't like our political system which essentially is a biased two horse race that both winners manipulate to improve their chances - Am I still British?


Clearly not if your spelling is anything to go by!

Touche, although I think it sums up our wonderful comprehensive education system.


Ok JM, and that wonderful British capacity for taking complete responsibility for oneself.

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 12 Oct 15 1.26pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 12 Oct 2015 11.16am

How is protesting in order to make your country what you believe to be a better place being anti your country? You might be wrong in terms of what you believe will make it better, but protest is almost the definition of patriotism since it demonstrates that you are committed enough to improving things to stand up and be counted. If anyone is anti-British (in this case) it's those who meekly accept the status quo and therefore contribute nothing (or little) to society. Corbyn, simply by dint of being a party leader, cannot be anti British. Nor can the leaders of any party, whether I agree with their ideology or not.


Not everything that has a protest march is for the betterment of the country as a whole though Syd, In fact in a large majority of cases I would counter argue that, it is largely minority groups campaigning for their own individual causes that protest the most.

Anti abortion, gay rights, teachers, fireman, transport unions, anti islam, pro islam, Students. They all arguabley are protesting for what they want individually (as a group if that makes sense ), not what is better for the country, but what is better for them, or what ever eases their own concience.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Oct 15 1.37pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 1.16pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.13pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 12.57pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 12.39pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 12 Oct 2015 11.16am

How is protesting in order to make your country what you believe to be a better place being anti your country? You might be wrong in terms of what you believe will make it better, but protest is almost the definition of patriotism since it demonstrates that you are committed enough to improving things to stand up and be counted. If anyone is anti-British (in this case) it's those who meekly accept the status quo and therefore contribute nothing (or little) to society. Corbyn, simply by dint of being a party leader, cannot be anti British. Nor can the leaders of any party, whether I agree with their ideology or not.


Protesting is one thing, spitting and planting eggs on peoples heads is quite another. And I wonder whether Jeremy Corbyn actually likes our country and our traditions.

Not sure he was actually spitting or throwing the eggs. What are these traditions that are ours, and what do you mean by 'likes our country'? I like the view of the New Forrest as Autumn claims the trees and the smell of salt on the air along the British coasts, but I don't like our political system which essentially is a biased two horse race that both winners manipulate to improve their chances - Am I still British?


Clearly not if your spelling is anything to go by!

Touche, although I think it sums up our wonderful comprehensive education system.


Ok JM, and that wonderful British capacity for taking complete responsibility for oneself.

That is so not a British trait, only the working class ever blame themselves. The other classes generally blame the working classes, unless they're racist.

The audacity of the middle classes and upper working classes, criticizing the work ethic of people who actually do physical labour based work, is a corner stone of British tradition.

Inherited by those who work in offices, who'll complain about people having 'shorter days', but failing to acknowledge that these people do a lot more than sit in meetings, send emails and type on keyboards.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

chris123 Flag hove actually 12 Oct 15 1.46pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 1.37pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 1.16pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.13pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 12.57pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 12.39pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 12 Oct 2015 11.16am

How is protesting in order to make your country what you believe to be a better place being anti your country? You might be wrong in terms of what you believe will make it better, but protest is almost the definition of patriotism since it demonstrates that you are committed enough to improving things to stand up and be counted. If anyone is anti-British (in this case) it's those who meekly accept the status quo and therefore contribute nothing (or little) to society. Corbyn, simply by dint of being a party leader, cannot be anti British. Nor can the leaders of any party, whether I agree with their ideology or not.


Protesting is one thing, spitting and planting eggs on peoples heads is quite another. And I wonder whether Jeremy Corbyn actually likes our country and our traditions.

Not sure he was actually spitting or throwing the eggs. What are these traditions that are ours, and what do you mean by 'likes our country'? I like the view of the New Forrest as Autumn claims the trees and the smell of salt on the air along the British coasts, but I don't like our political system which essentially is a biased two horse race that both winners manipulate to improve their chances - Am I still British?


Clearly not if your spelling is anything to go by!

Touche, although I think it sums up our wonderful comprehensive education system.


Ok JM, and that wonderful British capacity for taking complete responsibility for oneself.

That is so not a British trait, only the working class ever blame themselves. The other classes generally blame the working classes, unless they're racist.

The audacity of the middle classes and upper working classes, criticizing the work ethic of people who actually do physical labour based work, is a corner stone of British tradition.

