This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 25 Oct 2015 8.03pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 25 Oct 2015 2.20pm
I think you have to see prostitution as being several different motivations. These tend to be economic, although the problem has never really been so much with prostitution but the exploitation of sex workers in society and their 'ostracisation' from social protection (forcing sex workers closer to organised crime). In the rise of sex trafficking fear also plays a serious role (both of the traffickers and of the authorities - who are often interested in only the conviction of the traffickers, not the future of the girls trafficked). Its unlikely that many sex workers make a deliberate choice, to do what they do (but that's by no means true of all those in the trade), but they all do make an economic one. Its not a career of initial choice, the lure is always the economic factor.
Most of us have bills to pay, many of us don't do our ideal jobs. In situations where a person has chosen the sex trade (without compulsion) we should always keep our minds open as too their particular motivations It's important not to stereotype (not that you have) with people who choose the sex trade....Sometimes they aren't defenseless, poor innocents who have no other options and need to be protected....But in many instances they are......For others, the reason why can be a sliding scale.....I imagine. Some will see the amount they can earn an hour compared to cleaning toilets or working in Tescos and draw the obvious conclusions or view it as an easy wage top up or a way to pay off a debt.....Many don't think of the risks....Or have addictions or shock horror for some a high sex drive does factor in...The list of reasons is probably endless. Obviously there is a crime/drugs problem linked to this and this is entirely the fault of the criminalising of the sex trade. The law should be working to keep these workers safe. Edited by Stirlingsays (25 Oct 2015 8.09pm) I agree with you entirely, and not only does a legal trade keep the workers safe, it generates taxable income, protects the clients and allows the 'trade' to be moved from the street. The workers also would benefit much more from outreach services and such to assist them, provide skill training and services aimed at breaking them out of the sex trade. Also by using a centralized authority either via the Police or councils, to run and licence brothels and sex workers, you can then really focus on those who run exploitative and abusive operations, such as human trafficking, exploitative pimps, protect the workers from violent punters with security measures (and it encourages the girls to go to the police).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote johnfirewall at 26 Oct 2015 12.21pm
There's a difference between decriminalisation and having legitimate authorised services. You can already pay an eastern European gangster for sex with a prostitute thus funding the trafficking of more girls, and other organised crime without getting nicked. Maybe the government should run the railways and knocking shops. You could have a 'Buffet and a Muffing' carriage on each train, to while away the long delays. I seriously have never understood the mentality of governments trying to enforce morality over human nature. Things like sex and getting high are so very much ingrained in many peoples nature, that all the laws achieve is to criminalise people who otherwise would never come into contact with the Criminal Justice System. Getting a criminal record for a handjob from a hooker could quite easily mean you'd lose your job (as it would potentially mean a criminal record) and could even be treated as a 'sex offence' (if it was pursued as public indecency), putting you on the sex offenders registry. We're still tied to a strange middle classed puritanical influence, that simply demands that 'one moral code fits all', and all it achieves is further damaging parts of society, who never come into real contact with it (other than through religion maybe).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote johnfirewall at 26 Oct 2015 12.21pm
There's a difference between decriminalisation and having legitimate authorised services. You can already pay an eastern European gangster for sex with a prostitute thus funding the trafficking of more girls, and other organised crime without getting nicked. Maybe the government should run the railways and knocking shops. I feel that social services should run knocking shops, with the revenue raised going back into the local social services dept, whilst local NHS should be the source of 'recreational' drugs, with the money going back into the local NHS services. Keep the gangsters out, focus the police on 'protecting the legal trade', control the price, supply and quality control, and whilst you won't solve the problems, you'll stem the corruption and compounding of the problem (its arguably a lot better to treat addiction with rehab and social services, than to simply keep criminalizing people for possession, whilst providing them with cheap, high quality drugs at a reasonable price). A junkie who can afford their smack is much less of a problem to everyone else, than one who can't. Plus, if they do then get clean, its unlikely that they'll have a string of criminal convictions related to financing their habit holding them back from employment.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Similarly with addicts funding themselves through prostitution, what does it say about us as a society that we would rather they sold sexual services to strangers on the street, rather than just give them diamorphine (which can be produced at profit for the NHS at 1/35th of the street price of heroin)?
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 26 Oct 2015 1.24pm
In theory making it legal sounds aces, however in this country I fear it would just lead to more poor young immigrant women from eastern Europe being brutalised and sold into sex slavery. Sort that problem first, then make it legal and have an authority that can shut them down if standards are not met. To make it legal now would be sheer lunacey. You could be right, however by freeing resources from policing and putting licensing into the hands of local authorities, such as social services, you then have a basis on which to dedicate resources against illegal brothels. Initially the revenue raised from legalization should be used to 'protect the state monopoly' and focus on eliminating brothels that are not registered using freed up resources and revenue generated. I don't think you'll ever be able to fully eliminate the predatory trade of sex trafficking, not entirely, but by offering a legal alternative, you can reduce its profitability, whilst focusing resources on those that supply and run such operations. At present they seem to occupy a blind spot in society (local police aren't really interested in crimes against prostitutes let alone illegal migrants).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 27 Oct 2015 1.17am
Quote dannyh at 26 Oct 2015 1.24pm
In theory making it legal sounds aces, however in this country I fear it would just lead to more poor young immigrant women from eastern Europe being brutalised and sold into sex slavery. Sort that problem first, then make it legal and have an authority that can shut them down if standards are not met. To make it legal now would be sheer lunacey. It would lead to less I think. Just like the black market for anything the state can't stop a black market for drugs or brass still existing.....All it can do is lower the profitability of having one. With a legal option to compete with the black market would have to lower its prices to stay attractive. That lowers the risk/reward element for criminal gangs. The problem still exists but the numbers affected negatively are fewer. The gangs have a legal competition. I agree with the state aggressively attacking sexual exploitation and slavery.....That's independent of a change in the law for the sex trade designed to protect them. The problem of an illegal drug trade though is that it doesn't prevent people becoming drug addicts, or the availability of drugs either (which are fairly easy to get a hold of). It just creates an artificially high price for drugs that creates a lot of crime as addicts need to commit. Things like cocaine and heroin are actually very cheap to produce (Cocaine pure is about £1 per gram without a real laboratory, diamorphine, heroin probably around a fiver, for a gram of pure heroin). Crack is actually even cheaper than cocaine to produce). The street price of cocaine, is around £50 a gram for 20-30% cocaine hydrochloride and around the same for heroin of about the same quality. Amphetamines are ridiculously cheap to produce (as in the equivilent of 20 grams of street grade speed, is produced in a lab for pennies. These three represent the big problem drugs of abuse in the UK (although methadrone use is growing now its illegal). The fact is that an addict committing crime to maintain a gram a day heroin habit, is going to need to generate around 200 worth of crime to feed that habit. Where as with a legal source, allowing for purity, the need to find around a fiver a day (which means even legal work could support many habits). Plus you have the added bonus, that no one is really going to build up the kind of habits that are unsustainable because something like 2g of pure heroin, at say a tenner, would sustain even the most hardened tolerant smack head for several days (or put in another way, doing that much diamorphine would prove fatal to humans in that time span). Sounds cold, but that's a basic fact, even the most heroin tolerant person, is going to die if they're doing two grams of pure heroin in a couple of days.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.