Inherited by those who work in offices, who'll complain about people having 'shorter days', but failing to acknowledge that these people do a lot more than sit in meetings, send emails and type on keyboards.


Hey, working in an office is still working, I'm not sure working class has much meaning anymore. We all work, pay tax and then die.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 12 Oct 15 2.06pm

Quote johnfirewall at 11 Oct 2015 10.21pm

Quote rob1969 at 11 Oct 2015 7.11pm

Quote OldFella at 11 Oct 2015 6.55pm

Quote johnfirewall at 11 Oct 2015 6.42pm

This accusation was most notably thrown at Corbyn last week and and the defence from the left is usually that tolerance etc are actually British traits to be proud of.

Today I read something about the Black Power salute at the Mexico Olympics suggesting that the white Australian silver medalist suffered, as do people to this day in both countries as a result of 'racism imposed by British rule'.

Is that fair or are there quite a few self loathing Brits in that same way that there's trust fund guilt?

I find this awful Great Britain a bit paradoxical but wonder if it's just been bad since Cameron?

Edited by johnfirewall (11 Oct 2015 6.43pm)

I honestly don't understand your post, it needs sub titles for the hard of understanding


Read this several times - but ?

The Aussie who was on the podium with those guys wore an Olympic Project for Human Rights badge and also opted not to sing his national anthem and faced a backlash from the Australian Olympic Committee.

The quote you highlight was from some idiot on Facebook and I don't get it either. It just struck me as anti-British to blame us for the situation in 2 countries which have been independent for centuries.

By that logic Stirling they shouldn't support a football team. Imagine causing misery to another group of people by taunting them over their team's inadequacies.


They don't play your anthem when you finish second.

It was his idea that they wore a glove each, after one of the two americans forgot their pair.

 


Optimistic as ever

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 12 Oct 15 2.12pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.46pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 1.37pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 1.16pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.13pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 12.57pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 12.39pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 12 Oct 2015 11.16am

How is protesting in order to make your country what you believe to be a better place being anti your country? You might be wrong in terms of what you believe will make it better, but protest is almost the definition of patriotism since it demonstrates that you are committed enough to improving things to stand up and be counted. If anyone is anti-British (in this case) it's those who meekly accept the status quo and therefore contribute nothing (or little) to society. Corbyn, simply by dint of being a party leader, cannot be anti British. Nor can the leaders of any party, whether I agree with their ideology or not.


Protesting is one thing, spitting and planting eggs on peoples heads is quite another. And I wonder whether Jeremy Corbyn actually likes our country and our traditions.

Not sure he was actually spitting or throwing the eggs. What are these traditions that are ours, and what do you mean by 'likes our country'? I like the view of the New Forrest as Autumn claims the trees and the smell of salt on the air along the British coasts, but I don't like our political system which essentially is a biased two horse race that both winners manipulate to improve their chances - Am I still British?


Clearly not if your spelling is anything to go by!

Touche, although I think it sums up our wonderful comprehensive education system.


Ok JM, and that wonderful British capacity for taking complete responsibility for oneself.

That is so not a British trait, only the working class ever blame themselves. The other classes generally blame the working classes, unless they're racist.

The audacity of the middle classes and upper working classes, criticizing the work ethic of people who actually do physical labour based work, is a corner stone of British tradition.

Inherited by those who work in offices, who'll complain about people having 'shorter days', but failing to acknowledge that these people do a lot more than sit in meetings, send emails and type on keyboards.


Hey, working in an office is still working, I'm not sure working class has much meaning anymore. We all work, pay tax and then die.

Unless of course you are Mark Zuckerburg.....

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 12 Oct 15 3.21pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 11.26am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 12 Oct 2015 10.41am

It's a lot easier for us thickos to join in with the debate when Corbyn is accused of being a scruffy bearded lefty weirdo.

All this highbrow mumbo jumbo is for sydtheeagle and jamiemartin.

K.I.S.S.

Weird people are inherently more trustworthy than anyone who thinks they are 'normal'.


At last I feel better about this post because I'm designated as being weird by my "FRIENDS" but I can now sleep at night knowing that I am inherently more trust worthy than anyone who thinks they are"mormal" like my "FRIENDS". Just shows the benefits to be derived form MUMBO JUMBO even if one is moronic but patient.

 

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 12 Oct 15 4.13pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.46pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 1.37pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 1.16pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.13pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 12.57pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 12.39pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 12 Oct 2015 11.16am

How is protesting in order to make your country what you believe to be a better place being anti your country? You might be wrong in terms of what you believe will make it better, but protest is almost the definition of patriotism since it demonstrates that you are committed enough to improving things to stand up and be counted. If anyone is anti-British (in this case) it's those who meekly accept the status quo and therefore contribute nothing (or little) to society. Corbyn, simply by dint of being a party leader, cannot be anti British. Nor can the leaders of any party, whether I agree with their ideology or not.


Protesting is one thing, spitting and planting eggs on peoples heads is quite another. And I wonder whether Jeremy Corbyn actually likes our country and our traditions.

Not sure he was actually spitting or throwing the eggs. What are these traditions that are ours, and what do you mean by 'likes our country'? I like the view of the New Forrest as Autumn claims the trees and the smell of salt on the air along the British coasts, but I don't like our political system which essentially is a biased two horse race that both winners manipulate to improve their chances - Am I still British?


Clearly not if your spelling is anything to go by!

Touche, although I think it sums up our wonderful comprehensive education system.


Ok JM, and that wonderful British capacity for taking complete responsibility for oneself.

That is so not a British trait, only the working class ever blame themselves. The other classes generally blame the working classes, unless they're racist.

The audacity of the middle classes and upper working classes, criticizing the work ethic of people who actually do physical labour based work, is a corner stone of British tradition.

Inherited by those who work in offices, who'll complain about people having 'shorter days', but failing to acknowledge that these people do a lot more than sit in meetings, send emails and type on keyboards.


Hey, working in an office is still working, I'm not sure working class has much meaning anymore. We all work, pay tax and then die.


That wasn't the point being made.

 


Time to move forward together.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Oct 15 4.43pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.46pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 1.37pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 1.16pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.13pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 12.57pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 12.39pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 12 Oct 2015 11.16am

How is protesting in order to make your country what you believe to be a better place being anti your country? You might be wrong in terms of what you believe will make it better, but protest is almost the definition of patriotism since it demonstrates that you are committed enough to improving things to stand up and be counted. If anyone is anti-British (in this case) it's those who meekly accept the status quo and therefore contribute nothing (or little) to society. Corbyn, simply by dint of being a party leader, cannot be anti British. Nor can the leaders of any party, whether I agree with their ideology or not.


Protesting is one thing, spitting and planting eggs on peoples heads is quite another. And I wonder whether Jeremy Corbyn actually likes our country and our traditions.

Not sure he was actually spitting or throwing the eggs. What are these traditions that are ours, and what do you mean by 'likes our country'? I like the view of the New Forrest as Autumn claims the trees and the smell of salt on the air along the British coasts, but I don't like our political system which essentially is a biased two horse race that both winners manipulate to improve their chances - Am I still British?


Clearly not if your spelling is anything to go by!

Touche, although I think it sums up our wonderful comprehensive education system.


Ok JM, and that wonderful British capacity for taking complete responsibility for oneself.

That is so not a British trait, only the working class ever blame themselves. The other classes generally blame the working classes, unless they're racist.

The audacity of the middle classes and upper working classes, criticizing the work ethic of people who actually do physical labour based work, is a corner stone of British tradition.

Inherited by those who work in offices, who'll complain about people having 'shorter days', but failing to acknowledge that these people do a lot more than sit in meetings, send emails and type on keyboards.


Hey, working in an office is still working, I'm not sure working class has much meaning anymore. We all work, pay tax and then die.

Its not really working. I've been doing this office based working malarkey for donkeys years, and its never once left me actually physically and mentally shattered at the end of the day.

Long before that, when I was much fitter and younger I worked moving 25kg sacks of hops in a brewery, warehouses and worked then moved in retail -

All three were poorly paid, and involved far more actual work than I've ever done since.

Hard day at the office, 1st world problems. Try spending a day shifting 25kg bags of hops for 7 hours.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

chris123 Flag hove actually 12 Oct 15 4.55pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 4.43pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.46pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 1.37pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 1.16pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.13pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 12.57pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 12.39pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 12 Oct 2015 11.16am

How is protesting in order to make your country what you believe to be a better place being anti your country? You might be wrong in terms of what you believe will make it better, but protest is almost the definition of patriotism since it demonstrates that you are committed enough to improving things to stand up and be counted. If anyone is anti-British (in this case) it's those who meekly accept the status quo and therefore contribute nothing (or little) to society. Corbyn, simply by dint of being a party leader, cannot be anti British. Nor can the leaders of any party, whether I agree with their ideology or not.


Protesting is one thing, spitting and planting eggs on peoples heads is quite another. And I wonder whether Jeremy Corbyn actually likes our country and our traditions.

Not sure he was actually spitting or throwing the eggs. What are these traditions that are ours, and what do you mean by 'likes our country'? I like the view of the New Forrest as Autumn claims the trees and the smell of salt on the air along the British coasts, but I don't like our political system which essentially is a biased two horse race that both winners manipulate to improve their chances - Am I still British?


Clearly not if your spelling is anything to go by!

Touche, although I think it sums up our wonderful comprehensive education system.


Ok JM, and that wonderful British capacity for taking complete responsibility for oneself.

That is so not a British trait, only the working class ever blame themselves. The other classes generally blame the working classes, unless they're racist.

The audacity of the middle classes and upper working classes, criticizing the work ethic of people who actually do physical labour based work, is a corner stone of British tradition.

Inherited by those who work in offices, who'll complain about people having 'shorter days', but failing to acknowledge that these people do a lot more than sit in meetings, send emails and type on keyboards.


Hey, working in an office is still working, I'm not sure working class has much meaning anymore. We all work, pay tax and then die.

Its not really working. I've been doing this office based working malarkey for donkeys years, and its never once left me actually physically and mentally shattered at the end of the day.

Long before that, when I was much fitter and younger I worked moving 25kg sacks of hops in a brewery, warehouses and worked then moved in retail -

All three were poorly paid, and involved far more actual work than I've ever done since.

Hard day at the office, 1st world problems. Try spending a day shifting 25kg bags of hops for 7 hours.


So the only real work is that that requires brawn?

 

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 12 Oct 15 5.20pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 4.55pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 4.43pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.46pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 1.37pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 1.16pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.13pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 12.57pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 12.39pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 12 Oct 2015 11.16am

How is protesting in order to make your country what you believe to be a better place being anti your country? You might be wrong in terms of what you believe will make it better, but protest is almost the definition of patriotism since it demonstrates that you are committed enough to improving things to stand up and be counted. If anyone is anti-British (in this case) it's those who meekly accept the status quo and therefore contribute nothing (or little) to society. Corbyn, simply by dint of being a party leader, cannot be anti British. Nor can the leaders of any party, whether I agree with their ideology or not.


Protesting is one thing, spitting and planting eggs on peoples heads is quite another. And I wonder whether Jeremy Corbyn actually likes our country and our traditions.

Not sure he was actually spitting or throwing the eggs. What are these traditions that are ours, and what do you mean by 'likes our country'? I like the view of the New Forrest as Autumn claims the trees and the smell of salt on the air along the British coasts, but I don't like our political system which essentially is a biased two horse race that both winners manipulate to improve their chances - Am I still British?


Clearly not if your spelling is anything to go by!

Touche, although I think it sums up our wonderful comprehensive education system.


Ok JM, and that wonderful British capacity for taking complete responsibility for oneself.

That is so not a British trait, only the working class ever blame themselves. The other classes generally blame the working classes, unless they're racist.

The audacity of the middle classes and upper working classes, criticizing the work ethic of people who actually do physical labour based work, is a corner stone of British tradition.

Inherited by those who work in offices, who'll complain about people having 'shorter days', but failing to acknowledge that these people do a lot more than sit in meetings, send emails and type on keyboards.


Hey, working in an office is still working, I'm not sure working class has much meaning anymore. We all work, pay tax and then die.

Its not really working. I've been doing this office based working malarkey for donkeys years, and its never once left me actually physically and mentally shattered at the end of the day.

Long before that, when I was much fitter and younger I worked moving 25kg sacks of hops in a brewery, warehouses and worked then moved in retail -

All three were poorly paid, and involved far more actual work than I've ever done since.

Hard day at the office, 1st world problems. Try spending a day shifting 25kg bags of hops for 7 hours.


So the only real work is that that requires brawn?


And you still miss the original point made.

 


Time to move forward together.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 12 Oct 15 8.02pm

This thread has so many generalisations that I don't know where to start.

OK let's try.

Demonstration does not = moral high ground.

Manual work cannot be equated with administration or management although both are equally important.

Do we want the world run by white van man ?
We can't have a world where everyone does aspirational jobs. Not that I'm suggesting that "office based" is aspirational.
I would not agree that all no manual jobs are not hard work. Because there is no muscle involved does not mean it isn't tiring or demanding. Of course working a hard days graft moving s*** from one place to another takes it out of the anatomy but not all physical labour is poorly paid. Ask a plasterer or a plumber.
The vast majority of socialists are happy to become middle class and yet still remain in denial of the system that got them there.
Of course life is not a level playing field and all the whining about it in the world won't change that.

Corbyn's appeal to his targeted audience is so cynical it makes me chuck.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 12 Oct 15 9.02pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 12 Oct 2015 8.02pm

This thread has so many generalisations that I don't know where to start.

OK let's try.

Demonstration does not = moral high ground.

Manual work cannot be equated with administration or management although both are equally important.

Do we want the world run by white van man ?
We can't have a world where everyone does aspirational jobs. Not that I'm suggesting that "office based" is aspirational.
I would not agree that all no manual jobs are not hard work. Because there is no muscle involved does not mean it isn't tiring or demanding. Of course working a hard days graft moving s*** from one place to another takes it out of the anatomy but not all physical labour is poorly paid. Ask a plasterer or a plumber.
The vast majority of socialists are happy to become middle class and yet still remain in denial of the system that got them there.
Of course life is not a level playing field and all the whining about it in the world won't change that.

Corbyn's appeal to his targeted audience is so cynical it makes me chuck.


If you are a socialist because you are working class you get told it's the politics of envy. If you are a socialist because you are highly educated and/or wealthy you are accused of being a champagne socialist. Ergo it just can't be right to be socialist as nobody has a right to be one. And you certainly can't have an opinion on egalitarianism if you are the top of the pile as you should have given all of your hard-earned away as soon as you got beyond the modal income for the world.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 12 Oct 15 9.25pm

You just listed several good reasons not to be a socialist.

Socialism is illusory. What does it actually mean ?

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 13 Oct 15 9.44am

Quote -TUX- at 12 Oct 2015 5.20pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 4.55pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 4.43pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.46pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 1.37pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 1.16pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 1.13pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 12.57pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Oct 2015 12.39pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 12 Oct 2015 11.16am

How is protesting in order to make your country what you believe to be a better place being anti your country? You might be wrong in terms of what you believe will make it better, but protest is almost the definition of patriotism since it demonstrates that you are committed enough to improving things to stand up and be counted. If anyone is anti-British (in this case) it's those who meekly accept the status quo and therefore contribute nothing (or little) to society. Corbyn, simply by dint of being a party leader, cannot be anti British. Nor can the leaders of any party, whether I agree with their ideology or not.


Protesting is one thing, spitting and planting eggs on peoples heads is quite another. And I wonder whether Jeremy Corbyn actually likes our country and our traditions.

Not sure he was actually spitting or throwing the eggs. What are these traditions that are ours, and what do you mean by 'likes our country'? I like the view of the New Forrest as Autumn claims the trees and the smell of salt on the air along the British coasts, but I don't like our political system which essentially is a biased two horse race that both winners manipulate to improve their chances - Am I still British?


Clearly not if your spelling is anything to go by!

Touche, although I think it sums up our wonderful comprehensive education system.


Ok JM, and that wonderful British capacity for taking complete responsibility for oneself.

That is so not a British trait, only the working class ever blame themselves. The other classes generally blame the working classes, unless they're racist.

The audacity of the middle classes and upper working classes, criticizing the work ethic of people who actually do physical labour based work, is a corner stone of British tradition.

Inherited by those who work in offices, who'll complain about people having 'shorter days', but failing to acknowledge that these people do a lot more than sit in meetings, send emails and type on keyboards.


Hey, working in an office is still working, I'm not sure working class has much meaning anymore. We all work, pay tax and then die.

Its not really working. I've been doing this office based working malarkey for donkeys years, and its never once left me actually physically and mentally shattered at the end of the day.

Long before that, when I was much fitter and younger I worked moving 25kg sacks of hops in a brewery, warehouses and worked then moved in retail -

All three were poorly paid, and involved far more actual work than I've ever done since.

Hard day at the office, 1st world problems. Try spending a day shifting 25kg bags of hops for 7 hours.


So the only real work is that that requires brawn?


And you still miss the original point made.

Please elucidate.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Oct 15 10.02am

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 12 Oct 2015 8.02pm

This thread has so many generalisations that I don't know where to start.

OK let's try.

Demonstration does not = moral high ground.

Manual work cannot be equated with administration or management although both are equally important.

Do we want the world run by white van man ?
We can't have a world where everyone does aspirational jobs. Not that I'm suggesting that "office based" is aspirational.
I would not agree that all no manual jobs are not hard work. Because there is no muscle involved does not mean it isn't tiring or demanding. Of course working a hard days graft moving s*** from one place to another takes it out of the anatomy but not all physical labour is poorly paid. Ask a plasterer or a plumber.
The vast majority of socialists are happy to become middle class and yet still remain in denial of the system that got them there.
Of course life is not a level playing field and all the whining about it in the world won't change that.

Corbyn's appeal to his targeted audience is so cynical it makes me chuck.

It wasn't about pay, or what was better, but how people in office based jobs have a nasty tendency to view anyone who may work a labour job as lazy for only working shorter shifts etc.

Having done both, I can highly recommend office work for less exhausting, but it can be more stressful I guess (its hard to be stressed about your job when you spent six hours shifting 25kg loads into a hopper).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

chris123 Flag hove actually 13 Oct 15 10.09am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Oct 2015 10.02am

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 12 Oct 2015 8.02pm

This thread has so many generalisations that I don't know where to start.

OK let's try.

Demonstration does not = moral high ground.

Manual work cannot be equated with administration or management although both are equally important.

Do we want the world run by white van man ?
We can't have a world where everyone does aspirational jobs. Not that I'm suggesting that "office based" is aspirational.
I would not agree that all no manual jobs are not hard work. Because there is no muscle involved does not mean it isn't tiring or demanding. Of course working a hard days graft moving s*** from one place to another takes it out of the anatomy but not all physical labour is poorly paid. Ask a plasterer or a plumber.
The vast majority of socialists are happy to become middle class and yet still remain in denial of the system that got them there.
Of course life is not a level playing field and all the whining about it in the world won't change that.

Corbyn's appeal to his targeted audience is so cynical it makes me chuck.

It wasn't about pay, or what was better, but how people in office based jobs have a nasty tendency to view anyone who may work a labour job as lazy for only working shorter shifts etc.

Having done both, I can highly recommend office work for less exhausting, but it can be more stressful I guess (its hard to be stressed about your job when you spent six hours shifting 25kg loads into a hopper).


Well you speak for yourself, I don't hold that view, does anyone?

 

npn Flag Crowborough 13 Oct 15 10.12am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Oct 2015 10.02am

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 12 Oct 2015 8.02pm

This thread has so many generalisations that I don't know where to start.

OK let's try.

Demonstration does not = moral high ground.

Manual work cannot be equated with administration or management although both are equally important.

Do we want the world run by white van man ?
We can't have a world where everyone does aspirational jobs. Not that I'm suggesting that "office based" is aspirational.
I would not agree that all no manual jobs are not hard work. Because there is no muscle involved does not mean it isn't tiring or demanding. Of course working a hard days graft moving s*** from one place to another takes it out of the anatomy but not all physical labour is poorly paid. Ask a plasterer or a plumber.
The vast majority of socialists are happy to become middle class and yet still remain in denial of the system that got them there.
Of course life is not a level playing field and all the whining about it in the world won't change that.

Corbyn's appeal to his targeted audience is so cynical it makes me chuck.

It wasn't about pay, or what was better, but how people in office based jobs have a nasty tendency to view anyone who may work a labour job as lazy for only working shorter shifts etc.

Having done both, I can highly recommend office work for less exhausting, but it can be more stressful I guess (its hard to be stressed about your job when you spent six hours shifting 25kg loads into a hopper).


I've spent 30+ years in an office. In a brief period of a couple of weeks without work, rather than sign on, I did a bit of labouring for a garden company. At the end of the day I got the standard "bet that's the hardest days work you've ever done" line - I just didn't have the heart to tell him that, while it was physically draining, I'd count it as one of the easiest and most relaxing days I'd had, as you could just switch off your brain - you want that gravel moved from there to there? Done. You want it moved back again because you cocked up? No problem, done. I shovel, I get paid - no decisions to make, no responsibility - it was bliss!

 

Hoof Hearted 13 Oct 15 10.13am

This argument about office worker v manual worker is as relevant as old v young or men v women.

The fact is we need all types of workers.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 'Anti-British'